Public Order Policy Consultation Submissions
From June 28 until August 30, 2024, the Board received submissions from the public as part of this consultation process. We thank the hundreds of organizations and individuals who submitted their thoughts.
As was indicated at the time the consultation began, all submissions made as part of the consultation and received by August 30, 2024, now form part of the public record, and are posted below.
While the submissions were edited to remove any personal information beyond names, the Board did not edit submissions for content. One submission was excluded due to inflammatory language which was also unrelated to the topic of the consultation. Nevertheless, given the need to allow for free expression on this very sensitive topic, the Board did not edit or exclude a number of submissions that may be deemed offensive or hurtful. Thus, the Board does not endorse the opinions contained in the submissions; they are shared solely pursuant to our original undertaking, and to enhance transparency and accountability.
Furthermore, please be advised that some of the submissions contain discussions of incidents and matters that may be disturbing to some.
Finally, please note that a number of submissions were received without any content. These submissions were excluded from the list below.
- Caryma Sa'd
- Jamal Hassan (Self - Taxpayer - Toronto resident)
- Bruce Rubin
TPS reporting of statistics clearly demonstrate the alarming increase and escalation of Antisemitic violent hate crimes in Toronto. Pro-Palestinian and pro-Hamas supporters have specifically targeted Jews and Jewish institutions with a goal to intimidate Jews at their places of worship, the communities they live in, the businesses they own or work at, and the schools and universities they attend. The hypocrisy makes this especially egregious given that these demonstrations would not be tolerated if they targeted any other group but Jews. And once again, just ahead of the school year, ugly displays of hate and intimidation toward Jews are front and center at universities. Police inaction and lack of enforcement has simply emboldened the terror-supporting mobs that are inciting hatred and intimidating innocent Torontonians. Every bit of it is unacceptable – and the more it is ignored, the more this behaviour becomes normalized. There are many existing federal, provincial and municipal laws that are not - but MUST BE - enforced. Based on the Criminal Code of Canada, much of what the mobs are doing is not "lawful" protest protected by a constitutional right; rather they are committing criminal acts that are hateful, violent, targeted, and well-organized. Torontonians want to see enforcement and prosecution, not more platitudes and virtue signaling. Police should be re-trained and understand the relevant sections of the Criminal Code (below) so they can consistently implement a set of protocols to SHUT DOWN the protests where hatred and/or violence are incited, peace is disturbed, or access to schools and universities, religious institutions, or transportation infrastructure is blocked. Relevant Criminal Code sections: - Blocking or obstructing a highway (Sec. 423(1)(g)) - Intimidation (Sec. 423(1)) - Causing a disturbance (Sec. 175) - Common nuisance (Sec. 180) - Interfering with transportation facilities (Sec. 248) - Breach of the peace or imminent breach (Sec. 31 - Riots (Sec. 32, 33, 64, 65, 67, 68, 69) - Unlawful assembly (Sec. 63) - Mischief (Sec. 430) - Wearing a mask while committing the above offences (Sec. 65(2))
- Canadian Muslim Lawyers Association (Canadian Muslim Lawyers Association)
- Lance Juno
I have 2 thoughts to share.
The first is that any group that is aligned to a terrorist organization should be denied the right to demonstrate.
The second is that any group that, while demonstrating, uses any terminology or language that is hate related (like "from the river to the sea") should be arrested and charged with a hate crime. - Wendy Kovac (Royal LePage)
I am writing to express my concerns regarding the ongoing Palestinian protests happening every weekend in Toronto, and the significant impact these events are having on my business operations as a realtor in the area.
As you may be aware, these protests often result in road closures, restricted access to certain neighborhoods, and increased congestion, particularly in areas where I have several properties listed for sale. This has created substantial challenges for my clients and me in terms of scheduling property viewings, hosting open houses, and conducting other essential real estate activities.
The constant disruption has led to a decline in foot traffic to open houses, diminished interest from potential buyers who are discouraged by the difficulties of navigating the area, and even cancellations of scheduled viewings. Moreover, these protests have heightened concerns about safety and the stability of the market, prompting hesitation among buyers and sellers alike.
While I fully support the right to peaceful protest and the importance of raising awareness for vital causes, the frequency and intensity of these gatherings are having a detrimental effect on local businesses, including mine. The uncertainty surrounding the protests has made it increasingly challenging to maintain a stable business environment and provide the level of service my clients expect and deserve. - Vale Warren
Suggestions for priorities: 1) To reduce police presence (whether on foot, on bike, on horse, or by car) at protests, demonstrations, and occupations; furthermore, to abstain from restricting the freedom of movement of participants in protests, demonstrations, and occupations (for example, barricades or lines of officers controlling the route of a protest). Police presence does not make participants safer and does not reduce the chance of violence (often because officers are the ones enacting the violence). 2) To end the removal of non-violent protest occupations and encampments. Participants in such demonstrations take up public and private space because their needs and concerns are being ignored by people with/institutions of power; they should not be removed when they are not causing physical harm to either. 3) To end the destruction/eviction of homeless encampments, and instead collaborate with or defer to outreach organizations whose priority is to keep encampment residents safe, alive, and (if desired) informed of options to seek housing/addiction treatment/etc. Removal of tents/structures, residents' belongings, and residents themselves is highly traumatizing and makes it even more difficult for residents to seek assistance with the personal and/or structural issues that contributed to their situation. Tents/structures in public spaces are residents' last resorts, and not inherently a risk to public safety. 4) To continue to collaborate with initiatives/organizations such as Reach Out Response Network (RORN) to divert mental health 911 calls to non-police workers. Again, police presence at scenes of someone's mental crisis/distress does not make them safer and has resulted in the death of the person in distress.
Thank you so much for your time. - Sharon Krieger
Thank you for allowing me to discuss my concerns regarding the rise of antisemitism in our city .I have never experienced a time in my life ( born in Toronto , 1953 ) where I have felt more afraid , as a Jew , in this city . Also more fearful to continue to live in a city where I do not feel safe. I am shocked and greatly disturbed by the lack of concern that both Premier Ford and Olivia Chow have shown toward the community . They have clearly not done enough to speak out against these hate crimes ,especially targeted against the Jewish community ,knowing full well that protestors have strategically targeted Jewish areas , hoping to intimidate the residents . Police need to know that the government stands behind them in protecting the community . There should be zero tolerance for hate speech .. and certainly more training for the difference between hate speech and free speech. There is a clear distinction that needs to be made . i would like to see more training on hate crime enforcement . The protests appear to be a free for all in hate speech .. calling for the genocide of the Jewish people .. with little or no enforcement of laws whatsoever . I couldn't shop , recently , at a grocery store near my home.. whenever did you feel intimidated at a parking lot at a grocery store in this city ?? The protests at the 401 and Avenue road were allowed to go on far far too long, was it because the police were stymied on how best to handle this ? Graffiti everywhere .. Police need to adopt a zero tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech and bullying . We need safe access to our schools , places of worship and community service agencies , not places of protest to be used as such . The university , once a place for learning , became a place of intimidation , and prevented Jewish and Israeli students to be able to continue their studies out of fear . I support any resources and training the police can use to assist campus security to remove campus encampments . The masks , concealing identities of protesters worry me , they are engaging in hate speech , which is a criminal offense. I support all necessary resources that are needed to help protect my community so that we may live, once again, without fear . There is much that needs to be done so that illegal activity aimed at hurting Jews is contained and that there are consequences I will close by thanking the police for all they have done to protect our community. I will say , also , during the walk for Israel in June , I so appreciated the police presence .. They were wonderful and I felt safe
- JM
Hello,
First, I'd like to thank TPS for doing what they can to manage the protests.
However, given the increasing antisemitism and radicalization among the anti-Israel movement it is necessary for TPS to change the approach to anti-Israel /pro-Hamas protests.
In allowing and excusing inflammatory rhetoric TPS, under the guidance of this board and mayor, are encouraging hate.
It can no longer be acceptable for protests to occur in predominantly Jewish neighborhoods.
When protesters call for "Intifada now" it means violent uprising. Are those calling for intifada or "celebrating the resistance" looking for a peaceful two state solution? The word Intifada is connected to Arafat's use of suicide bombers in Israel; a campaign that resulted in many Canadians including Canadian teenagers being blown up.
It is not acceptable for protesters to hold signs saying death to Jews in any language.
It is not acceptable for protestors to march outside Jewish homes especially while performing Hitler salutes.
It is not okay to display pro-Hamas signs and images such as the inverted red triangle, drop images of Swastika's in mailboxes, spread Hamas propaganda on social media disguised as anti-Zionist rhetoric, and attack Jewish schools and businesses.
Unless the harassment and death threats are addressed, more and more people will become radicalized.
Everyone is welcome to protest the current Israeli government, but it is not acceptable to blame Canadian Jews or Israeli Canadians for what is occurring half a world away.
Somewhere along the line there has been a misguided impression that this will go away. It's not going anywhere. We need to work for peace and that starts with recognizing everyone regardless of perceived privilege deserves to feel safe in their home, city and country.
I am an immigrant who grew up in a police state. The joy of living in Canada is to be in a place where people are free to put aside whatever hate, ugliness, fear and prejudice they grew up in and embrace everyone. Even your historic "enemies."
Finally, maybe it's time to consider hiring more police officers so the 2500 active officers serving over 3 million have support and the resources to keep everyone in our city safe? - Cassandra Brown
Hello, and thanks for reading these submissions. As a member of the wider public (and not Jewish), I am absolutely outraged at the lack of action on behalf of our Government and police force when it comes to the so-called pro-Palestinian rallies and protests. I have been watching these displays if hate and incitement to violence for 10 months now, almost unsanctioned. There has been police presence (thank goodness) and I am appreciate of this, but I cannot imagine how terrifying it must be for anyone with a Jewish background in Canada. I feel like the laws are not being enforced as many of the incidents are obvious and classic examples of hate speech and incitement /glorification of violence. Why are these not shut down is beyond me. If the Police officers don't understand the definition of these criminal offenses, then they needs proper instructions and training. Imagine of any of these offenses were directed at any other minority group - black, lgbtq, etc. The cops would be all over it. I am ashamed and embarrassed bu the lack of action and I find the government complicit to the inaction. Let us know what we need to do - as the taxpayers and larger public - to shut down and punish spreading hate in this country. Happy to vote a different party, help fundraise, etc. We cannot carry on like this and end up in a lawlessness society like UK these days... Thank you. Cassandra Brown
- Cortney Garay
- Shirley Zussman
SUBMISSION TO THE TORONTO POLICE BOARD ON ANTISEMITISM IN TORONTO
I am grateful to have this opportunity to connect with the Toronto Police Service to discuss my concerns about the precipitous rise in antisemitism in Toronto. This is not, however, just a Jewish community issue. Any minority group living here should feel safe. All levels of government have a responsibility to hold people accountable for criminal and unruly behaviour. Sadly, the existing laws and bylaws have not been consistently applied when Jews are targeted. They must be enforced during protests, encampments, and unlawful assembly.
Premier Ford and Mayor Chow have not played a strong enough role in speaking out against hate crimes against Jews, especially when they know how often protestors have strategically targeted demographically Jewish areas, hoping to intimidate and demonize residents. Both need to be unequivocal and consistently show more leadership when these events take place. The police need to know that our governments stand behind them in protecting the Jewish community from hate-filled protestors bent on dehumanizing, intimidating and demonizing Jews.
Existing officers and new recruits require updated training on antisemitism and hate crime enforcement with the concomitant funding and resources to achieve this. To help police carry out existing laws and bylaws, they need to learn protest management strategies so that they can enforce laws, which maintain peace and order, particularly in major intersections and predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods.
I have been a witness to several protests, including the one on Avenue Road and Wilson where I once lived. Demonstrators hijacked a vital intersection without regard for the safety and security of drivers and residents living there and the drivers distracted by them on the 401. Police allowed this to go on far too long, stymied by how best to handle it.
I saw the posters of kidnapped Israelis that I put up on streets in my neighbourhood of Avenue Road and Lonsdale vandalized. The faces of babies and others were vandalized, viciously excised with the use of box cutters. Racists were roaming neighbourhoods cutting out the faces of Jews. Images of their missing faces continue to haunt me.
Nazi and Hamas graffiti, slogans, epithets and threats to kill Jews have multiplied all over the city. I saw Indigo Book Store defaced, with red paint thrown on the photo of the founder, Heather Reisman, because she is a Jew. Jewish community centres and synagogues in my area and elsewhere have been targeted with bomb threats. I fear for my 4-year-old grand-daughter who takes swimming lessons at a Jewish Community Centre 㤼㸶 used by people of all races and faiths. I am afraid to walk the streets in Toronto wearing a Star of David for fear of being attacked. Many Jews, including my adult children, have taken down their mezuzah, a talisman that Jews affix on their front door, fearing for their safety if they leave them there.
Police need to adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech or bullying particularly at public demonstrations. They need updated training to know the difference between hate speech and free speech. In addition, we need police to be trained on hate crime enforcement so that police know when that line is crossed, and hold those breaking the law accountable.
While the right to protest is constitutionally protected in Canada, that right is not absolute. Not all protest gatherings are legal. Hate speech is NOT protected at protests. Obstructing highways or transportation facilities are not allowed and are not considered reasonable limits on the right to protest.
We need to ensure protests are not obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business 㤼㸶 both have regularly taken place in our city since October 7. We need safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent them from being used as venues for protest.
All these requirements come at a great cost. I support the police department in obtaining all the necessary resources it needs to maintain peace and order. There should never be any tolerance for hate speech at demonstrations. I support any and all measures to assure that police have the training to identify and respond quickly to hate speech, slogans and symbols that target Jews and other minorities.
University campuses are private property, and therefore encampments there are considered trespassing and against the law. University leaders are responsible for ensuring their campuses remain free from obstructions. Sadly, most failed to enforce laws relating to trespassing on university property. Students and some professors spewed hate speech, held up signs directed toward Jewish and Israeli Canadian students, and stopped them from going to classrooms and other areas of the campus. I support any resources and training the police can use to assist campus security to remove university encampments and ensure peaceful protests.
I'm worried about people concealing their identity at these protests. I am aware that it is an offence to conceal one's identity while committing a criminal offence. Therefore, masked protestors who are engaging in hate speech or that remain masked when a protest transitions into an illegal riot are guilty of an offence, and should be apprehended.
I ask that the police exercise a zero-tolerance approach when it comes to any form of hate speech at a public demonstration (which means an additional charge if they're also wearing a mask). Although there are many things being said at protests that are extremely offensive, and hurtful to the community, it is important to note that the police only view hate speech as it is currently defined under the criminal code. Police must apply a zero-tolerance definition to hate speech while learning about certain pejorative expressions, which have an equally negative impact on the Jewish community.
Police need updated training in both antisemitism 㤼㸶 how it is defined -- and hate crime enforcement that includes understanding the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech to identify the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda (including foreign language material). For example, things said at protests in Arabic are not the same as things said in English, and are often more criminal in nature because they speak to their genocidal intent.
I thank the police for all they've done to increase their presence and understanding of how much antisemitism has grown in our city. There is much that needs to be done so that illegal activity aimed at hurting Jews is contained and that any crimes committed by protestors have a consequence. That is the only way our city will be safe from those who hate Jews and anyone who stands in the way of their goals.
Thank you, too, for including my perspective in this public consultation. - Michael Baigel (Personal)
- Amichai Wise, Director of the Office of the SE for Deborah Lyons (Special Envoy for Preserving Holocaust Remembrance and Combatting Antisemitism, Government of Canada)
- Marion Eva Waldmann
- Michael Orr
Antisemitic intimidation and the promotion of hate and terrorism needs to stop. The police need to be more proactive and resourced accordingly. Members of the Jewish community are being targeted and harassed without justification.
- Sherri Storm
Dear Members of the Toronto Police Services Board,
I am writing to express my gratitude for the Toronto Police Service's support and protection during the "Walk with Israel" event held in June. The presence and professionalism of your officers were invaluable in ensuring the event's safety.
However, I must also address a significant concern affecting my family and many others in our community. The rise in illegal protests and rallies targeting the Jewish community, marked by hateful rhetoric, offensive written messages, and disturbing symbols, has created an atmosphere of fear and distress.
To better address these issues, it is crucial that officers receive comprehensive education and clear directives from the Toronto Police Services Board. Training should focus on recognizing and responding to illegal hate speech, as well as identifying and addressing offensive symbols and written messages. Such training would empower officers to take appropriate actions, including making arrests when necessary, and help reinforce a clear stance against hate and discrimination.
Providing officers with this education and clear guidance will not only enhance their ability to effectively manage these situations but also send a strong message that intolerance and hate will not be tolerated in our community.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter and for your continued commitment to maintaining the safety and inclusivity of our city.
Sincerely,
Sherri Storm - Aviva Pratzer
Dear Toronto Police Service,
First and foremost, I want to extend my heartfelt thanks for your unwavering dedication and service to our community. Your commitment to upholding safety and order in Toronto is truly valued.
However, I must address a pressing concern. As the police set priorities in policing protests, demonstrations, and occupations, and as you direct the Chief in establishing procedures that align with community values and expectations, it is essential to acknowledge the increasing impact of recent issues. The rise in antisemitism, vandalism of community spaces, and hate speech has significantly affected our sense of safety and well-being. As a community in Toronto, Jewish people feel unsafe and afraid.
I urge the Toronto Police Service to consider implementing measures to help and protect our community:
Zero Tolerance Policy: Enforce a zero tolerance policy for antisemitic actions, hate speech, and vandalism. Clear, stringent consequences for such behaviors will underscore the commitment to maintaining community safety.
Increased Patrols: Increase police presence in areas particularly affected by these issues, including places of worship, community centers, and educational institutions, to deter and address incidents swiftly.
Enhanced Reporting and Support Systems: Establish and promote accessible reporting channels for victims of hate crimes and vandalism, and provide them with robust support services.
Regular Review and Accountability: Regularly review the effectiveness of policies and procedures related to managing protests and demonstrations, ensuring they meet the community's needs and expectations.
By taking these types of steps and others, the Toronto Police Service can help restore a sense of security and inclusivity in our community.
Thank you for your attention to this matter and for your continued efforts in safeguarding our city.
Sincerely, Aviva - Daniel Koren (Allied Voices for Israel)
- Elana Solomon
I'm concerned about the Toronto police service board consultation on public order under way, TPSB directly . My concern is the antisemitism,taken over our streets,targeting our religious institutions,invading campuses. Tha use of offensive language at the protests,demonstrations AND occupations are not peaceful or safe for a Jewish person. It is not a peaceful assembly, targeting hatred towards the Jewish people and students. Jewish residents understand how this antisemitic rhetoric,vandalism of our community spaces are targeting of Jewish owned businesses,constant protests and encampments have impacted my ability to to live my life and mental,health and safety. This atmosphere in the city is gone too long without any consequences! I is gradually looking like the pre WW2 in Germany , which was so antisemitic gathering on the streets. It started with gathering of"free "speech end similarly with concentration on Jewish hatred as use before the summer and now again in the fall! I am wondering how long this group going freely in this city of Toronto,is letting this to continue? And how much more it will go . Sincerely,Elana
- Janice LaForme
I support the submission and recommendations of Mr. Mark Sandler on behalf of the Alliance of Canadians Against Antisemitism
- Lora Sloan
I have been appalled and outraged by the lackadaisical manner in which the City and its enforcement agencies have managed the anti-Semitic, anti-Israel, pro-terrorist demonstrations over the past year since the atrocities of October 7, 2023. Shame on Toronto. In particular, shame on Mayor Chow for allowing these embarrassing, threatening, and dangerous actions to persist. What message is this sending? And how do these protests reflect and support Canadian values and our ally in the Middle East, Israel?
In particular, the blocking of Avenue Road at the overpass to Highway 401 was an abhorrent example of City complicity in anti-Jewish racism. The fact that this was allowed to persist for two weeks when laws prohibiting exactly this kind of behaviour could have been enforced IMMEDIATELY. Unfortunately this demonstrated an ugly biased within City Council and further encouraged threatening, dangerous behaviour by hordes of racist people in our City. In fact, just the other day, a Jewish man was arrested who was peacefully protesting at Bathurst and Sheppard by sitting on a median with a sign about the hostages. He wasn't saying anything violent nor did his message incite hatred. He also wasn't obstructing traffic. Yet we have seen violent protests and praying sessions disrupt traffic and daily activities with no consequences. Even the lack of enforcement during the encampments at our universities. That is private property and Jewish students were unable to attend classes and feel welcome. These encampments were allowed to go on for weeks with no consequences and disrupted classes and intimidated paying students. Some of the protesters on campuses weeent even students.
I am disgusted. I expect and demand much better from our City leaders. Toronto is for everyone and Council needs to start protecting everyone. Lately it appears to be pandering to various religious and immigrant groups at the cost of others.
City Council must do better. This period is a stain on our history that can never be cleansed. But the City can do better going forward. - Councillor Alejandra Bravo (City of Toronto)
- Rosalyn Train
- Councillor Alejandra Bravo (City of Toronto)
- Jody Berkes
- Alyson Gampel (Parent of TDSB children and taxpayer in the city ofToronto)
- Paula Miller (None...Toronto resident...)
I would like to see Zero tolerance of towardsbreaking and contravention of existing laws; ENFORCEMENT of existing laws: ie: masking during a Protest is unlawful...lay charges. Screaming to incite hatred and screaming threats, calling for genocide: lay charges. Improving protest management: blocking and obstructing traffic which impinges on people's rights to access regular businesses and impedes daily routines, first responder access, etc...lay charges. Creating a camping area on private property...lay charges. Please please please provide the officers with the training and back up support they need to deal with the takeover of civilization we are experiencing! Please provide officers with a full list of hate groups and keep it updated. These groups multiply daily. Please send officers to training on antisemitism and Holocaust education through proper channels with trained specialists... not just stuff on the web.
- Ezra Levant (Rebel News Network Ltd.)
- Hanita Braun
To the attention of Toronto Police Service
Below please find my Actionable Recommendations for the TPS re: policing improvements needed to ensure the safety, security and peaceful enjoyment of our city.
1. Enforcement of Laws During Protests and Demonstrations
Recommendation: - Enhance Police Training: Ensure comprehensive training for officers on laws governing protest management, including the enforcement of laws related to mischief, trespassing, unlawful assembly, and other relevant offences including face coverings. - Focus Areas: Prioritize maintaining peace and order in major city intersections and in predominantly Jewish neighborhoods where such demonstrations are more likely to occur, while ensuring that the residents and the city's general population are not blocked, delayed, harassed or bullied. - Outcome: This training will equip officers to effectively manage protests and ensure that all applicable laws are enforced, thereby preventing unlawful activities and ensuring that the city's needs are well served and protected, as your motto says To Serve and Protect.
2. Addressing Hate Speech in Public Demonstrations
Recommendation: - Adopt a Zero-Tolerance Approach: Implement a zero-tolerance policy for any form of hate speech, incitement to violence, harassment, intimidation or bullying at public demonstrations. - Update Training: Police training should be updated to include specific content on antisemitism and on hate crime enforcement. This includes understanding the historical context, the impact of hate speech, and the tactics and symbols being used in hate propaganda. - Outcome: Officers will be better prepared to identify and respond quickly to hate speech, hate propaganda and harassment, thus ensuring that public demonstrations remain lawful and do not incite violence or hatred.
3. Blocking of Streets, Encampments and Private Property Enforcement
Recommendation: - Improve Protest Management: Develop and implement strategies to ensure protests do not obstruct traffic nor prevent ordinary people from conducting their business without blockage or impediment. - Establish Safe Access Zones: Implement safe access zones around places of worship, schools and community service agencies to prevent these locations from being used as venues for protests, harassment or bullying. - Support Resources: Acknowledge the resource costs associated with effective protest management and advocate publicly for additional resources to support these activities. - Outcome: Enhanced protest management will ensure that public order is maintained without infringing on individuals' rights to protest peacefully. Ensure that protests are truly peaceful without incitement to hate and violence, without calls for destruction and annihilation and without disturbing the peaceful functioning of the city.
4. Addressing University Campus Encampments
Recommendation: - Support Campus Security: Provide training and resources to assist campus security in managing encampments and protests on university property. - Enforce Trespassing Laws: Ensure that university leaders enforce laws relating to trespassing on their property, with police support when necessary. - Outcome: This will help maintain a safe and secure environment on campuses, protecting students from hate speech and other unlawful activities.
5. Masking and Identity Concealment at Protests
Recommendation: - Zero-Tolerance for Hate Speech: Reinforce the zero-tolerance approach for hate speech, with additional penalties for those who conceal their identity while engaging in such activities. - Update Training: Ensure police training includes identifying and addressing hate speech, even when masked individuals are involved. - Outcome: By addressing identity concealment in tandem with hate speech enforcement, police can effectively deter criminal activities at protests.
6. Training and Education on Emerging Hate Groups
Recommendation: - Expand Training on Hate Groups: Provide updated and comprehensive training for police on emerging hate groups, hate speech, and antisemitism. - Content Focus: Training should include historical context, the identification of hate symbols, slogans, and foreign language material used in hate propaganda. - Outcome: Officers will be better equipped to detect and respond to the presence of hate groups and hate speech in public demonstrations.
7. Reporting and Responding to Hate Crimes
Recommendation: - Enhance Hate Crime Training: Advocate for TPS-wide enhanced training on hate crimes, focusing on the identification of hate symbols, hate speech and propaganda. - Zero-Tolerance Enforcement: Ensure a consistent, zero-tolerance approach to hate speech and symbols at protests and other public gatherings by enforcing all laws. - Outcome: Improved training will enable police to effectively identify and prosecute hate crimes, thereby protecting all vulnerable communities.
8. Responding to Hate Symbols in Public Spaces
Recommendation: - Streamline Reporting and Response: Develop a unified approach between police and municipalities for the quick removal of hate symbols and graffiti. - Support Resources: Advocate for additional resources to support hate crime enforcement and the timely removal of hateful content. - Outcome: A coordinated response will ensure that hate symbols are promptly addressed, maintaining public spaces that are safe and welcoming for all community members.
Conclusion These recommendations emphasize the need for comprehensive training, a zero-tolerance approach to hate speech, to incitement and to intimidation, thus improving protest management, and enhancing the collaboration between police and other stakeholders. By implementing these recommendations, the Toronto Police Service can ensure that they are effectively protecting the city of Toronto, the vulnerable communities, while maintaining public order, safety and security while upholding the rights of all citizens to the peaceful and unobstructed enjoyment of our city.
Respectfully, (Resident of Toronto for 55 years) - Justin Jamieson (n/a)
In a democracy, we have the right to protest, provided that it is orderly. What should not be tolerated are protests against specific groups of people as we've seen in Toronto these past few months.
"Occupations" that restrict or prevent access to buildings, or that block roads should be shut down with zero tolerance. We live in a big city where disruptions due to construction or traffic are increasing in occurrence. We cannot allow activists and hooligans to make life more miserable for everyone. - Hanita Mek
Police officers should be educated on specific terrorist vocabulary. For example when protesters yell in Arabic "Slaughter the Jews", police officers should know to arrest those individuals. Similarly, police officers should be aware of what a swastika is and the rules around carrying signage with swastikas.
When protesters carry signs that Insight violence or that are racist, those should be confiscated and the individuals should be charged wherever hate crimes are applicable. If charging them is not possible, they should be removed from the protest.
Police should be empowered to enforce laws even during protests. If, as had been suggested, they are vastly outnumbered, this should be communicated publicly as the reason that not all required arrests have been made. I expect that they would make arrests after the fact for all violations by following the individuals that are breaking the rules.
During press conferences and when public statements are made, the police should be clear about which group's members were arrested. For example, if a protester from the 'pro-Palestinian' side is charged or a pro Palestinian protest blocks roads, it should be communicated to the media as such.
There should be a report that highlights all disruptions caused in the city by affiliation / protest cause.
Reports on antisemitic incidents and islamophobic incidents should not be combined and need to be discussed separately. When speaking about occurrences of antisemitism, members of the police should refrain from adding "and Islamophobia" to their sentences.
There should be strictly no masking rules in protests. There should be strict no protesting rules near places of worship.
Individuals that commit crimes and cannot be arrested at the time should have their pictures publicized even if they are wearing a mask. It is not acceptable to have groups of protesters removed for their own safety when the other group of protesters is larger and more violent. The protests should be completely stopped on the violent side instead of violating the peaceful group's freedom of speech because of the violent nature of the other group.
Any speech that promotes or glorifies terrorist acts, such as October 7th should be reported, and charges laid. - Jennifer Brown
Hi everyone
Today is the final day to submit your recommendations to TPS on ensuring a safer city for the Jewish community.
Actionable Recommendations for Toronto Police Service
1. Enforcement of Laws During Protests and Demonstrations
Recommendation: - Enhance Police Training: Ensure comprehensive training for officers on laws governing protest management, including the enforcement of laws related to mischief, trespassing, unlawful assembly, and other relevant offences. - Focus Areas: Prioritize maintaining peace and order in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighborhoods where such demonstrations are more likely to occur. - Outcome: This training will equip officers to effectively manage protests and ensure that all applicable laws are enforced, thereby preventing unlawful activities.
2. Addressing Hate Speech in Public Demonstrations
Recommendation: - Adopt a Zero-Tolerance Approach: Implement a zero-tolerance policy for any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. - Update Training: Police training should be updated to include specific content on antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. This includes understanding the historical context, the impact of hate speech, and the tactics and symbols used in hate propaganda. - Outcome: Officers will be better prepared to identify and respond quickly to hate speech, ensuring public demonstrations remain lawful and do not incite violence or hatred.
3. Blocking of Streets, Encampments, and Private Property Enforcement
Recommendation: - Improve Protest Management: Develop and implement strategies to ensure protests do not obstruct traffic or prevent people from conducting their business. - Establish Safe Access Zones: Implement safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent these locations from being used as venues for protests. - Support Resources: Acknowledge the resource costs associated with effective protest management and advocate for additional resources to support these activities. - Outcome: Enhanced protest management will ensure that public order is maintained without infringing on individuals' rights to protest peacefully.
4. Addressing University Campus Encampments
Recommendation: - Support Campus Security: Provide training and resources to assist campus security in managing encampments and protests on university property. - Enforce Trespassing Laws: Ensure that university leaders enforce laws relating to trespassing on their property, with police support when necessary. - Outcome: This will help maintain a safe and secure environment on campuses, protecting students from hate speech and other unlawful activities.
5. Masking and Identity Concealment at Protests
Recommendation: - Zero-Tolerance for Hate Speech: Reinforce the zero-tolerance approach for hate speech, with additional penalties for those who conceal their identity while engaging in such activities. - Update Training: Ensure police training includes identifying and addressing hate speech, even when masked individuals are involved. - Outcome: By addressing identity concealment in tandem with hate speech enforcement, police can effectively deter criminal activities at protests.
6. Training and Education on Emerging Hate Groups
Recommendation: - Expand Training on Hate Groups: Provide updated and comprehensive training for police on emerging hate groups, hate speech, and antisemitism. - Content Focus: Training should include historical context, the identification of hate symbols, slogans, and foreign language material used in hate propaganda. - Outcome: Officers will be better equipped to detect and respond to the presence of hate groups and hate speech in public demonstrations.
7. Reporting and Responding to Hate Crimes
Recommendation: - Enhance Hate Crime Training: Advocate for TPS-wide enhanced training on hate crimes, focusing on the identification of hate symbols, speech, and propaganda. - Zero-Tolerance Enforcement: Ensure a consistent, zero-tolerance approach to hate speech and symbols at protests and other public gatherings. - Outcome: Improved training will enable police to effectively identify and prosecute hate crimes, thereby protecting vulnerable communities.
8. Responding to Hate Symbols in Public Spaces
Recommendation: - Streamline Reporting and Response: Develop a unified approach between police and municipalities for the quick removal of hate symbols and graffiti. - Support Resources: Advocate for additional resources to support hate crime enforcement and the timely removal of hateful content. - Outcome: A coordinated response will ensure that hate symbols are promptly addressed, maintaining public spaces that are safe and welcoming for all community members.
Conclusion These recommendations emphasize the need for comprehensive training, a zero-tolerance approach to hate speech, improved protest management, and enhanced collaboration between police and other stakeholders. By implementing these recommendations, the Toronto Police Service can ensure that they are effectively protecting the community, maintaining public order, and upholding the rights and safety of all residents. - Molly Shoichet
I am grateful to the Toronto Police for protecting the rights of Jewish people to live in a civil society, free of hatred, hate speech, vandalism and acts of violence. All Canadians have the right to live in peace. I appreciate the Toronto Police protecting us against anti-semitism and racism in all of its forms. The right to free speech is not a right to hate speech. The right to peaceful demonstration is not the right to violence or destruction. The police are our allies and have a duty and responsibility to protect us all, as I know that they will continue to do.
- Kennair (Private citizen)
After 11 months of protestation we more than understand the issue. We sympathize with both side of the problem. However it is time for them to stop. It should have stop a long time ago. Canadians and Torontonians have not created the problem and are not taking part is resolving the problem. To be honest I do not understand that permits have been issued and for so long. We the residents of Toronto have had enough of the congestion that protest groups bring. Every single weekend for the past 11 months we have had to deal with extra congestion and incredible amount of loud speaker voices. How can a city not think about its other citizens. Where are the clear minds thinkers at City Hall ? The protesters have invaded our already congested city for far too long. Enough is enough.
- Avi & Daniel (YALLA!)
Actionable Recommendations for Toronto Police Service
1. Enforcement of Laws During Protests and Demonstrations
Recommendation: - Enhance Police Training: Ensure comprehensive training for officers on laws governing protest management, including the enforcement of laws related to mischief, trespassing, unlawful assembly, and other relevant offences. - Focus Areas: Prioritize maintaining peace and order in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighborhoods where such demonstrations are more likely to occur. - Outcome: This training will equip officers to effectively manage protests and ensure that all applicable laws are enforced, thereby preventing unlawful activities.
2. Addressing Hate Speech in Public Demonstrations
Recommendation: - Adopt a Zero-Tolerance Approach: Implement a zero-tolerance policy for any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. - Update Training: Police training should be updated to include specific content on antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. This includes understanding the historical context, the impact of hate speech, and the tactics and symbols used in hate propaganda. - Outcome: Officers will be better prepared to identify and respond quickly to hate speech, ensuring public demonstrations remain lawful and do not incite violence or hatred.
3. Blocking of Streets, Encampments, and Private Property Enforcement
Recommendation: - Improve Protest Management: Develop and implement strategies to ensure protests do not obstruct traffic or prevent people from conducting their business. - Establish Safe Access Zones: Implement safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent these locations from being used as venues for protests. - Support Resources: Acknowledge the resource costs associated with effective protest management and advocate for additional resources to support these activities. - Outcome: Enhanced protest management will ensure that public order is maintained without infringing on individuals' rights to protest peacefully.
4. Addressing University Campus Encampments
Recommendation: - Support Campus Security: Provide training and resources to assist campus security in managing encampments and protests on university property. - Enforce Trespassing Laws: Ensure that university leaders enforce laws relating to trespassing on their property, with police support when necessary. - Outcome: This will help maintain a safe and secure environment on campuses, protecting students from hate speech and other unlawful activities.
5. Masking and Identity Concealment at Protests
Recommendation: - Zero-Tolerance for Hate Speech: Reinforce the zero-tolerance approach for hate speech, with additional penalties for those who conceal their identity while engaging in such activities. - Update Training: Ensure police training includes identifying and addressing hate speech, even when masked individuals are involved. - Outcome: By addressing identity concealment in tandem with hate speech enforcement, police can effectively deter criminal activities at protests.
6. **Training and Education on Emerging Hate Groups
Recommendation: - Expand Training on Hate Groups: Provide updated and comprehensive training for police on emerging hate groups, hate speech, and antisemitism. - Content Focus: Training should include historical context, the identification of hate symbols, slogans, and foreign language material used in hate propaganda. - Outcome: Officers will be better equipped to detect and respond to the presence of hate groups and hate speech in public demonstrations.
7. Reporting and Responding to Hate Crimes
Recommendation: - Enhance Hate Crime Training: Advocate for TPS-wide enhanced training on hate crimes, focusing on the identification of hate symbols, speech, and propaganda. - Zero-Tolerance Enforcement: Ensure a consistent, zero-tolerance approach to hate speech and symbols at protests and other public gatherings. - Outcome: Improved training will enable police to effectively identify and prosecute hate crimes, thereby protecting vulnerable communities.
8. Responding to Hate Symbols in Public Spaces
Recommendation: - Streamline Reporting and Response: Develop a unified approach between police and municipalities for the quick removal of hate symbols and graffiti. - Support Resources: Advocate for additional resources to support hate crime enforcement and the timely removal of hateful content. - Outcome: A coordinated response will ensure that hate symbols are promptly addressed, maintaining public spaces that are safe and welcoming for all community members.
Conclusion These recommendations emphasize the need for comprehensive training, a zero-tolerance approach to hate speech, improved protest management, and enhanced collaboration between police and other stakeholders. By implementing these recommendations, the Toronto Police Service can ensure that they are effectively protecting the community, maintaining public order, and upholding the rights and safety of all residents. - A.G. Belaiche
Dear Sir/Madam,
Thank you for conducting this timely and important public consultation regarding the establishment of a policy on police action in respect of protests, demonstrations and occupations.
The results of this consultation will likely help inform and shape policies for police services across Canada.
This consultation will hopefully result in meaningful changes, as necessary, to help Toronto Police perform their duties and responsibilities effectively in response to unprecedented challenges to public order, public safety, and more broadly, to public order.
I am a native-born Torontonian and have lived in Toronto for most of my 60+ years.
Since October 7, 2023, I have seen a significant increase in public demonstrations in Toronto that have become increasingly angry, hostile, and confrontational. Even when these demonstrations appear "peaceful", they often carry a real undertone of anger and hostility designed not to advocate, but to intimidate.
I have seen angry and hostile political demonstrations across the City, in local communities and neighbourhoods, that are fundamentally inappropriate locations for such demonstrations.
I am deeply troubled by the shocking deterioration in public order and conduct in the City of Toronto and am writing to outline my concerns and views respecting this serious development.
First off, I want to thank the many members of the Toronto Police Service who have demonstrated remarkable restraint and patience during a period when police officers have found themselves confronted, taunted and even humiliated by demonstrators who have shown striking disregard, hostility and anger towards law enforcement, but also to members of other communities.
In the context of such unprecedented demonstrations, the role of front-line officers and their supervisors is critically important.
These law enforcement agents must have, or be given, all of the tools and powers as are necessary to enable them to perform their duties and responsibilities effectively. That role must be supported by appropriate and effective education and training so as to enable prompter and more informed decision-making, often times on-the-spot.
As a lawyer, I am familiar with, and sensitive to, the public interest in protecting freedom of expression as a right entrenched in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. However, freedom of expression has never been limitless.
Reasonable and justifiable limitations on Charter rights are specifically recognized by section 1 of the Charter as and have been recognized as legitimate societal interests by Canadian courts, including the Supreme Court of Canada.
A well-drafted policy adopted by the Toronto Police Service Board after public consultations should readily withstand judicial scrutiny. As a preliminary question, has the Board considered formally consulting the Law Society of Ontario as part of its consultation process for this policy?
KEY PRINCIPLES
There are certain key principles that should be clearly recognized and enumerated in a TPS Board Policy regarding demonstrations. Such a board These include the following: Canadians have a reasonable expectation that they may go about living their day-to-day lives without a fear of intimidation or harassment on public streets, and particularly, in their local communities.
Canadians also have a reasonable expectation that all residents will conduct themselves appropriately and show mutual respect for every other resident, regardless of their backgrounds, religions, political opinions, or for any other reason.
Generally speaking, these expectations translate into two buckets:
1. Conduct and Behaviours; and 2. Time and Place.
CONDUCT AND BEHAVIOURS
The conduct and behaviours exhibited by too many political demonstrators over the past year have included acts of intimidation and harassment.
While this conduct and these behaviours are seldom effectively actionable through the criminal law, they can be, and are, distressing and disturbing to residents. While political demonstrations and expression should not be muzzled, the manner of such political expression should not be such as to create fear or intimidation for residents in any public space.
Masking of Demonstrators
Demonstrators have often. and almost typically wear. masks, disguises and other face coverings, such as keffiyehs.
There are only two legitimate reasons for wearing of masks and veils: genuine medical needs and genuine religious reasons.
No one should have any expectation of privacy with respect to their attendance at a political demonstration. If there are not already laws on the books to prohibit masks and disguises at public demonstrations, then Toronto Police should be enforcing such laws, and their policies should reflect their commitment to enforcing such laws.
TIME AND PLACE
Designation of Public Spaces for Protests
Pro-Hamas demonstrations over the past ten months have caused significant disruptions for residents in their day-to-day lives. It has caused people to be late for business appointments, for medical appointments, for travel, and for work.
It has been shocking to see demonstrators arrogate to themselves, in now a consistent and flagrant manner, the use and occupancy of public roadways for private political purposes, and now, as well, for religious purposes.
Seeing the defacing of public and private property by pro-Hamas supporters is deeply troubling.
These demonstrators have also caused the City of Toronto to have to incur significant and unexpected policing costs.
All of these costs and disruptions could be more effectively managed by designating certain locations in the City for political demonstrations, likely to exceed a fixed number of people, i.e., 200.
Such locations could include, for example, Nathan Phillips Square (City Hall), Metro Hall, Queen's Park.
Permitting of Protests
The City of Toronto has a department that issues permits for street events. It is a small and very busy department. The office ensures that all street events comply with terms and conditions governing road occupancy.
While there is of course a difference between political demonstrations and street events, the City's interests in both scenarios should be identifiable and protected.
As part of its consultation process, the TPS Board should consider the important terms and conditions under which the City authorizes organizations to occupy roads.
Why should charitable organizations planning a street event for a community be subject to more stringent terms and conditions for their use of the street than a political organization that clearly has ample resources to plan and execute weekly, if not more regular, protests and demonstrations?
It should be clear that where political demonstrations are planned days, or even weeks in advance, demonstrators should be expected to apply for a permit that would enable advance planning by the City to ensure public safety and the responsible use of public resources.
Final Comments
The Toronto Police Service Board needs to demonstrate leadership and take accountability for the breakdown in public order and public safety over the past ten months or so.
This consultation is very much to the Board's credit but ultimately, it will require clear and declared support from political leaders who have to date demonstrated a sad and shameful reticence to speak clearly about public expectations for political demonstrations.
Resources must be found to support police training about laws governing protest management so as to enable the enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, and protect public rights to freedom from hate, intimidation or harassment.
There must be absolutely no tolerance for hate speech and we must ensure that Toronto Police officers are trained to identify and respond quickly to hate speech. All Toronto Police officers should receive updated training in antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. This is critically needed and should be an integral part of the training and education of all new police officers in Ontario.
Thank you for conducting this consultation. I would be pleased to participate in any further consultations. - Lynn Wintraub
I would like demonstrators to be stopped from behaving in a threatening manner. I don't believe they should be entitled to stop traffic, yell threatening hate speech or allowed anywhere near children. Kids of any religion should not be exposed to the hatred that these groups espouse. I expect the police to uphold the law and protect citizens. While, I believe in freedom of speech, many if these demonstrations have been unlawful, but allowed. Why were demonstrators permitted to stop traffic? Why were they allowed to stop other students from entering buildings on university campus? I worry about my grandchildren's safety. They attend Jewish day schools.
- Norman Gardner (Jewish War Veterans of Canada)
When doctors identify an ailment in a patient they work quickly to deal with the ailment so that it does not hopefully impair the patient, the same holds true for appeasement of illegal demonstrations which include the blocking of traffic which affects emergency vehicles and further impairs members of the public. The fact that some demonstrators have been masked while demonstrating in front of businesses , blocked traffic, made hateful remarks and allowed to do so without police making arrests and charging them for their law breaking activity has only reinforced them to continue these obstructionist and illegal activities. The result has been more confrontation, more police activities, a huge increase in the police budget as well as endangerment for the public and the police. If the police do not act to deter these confrontational situations it is likely that some members of the public may act due to frustration and anger at being subjugated to what they feel is discriminatory acts that endanger themselves. It is time to deal effectively with these demonstrators who mask themselves and have accosted members of the public and police. The community deserves security, it deserves law and order and it deserves action against bigotry. It deserves police to act in accordance with the principles of delivering public safety. Respectfully
Norman Gardner - Jack Gemmell (Policing Committee of the Law Union of Ontario)
- Shaalee Sone
Toronto has been my home for my whole life. It has now become so unsafe for me that I have started planning how to leave when I need to.
I have been disappointed by the way police stand and protect protesters who are spewing hate speech at Jews (coded as Zionists). The Toronto police need to act and protect citizens against hate speech.
One avenue of improvement is to teach officers what slogans are hate speech, including in English and Arabic. For example, there have repeatedly been flags of terrorist organisations at protests, yet they are in Arabic so the officers are not aware.
I appreciate that the police are requesting this call for advice. It gives me hope that you will actually make Toronto safer for me. - Nicole Corrado
Download file
Please do not police peaceful protests. People have a right to free speech and voice their opinion. It is a democracy. If no one is being injured, let the protesters be. A board should be consisting solely of civilians who are not police officers or employees of police or military. This board needs to be neutral. Nicole Corrado - Rosalie Moscoe
I am concerned about police and if they are receiving enough information about laws regarding hate speech, updated training about how to calm inciting antisemitism and maintaining public order. Hate speech is not free speech. Police need to take action. Please update police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. Are encampments on universities, blocking of streets illegal? If so, can't police do anything about it- to stop it? Public safety in universities and elementary schools is important. What are police doing about it. If it's reported police need to come to the school and let them know about democracy and that all should be welcomed! Masking one's identity should not be allowed in demonstrations. Why should they get away with hate crimes? This is not Iran. Education of police force is important and proper training of police in various situations of hate speech, crimes and intimidation. Students need to feel safe.
- Ken Kadonoff
I would like to see a stronger police response to the many protests throughout the city. Often, these protests are intrusive and interfere with the normal daily events that citizens need to function in their daily lives. Interference with access to public spaces and universities should not be tolerated and police resources need to improve. It appears that more training is appropriate so that police are educated on their range of responses to these protests. Under no circumstances, should anyone be allowed to be masked while protesting in public spaces. Also, the abnormally high number of protests occurring seem to be designed to inflict hate and antisemitism. The pro-Palestinian participants appear militant and organized to cause further disruption. Conducting prayers in public places should not be tolerated since there are many available venues for religion to be practiced. This should not be imposed on citizens of other faiths. Overall, I would like to see a stronger police response that contributes to the safety of minority groups, and makes them more comfortable as they go vote their regular lives.
- Brian Silverman
- Joanne Goldman
I am grateful to the Toronto police services over the past 11 months in their work to protect the Jewish community during a period of significant rise in antisemitic incidents. Given continued problems and concerns, I am hopeful that the following actions can be taken to further ensure the safety of all Toronto citizens, including Jewish citizens who are increasingly being targeted by hate crimes:
1. Further police training about laws that govern protest management to ensure that laws to maintain peace and order everywhere, including major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods are enforced.
2. Support police to identify hate speech and adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. Police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement is necessary to achieving this goal.
3. Provide police with the resources to ensure safe access zones around places of worship, schools and community services agencies.
4. Ensure resources and training for police to enable them to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests.
Thank you for the opportunity to inform policy recommendations. - Allison Scanlan
As a condominium owner downtown Toronto (University/Adelaide) , our Police Station is 255 Dundas Street West. The number of police at this station has not changed in over 10 years. With the increase in crime and homeless encampments and begging in the area,I believe another 50 officers would be welcome.
It is sad to see the decline in business, the culture shift to one of fear amongst those of us who live and love downtown. I am afraid to take the subway, afraid to walk at night . The area is filthy - and the island parks in the middle of University are no longer safe to walk with my grandchildren and dogs.
The protests downtown on the weekends are frightening. I have seen such angry mobs. My condo building goes into lockdown.
I love to breakfast at Cafe Landwer on University on the weekend but have stopped doing so for fear of Palestinian protests. Dundas square and the Eaton Center are also regular spots that I have stopped visiting.
We recently walked to the Well with the grandchildren, and had several bad interactions with mentally disturbed individuals. One was completely pantless urinating on a planter outside a building at 2 in the afternoon.
i dont feel safe in my home. I am seriously considering moving out of the downtown core. - Nicole Corrado
Download file
Please do not police peaceful protests. People have a right to free speech and voice their opinion. It is a democracy. If no one is being injured, let the protesters be.
A board should be consisting solely of civilians who are not police officers or employees of police or military. This board needs to be neutral.
Nicole Corrado - Adam Cohen
Freedom of speech is but one Canadian core value. And the ability of one to exercise this right does not preclude someone from breaking other laws in the process. In fact I believe that when you are breaking the law, your right to free speech is no longer a fundamental right.
Speech that incites hatred, misinformation, violence to all groups (antisemitism is at it's worst) have no place in Canada. To protect Canadian values, peace abiding citizens need the police to protect them. And the police need to be provided with the proper tools which includes proper training and funding to identify hate, especially to the Jewish community at this time.
There must be a zero tolerance policy in this or the police will appear weak in the eyes of pro-hating protestors.
As well, all Canadians should be held accountable for their actions. Using masks to conceal crimes is unacceptable but has become the norm in daily protests and is a slap in the face to the police and all law abiding citizens.
Freedom of speech is not an excuse to shut down public roads, disturb the peace, promote hate, etc.
The above are core values to protecting on our streets and to safeguard a free and democratic city and country. - JEFA Executive (Jewish Educators and Family Association of Canada)
- Tal Milman
Dear Toronto police services,
Thank you for taking the time for an open consultation from the public. I write with concern around protest in our city over the last 10 months. There seems to be a significant disparity between how certain groups are treated versus others. It appears to me that the rise in antisemitism in the city as demonstrated by open bomb threats against Jewish institutions, burning of Jewish businesses, shootings at Jewish storefronts and synagogues, and the assault of Jewish school children is largely being swept under the rug. While I appreciate that, these occurrences may be challenging to prosecute and interrogate, they are a direct assault on not only Jewish people, but every single person in the city. Meanwhile, we have seen aggressive policing of so-called "Islamophobia and anti-Palestinian hatred" occurrences. This is test are clear that antisemitism is on a much more significant rise than any other form of ethnically targeted hatred in the country. And yet it does not feel that it is getting nearly the same attention that other groups are receiving and also rightfully deserve. Casein point, photographed individuals Counter protesting at the March for Israel, performing the Nazi salute and wearing flags and paraphernalia that support terrorist organizations. University campuses, anti-Jewish groups are selectively targeting Jewish Organization information booths With loudspeakers, and interrogating and scaring away potential Jewish students who want to feel a sense of connection with their community. This has nothing to do with world conflict, this has everything to do with anti-Semitism.
I hope that with this consultation, you hear a resounding voice that the city of Toronto needs more from the Toronto police services to protect the Jewish community and demonstrate not just to the Jewish community, but to all ethnic communities that it will stand in support of them and not tolerate hatred. It should show the same degree of support for all groups, not just the one with the most news airtime at the moment.
Sincerely, Tal - David Harding (The Change Lab)
- Jennifer Baer (None)
- Linda Silver (Community)
Inexcusable for rallies to intimidate, threaten. Harass etc. the Hillel university campus at tmu was surrounded by protesters - this is a threatening act. The protesters should be arrested for aggressive, intimidating potentially violent behaviour. " Bullying " behaviour would not be tolerated and appropriate laws applied
Gatherings with anti Jew slurs, signs etc should be treated as racist behaviour and appropriate laws applied .
Protests at Jewish community events intended to disrupt cultural or religious gatherings should be disallowed. Appropriate charges applied .
The anti Jew bullying behaviour of the protesters is intolerable and has gone largely unchecked.
The protest are not just anti Israel - they are anti Jew. If it's just against Israel then it would be restricted to the Israeli consulate and not religious institutions, religious schools, cultural events etc
Enough is enough- these are hate crimes and should be treated as such to the full extent of the law. - Aaron Peters (Concerned Parent)
To Whom It May Concern: Thank you very much for facilitating community consultation on this very important topic.
I am member of the Toronto Jewish community and over the past year there have been significant security issues at my childrens' school and at our family's synagogue. TPS has been indispensable at ensuring our safety at these institutions. We are so very grateful for the leadership and support provided by TPS. Sadly, these security threats are not abating and we continue to need and rely upon TPS support and resources. As a result, I urge TPS to maintain their focus on these institutions.
Furthermore, I believe that any protests that enter into Jewish neighbourhoods should be treated as unlawful assembly and should be enforced under the existing laws in the Criminal Code.
Thank you so very much for your consideration of this submission and for TPS's ongoing commitment to ensuring the security not only of the Jewish community but of the overall Toronto community. - Canadian Union of Jewish Students (Canadian Union of Jewish Students)
- Danielle
With all due respect for our constitutional rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly of all people we need to ensure community safety and preserving the peace by providing a safe place for protests. The size and frequency of the protests are causing chaos on downtown mobility and the economy. Effective policies, a dedicated place, and increased funding for our police will provide respect and understanding for the people and better way to manage their assembly.
- Pamela Bader (Luxury International Real Estate Inc.)
Please do not permission for any protest in downtown. It creates a lot of chaos and problems. It disturbes work and life of living in downtown
- Gail
I agree with the submissions of ALCAA, the Alliance of Canadians Combatting Anti-Semitism. More must be done to preserve public order in Toronto, to prevent hate speech, specifically hatred of Jewish people, and to ensure that Jewish people and their allies are safe in our wonderful city. Hate speech, encampments, and the exclusion of Jews in our City must be stopped without further delay. Please keep Toronto safe for everyone, including Jewish people.
- Michele Breslin
As a member of Toronto's Jewish community, I am alarmed by the rise in antisemitic protests, vandalism, and targeted demonstrations that have made many of us feel unsafe in our own neighbourhoods and institutions. The Toronto Police Service Board's (TPSB) Public Order Policy consultation is a critical opportunity for our community to demand stronger protections.
We appreciate the dedication and hard work of the TPS in maintaining public safety, often under challenging circumstances. We recognize that the members of the TPS face significant obstacles, including political pressures that can sometimes limit their ability to act decisively. Despite these challenges, their commitment to protecting all communities in Toronto, including ours, does not go unnoticed. We understand that the complexities of managing protests and maintaining public order are immense, and we are grateful for their ongoing efforts to keep our city safe. However, to truly safeguard our community, we believe that additional measures must be implemented.
First, the TPS must enforce existing laws more rigorously during protests, particularly in Jewish neighborhoods. Safe access zones around synagogues, schools, and community centers are essential to protect us from harassment and threats.
Second, the line between hate speech and free speech during demonstrations is often blurred. While freedom of expression is a fundamental right, it cannot be a shield for inciting hatred or violence, particularly against the Jewish community. The use of masks to conceal identity during illegal acts, including hate speech, is also deeply troubling. The TPS must enforce strict measures against this and adopt a zero-tolerance policy towards antisemitic slogans, symbols, and language. Enhanced training in antisemitism and hate crime enforcement is crucial for officers to identify and swiftly respond to these threats, with a focus on understanding the historical context and recognizing specific symbols and language used in antisemitic propaganda.
Lastly, the issue of encampments on university campuses, which have frequently become hubs of antisemitic activity, must be addressed. These encampments are not only illegal but also create a hostile environment for Jewish students, who are often the targets of hate speech and intimidation. The TPS should be prepared to collaborate closely with campus security to ensure that these encampments are dealt with swiftly and that the safety of Jewish students is prioritized. This collaboration should include providing the necessary resources and support for campus security to manage such situations effectively.
The Jewish community's safety depends on the TPS taking decisive action. The TPS must vigorously advocate on behalf of our legitimate concerns and implement policies that make us feel secure in our city.
Thank you. Michele Breslin - Charlotte Zigler (Private citizen)
- Jonah Libman
I just wanted to add my concerns about the rule of law. I was born and raised in a Canada as the child of WW2 survivors, who were proud and grateful to call themselves Canadian, where I was taught that the law is the law for everyone. The level of intimidation, violence and vandalism we are witnessing sis unprecedented in my memory, not only because I don't remember such a sustained hatred against one small group of Jewish people, but because nothing seems to be getting done to remedy or address this vile hatred. I am truly concerned for my young grandchildren and the country they are inheriting. Thank you!
- Beth Herst
- Sandford Borins
- Rhonda Moscoe
Dear Toronto Police Force, my grandparents, my parents, myself, my daughter, all lived peacefully in Toronto until 2023. I'm currently in Amsterdam, for two weeks, (yesterday at the Anne Frank museum) where 140,000 Jews lived in 1941, and by 1945, 102,000 were murdered. And it stared with protests. It started with separating Jewish kids at schools, not allowing Jews to walk in certain areas, restricting movement. It started with signs. In Toronto on st Clair ave, a block from my house , I see signs saying " F-uck the Jews" . My daughter's school at Harbord and Ossington has swastikas, etched into the desks, walls. Can you imagine me walking with a sign that says "f-ck the Syrians , "(because their leader killed 500,000 people.? What would you do? So why are protesters allowed to keep people off university campuses. A crime . But allowed. Why are the perpetrators masked. ? Though it's not allowed. Why is this tolerated? Where are the police to protect me? My daughter? If force by the police are not shown now, it will be out of control. Why are muslims allowed to block traffic at Dundas and Yonge, put their mats down and pray , and block traffic. I'm in Europe now. We are told not to show a Jewish star on our necks, we are told not to speak Hebrew in the streets. I'm home in 2 days. But I know this is coming to Canada in the next year, this is our future. So please train your forces, on what hate speech is. "Globalize the intifada" means blow up Jews. Kill them. That is hate speech. Last week 100 Jewish institutions received bomb threats across Canada. There has been shooting through school building. What was done? Nothing!!!!!
Please disband protests on university campuses, now, not later, on private property, which is illegal. Why is nothing done? If not now, then when? What starts with the Jews. Does not end with the Jews. It's pure hate. Hate is taught. Hate festers. Please make sure the police force is educated on radicals. This is the beginning. I saw a protest in Dam Square yesterday in Amsterdam. With masked , all dressed in black people, shouting. 5 min walk to the old Jewish quarter. And you know what, the police came in with guns, and dismantled it. Pushed them out of the square. I'm here in the future. And the future is scary. I can't wait to come home in two days, but hoping you can change things now. So my future in Toronto is not scary. So my daughter can walk freely on her choice of university campus in a year. This is our right as Canadian citizens. We live peacefully, and deserve to exist peacefully like every other Canadian. Thank you. - M Krik (None)
Our expectations are quite simple: police need to enforce the law. Period. Regardless of what cause the protesters have taken up, or whether they have been there protesting for 1 hour, 1 day, or longer. As downtown residents, we are so tired of having our streets blocked, our buildings defaced, our parks inaccessible, and our safety threatened when we go outside due to these protests. Particularly when the majority of protesters do not live in downtown Toronto. We are also so frustrated watching valuable police resources consumed by simply babysitting and, by their lack of action, enabling the protests. The right to free speech does not include the right to occupy and encamp.
- Jonathan Born
Freedom of speech is a fundamental Canadian value. However, calling for the genocide of Jews, including through euphemisms, is not protected speech. Supporting groups that call for the genocide of Jews including terrorist organizations such as the Taliban, ISIS, Hamas and Hezbollah is not protected speech. To protect Canadian society, we must ensure that our police receive the training to identify anti-semitic and genocidal speech. We must also ensure police have training and the necessary funds to enforce laws to hold perpetrators to account for committing crimes, for which there should be zero tolerance. There must also be a political will at all levels of government to actually enforce the law, which is currently lacking. There cannot be two-tiered policing and the propensity of a group or groups toward violence should not be a limiting factor on the police's willingness to enforce the law. Police must have the resources to ensure that children can attend school safely and to ensure that individuals and families can attend community venues without worry of threats of violence or terrorism. Using masks to conceal identities while committing a criminal offense must not be tolerated. Police must have the resources and training and be supported by political will to enforce laws with respect to illegal protests, encampments and blockades. The well-being of our society requires our police to have funding, training and support of politicians to combat the increasing threats from individuals and groups supporting and promoting antisemitism, violence, genocide and terrorism.
- Stephen Tanny
- Gabrielle Levinson
The antisemitism in Toronto is beyond appalling and concerning. Quite tragically, the petrifying antisemitism in Toronto that we have ALL experienced has come up in conversation multiple times a day with my fellow Jewish Torontonians. The basis of our concerns is really quite simple - we want to stop living in fear on a daily basis to show our Judaism and ultimately, worrying about our safety and future in Canada. Consequently, the priorities that we suggest include: 1. Make protests against Israel illegal, and follow through on punishments for those that plan or attend protests. Somehow, it seems like antisemitism is allowed to be defined by everyone EXCEPT Jews. When we say that anti-Zionism feels synonymous with antisemitism, we do not say it lightly. It is not up for debate that anti-Israel protests is more than intimately linked with antisemitism and makes us very fearful. For example, the protest that took place at Union Station today (August 29th) where people were chanting "Free Palestine. There is only one solution: Intifada revolution" is extremely scary. I need to take a train tomorrow morning and will need to enter the area of Via Rail trains from the entrance that the protest took place today. I am fearful that a protest of the like will happen tomorrow for my safety, and for my emotional well-being as hearing the promotion of mass murder of Jews saddens and terrifies me to my core - as it should for any human being. There is a fine line between hate speech and freedom of speech and with no debate, anti-Israel protests are people using their freedom of speech to spew hate speech. Hate speech is illegal - treat it as such, including when it is towards Jews. With all candour, we do not feel like a priority and frankly, we feel like we have mostly been ignored by Toronto and the Toronto police.
2. Create more protection for Toronto Jews. Add more security to places of Jewish worship and schools. We do not wear kippahs or even small Star of David necklace pendants in public. We should at least be able to do so in these locations - if we do not get the privilege of everywhere else.
Thank you. - Gail McGregor
Protests blocking sidewalks and roadways are a safety hazard. Oftentimes protesters are aggressive and it can be dangerous to find yourself in the middle surrounded by masked people. No one should be allowed to conceal their identity which perhaps allows them to behave differently than if they can be identified. Anti Semitic rhetoric invites acts of aggression against Jews. Chanting slogans that call for the extermination of the Jewish people is hate speech and not free speech. The protestors have had little to no consequences and are acting with impunity. Please enforce the law and hold protestors accountable.
- Gloria
- Gale Borison-Socken
Over the last 10 months it has become increasingly more difficult to go about life as a law abiding Canadian Jew living in Toronto. With the rapid rise in antisemitism, I no longer feel safe frequenting any Jewish institutions, schools, stores or any Jewish public spaces. This has made life very stressful for myself and members of my family. Therefore, the first priority for me is the restoration of a sense of safety. I also feel that protesters and demonstrators should have to stand back from entrances to Jewish or other public spaces so that ordinary law abiding citizens can enter or leave these places without being harassed, threatened or hampered in any way. The next priority for me protection of Jewish students from primary school through University. Hate-filled encampments should not be permitted to foment antisemitism rhetoric or in any way harass students as they attempt to persue their studies. Toronto has long been known as a city of neighbourhoods—I hope we can one day soon return to a more tolerant and inclusive way of life for all law abiding Torontonians.
- David Freudenstein
- Jenn Green
As a mother of 2 Jewish children, and the granddaughter of a Holocaust survivor, I live in constant fear of my children's safety. Knowing the dangers of what happens with antisemitism is not adequately addressed in society makes me fearful for the lives of my 2 and 5 year old children in the current climate.
I am so grateful for the support from TPS for the Jewish community. I am so grateful that the police have shown up for us.
My fears surround the safety of our religious institutions and Jewish schools. The constant attacks, be it graffiti, bomb threats, arson, shooting, is all too much.
I want to thank you for the support to date, and ask that (1) increased vigilance be paid to our religious institutions and schools and (2) that when people are breaking the laws at rallies or in the streets, promoting terror and supporting terrorists, that they be treated as law breakers. When people get away with these things it emboldens other people to do the same.
Thank you most sincerely, Jenn - Joel Shupac (n/a)
I wish to express my respect and gratitude to the Toronto Police for their conscientious and dedicated service in protecting the public in a difficult time, and for their exemplary adherence to the democratic ideals which are the strength and glory of our country. The suggestions which follow are made in the spirit of enhancing and strengthening our liberal democratic order:
1. There should be zero tolerance for hate speech, which is the precursor to ideologically motivated violence. This includes blanket statements such as 'All Zionists are racists' and 'All Zionists are evil', as well as statements and chants calling for genocide and all statements demonizing a religious or ethnic group. When the police sees or hears such statements arrests should be made.
2. Being masked in the commission of a crime is itself a crime and should be treated as such, as it obstructs the apprehension of criminal acts.
3. Wearing the insignia of a terrorist organization which has been designated as such by the law in Canada should be treated as an offence as constituting providing support to such organizations and fulfilling their criminal objects.
4. There should be zero tolerance for actions interfering with public enjoyment of public spaces and rights of way as well as with the enjoyment of private property rights. This includes demonstrations and public prayer in public spaces and occupations and encampments on private property such as that belonging to schools, colleges and universities.
5. Demonstrations should not be permitted adjacent to or near houses of worship, community institutions or hospitals, nor in residential areas which have concentrations of population of targeted groups, as such demonstrations constitute intimidation of said groups. Such demonstrations should properly take place outside public buildings such as legislatures and consulates.
6. Recognizing that police must always exercise operational discretion in policing demonstrations and protests and that police resources are strained by the large number of such events, it is submitted that energetic enforcement of the law as proposed above would likely result in fewer and more law abiding demonstrations and protests.
Thank you for your attention and consideration of these submissions. - Beth Herst
- Paul Resnick
Thank you for this opportunity to provide views on a new Police Board Policy on Public Order. Unfortunately, since October 7, 2023, the citizens of Toronto have been subjected to an unprecedented increase in the percentage of incidents of hate speech against Jewish people in public demonstrations across Canada. To best protect the safety of all Canadians, police must adopt a zero tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. If it is too onerous to train the entire police force to best recognize and respond to these incidents (focused on enforcement of hate crime and antisemitism), then I suggest that the Board recommend a special task force of officers to take the requisite updated training. This training should include the true meaning of certain sayings and symbols that are used by protesters and are an obvious threat to the safety of the community. Members of this force can then attend each public demonstration and enforce the laws, as appropriate. The Police should receive the support, funding and training necessary to assist Campus Security when called to manage encampments and protests on University property. Lastly, I support police training re: laws that govern protest management, particularly in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighborhoods.
Thank you. - Sanya Cvetanovic
First, I have to say that I strongly opposed to the crazy idea that some of the City councillors had few years ago and that is to reduce funding for the Toronto Police. Second, I appreciate what in general Toronto Police does for the City of Toronto.
However, I was disappointed with the lack of response by the Toronto Police during pro-Hamas, pro-terrorist, anti-Jewish demonstrations all over the City.
To clarify: I am not Jewish. What a bad state of the society is if we have to say what is our ethnic background to be treated differently!
In short: I don't feel safe in this City since October of the last year.
Police and politicians allowed masses of aggressive people to rule the streets of the Toronto, to block traffic, to prevent for days TTC to operate some lines along their whole route, to harass for months neighbourhoods, intimidate people on the streets, in the restaurant, damage businesses, schools, and call for jihad, and direct support of the terrorist groups.
Finally, it is super disappointing that both Police and politicians have double standards: there was one standard for treating peaceful protesters in 2020 and 2021, and another standard for treating these aggressive pro-terrorist, anti-Jewish, anti-Israel protesters.
What these terrorist supporters have been doing in Toronto since last October has nothing to do with their freedom to protest. By allowing to continue this aggressive harassment of the City by these terror supporters, City of Toronto and Toronto Police sent a wrong message to these terror supporters. That message is: just continue what you are doing, police will not take any measures against you.
Sincerely, Sanya Cvetanovic - Nita Patel (N/A)
I believe in Canadians having the right to protest. However, I do not think protestors should be allowed to mask and thus hide their identity. Masked protestors are more likely to engage in behaviour which threatens the safety of the public: From hate speech to physical intimidation. If your cause and actions are just, masking to hide your identity is unnecessary, in my opinion.
Also,
Protestors should not be allowed to block roads, and intersections㠼㸵especially in larger centres like Toronto where traffic is already an issue. Ambulances and emergency vehicle need to be able to get through the city as efficiently as possible.
Lastly, protestors who raise flags of terrorist organizations (as listed by Canada), as well as use the hakenkruz should be arrested/removed from the protest. Failure to do so further emboldens protestors and makes a mockery of what our country stands for. - Janice Socket
- Anita Gutterman
My concern is for Jewish schools, synagogues, and other identifying Jewish institutions, they should be protected from vandalism and anti Jewish protestors. I know the politicians didn't vote it unlawful however more of a police presence would be a deterrent. Demonstrators who block traffic, and spew hate are of equal concern. When the Truckers did this they were charged and in Toronto they were stopped altogether. Hopefully something can be done about this. Each time they successfully pull it off , it empowers them and our politicians are persuaded by them, which makes the situation worse!
- Steven Sofer
First, I want to thank the police for all that they do. While it is a shame that their presence is necessary, their presence has made it safer to attend certain community events and religious services.
I believe that the police could do more to keep our community safer if they enforced the laws that do exist - including with respect to hate speech, trespass and vandalism. If the police are being told by politicians not to enforce the law, they should tell us who tells them. If the police are making the decision on their own not to enforce the law, they should tell us.
Free speech, including disruptive protests, are fundamental freedoms. When these freedoms are exercised in a manner that violates the law, the police must step in.
I recognize that the line between legal and illegal protest is not always an easy one to draw. It just appears that recently the police have erred on the side of not enforcing the law. As a result, Toronto is not as safe a place as it should be. I believe the police want to do their job. It is imperative that they do. - Tamara M
Please crack down on these hate fests. I no longer feel safe in my own city. This would not be permitted for any other group. Jews, most of whom support Israel, are constantly confronted with hate and harassment. The anti Israel protests should be confined to the embassy and not be allowed in our neighborhoods, schools and synagogues. Jew hate is festering and we need people to be held accountable.
- Nick Fairhead
I believe citizens should have the right to protest, an important feature of modern Western countries... However, if such protests are openly in support of known terrorist organizations, then they should be banned for spreading hateful speech & ideologies. Their members should also be watched as potential dissidents, or worse, agents for violent foreign Governments. If in their protests they are infringing on local citizens Rights (such as stopping students from attending classes), or calling for violence against another group, then these things should immediately be considered unsafe and criminal acts. Protesting causes should not act as intimidation tactics.
- Zach Lieberman
I'd like to begin by thanking TPS and its officers for doing tremendous work -- often involving many additional hours of overtime and in tense, challenging situations -- to try to keep the Jewish community (and all citizens of Toronto, more broadly) safe and enforce the law within the bounds of the current framework.
As a proud Jewish person, born and raised in Toronto, I believe there needs to a change in by-laws, laws, and how they are enforced, to ensure our city remains a safe, respectful place for all people, regardless of faith, creed, ethnicity, identity, and the like. And that includes Jewish people and Zionists.
As it stands now, there have been far too many incidents of intimidation, hate speech, hate-motivated actions, and violence targeting the Jewish community and Zionists than are acceptable in any democratic, respectful, well-functioning society.
A few examples include: - People walking through predominately Jewish and Zionist neighbourhoods, disturbing the peace and intimidating residents with hateful chants, signs, and physical confrontations with verbal threats of violence - People wearing full face coverings, blocking major intersections, carrying signs and/or flags of registered terrorist organizations, and/or with statements and/or chants that promote hatred and/or incite violence (e.g. "there is only one solution, intifada revolution"; "globalize the intifada", "we don't want two states, we want all of it") - People surrounding Jewish and/or Zionists in public or private spaces, preventing their movement and/or access to buildings or otherwise open spaces, unless they denounce their beliefs
The lack of immediate action to shut down such activities has created an environment where such behaviour is now deemed acceptable, and hate has grown out of control.
There should be zero tolerance for anyone who participates in such activities. Full stop.
I am fully in support of the submission made by the ALCAA to rectify the situation. And I trust that the TPS and other stakeholders will take this matter seriously and act immediately to ensure Toronto remains a great city. - Kevin Elliott
I live and work downtown. These constant protests have changed the City . Not only is this hurting all businesses downtown but they are disrupting my life and giving me one more reason to move out of the downtown core. My mother lived in Oakville until her death in June and because of these protests there were several times I was unable to leave my building by car to see her. Those missed visits are now regretfully gone forever. This tolerance I had for these groups is fading fast as the majority is asked far too often to put their plans on hold while these groups march defiantly through our streets. This is not the Canada I remember .Enough already.
- Annie
- Amy Fernandes (n/a)
I have the utmost respect for all members of the Toronto police service but I do believe that some additional measures should be implemented in the public order policies going forward. 1. Education of officers in recognizing what hate speech consists of. 2. Immediate arrest of anyone committing a criminal offence in the presence of an officer.
- Marcia Pinchefsky (CIJA)
I, like many others, am concerned about safety on university campuses and public schools. Encampments at universities here in Toronto and elsewhere have been the source of hate speech (speech / slogans / symbols) directed toward Jewish and Israeli Canadian students. There should be resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests. While the right to protest is constitutionally protected in Canada, that right is not absolute and so not all protest gatherings are legal. It is important to note as well that hate speech is NOT protected at protests. Similarly, actions like obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business. Since it IS an offence to conceal one's identity while committing a criminal offence, masked protestors who are engaging in hate speech or that remain masked when a protest transitions into an illegal riot are guilty of an offence. Police should exercise a zero-tolerance approach when it comes to any form of hate speech at a public demonstration (with an additional charge if they're also wearing a mask). While police do receive some training on antisemitism and hate speech, this may not have been sufficient. I support and advocate for police receiving additional resources that may be required to support antisemitism and hate crime enforcement training. That training should include specific content regarding how to address the presence of antisemitism and acts motivated by hate as part of public demonstrations. This includes understanding the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech being able to identify the tactics and symbols and slogans used in hate speech and propaganda. The police must know where the line is and be ready to hold perpetrators to account for their actions. To be clear, inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group ARE severe offences and must be dealt with accordingly. There should be a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. There must be adequate and appropriate updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement.
- Mary Throop
- Erika Rubin
In general I think the police need to do a better job distinguishing between speech and action. People need to given great latitude to express their thoughts - to say things even if these things are offensive or distasteful to others. However, too many demonstrations that have been allowed by the police to continue have not been about speech - they have been about action - blocking intersections and roads, blocking access to buildings and facilities, and bringing mobs into neighborhoods to intimidate residents, screaming into people's faces. Too often the police have prioritized the rights of demonstrators over the rights of the public and the community. The police need to be both more creative and more forceful in preventing demonstrators from gathering in places that infringe on the broader community's rights of access and freedom of movement and moving them when they do. They need to preserve demonstrators right to gather, speak, demonstrate - but to make sure they are doing so in locations and places that do not make the community feel unsafe. This was done extremely effectively at UJA's walk for Israel. As well, masking should be prohibited. As a society, this encourages people to say and do things they don't want to be held accountable for. Many jurisdictions ban the masks and Toronto should be no different.
- Kim Shannon (Sionna Investment Managers)
On top of the daily challenges of more people living in the core with less available roads due to construction, bicycle lanes, illegally stopped vehicles, we additionally have regular protests blocking events and road ways. As a result, even though I chose to live in Cabbagetown and Moorepark because I wanted the convenience of easily accessing and using what used to be a fabulous city, I find myself loath to bother venturing around my chosen city. I am finding myself heading north to my country home and dining and socializing up there more frequently. It's much less frustrating. This is a loss of business and tax revenue for the city.
- Nathan Leipciger
Hi Toronto Police Community,
My name is Nate Leipciger and I am a Holocaust survivor.
I know what it feels like to be attacked by hate motivated bullies. It is completely unacceptable that our great grandchildren should be attacked for who they are.
I believe the best in our community and I hold onto hope that these attackers do not realize the crime they are committing nor do school administrators understand the grievous nature of what they are enabling.
For me, police presence in our schools would be welcomed as an immediate short term solution. What needs to be done, in my opinion, is to create a police educational team to go to each school and teach our students the advantages and freedoms inherent in democracy as opposed to totalitarian rule. With the advantage and freedoms come responsibilities which include respect for the law and right of all people to be free of prejudice and harassment. This has to apply to all.
The importance of mutual respect and acceptance must be introduced as a given in a free and democratic society. It must be emphasized in the presentations what is unacceptable behaviour in our society, and that acting against these will be punishable by prescribed penalties which includes expulsion from school and even criminal detention. I believe that students want to do the right thing and it is incumbent upon us to help them do so.
Mutual acceptance (rather than tolerance which is temporary and negative) among our students and adherence to the principles of a free and democratic society is the only true solution to jew hatred, and indeed all forms of hatred.
For generations we have put our trust in you, please don't let us down now.
Sincerely,
Nathan Leipciger - Ari
I suggest two priorities for the Service:
1) Ensure protest is not used as camouflage for targeted intimidation of specific groups of people. There is likely a difference in the intent of a protest held at Queen's Park versus next door to a religious institution.
2) Ensure protest does not become accepted as justification for illegal activities (such as blocking roads, graffiti or harassment) 㤼㸶 the general public should witness that the same rules are being applied to protesters as everyone else. - Adrian Butscher
I am not well-versed in the law or even the correct terminology for the definition and maintenance of "public order" in Canada. I am an ordinary citizen; and I am concerned that protests and occupations 㤼㸷 especially those occurring since 7 October and related to the war in Gaza 㤼㸷 have crossed a line. It is not appropriate for protest groups to occupy public places and de-facto public places (e.g. university campuses) for extended periods of time, or to engage in speech that borders and crosses over into hate speech and/or support for terrorist organizations and terrorist practices. I myself have witnessed swastikas displayed at an anti-Israel / pro-Palestine protest, and have seen congratulatory words in support of rapes and murders committed on 7 October in Israel. There is no place for this kind of repugnant protest in Canadian society. Furthermore, it clearly has a propagandistic and political element that promotes the interests of political forces inimical to our society (e.g. Hamas, Iran's theocratic government). This too is unacceptable.
I would expect to see police practices that prioritize the following: - protests with permits - enforcing noise limits - signage and slogans must remain well within the bounds provided by hate speech laws - protests must remain peaceful and in no way incite violence - no occupations - disclosure of funding sources and organizing groups - laying charges when illegal activities have taken place
Thank you. - Sheryl Skopit
The antisemitic rhetoric, vandalism of Jewish community spaces, the targeting of Jewish-owned businesses, constant protests, and encampments over the past 11 months have impacted my ability to live my life, my mental health, and my sense of safety.
In recognizing that the police are responsible for enforcing laws to maintain peace and order, I believe that it is crucial that they be provided with adequate resources enabling them to do so, and that police receive specific training in the following areas:
- about the laws (and enforcement of those laws) that govern protest management, particularly those protests that impact major intersections and predominantly jewish neighbourhoods; ensuring that protests are not allowed to obstruct traffic or prevent people from going about their business and for the imposition of safe zones around places of worship, schools and community services; - in what constitutes antisemitism and for hate crime enforcement; - for identifying and quickly responding to hate speech/incitement of hate for which there should be zero tolerance. Including extra charges when such speech is being conducted by those hiding behind masks; - for assisting campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests, and for managing protests at all school levels; and - for identifying tactics and symbols representing hate propaganda.
It is of utmost importance that all individuals living and working in the City of Toronto feel safe and protected while going about their daily lives. It is my hope that the police will be provided with the resources and training required to execute their lawful duties in a manner that meets the expectations and values of the community. Thank you. - Stephanie Michelle
- Edit Kuper/ Pinchus Gutter (Canadian Jewish Holocaust Survivors & Descendants)
Download file
August 29, 2024
The Canadian Jewish Holocaust Survivors and Descendants (CJHSD) represents Holocaust Survivors and their offspring. This is a cohort of older Canadian adults who have lived through and somehow managed to survive the physical privation or verbal attacks on their person and the decimation of whole communities by the German Nazi Regime of Hitler in a variety of countries. Post-Holocaust some were fortunate enough to be allowed to emigrate to Canada, many to Toronto and begin new lives here. While the memories of their traumas of loss and abuse remained vivid, they managed to raise families and build new lives. Most of their descendants carry within them elements of the legacy of their Holocaust survivor parents and of that dark history of the decimated communities from which their families arose. They remember the stories of how hate had developed into mass murder even among close neighbours. 1. The top priority is to Train Officers to understand Jewish history. One of the most effective ways is to have police officers hear from Holocaust survivors or some of their descendants. This will clearly demonstrate how and why most Toronto Jews are so affected and nervous in the current antisemitic climate.
2. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech. There is a difference between Hate Speech and Free Speech. All violent movements, including the Holocaust began and begin with words. Antisemitism is also expressed through words. Therefore, there should be Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech in written or verbal form or for Hate Symbols.
3. School Public Safety Is a priority. Our community's greatest treasures are our children, not only those in pre-school, elementary grades and high school but also at universities. We must have them absolutely protected at all costs from hate AND any harmful actions by antisemites
4. Protection of Jewish Institutions: Toronto Jewish institutions, which have been built and cherished for several generations. must be protected from antagonists who wish to harm them or their attendees. Most survivors and other Jewish adults are fearful of attending prayer services or events there.
5. The Encampments: When Holocaust Survivors see the encampments and intimidation and protests, it reminds them of their own past incarceration.
6. Support for Israel: The only country with Jews as leaders is Israel, which is a small state created post Holocaust and has less than 10 million citizens (9,387,021) of which 2 million are Moslem. There are many Arab countries with 464.68 million people and most of their citizens are of the Moslem faith. So it is not surprising that the 335,295 Canadians who identify as Jews, feel support for Israel, although not all necessarily agree with each of its current policies.
We hope these items will help The Toronto Police Service Board in planning.
Pinchus Gutter, Edit Kuper Co- Presidents. CJHSD - Stephanie Michelle
- Eleanor Fish, CM (personal)
I urge the Toronto Police Service to have a more visible presence around Jewish schools, synagogues and in Jewish neighborhoods during those times when we have seen acts of vandalism and hatred. Routine patrolling during these hours - generally at night- will go a long way to deter this antisemitism. Knowing that the Toronto Police force is there to serve and protect all communities, regardless of religion is essential. I urge the Toronto Police Service Board to decry these antisemitic acts - openly to the media.
- Howard Geoffrey Bockner
For too long certain groups who claim "victim" status have been bullying individual Jews and Jewish businesses and institutions in this City. When this happens the objective rule of law erodes and street mobs believe they can do whatever they want with impunity. Jews are "the canary in the coal mine" so this will not end with Jews. Unfortunately there is a hard core in these "victim" groups that only understand tough measures ie. mass arrests of instigators and their violent followers. Appeasing criminals will only lead to more criminality. Political, religious prejudices and baggage must be parked at Canada's door when entering this country. Therefore our police should be lobbying our federal government to do a much better job at vetting those who want to come here. Our police have done an excellent job over the decades here in Toronto. Let's not let those who want to destroy our freedoms take over. Sincerely, Howard Bockner (Ward 11)
- John bakous
The issues are as such we need only a one tier policing system not a two tier. There should be zero tolerance for any demonstrations in front of any house of worship nor vandalization. Zero tolerance for any out-door prayers that block streets, sidewalks or intimidate people. There must be zero tolerance for any demonstrations that block traffic or commandeer any building. It is not acceptable to wear a disguise while demonstrating. We have competing issues while the police want to and should maintain order the politicians wish not to offend in any manner so as not to have issues coming up for the next election.
- Sequoia McDowell
Hello,
As a resident of East Toronto who works downtown and a father of four, one of whom is a student at University of Toronto, I am alarmed and concerned at what seems to be a tolerance for lawlessness, vandalism, and ethnic violence in and around our city. Tolerating regular takeovers of the street, especially by groups of religious or political radicals, emboldens these groups and encourages them to escalate to the next level of violence. Lawless mobs braying for violence are followed by vandalism and broken windows, which will be followed by violence against citizens of this city if left unchecked.
At times I am contacted by friends in other countries, asking if what they saw on the news about Toronto (some act of lawlessness, or a pro-Hamas rally) is really happening here. It embarrasses me to have to admit that it is. I moved to this city from the United States seven years ago and have since purchased a house in Riverdale and become a citizen of Canada. I love this country and Toronto, and it pains me to witness what the city is turning into. I am still glad I moved here, but the city feels distinctly less safe and welcoming than it did when I first fell in love with the place within weeks of moving here. I say this as a Jew in particular, but I don't think Hamas supporters taking over the streets and calling for "death to kkkanada" is good for anyone.
Please make clear to Torontonians, Ontarians, and the rest of the world that Toronto is a diverse and welcoming place that is also safe and does not tolerate rallies for ethnic wars and hatred. - Susan Brooks
Police services board Submission: Thank you for the opportunity to make a submission on the following: The principles that should be included in the Board's "Policy on police action in respect of protests, demonstrations and occupations". The priorities the Board should establish including directing the Chief to set procedures愼㸰that allow police to execute their lawful duties in a manner that meets the expectations and values of the community.
Background: This is a very important issue as there are frequent protests in Toronto where protesters engage in behaviour that is threatening towards members of the Jewish community and others and this has created an environment of fear for me and many other people. There have been protests where people have chanted hate speech; targeted Jewish businesses, neighbourhoods and synagogues; made threatening statements; worn or carried symbols of terrorist entities; blocked infrastructure and private property; and engaged in other behaviour intended to create fear and intimidate the community. In many situations, it appears that the protesters have been allowed to engage in this behaviour with no repercussions as few arrests are made. This sends a message that unlawful behaviour is tolerated and leads to an escalation of the behaviour. This situation has been traumatizing for the Jewish community.
For example: Synagogues are being repeatedly vandalized, bomb threats made against Jewish organizations and an 88 year old Jewish man was assaulted at a pro-Israel rally in North York on August 18, 2024. At the Eaton Centre on December 17, 2023, a protester threatened to put someone "six feet under" and the officers present did not arrest him. It was not until February, 2024 that an arrest was made. I understand that police may be concerned that making an arrest may lead to escalation from the crowd. However, making an arrest at a later date does not ensure community safety and is not an effective deterrent as the unlawful behaviour receives extensive news coverage while arrests that are made at a later date receive much less attention. Also, delaying an arrest helps offenders avoid accountability as they usually wear face coverings that make it difficult or impossible to identify them and complicate the investigation and prosecution. On June 11, 2024, masked protestors marched through a Jewish residential area screaming "baby killer" and "filthy Zionist rat" at residents. The Toronto Sun reported that police were there but no arrests made. The reporter stated that the roving mob looked like a militia and that, to those living in the area, what they were witnessing was like something out of a horror movie. It is both terrifying and shocking to see this type of hostility and menacing behaviour towards the Jewish community permitted to take place in Toronto with no repercussions.
Although police have the powers to address unlawful behaviour at protests, it does not appear that these powers are being utilized for the most part. As stated, protesters were permitted to march in a Jewish neighbourhood spewing hate speech without arrest, although it is clear that protesters are not entitled to infringe on the rights of land owners in the lawful use and enjoyment of their property and that breaching the peace and causing a disturbance are offences under the Criminal Code.
I understand that the Office of the Independent Police Review received complaints about police conduct during the G20 summit and found that people's愼㸰Charter愼㸰rights were violated and this has likely influenced policing of protests. However, the pendulum seems to have swung so far in the opposite direction that it appears police are reluctant to take any action against protesters to avoid the risk of violating their "right to protest" even if it means police are not fulfilling their obligations to keep the peace and protect those affected by the protests. As a result, behaviours that would be considered unlawful in any other context are allowed if they are part of a "protest". The primary principle guiding the police seems to be on the need to "respect the rights of protesters" even if their actions violate the law, do not fall within the right to protest and threaten and endanger members of the public. The fear created by these protests has had a significant impact on my life. I have lived in Toronto my whole life and I was never afraid to wear a jewish religious symbol in public. However, I am now afraid and when I take the subway or go to a public place, I cover it up or take it off. I also worry about the safety of family members and friends who wear identifying jewish symbols. As well, I am afraid to attend Jewish community events because of the risk of violence and harassment from those protesting. I understand that, in policing protests, there is a balance between respecting the constitutional rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly while also protecting the public, ensuring community safety and preserving the peace. I see that the police document entitled, Procedure 11-04愼㸰Protests and Demonstrations, has guidance on the rights of citizens and role of police including the following statements:
Police Procedure Chapter 11 㤼㸶 Crowd Control Citizens have the legal right to demonstrate peacefully. However, they are not entitled to infringe on the rights of land owners in the lawful use and enjoyment of their property. The role of the police at these types of incidents must be one of complete neutrality and action should not be taken until the situation has been carefully assessed. Police officers should only become involved when there is a breach of the peace or a violation of provincial and/or federal law, or when there is strong suspicion that such a breach or violation may occur.
Police Officer Upon arrival at the scene of a protest or demonstration shall: become familiar with the circumstances surrounding the incident prevent any breach of the peace ensure persons and vehicles have access to the premises concerned and are not intimidated or interfered with maintain a position of impartiality in dealing with all parties involved
Although the document provides direction on respecting the right to protest, it does not seem to provide direction on when action should be taken to protect the public.
Recommendations: To enable police to keep the peace and execute their duties in a manner that meets the expectations of the community, they should receive receive training and direction on the distinction between protected actions and actions that violate the law. In particular, it should be clear that the right to protest only applies to peaceful assembly, that acts of violence and speech that threaten violence are not protected under the Charter and that there is no right to hold a protest that endangers others, damages property or significantly restricts essential services. Training should also be provided on what constitutes hate speech. For example, "globalize the intifada", which is often chanted, is a call for violence against Jewish people.
The principle guiding police should be that there will be a zero tolerance approach to enforcing the law and that actions that would be considered unlawful outside of a protest will not be tolerated as part of a protest. It should be clear that police have a duty to maintain public order and to protect individuals and society from potential harm and that the right to protest does not override these duties. This means that the laws that limit actions at a protest must be enforced, for example: Under section 175 of the Code, causing a disturbance, for example by impeding others; fighting; screaming; swearing; using obscene language; obstructing people in a public place can lead to an arrest. Under section 31 of the Code, police may arrest people committing a breach of the peace which includes disorderly conduct that disturbs public peace and order. Under s. 63 (1) of the Code, the police can arrest people for unlawful assembly (conduct that causes persons in the area to fear, on reasonable grounds, that they will disturb the peace tumultuously) and any愼㸰person愼㸰who commits this offence while wearing a disguise without a lawful excuse is guilty of an offence.
Protests taking place in residential areas, places of worship and on private property etc. should be immediately dispersed and protesters arrested. There is no legitimate reason to hold protests in these areas. The only purpose is to try to intimidate people which violates the law and interferes with the lawful use and enjoyment of property. Protests can take place at locations such as a consulate or City Hall.
Police should be directed to make arrests at the time of an offence rather than waiting until a later date especially if the offender is wearing a face covering as the law punishes the愼㸰act愼㸰of wearing a mask or other disguise to commit offences.
Police should communicate with the public to make people aware that the right to protest only applies to peaceful assembly and to explain the limits that exist. For example, the Toronto Police should put this information on their website as the Halton Police have done. https://www.haltonpolice.ca/en/staying-safe/demonstrations.aspx. Police should also issue a press release making it clear that the rights of protesters do not override the rights of other members of the public and that a zero tolerance approach to enforcing the law will be followed. From what I have witnessed, protesters are not concerned about repercussions for their actions and appear to believe that behaviour that would not be tolerated outside of a protest will be tolerated at a protest. A different message must be clearly sent to them.
Thank you for considering this submission. - Debbie Elman
- Shoshannah Kashton
I have lived in Toronto my whole life. In fact my mother's side of the family came here in the late 1800's. Escaping the pogroms of Eastern Europe they worked hard and sought to build a life in Toronto.
What we have experienced this year in Toronto is unprecedented and frightening. My son who received a scholarship to attend TMU started the fall semester in September 2023. With a lot of effort made by me to drive him down and pick him up he barely managed to attend. Academically he did fine but the fear he had being on a hostile campus. He felt he had to his Kippah - religious head covering and was extremely careful to make sure his religious fringed under garment was hidden. He felt intimidated and fearful of the pro- Palestinian group on campus who would block escalators,stairwells and hang up hateful posters and scream on campus. To add to his anxiety the area on Victoria street seems to have a homeless group living there and is a place of drug dealing which I witnessed while waiting for him to write an exam. Closer to home our synagogue and school my son attended for high school has been vandalized. A local Jewish student was harassed at a local school. The highway entrance near us was taken over by protesters and recently at Sheppard and Bathurst an 88 year old Jewish man was attacked. Schools and synagogues are on high alert.
This is not the Toronto I grew up in. In the history of the Jewish people in this city we are for the very most part law abiding and good citizens. The encampments and protesters are not. I was raised to be respectful and grateful for the police services. What I see in these protesters is a flagrant disrespect for our city, our western values, the police and our monuments and private property.
When I see the protesters disrespect for WW1 and WW2 monuments, Indigo bookstores, Mount Sinai hospital it is just horrible and unlawful. I really insist that the police take these actions seriously because the Jewish community here is being traumatized. My late Father was a holocaust survivor and while I miss him I am relieved he isn't bearing witness to this hate. My father came here after escaping from communist Romania in the early 1960's. He came with nothing, worked very hard. At one point he represented Ontario on a UN mission. He spent decades helping the M攼㸹tis and aboriginal communities in Ontario. How saddening that the city he loved has let him down. How sad his grandson had to leave university to attend school online because he is afraid.
How incredibly awful we have a mayor who doesn't support the Jewish community. Our community works hard, we have contributed a lot to Toronto financially, in the arts and in our volunteers.
We deserve to be strongly protected. We demand to be protected just like any law abiding citizen should expect.
Those who stand by and don't do anything to stop hate will eventually see the demise of freedom and democracy.
There just has to a respect for the laws and order in society- or we won't have one. - Mike Scott
The rate of targeted hate, antisemitism, and violence to jewish members of the community and city is unacceptable. Conflict in Israel does not warrant these high levels, and the police require additional training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement for support our community. In too many instances, what appear to be peaceful protests become increasingly violent, call for harm targeting jewish people and institutions, and are unacceptable. My children have police in front of their school to protect them - where is this ok? The police need training, and there need to be a zero tolerance definition of hate speech, alongside education and training for the force and staff to keep Torontonians safe. I have reported hate crimes on my lawn, and had to describe to the office WHY this is a hate crime when they asked. Jewish people and the jewish community in general, are being target, and have minimal support from the police
- Jin Huh (Social Planning Toronto (SPT))
- Meryl Rosenthal
Thank you very much for the opportunity to provide input. Firstly, I would like to thank the Toronto Police for all that you are doing through an unprecedented time that places what must be a tremendous amount of stress and responsibility on the Toronto Police. I have had the occasion to be on a number of Jewish community calls with Police representation, and each time have felt reassured by what the Police had to say as well as the professionalism. Additionally, I was very grateful for the significant Police planning and presence at the Walk for Israel. Given the current state and the possibility of protests, hate speech, even violence, I was initially fearful of attending, however, felt comfortable and reassured when I attended a community webinar with Police representation. At the actual event I felt safe and grateful to the Police for enabling 50,000 supporters of Israel to come together. It was an uplifting day of support for Israel and our community and would not have been even remotely possible without the lengths that the Police went to. Since October 7th the increase in anti-semitism and anti-zionism has been both alarming and terrifying. From protests at Jewish businesses and neighbourhoods, to encampments, hateful and violent rhetoric, swastikas and graffiti, to threatening emails sent to hundreds of jewish institutions rs, It is overwhelming and it is here in Toronto which would never have thought that it would be possible. I have always been so proud to live in Toronto, we have a cultural mosaic and have felt it was a city of tolerance and mutual respect. At this point, I am deeply concerned and frightened for my children and grandchild and what the future holds and fervently believe hat the Jewish community should be, as all communities should be, safe to go to places of worship, to schools, and more. At this truly precarious moment in time I feel it is critical to have re-enforced Police resources (can only imagine how thinly spread our current Police force is), and given that this is all unprecedented, to have very clear policy and training for Police on what constitutes antisemitism, hate speech, how to manage protests, how to enforce, and hold perpetrators accountable. I feel that this is an utmost priority - the only way to take steps to restore Toronto to what it once was, a city of tolerance and respect, where all residents can contribute to the city and live peacefully side by side. With many thanks and best regards, Meryl
- Andrea
Please know that I am extremely grateful for the work that the Toronto police have been doing in protecting the Jewish community. I understand that the Toronto Police Service Board is developing a new public order policy on how the police deal with protests, demonstrations and occupations. I believe that Toronto police officers would benefit from having such a policy in place.
Since October 7th, 2023 - as a Canadian member of the Jewish community - I have felt vulnerable. While I believe that everyone is entitled to voice their opinion, when those sentiments approach deliberate hate speech and intimidation, I do not feel safe.
Here are a few examples of circumstances that have made me and my family feel unsafe in Toronto: - While standing quietly at a "free the hostages rally" holding an Israeli flag, individuals walking by shouted within a few inches of my face that I am a murderer and support "genocide". - My daughter and son-in-law were in a delivery room of Mount Sinai hospital in November of 2023. They heard continuous chanting "globalize the intifada", "Zionists are racists" and "free Palestine". Criticizing Israel's political policies is legitimately free speech, however calling to globalize the intifada is dangerous and intimidating. - My daughter has said that she wouldn't wear a Star of David necklace on public transit when she has her young daughters with her for fear that someone may physically assault them. - Palestinian protesters on many occasions have targeted Toronto's Jewish communities including highway overpasses and residential neighbourhoods. - The deliberate targeting and vandalism of Jewish community centers and synagogues.
A policy that clearly defines the difference between protected speech and activities and hateful ones particularly when it comes to anti-Israel and anti-Zionist issues would be helpful to everyone. The policy should encompass the overriding principle of zero tolerance for ALL hate. - Jonathan Pinkus
We need a much higher police presence in Jewish neighborhoods, particularly in or around public schools.
There has been an explosion in anti-semitic hate and violence and in many cases it is going unaddressed and unchallenged. Areas such as Bathurst Manor and Armour Heights would greatly benefit from a significantly increased police presence. People are afraid and this cannot continue. - Mark Sandler, LL.B., LL.D (honoris causa) (Alliance of Canadians Combatting Antisemitism (ALCCA))
- Jordan Saperia
Freedom of speech is a fundamental Canadian value. At the same time, there are reasonable limits on freedom of speech. Calling for the genocide of Jews is not protected speech. Supporting groups that call for the genocide of Jews is not protected speech. To protect Canadian society, we must ensure that our police receive the training to identify anti-semitic and genocidal speech, which means understanding how certain words and phrases indeed constitute anti-semitic and genocidal speech. We must also ensure police have training and the necessary funds to enforce laws to hold perpetrators to account for committing crimes, for which there should be zero tolerance. Police must have the resources to ensure that children can attend school safely and to ensure that individuals and families can attend Houses of Worship and other community venues without worry of threats of violence or terrorism. Using masks to conceal identities while committing a criminal offense must not be tolerated. Furthermore, police must have the resources and training to enforce laws with respect to illegal protests, encampments and blockades. In summary, the well-being of our society requires our police to have the necessary funding and training to combat the growing web of threats from individuals and groups supporting and promoting antisemitism, violence, genocide and terrorism. These are essential principles to preserve law and order on our streets and to safeguard a free and liberal democratic society.
- Michael Cohen
Correction to previously submitted statement.....
'impressive' should be changed to 'oppressive'.
Thank you Michael Cohen - Rao Yendamuri (Hindu Forum Canada)
- Eileen Silver (Independent submission)
Thanks to the TPSB for reaching out to the community to ask for input into a critically important policy on police protests, demonstrations and occupations in Toronto. I do not represent any specific organization in Toronto. I am a retired provincial civil servant, having spent my entire career in public policy, primarily in the education sector. In my years as a civil servant, I conducted many consultations, and I know that submissions from key community organizations hold significant weight, in terms of prominence the submission is given in development of policy. Having said that, I want to implore the TPSB and the staff analyzing the submissions, to take seriously submissions like this one… submissions that come from individuals in the community with "lived experiences"… and who have taken the time to request a say in the future of policing and safety. Your new policy will impact me, my family and the entire Toronto community in ways that are critical to our safety and well-being. I have lived in Toronto my entire life… and I no longer feel safe living in this city. In particular, I am part of the Toronto Jewish community and have personally felt frightened, triggered (my father is a Holocaust survivor) and appalled by the antics of protesters over the past months. I applaud the police for providing protection at the religious and community venues that I attend…. But I have been saddened by the lack of action taken by the police in many protests, demonstrations and occupations in Toronto. I implore the TPSB to consider the following items when establishing its new policy….. to address, what I believe to be lawlessness and terror at many of the recent events (UofT encampment and blockage of key bridge at Ave Road/Wilson being two of many cases in point). Please ensure that proper funding and resources are put in place for the following: 1. Enhancement of police monitoring and response capabilities for demonstrations, protests and encampments. Toronto police need to enhance their surveillance activities in order to secure better information about events before they occur, and develop more fulsome plans of action to deal with events. 2. Enhancement of Police Officer training/education on hate crime. Both experienced and novice police officers need to have better training to identify and respond swiftly to hate speech, slogans and symbols. The law is complex and officers need to understand what they can do to correctly and swiftly enforce law and order. 3. There should be improved protest management strategies in place at all times. In particular, protests should not obstruct traffic or prevent people from going about their everyday lives. Protests should not terrorize/scare people in their home communities or places of business. There should be zero tolerance for hate speech at demonstrations. 4. The police should establish and enforce "safe access zones" to ensure that places of worship, schools and community services (day cares, group homes, etc) are protected from protests. 5. Police should put greater resources into Community Liaison Officers for targeted communities such as the Jewish Community. While there are specific enforcement staff tasked with providing liaison duties between police and major Jewish organizations, the number of incidents against targeted groups such as the Toronto Jewish community should necessitate a deeper level of contact and a more direct line of communication for ongoing incidents. 6. Enhanced cooperation on digital communications. Police must have the capability to liaise with the Jewish community and respond rapidly to digital hate. They must also work together with Jewish community leaders to develop joint digital communications that will prevent false information from spreading and advance trusted action-oriented and accurate messaging.
- Mark McQueen
On far too many occasions over the past ten months, portions of Toronto have been devoid of "public order."
For months, many of these so-called "peaceful protests" in support of Palestine or against Israel have consistently included calls for a new "intifada," which for many harkens back to the 2000-02 Al Aqsa intifada, when Hamas, among others, organized terror attacks that killed or wounded thousands of Israeli citizens.
I embrace free speech, but chants that are widely interpreted as calls for terror attacks against Jews do not reflect the Canadian values that I grew up with. Are there no limits to civil disobedience?
What of the protesters who slowed ambulances from reaching Toronto's key downtown hospitals? What about the agitators who wouldn't allow children to enjoy their moment with a Mall Santa? What of protests that blocked access to a predominately Jewish neighbourhood in North York?
Based upon various public statements, TPS seems to extend the benefits of our Constitutionally-protected speech and association rights to "rallies" involving individuals displaying Hamas flags and featured "victory" speeches regarding terrorist attacks. Under instructions of their supervisors, our TPS members have stood by as many of these "shut it down" rallies went from being alleged reflections of free speech (albeit blocking roadways) to being against the core values that have served Canada so well for decades.
While Canada's Justice and Public Safety Ministers were quick to come out against the "championing of violence" last Fall, these statements had no impact on those who needed to hear the message.
Various jurisdictions have approached these same issues in different ways: France, for example, was quick to outline a 5-Year Prison Sentence for "Sympathizers of Hamas and Islamic Jihad." Although the American Constitution also guarantees Freedom of Speech. the Houston, Texas police department doesn't extend those "free speech" rights to protestors choosing to block city-owned thoroughfares, unlike TPS (as per public statements by TPS spokesperson Stephanie Sayer); Israel-Hamas war protests in that major U.S. city must be conducted on the sidewalk.
Prior to the April 2024 Al-Quds March on University Ave., Toronto Deputy Police Chief Lauren Pogue advised the public that "you can't disrupt the city, people are trying to go about their business, they're trying to attend medical appointments...you still have to operate within the law."
There was no follow-through once the protest began to assemble, which only served to embolden the crowd as it "shut down" one of our main avenues, right in the shadows of the Ontario Superior Court. Many in the crowd were waving the flag of Iran, honouring Ayatollah Khomeini - a cold-blooded murderer, while blocking ambulance access to three key city hospitals.
Taxpayers lose confidence in our public servants in such instances. The week prior, TPS arrested four males for breach of the peace when they physically interfered in the arrest of another anti-Israel protestor. Inexplicably, three of the four were later released unconditionally by 51 Division; the fourth was turned over to the OPP due to an outstanding warrant.
These anecdotes are all examples of circumstances (as reported in the media) where TPS has undermined our confidence in the administration of justice. This calls for an improved approach to maintaining public order in our city. - Sharon Stein
I wonder when the TPforce is going to be more proactive and shut down the aggressive pro Hamas bullies . They should have done so at the beginning when they were illegally demonstrating at the Eaton Centre and Yorkdale. They act fast enough when they feel Muslims are being exposed by potential anti- racism threats ( even if not certain )
- Malka Lewittes
- Danny Wald
Behaviour at protests cannot all be protected by Free Speach. The protests taking place incite hate. Masked protesters have been threatening others and make citizens feel unsafe and outwardly support and encourage violence and terrorist organizations. Police should be able to disperse and arrest and a firmer stance must be taken on what is permitted.
- Joel L Rubinovich (Self)
In order to be successful, there must be communication between the public and the police. In order to communicate successfully, there must be a police presence. In order to have a police presence, there must be a sufficient number of police, well trained, equipped and with a common goal. To that end, it's important that police should NOT be doing non-essential jobs ( such as minding repair work) but should be limited to policing work, properly supervised. There should be no interference from non-civic sources. They should be seen and heard.
- Michael Lloyd
1. Police appear hesitant to intervene in illegal activity during a protest, instead (hopefully) documenting for a subsequent arrest. Other protestors observe the police doing 'nothing' and assume that the activity is permissible, resulting in escalation. It is understandable that dragging people out of a crowd is problematic, but it needs to be communicated to the crowd (megaphone) that individuals will be prosecuted. 2. Counter-protestors are often arrested to prevent confrontation with protestors. The police should provide separation to allow counter-protest, and anyone disrupting the barrier should be prosecuted. 3. *Costs for extra policing should be shouldered by organizations that hold the protests. Protests should be approved and sanctioned by the police with appropriate fees applied, and protests not sanctioned should be taken down immediately by police. *costs should be inversely proportional to the burden imposed by counter-protestors. A small group that requires 100s of police for protection from counter-protestors should not be faulted or charged for the exertions of the counter-protestors.
- Brooke Langman
I have been increasingly disturbed by the mass protests that have, at best, inconvenienced Torontonians. While I am willing to listen to those with differing opinions than mine, the behaviour and harrassment of some protestors is simply unacceptable and cruel.
Many of the chants seem to be permitted because the average Canadian will not recognize the hate speech disguised in Arabic.
I would encourage the TPS as well as my fellow Canadians, to enact positive change in their own communities versus putting so much effort into a cause that is impossible to know all the details of as an average Canadian citizen, removed from the conflict.
It is an extremely large number of protesters who have obstructed our daily activities, and I can understand that managing such a crowd comes with difficulty and risk of inciting further violence.
As a suggestion, I would like to see those who are chanting for "intifada" and the destruction of Israel to be given a compromise -- perhaps permit them to wear clothing expressing their stance, but those who are engaging in hate speech should be seen on our streets serving in ways such as cleaning up our streets, vs. simply being a public nuisance.
I would also urge the TPS to employ more Arabic (or other Middle Eastern languages) speaking police or lay officers who may be better able to commune with this population and interpret for others.
This is not about one religion or another, it is a matter of preserving the safety of all citizens, in all regards.
Enough is enough.
Thank you for your consideration and for encouraging public feedback.
Sincerely, Brooke Langman - John Freedman (Professor Emeritus, University of Toronto; St Michaels Hospital)
I, like many others, am concerned about safety on university campuses and public schools. Encampments at universities here in Toronto and elsewhere have been the source of hate speech (speech / slogans / symbols) directed toward Jewish and Israeli Canadian students. There should be resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests. While the right to protest is constitutionally protected in Canada, that right is not absolute and so not all protest gatherings are legal. It is important to note as well that hate speech is NOT protected at protests. Similarly, actions like obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business. Since it IS an offence to conceal one's identity while committing a criminal offence, masked protestors who are engaging in hate speech or that remain masked when a protest transitions into an illegal riot are guilty of an offence. Police should exercise a zero-tolerance approach when it comes to any form of hate speech at a public demonstration (with an additional charge if they're also wearing a mask). While police do receive some training on antisemitism and hate speech, this may not have been sufficient. I support and advocate for police receiving additional resources that may be required to support antisemitism and hate crime enforcement training. That training should include specific content regarding how to address the presence of antisemitism and acts motivated by hate as part of public demonstrations. This includes understanding the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech; being able to identify the tactics and symbols and slogans used in hate speech and propaganda. The police must know where the line is and be ready to hold perpetrators to account for their actions. To be clear, inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group ARE severe offences and must be dealt with accordingly. There should be a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. There must be adequate and appropriate updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement.
- Eli Mogil (individual)
A key focus, in my view, is for TPS to ensure thwat protests 1. Do not result / do not communicate hate speech. With respect, this goal has not been met to date. 2. Do not result in the interruption of key infrastructure (roads, rail). With respect, this goal has not be met to date.
I would encourage TPS to address these two goals. - Jason Wolkove
- Sokol Lorne (None)
The fact I am apprehensive—even scared—to walk on major streets in my hometown of Toronto should say it all. However I have to add, when our mayor (the ChowARD) openly chooses which groups can be targeted, abused and suffer hate-filled protests, then our city has fallen into such a sad state it might not be recoverable.
- Cindy Bowman
Since October 7 2023, there has been vile anti Israel and antisemitic graffiti and posters put up all over the city of Toronto. The Jewish community does our best to report to 311, the police and neighborhood organizations. Our efforts seem to fall on deaf ears with some councillors (Chris Moise) and the city (Mayor Chow). In concert, pro-Palestinian encampments and protests have infiltrated our public spaces and universities. As a member of the Jewish community, I feel the above have created a climate of hate and fear, and have made me feel unsafe in my community. The TPS has worked towards protecting our community and helping with kerpinf protesters in check and helping to disband the encampments. More needs to be done by the city to support your efforts. I call on you to engage Olivia Chow and city councillors to vocalize support for the Jewish community and propose a harder line on antisemitic and hateful activities.
- Diana Goldman
First, I'd like to thank the TPSB from the bottom of my heart for all your extraordinary efforts in trying to keep the Jewish community save over the past 11 months. I appreciate it more than I can say! Sadly, despite the current measures, antisemitism here in Toronto, and around the world, is rising at an alarming rate. This only highlights the need to enforce all the laws at your disposal to help quell the overt hate speech (written and verbal), acts of violence, and intimidation toward the Jewish community, as well as ensuring that pro-Palestinian protests are carried out peacefully and are held in appropriate places within the city that don't impede access to buildings, hospitals, parklands, public spaces, sidewalks and roadways. The right to free speech and peaceful protest is a privilege I hold dear, but when that privilege is highjacked and used to promote hatred (and worse), it's time to step it up and do all that's necessary and within the law to put a stop to it. I never imagined that I would come to feel anxious, fearful, threatened and intimidated while living in Toronto, but sadly, that is now part of my daily existence. My parents' families moved to Canada to escape these threats and to live where they truly believed they, and their children, would be safe. That is no longer the case. Thank you for your kind consideration of my comments.
- S. Silver
Police should shut down protests and demonstrations that have have not been issued permits where permits are required.
Police must disband demonstrations on private property that are not permitted by the property owner.
Protests and demonstrations must not be held adjacent to or in the vicinity of schools where children can see the demonstrations or can reasonably be adversely affected by protesters.
Protesters and demonstrators must not be permitted to wear masks or clothing associated with or endorsing terrorist groups or violence.
Speakers attending protests and demonstrators who are known to be affiliated with terrorist organizations and hate groups must not be permitted to speak.
Protesters and demonstrators who make hateful slogans and statements (verbal or written) and who seek to intimidate or provoke violence must be removed from the demonstration/protest. If there is a reasonable threat to public safety and order the entire event must be shut down. Arrests must be made when a criminal act has been committed (without exception).
Arrests should be publicized for the public to have confidence in our police service.
Demonstrations and protests must not hinder public access to our public institutions (eg. Hospitals and public transit, main roads and infrastruture).
Police actions must not create a double standard. The policy must be implemented equally.
If police are afraid that enforcing the rule of law during protests and demonstrations will result in violence then these are exactly the types of protests and demonstrations that must be shutdown.
Officers who are biased and cannot separate their personal feelings from their professional duties to uphold the law and the public order policy should be required to undergo training so they can perform their duties. If they remain biased and prejudiced towards groups involved in the protests/demonstrations they must declare their conflict and recuse themselves from policing these protests.
Police should charge a fee for policing events. - Daniel Green-Leipciger
I am really scared for my kids, and our whole community.
I have heard so many first hand stories of jewish youth being victims of hate-motivated assaults in Toronto District schools, I've started to really fear for the future of our community.
If it is possible, I would love to see police stationed in or near TDSB schools who have a history of hate-motivated assaults that school administrators have not been able to stop.
Our kids deserve to feel safe at school .
Please help us. - Leon Kushner
It should be obvious by now that Jews are under attack at all levels at all places and by various people and organizations. You know the statistics because you monitor the crimes. I want you to succeed in doing your job in enforcing the laws we already have in place in order to keep us all safe. I'm also not naive and realize that politics sticks it's ugly nose into your business. All I ask is that you try your best to ignore the politics. Ignore the pressure of some of our politicians and their political bias. Just do your job morally and ethically. Be courageous and be fair. And most of all, be safe! G-d Bless!
- J Breslin
- Jerome Breslin
As a member of Toronto's Jewish community, I am alarmed by the rise in antisemitic protests, vandalism, and targeted demonstrations that have made many of us feel unsafe in our own neighbourhoods and institutions. The Toronto Police Service Board's (TPSB) Public Order Policy consultation is a critical opportunity for our community to demand stronger protections.
We appreciate the dedication and hard work of the TPS in maintaining public safety, often under challenging circumstances. We recognize that the members of the TPS face significant obstacles, including political pressures that can sometimes limit their ability to act decisively. Despite these challenges, their commitment to protecting all communities in Toronto, including ours, does not go unnoticed. We understand that the complexities of managing protests and maintaining public order are immense, and we are grateful for their ongoing efforts to keep our city safe. However, to truly safeguard our community, we believe that additional measures must be implemented.
First, the TPS must enforce existing laws more rigorously during protests, particularly in Jewish neighborhoods. Safe access zones around synagogues, schools, and community centers are essential to protect us from harassment and threats.
Second, the line between hate speech and free speech during demonstrations is often blurred. While freedom of expression is a fundamental right, it cannot be a shield for inciting hatred or violence, particularly against the Jewish community. The use of masks to conceal identity during illegal acts, including hate speech, is also deeply troubling. The TPS must enforce strict measures against this and adopt a zero-tolerance policy towards antisemitic slogans, symbols, and language. Enhanced training in antisemitism and hate crime enforcement is crucial for officers to identify and swiftly respond to these threats, with a focus on understanding the historical context and recognizing specific symbols and language used in antisemitic propaganda.
Lastly, the issue of encampments on university campuses, which have frequently become hubs of antisemitic activity, must be addressed. These encampments are not only illegal but also create a hostile environment for Jewish students, who are often the targets of hate speech and intimidation. The TPS should be prepared to collaborate closely with campus security to ensure that these encampments are dealt with swiftly and that the safety of Jewish students is prioritized. This collaboration should include providing the necessary resources and support for campus security to manage such situations effectively.
The Jewish community's safety depends on the TPS taking decisive action. The TPS must vigorously advocate on behalf of our legitimate concerns and implement policies that make us feel secure in our city.
Thank you. - Phil Poulos (My Personal Views)
I believe people have a right to protest IF they protest to effect change. They do this by getting their message to those in a position to make change, be it members of the Government, University groups, heads of Corporations, leaders of Religious groups... But this also means the protesters have no standing to be disrupting areas where the people they are trying to reach are no longer there. This means there is no good reason for protesters to be on University grounds after the work day has ended and Faculty & Staff have left for the day. There is no good reason for protesters to be at the Parliament buildings if there are no elected representatives inside. There is no good reason for protesters to be blocking busy roadways or establishing over night structures...none of that is 'protesting'...and as such they should have to leave.
- Deborah spivak
The display of Hamas headbands and flags just like a swastika or an ISIS banner should not be allowed in any protest. Glorifying October 7 th should not be allowed - any chants which I've heard in front of my synagogue already calling for intifada revolution should be grounds for arrest. The police would never allow chants for the lunching of black people , so why are chants for the lynching ( stabbing /burning/bombing…) of Jewish people permitted? We all have videos of these hateful terrorists supporters and no arrests were made for hate speech !
- Lori Cohen (Rabbi Lori Cohen)
I live in a safe, middle class area of Toronto, or so I thought. The synagogue near me on Bayview has been vandalized 5 times this year. Graffiti I see around the city is frightening with its hate messages. When I saw a video of roads blocked and masked "terrorists" hanging from the ramps at the Toronto City Hall, I felt that I no longer was in Toronto. My belief that this city, this country, is law abiding, respectful, a safe, has come crashing down. My husband and I have discussed whether or not we would be safer in another country.
- Susie Kaplan (Citizen)
The police have to uphold law and order and that is not happening. Crowds are attacking a minority...the Jewish people !! And why??? Thisvid not acceptable that I csntbleave my house!!!! You must help us save our lives!!! you must!!
- Brad Rosenberg
Dear Members of the Toronto Police Services Board,
I am writing to express my concerns and recommendations regarding the enforcement of public order during protests, demonstrations, and other public gatherings within Toronto. My submission focuses on several key areas where I believe policy updates and enhanced police training are necessary to ensure the safety and security of all citizens, particularly in the context of rising antisemitism and other forms of hate speech.
1. Enforcement of Laws It is evident that during certain protests and demonstrations, laws relating to mischief, trespassing, and unlawful assembly are not always enforced consistently. I urge the TPSB to ensure that police officers receive thorough training on the laws governing protest management, especially those pertaining to maintaining peace and order in major intersections and in predominantly Jewish neighborhoods. This will help ensure that all relevant laws are enforced effectively during public gatherings.
2. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech The line between hate speech and free speech can be complex, but the police must be prepared to act decisively when hate speech occurs. Incitement to hatred and calls for genocide are severe offenses that must not be tolerated under any circumstances. I strongly advocate for a zero-tolerance policy towards hate speech at public demonstrations and recommend that police receive updated training on recognizing and addressing antisemitic and other hate crimes. This training should include understanding the historical context, identifying hate symbols, and recognizing tactics used in hate speech, including those in foreign languages.
3. Blocking of Streets and Public Spaces While the right to protest is constitutionally protected, it is not absolute, especially when it infringes on the rights of others. Protests that obstruct highways, transportation facilities, or prevent people from conducting their daily business should be managed more effectively. I recommend that the TPSB implements policies that ensure protests do not obstruct traffic or block access to places of worship, schools, and community service agencies. Additionally, police should be provided with the necessary resources to maintain peace and order during such events.
### 4. **Encampments on University Campuses** Encampments on university campuses have been a source of concern, particularly when they involve hate speech directed at Jewish and Israeli Canadian students. Universities, as private properties, should enforce trespassing laws, but the police should be ready to support campus security when needed. I encourage the TPSB to provide police with the resources and training necessary to assist in managing encampments and protests on university campuses, ensuring the safety of all students.
### 5. **Addressing the Issue of Masking at Protests** The use of masks during protests can be concerning, especially when individuals conceal their identities while committing criminal offenses. While wearing a mask is not illegal, it becomes an offense when used to conceal identity during criminal activities such as hate speech. I recommend that the TPSB enforce a strict policy against masking in such contexts and provide additional charges for those who engage in hate speech while masked.
6. Enhanced Police Training on Hate Crime Enforcement The current level of police training on antisemitism and hate speech is insufficient. I strongly urge the TPSB to mandate updated and comprehensive training for all officers on hate crime enforcement. This training should cover the identification of hate groups, the symbols and language used in hate propaganda, and the appropriate responses to such activities. Furthermore, it is crucial that police are provided with the resources necessary to support this training and its application in the field.
7. Reporting and Responding to Hate Crimes When citizens witness hate symbols or hear incitement to genocide at a protest, it is imperative that the police respond swiftly and decisively. I recommend that the TPSB emphasizes the importance of a zero-tolerance approach to hate speech and symbols during public demonstrations. Additionally, enhanced hate crime training should be provided to all officers to ensure they can identify and respond appropriately to such incidents.
8. Collaboration with Municipalities on Graffiti Removal Hate symbols and antisemitic content in graffiti should be addressed promptly. I suggest that the TPSB works closely with municipalities to ensure that such graffiti is removed quickly and that the police are responsive to reports of hate speech in public spaces.
In conclusion, I believe that the above recommendations will significantly enhance public safety and order in Toronto. By adopting a zero-tolerance approach to hate speech, improving protest management, and ensuring that police are adequately trained and resourced, the TPSB can better serve and protect all members of our community.
Thank you for your attention to these important matters.
Sincerely,
Brad Rosenberg - CWAA (Canadian Woman Against Antisemitism)
- April McGeown (An Individual non-Muslim in a Muslim community)
I was born here in Toronto 71 years ago and lived in Thorncliffe Pk. For 50 years this October, but I am beginning to wonder how safe anyone is in this community or city if we don't give them what they want, and it makes me wonder who is running this country or world, as it is getting so dark as everyone seems afraid to upset a group of people that thinks their loudness and power overrides everyone else. We know they plan to take over control, according to Islamic ideology, what are leaders going to do to stop it? Many are praying for a leadership of this country and the nations that will follow God's ways, so I ask you let us find hope in all of this by giving us a safe city back before the enemy causes WW3. In regards to how a protest around my area, Thorncliffe Park, affected me that was on, of all days, Easter Sunday, and led by a police escort, I found a short video of the end of it on Youtube and made my comments and got a reply that made no cense to me so I gave another reply that I hoped would make cense to him and anyone involved in these protests. The video is titled Palestine's people against Israel in Thorncliffe Park if you which to view for yourself. Here is what I had to say to them and sent it to the Mayor and Doug Ford without any response. Youtube made edits of statements of truth in regards to the faith this country was built on, The Judeo/Christian system, which my Messianic Jewish Pastor found unbelievable. I do not understand why these protests have been allowed to go on for so long when The Truckers protest was shut down within three weeks and that affected Canadians freedoms while these people are trying to force us to believe in their cause that is on the other side of the world and their information is so wrong. As a Toronto born and raised member of this city, for 71 years, and 50 years living in this community, I must say, I was very dismayed with this protest taking place on Resurrection Sunday, which is the Highest Holy Holiday of us Judeo/Christians and is also the system this country was built on, which gave us all the freedoms we enjoy. Respect should be provided all people of faith, as God Loves all people equally. God used Israel and Jesus to bring us the greatest gifts in this world, of forgiveness of Sin, and a restored relationship with him that was broken in the garden, and eternal life. Christians pray that all people will experience God's unconditional Love and mercy and grace we don't deserve, that will change mankind's hearts and help us all live in Peace together, instead of war and hate. May God Bless all with his love and presence, today and until his return, when Jesus will bring lasting Peace on the Mount of Olives where he left from. Saleem Pasha responded with: I agree with you my friend, We are enjoying peace here in Canada but we do like to see peace everywhere in the world like Palestine, Kashmir, Iraq, Syria etc. --- My final response is below. Peace can only come when you allow the Prince of Peace, JESUS King of the Jews and the World into your heart, as Lord of your life, to show you the truth. Jesus said I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life, no man comes unto the father but by me, (or) is sin free to enter heaven unless washed by his blood. The enemy of all our souls is satin who is still spinning his web of lies to mankind to keep us divided and in darkness from seeing the truth of who God is, what he has done for mankind and how he is in control, not man. Protests, especially on the day we celebrate his Resurrection from the dead to set us ALL free, does nothing but show disrespect for what this country stands for and it took away my peace after a Joyful time at church. Find peace with God, then find out what he would have you do to help others find it too, and let him show you what to do in prayer and action here and or over there, to be part of the solution and not part of the problem. People need to stop trying to force us to solve their problem, a problem of the heart. No one has the right to say that anyone else does not have the right to exist only God gives life and takes it away. Jesus said, Love God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength and Love your neighbor as yourself. Find the facts and truth will fill your soul with light and show you the path to take. Jesus is the answer for the worlds problems, and the only one that can bring order out of Chaos. He is trying to get mankind's attention through signs in the sky and earth and will shake everything that can be shaken until all that is left is what can't be shaken and that is his Unconditional LOVE for mankind. Nothing and no one can stop it, but sometimes it takes us coming to the place of having nothing else to cling to before we realize what we are missing. PRIDE is an umbrella term that covers all the SIN in mankind's lives. When it goes, man stops being his own God and the world will find peace. Pray for the Leaders of all the nations of the world, as it starts there and filters down, for better or for worse. I pray this will help, as it comes from a life time of experience in learning from the only one you can trust or totally rely upon on this earth and that is the sovereign trinity. God is knocking on the door of your heart and waiting for you to open it and invite him in so he can have a relationship with you too! One last thing. If you have not yet read the book "The Son of Hamas" you should read how a son of the leadership broke away from the hate and death their hearts only know and is speaking out to help the world to see the truth. There is lots of videos on YouTube about him since the start of the war. He was at Canada Christian College years ago when it was on Wynford drive, just up the street from here, and he spoke out then too. God Bless. I pray for our Police Department to always be protected by God and be given all the staff they need to do the job safely and with the training they need to do it right.
- Lena Solomon
- Jenna Fleming
I am extremely concerned for the safety and well-being of Jewish children within their Jewish schools. They have been balancing acts of antisemitism through vandalism and violence on children's school that is incomprehensible.
Toronto is supposed to be a multicultural inviting and warm city and one that I love dearly. However, since October 7th I have not felt safe as a Jewish woman and I do not feel safe for my Jewish children and their peers. - Rita Dempster (Citizen)
I think it is important that the protests inciting hate be controlled. The hate towards our Jewish communities, the blockage of roadways, protests at Union stations etc. affect everyone's freedoms. I would like to see no face masks worn when protesting, and the incitement of hate stopped. If action is not taken, the protests will continue to escalate, and our Jewish communities are at risk.
- Sergey Kvyatkovskiy
I am writing to express my concerns about the rise in pro-Palestinian protests that have included anti-Semitic rhetoric and actions. While peaceful protest is a fundamental right, hate speech and violence, as defined by the Canadian Criminal Code and the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, must not be tolerated.
I have personally experienced the impact of these protests, which have disrupted my ability to visit friends and family. These protests threaten not only the safety of our city but also the well-being of residents like myself and my family.
I appreciate the Toronto Police for their efforts to keep the Jewish community safe and strongly support a **zero-tolerance policy** for hate speech and violence at public demonstrations, with strict enforcement of the Canadian Criminal Code's provisions. Adopting the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism will help law enforcement address these issues more effectively.
Police officers should receive mandatory training on anti-Semitism, hate crimes, and bias awareness to ensure fair enforcement. Recognizing hate symbols and rhetoric, including those in foreign languages, is crucial.
I also advocate for **safe access zones** around places of worship and community centers to protect vulnerable populations from targeted protests. Demonstrations should not block public spaces or disrupt daily activities.
Improving police-community relations and enhancing digital communication will help prevent misinformation and ensure swift responses to incidents. Thank you for considering these measures, and for your ongoing efforts to protect all communities in Toronto. I look forward to contributing to this important discussion. - Camille Renda (Canadian Jewish resident)
As a Jewish person I am very disappointed worried and angry to see what's happening on our university campuses protests that are really more like threats to our Jewish community why is it allowed to happen in our city province and Canada this needs to stop the police force our politicians city provincial or federal even our mayor needs to stop being one sided we want to be treated just like every Canadian without fear and worry. This is Canada to be respected and respect these times are showing that we Jewish people don't matter let's get real we don't cause any problems we help we won't peace. Thank you
- Lyla Jackson
I request that the police realize that the "pro-palestinian protestors" that regularly take over Toronto streets and disrupt city events are actually pro-terror gangs that are terrifying to Jews and non Jews who live and work in the city. The police must take strong action to not allow them to close streets or disrupt events ever. The objective of terrorism is to instill fear in people and prevent them from living their lives freely. This week I wanted to take my children to the CNE but I saw on social media that the masked gangs were planning on taking over union station. I knew from experience that the police would allow this and so we stayed home instead of going to the CNE. The terrorists won that day. We have laws that are being broken daily and by failing to arrest the lawbreakers, they are emboldened and the city becomes less liveable for Canadian families. I can no longer feel safe allowing my teenagers to take the subway alone since I keep reading about sexual assault and the fact that so many assaults are done by people out on bail is mind boggling.
- Boris Milman (Toronto citizen)
Download file
Dear Mr. Michael Kerzner, Solicitor General, MPP Dear Mr. Myron Demkiw, Chief TPS Dear Toronto Police Service Board Dear Ms. Olivia Chow, Mayor of Toronto I am a psychologist working in Ontario for the past 20 years, and part of a group of psychologists and psychotherapists, with decades of experience, working with the public at large and with members of the Police Service. This letter is aligned with the experience of this entire group. The reason for this letter is to share with you a general feeling of increasing anxiety regarding the lack of protection by the law enforcers, that, based on our work experience, Ontarians are experiencing lately. I am writing below about the ever-escalating emotional damage that we, as psychologists and psychotherapists, are witnessing in our society, through our clients, coming from all over Ontario. The increased rate of crime, even if not always reported (for which we are grateful) it is felt, unfortunately often experienced and constantly feared in the community. This fear keeps escalating every day, to the extent that it often impacts people's normal functioning in everyday life and ultimately productivity. For example, in certain parts of Toronto women are advised by the Police, to not walk by themselves as they may be attacked. In other parts of Toronto people report that masked mob patrol Jewish neighborhoods harassing people outside their homes, obviously not fearing repercussions. Women are reporting being attacked while driving alone, when stopped at traffic lights. These experiences are felt to be associated with a significant failure of the system under current circumstances, a systemic failure of leadership/city leadership. There is a common, ever clearer sense in our clients, that we do not live in a society ruled by law and order anymore. A sense that laws are being bent to be enforced only when and how they serve political interests, rather than respected, as they should be in a lawful society. Therefore, there seems to be a general feeling that we are not protected either by the Police, or by the law. And this is not felt to be the fault of Police. Rather, there is a general feeling that the Police Service often has no ability to enforce protective laws. The members of the Service themselves feel more and more discouraged and conflicted, as they feel themselves prey to politicians and politics, to a justice system that recently more often punishes them for performing their job, while rewarding the criminals by allowing them to go free. In other words, the Service feels unprotected itself, caught in the net of helplessness, conflicted between their duty of enforcing the law and protecting the public, and the fear of repercussions when doing so. Members of the service as well as members of the public feel that laws seem to be easily circumvented by political interests, while Police officers often are shown in the media as being humiliated when trying to serve and protect, with no obvious consequences. The inability to dismantle the occupation of Toronto University, despite clear discomfort and disturbance of other members of the University, is only one such example. Other clear infractions as seen in the media become permissible, described as a matter of the circumstances, even before anybody seems to be addressing the victims, particularly when they are part of the Service. The resulting perceived inability to prevent this from happening again, becomes conducive to a loss of motivation and burnout. Moreover, our clients feel that the public is mostly informed about wrongdoings, which of course should not be permitted and should be punished, but very seldom is the media engaged in describing any acts of heroism, or just good deeds, by members of the Service, or even the reality of circumstances under which many of the heroes of the Service function. I say heroes, because we, as psychologists working with members of the service, often hear about how many lives have been saved by these men and women, or how many times these men and women sacrificed themselves to save the public. It is a general feeling, that very little does the media dwell on these acts. Furthermore, our clients express a lot of frustration related to the way things are presented in the press, which defies accountability, for it is felt that there is no differentiation or acknowledgment of journalistic opinions, over facts. This further reinforces the general feeling of frustration inherent in the efforts to cope with the current situation. Moreover, while Ontario in general and Toronto in particular, show a negative correlation between the increase in population and the size of the Police service, this predicts an increase in the ratio of crime per Police officer, and with it an increase in burnout and PTSD cases among members of the Service on one hand, and an increase in mistrust of the members of the public in the ability of the Service to actually satisfy the needs of public security, on the other. I am writing this letter as a psychologist and as a member of the public, hoping, like our clients, and probably all good people of Ontario in general and of Toronto in particular, that things can improve: that the Police can be Refunded, and the funds invested in the best way towards restoring public trust in the ability of the Police Service to recapture the rights to exercise their obligation to help and protect; that the Police and the public can again feel that we can return to being a law-abiding society, and, like not so long ago, not live in fear and enjoy the wonderful, well-understood freedom that living in Canada had to offer. June 2024 Respectfully, Lena Solomon, PsyD David Direnfeld, PhD Leah Lundell, PhD Brian Levitt, Psy.D Anna Baranowsky, PhD Alvin Altrows, PhD Janice Weintraub, PhD Tally Bodenstein Kales, PhD Stephany Bot, PhD Michelle Foster, PhD Joel Rosenberg, Ed.D Simone Levey, PhD Eyal Bodenstein, PhD Tania Cotler, PhD Lisa Couperthwaite, PhD - Harry Zeit (Individual)
As an emergency physician, for many years I worked in fairly close contact with the police over many years. The police force I see today has changed profoundly and I no longer feel protected in the way I once did. At one point the priority of policing seemed to be primarily to protect the populace, especially the most vulnerable members. Lately that has changed. I note in particular how the police have failed to provide a sense of safety to the Jewish community, allowing public demonstrations of hatred and antisemitism to flourish in Toronto. At the very least, there should be zero tolerance for individuals covering their faces (after all, this is against the law, and if this isn't being enforced, the law is no longer being enforced) and for bands marching through Jewish neighbourhoods expressing hatred. I don't think this is very much to ask. In a time when we all feel more threatened and insecure (including police officers) we need a vision of maintaining safety and the dignity of democracy.
- N Keown
These pro Palestinian protests where people shout about hating Jewish people and shouting from the river to the sea Palestine will be free, meaning to exterminate the Jewish people, is all terrifying and I now have anxiety about being in public places as I fear for my safety. We have seen how the protests can turn violent so quickly. I fear for my kids going to school and people knowing the fact they are Jewish. My son was told he cannot participate in a student committee at university because he is Jewish, as there is a pro Palestine student on the committee that he would be working with, the organizers were concerned she won't accept working with him and are concerned for his safety as she is aggressive.
There needs to be a clear message that hate speech is illegal and will not be tolerated, even if it means silencing the person spewing the hate. Otherwise they seem to be emboldened and teach others to hate too. We wouldn't accept the klu klux klan spewing words of hate against black people, or hate speech against gay people, so why wouldn't we silence this hate? Seeing swastikas is horrible, saying Jewish people are hateful, etc is terrifying. - HARLEY MINTZ (MINKIDS GROUP)
Michael Diamond has eloquently outlined his, and many of his fellow Jewish Torontonians, concerns and requests of our TPS. I heartily endorse his comments, repeated beow.
To the Toronto Police Services Board. Thankyou for listening. I am a second generation Jewish senior, living in Toronto. I am a retired investor and have had extensive involvement with philanthropy both in support of the Jewish community and the broader secular community. The events of October 7th shocked and upset me for many reasons. But the reaction of too many of my fellow Canadian citizens and residents to the events of October 7 and the Israeli incursion into Gaza has upset me far more!. I, my children and grandchildren, are being blamed for a situation in the Middle East I have no control over, and for the decisions made by a government on the other side of the world. As a result, I no longer feel safe in my own city. We used to refer to Toronto as "Toronto the Good." Personally, I cannot say that any more. It's not Good when a significant number of people do not feel comfortable in their own city. You know the reasons why because of your positions on the TPSB. The implied threats, actual threats, and general intimidation that has taken place along with the actual attacks on physical structures and individuals, in apparent response to decisions of a foreign government, are simply uncalled for regardless of whether you agree with that (Israeli) government or not. I can effectively argue the Israeli case but that is not the point. The point is, that importing conflicts into our multi-cultural society is highly problematic to the overall health of that society. Moreover, the fact that actual or threatened violence, and "in your face" aggression is used by the pro-Hamas supporters against supporters or perceived supporters of Israel, is simply wrong and in many respects, illegal. We Jews are not accustomed to behaving as our enemies currently are doing. We tend not to bully, we march but positively, and avoid disparaging those with whom we disagree other than via the use of rational argument. And we try hard to be good Canadians. Many of us are responsible for that which has been Good about Toronto. Thus far, we have not responded to our adversaries with aggressive tactics as they have done, because it is not our style. However, there are those in community who are tired of the attacks, and believe we should be responding to fire with fire, so to speak. What has stopped that from happening is the Toronto Police, as well as the police forces in other areas near Toronto. Led by our community organization, UJA, we are encouraged to refer our fears and challenges to the police which is what should happen in a healthy society which believes in law and order. Which leads me to the major point of this note. There are some 200,000 Jews in the GTA. Due to the security threats against us, we are mobilizing and spending large amounts of time and money to combat those threats and keep ourselves safe. To the extent that we can continue to count on the Toronto Police, who have generally done their best to respond to protect us as best they can, we do not need to mobilize to threaten or bully or respond to that bullying. To the extent however that the Toronto Police do not have our backs, or are not properly equipped to deal with those who would upend our society, many of us will inevitably be forced to take matters into our own hands. For some that may mean leaving the city. For others, it may mean organizing groups to protect each other, which will inevitably lead to escalation and more conflict. This is not what we want. But it is an inevitability which leads to the recommendations which follow: 1. The Board must ensure that the necessary funds are available for the police to do their job properly, a job that is much greater in scope now than it was several years ago. There are two aspects to the necessary investments. 2. First, more funds are required simply because the demands being put on the police forces to respond to specific incidents which are increasing monthly, and to deal with the many marches and protests, are materially greater in scope than in the past. We are well aware that the funding provided to the Toronto Police, even before considering the current challenges presented by the Pro Hamas protesters, has been insufficient to deal with rising crime, an increasing population, etc. Add to that the exponential rise in need because of the Pro Hamas protesters, and it becomes virtually impossible for the Toronto Police to do their jobs optimally. 3. A related challenge is to ensure that the individual members of the police force, who are generally well intentioned, have the necessary training to use existing hate laws effectively, and know when to use them. The Police must apply the rule of law consistently in order to maintain order and trust. Therefore, all members of the Toronto Police must be educated and up to date on current challenges, and the application of current laws to those challenges. Part of that must be training in the nature of the protests, the anti-semitism which is embodied in much of what the pro- Hamas crowd participate in and some understanding of the origins and nature of the hatred which is often at the core of what are often overly aggressive protests and attacks, not to mention the individual anti-semitic attacks taking place daily in our city. 4. The Toronto Police are entrusted with maintaining law and order in the City of Toronto. That means there should be zero tolerance for hate crimes and public disturbances which violate federal, provincial or municipal laws/bylaws. We do not blame the police for the predicament we are all in. In fact, we appreciate the police for their hard work in helping us to deal with the intimation, bullies and attacks thus far. And we know that this Board would love to have the necessary funding to do what is needed. But, given that there is every chance that the pressures will increase before they subside, it is critical that the Toronto Police and its members be provided with the funds, the resources, and the education and training they need to manage what is now an escalating and challenging situation. The first responsibility of government at all levels is to ensure an orderly society and require the adherence to our laws. To the extent that is done with the necessary resources, we can weather this storm. But without the necessary resources, you can expect an escalation which could be explosive in nature and far more costly in many respects to deal with. Respectfully submitted, Michael Diamond - Daniel Kolber (private citizen)
To Whom It May Concern: I will proffer that the majority of Canadians have been appalled by the apparent lack of police enforcement of our laws pertaining to hate speech, public gatherings, the uttering of threats, general civil disobedience, and the wearing of face masks in public while clearly endeavouring to further hate and terror. In particular, the Jewish community has seen a severely lacking approach to the protection of Canada's Jewish minority since the 7th October, 2023. The sheer idiocy of all this is that if the Ku Klux Klan were marching masked and robe and intimidating the Black community by holding parades and spewing hatred around our City and Country, it wouldn't have lasted hours, let alone MONTHS!! The Police force, which I have tremendous respect for, would have acted - with haste, determination, and with force as need be. And yet what we have seen since Oct 7th is the opposite of that. Our Police have seemed bewildered, lost and confused, and unable to tamper the hatred fomenting in our public places. In fact, the Police have offered these hateful protestors coffee... The saying goes: "they go after the Saturday people (i.e., the Jews), then they'll go after the Sunday people (i.e., everyone else)". What we have seen the past 11 months is an attack on democracy from far-left-wing groups, much of it financed by Iran which is NOT an ally or friend of Canada. The "thin blue line" needs to enforce our laws better, that's the bottom line, or all Canadians will suffer the consequences. thank you.
- Marisa Small (Community member)
Various incidents of anti-Jewish sentiments have left me feeling unsafe in my city: bomb threats at my nieces' high school, graffiti all over, a run in with someone tearing down hostage posters at my neighborhod school (when I asked the person to stop they screamed at me about "Israeli apartheid" and various other antisemitic utterances. I am on edge bc my 4 year old attends a Jewish school and I fear very much for her safety. My son attends public school and on one of the last days of school the yard was defaced with multiple swastikas.
- Hunter Van Ness
Freedom of expression is critical, however many Jews no longer feel safe in Toronto. Protests too often cross the line from free speech into hate speech. Racist chants and troubling signs, combined with the surge in hate crimes against Jewish buildings and institutions, mean that many Jews no longer feel safe. The police have an incredibly difficult role to play; it is not easy. I hope that the police have all the resources they need to ensure all citizens feel safe in this great city.
- Sasson Azoory
I am retired and seriously concerned about antisemitism incidents in Toronto. My grandchildren who attend primary school have to take extra precaution going to school to school and can't understand why they have to take extra precautions while their friends don't .I wish our politicians and the silent majority stand strongly with the Jewish people against hate. I wish the police priorities are allocated to the community with the largest incidents of hate. Unfortunately, Jews need police protection in schools, community centers and synagogues. Thank you
- Kristin Berry (Citizen)
To Whom It May Concern,
I am a residental citzen of Toronto. Thank you for allowing me to share my perspective on these impotrant issues. The following are my recomendations I hope you will consider.
Essential Training on Death Threats in Different Languages: Officers must undergo comprehensive training to fully grasp the historical context, meaning, and impact of death threats in different languages. It is crucial for law enforcement to understand that chants at protests can be veiled calls for genocide and should not be trivialized.
Combatting Propaganda: Police must be equipped to swiftly identify and comprehend the tactics and symbols employed in propaganda, including those that camouflage anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. For instance, "anti-Palestinian racism" which wrongfully seeks to criminalizes Jewish, Christian, and Israeli identities.
Vigilant Chant Awareness: The force must be keenly aware of specific chants and symbols that promote the the targeting of Jews and Christians.
Lessons from History: Incorporate powerful lessons from history to underscore the perils of unchecked antisemitism and hate speech, and to underscore the potential for these to escalate into real acts of violence. I recommend everyone attended training from https://www.fswc.ca/. As a non-jewish person I really learned so much from them.
Lastly, cotinue to facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation.
I appreciate your service and personal sacrifice. With grattitude Kristin Berry - Ayelet Bercovich
The rise of Antisemitism in our once great city is extremely concerning to me, and especially for my kids who are growing up to see protests, hearing hate speech and witnessing all of it being paraded on Toronto's streets, permissible and legitimate. As my daughter starts her first year at TMU, I am so afraid she will see Swastikas, and hear for the destruction of Israel chants wherever she goes. How is this possible in 2024? How did we get here? Shouldn't safety of all citizens be the number one priority? Something has to be done to tighten punishments and hold all hate speech criminals accountable for their dangerous rhetoric. It starts with words.
- Oscar Zimmerman (Personal)
TDSB consultation
My family grew up near Lviv in western Ukraine . For 10 years before ww2 antisemitism was accepted in the public square .The result was there was minimal pushback against the murder of 6 million Jews including 1 million children .Moat of my family died in the Holocaust and my sister was born in a refugee camp in 1947.My parents came to Canada in 1949 and I was born in Canada in 1952. While growing up there was anti semitism in the playground and the workplace but it was un acceptable at that time for anti semitism in the public square ! This situation ended last October with the Gaza war .The police need to treat anti semitism as a specific cancer which has to be dealt with harshly and distinctly in the public square including social media and as hate speech by clergy and other public persona need to be enforced to the maximum allowed by law ! Appeasement makes this cancer worse ! To mitigate the freedom of speech challenge these draconian enforcement laws should be reviewed and adjusted to reflect rising stable or declining antisemetic incidents on an annual basis to make sure there is sufficient merit to make sure those who enjoy the freedom of speech face accountability before the law when they use this platform for hate speech . It should be codified for police enforcement that anti Israel arguments such as "from the river to the sea" or "Israel Gaza genocide " or "Israel apartheid " or such similar items will on the face of it be treated as hate speech as a factual matter for law enforcement .
In terms of Jewish and other public institutions like hospitals and universities and Jewish community centres any protests and encampments must take pace more than 180 feet from the legal boundary of the institution and if closer will be considered a hate motivated event and all those protesting can be arrested and prosecuted !no catch and release !
A zero policing tolerance policy to anti semitism in the public square is called for until this cancer goes into remission !
Sincerely Oscar Zimmerman Toronto - M Capler
When police witness or learn that hate speech and incitement has occurred, we want them to have the training and support to be able to and prepared to hold perpetrators accountable for their actions.
- Brian Cole
The Toronto Police needs to take a harder stance against the hate protests that happen almost every weekend in the city. Enough is enough. It must stop. If you see Nazi or Hamas symbols, take action. If people are preventing from accessing private or public property that they should, arrest the people that are preventing it. Vandalism? Graffiti? Noise violations? Unpermitted demonstrations? That is just the tip of the iceberg but I believe you have laws or bylaws on your side in many of those cases, so please enforce them more vigorously.
- Irina Milman
First and Foremost I would like to thank the Toronto Police for taking the time to have these community consultations and for enforcing the laws and protecting the public. Your thoughtfulness and kindness for my grandchildren and their safety, your smiles (and stickers) mean the world.
The point of the recent protests was and is to intimidate and to isolate the Jewish community. My hope is that the TPS will use the current existing hate speech laws and enforce them to the full extent.
In order to do that in the current environment, it is important for the TPS officers to have a thorough understanding of the historical context, as well as the meaning of implications and terminology used by the protesters. Such that when terminology being used calls for genocide of Jews, it is understood and treated as hate speech.
The current protesters deliberately choose Jewish areas and communities for their protests. They are masked and trespass on private property. They accost Jewish children with verbal intimidation. I have witnessed all of this.
The encampments are another form of intimidation, intimidating Jewish students and professors/staff and generally interfering with the freedom of all students, as these encampments are treated by the protesters as their own fiefdoms.
Freedom of speech is not freedom of hate, not freedom of intimidation, not freedom of racism. As such, it is my hope that TPS will enforce a zero tolerance policy toward hate speech, towards racist speech, labelling any group or people is racist, towards intimidation. Masks hide identities of those committing crimes, acting in hate and violence. The masks should go.
All Torontonians should feel free to walk the streets, pray in their religious domicile of choice, go to school without being harassed and intimidated, physically or verbally.
Given the current environment, it is also important for the TPS officers to understand external influences affecting the current conflict. SJP is an organization which has been planting the seeds of hate against Israel and the Jewish people for 20 yrs, it has direct ties to Hamas and Iran, and has been instrumental in orchestrating the student encampments. The protests have also been linked to Iran and its proxies.
As some background. Iran and Qatar own most of the world's oil resources. Iran and the IRGC think that the only thing standing between them and subjugation of the entire Middle East is Israel and Jews. Their leaders are ruthless theocrats with absolute power, for whom people are disposable, including children, used to clear minefields, as child soldiers etc. They crave empires, democracy is their bane.
They have spent their unlimited trillions to influence Universities (my son was in the Uni student union- 15 yrs ago the head of which was a 15 yr older MEstern "student" with one anti-Israel agenda), journalism schools and the "Progressive" movement. They used old KGB anti-Jewish tropes and propaganda tactics to influence the Middle East and spread this propaganda to the West.
Ironically, it was Jewish people of the region who were referred to as Palestinians and Nakba was referred to as the catastrophe of the failure of the surrounding Arab states to annihilate modern Israel on its birth and genocide the Jews. Yet with trillions and the KGBs propaganda template, an inversion of history and an inversion of the current conflict has created an atmosphere of unchecked hate "fueled" by Iran, and Qatar (soft sell).
There are no Jewish protesters in front of mosques, harassing Muslim children, shouting racist slogans and intimidating Muslims. The Muslim community should speak up and demand the same of the "agents of Iran" and their indoctrinated disciples.
It is my hope that the TPS will assist in removing this atmosphere of hate and return our city to a welcoming, safe environment, free from hate and intimidation for all Torontonians. - Herbert Brill (n/a)
I am a private citizen. I support the right to protest, as we are a free society with a Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Charter rights do not extend to supporting hate or hiding one's face in a protest. Thus, I think the police should make the following clear: 1) Registered protests on the grounds of our elected government are supported 2) Protests on city streets must be registered just like any march and the route reviewed for community safety and economic impact. This is a larger conversation on establishing principles for this, which is up to our elected municipal officials. 3) Displaying hateful messages will not be tolerated and risks the protest being cancelled and dispersed. 4) Masks cannot be worn by protesters, or again the protest will be cancelled and dispersed. 5) If a counter protest is organized to a community march, it cannot obstruct or even narrow a street that the march runs through, since intimidation of marching as a community should not be tolerated. 6) Protests on private property should be dispersed immediately when requested by the owners of that private property. Since public government land is plentiful, protesting on private property is simply intimidation, and should not be tolerated.
The principles above ensure everyone's freedoms are protected, including safety and the right to protest.
Submitted respectfully Herbert Brill MD MBA FRCPC - Martin Schwartz
- Talia Myers
Hate-inciting protests have a significantly negative impact on our community. Not only do these protests have immediate negative local effects in and of themselves (eg compromising the safety of those people and businesses in close proximity to these demonstrations) but also catalyze significant negative ripple effects including accelerating antisemitism across Canada in a range of settings (general public, schools, workplaces). Such hate-inciting demonstrations should and must be stopped and the police have a significant role in ensuring that public order and Canadian values are upheld.
- Aaron kucharczuk
It seems as though lawlessness in our city has skyrocketed recently, and it seems to be because of two-tier policing.
It has appeared as though in the context of a 'protest' or just a large enough mob of people, there is no enforcement of the law. They are permitted to harass, detain, abuse, disturb the peace, interfere with highways, put others at risk, trespass, and overall be hateful menaces. The police seem to be present largely to provide escorts, and even embarrassingly serving them coffee.
Additionally, this appears to be the case as it pertains to certain groups only; this 'hands off, let them destroy society because they outnumber us' approach was not the approach taken historically with truckers nor G20 protestors.
The Anti-Racism Act requires the TPS to produce racial data, with the goal, as stated in the Anti-Racism Act Data Standards, as eliminating racial disparity, defined as unequal outcomes.
Alarmingly, the data analysis related to this racial data does not control for variables such as 'did the person actually commit the crime'. This puts considerable pressure on the TPS to minimize the arrests and other police interactions with members of 'racialized' groups, regardless of their guilt.
It is my perception that this is why the police does not care to intervene in recent matters, whereas it has in the past.
Regardless of whether my suspicians that the Anti-Racism Act is causing the TPS to act in a racist manner are correct, can we please increase the enforcement of our laws?
Justice is supposed to be blind - please just arrest everyone you see who commits a crime.
We need to make Toronto a safer place for our families. The lawlessness must end. - Lynne Morris
- David Direnfeld
I am making the following suggestions: 1) video recording anti-Israeli protestors for the purpose of identifying hate speech and charging such individuals 2) educating TPS on the difference between hate speech and free speech 3) interpreting coded language (i.e., intifada, from the river to the sea, zionism=nazi, armed resistance, martyrs, we dont want no two states, we want 48...) 4) enforcing legislation prohibiting face coverings while committing an offence 5) ensuring Jewish students/faculty/staff are not prevented access to schools/campus spaces 6) arresting those flying the Hamas flag
- Carolyn Schwartz
I was born and raised in Toronto and have lived downtown for the past 37 years. It was a great city where people from all different backgrounds and religions were kind and respectful to one another. It was the Canadian way. For the past year, I have witnessed so much hatred and disruption in our streets that I do not recognize Toronto anymore. There is a big difference between free speech and hate speech. There have been countless protesters, agitators and those who want to intimidate by holding up antisemitic signs and symbols, chanting hateful slogans, all while cowardly hiding behind face coverings used to conceal their identity. These face coverings should be banned in all public places. I took a video at Bloor and Yonge where two men set up a table and were selling Keffiyehs (also known as the hipster Swastika to many) in front of six police officers who allowed it. I believe you need a permit to sell products from the street in which they no longer allow in that area of Bloor street. Why are there different rules for different groups? In August, a large group of Muslims shut down Dundas street between Yonge and Bay streets to pray while several police officers allowed it and seemed as if they were protecting them. Why are our streets allowed to be used as a place of worship when they have Mosques and other places to pray at? What would happen if Christians or Jews closed down the exact section of Dundas street to pray? Taxpayers should be able to drive on the streets not take detours so that certain groups can do whatever they want whenever they want. The Police should have the power to enforce these laws and rules without intimidation.
- aaron unger
My submission is simple. Our esteemed police force, who is outstanding in every respect, must be empowered to combat clear and obvious hateful marches on our street. Hateful signs or messages promoting non-Canadian values must be stopped - "From the River to the Sea", "Global Intifada" are essentially calls for the armed annihilation of a nation. Likewise, the promotion or display of support for Canadian-recognized terrorist organizations must be stopped. Our laws must be enforced and enforced harshly to stop the wave of hatred that has been readily allowed to permeate our streets. To do nothing simply empowers these people to take more radical steps, as they have systematically done. On behalf of a proud Canadian and Torontonian, I ask you to please stop our city from being taken over by this illegal activity. Freedom of Speech does not give some the right to promote hate and that is what has been happening for many months now. Thank you!
- Julius Diamond
August 28, 2024. To the Toronto Police Services Board. Thank you for the opportunity to provide input Policing for our Great City. Civil Society remains functional only through the enforcement of law and order. Police are the first line of defense to keep a society living in harmony with one another. There are those that will ignore and break the law. Residents and visitors of the city rely on the Police to apprehend and charge those that disturb the quiet enjoyment of the city for all inhabitants. Police by their words and actions send messages to the public. If those messages are not neutral without favor to any group, the integrity of the Police is lost and without that faith in Police, people will act in their own self-interest to protect themselves. If the police won't, we will. I was a vehement opponent of those that would defund the police, or re-imagine policing which policies put not only the public at risk but also our brave policemen who risk their lives every day for our protection. I respect the police for all their efforts and thank them for putting their lives on the line for us. However, if the police do not act, and forcefully act, to enforce the law especially now with pro-terrorist protests, University encampments, Anti-Semitic rhetoric and slurs, attacks on synagogues, attacks on Jewish owned businesses, and threats to Jews continually without Police enforcing the law, Jews feel unsafe. Heretofore Jews have relied upon law enforcement to protect them. That woefully has not been an all-encompassing protection. If elements in society are allowed to commit hate crimes which contravene the law, the Jewish community will instead of peacefully protesting take steps for their own protection. Jews don't want to take matters into their own hands, but vigilantism fills the void in the absence of law enforcement. Police should be given all the resources to keep all inhabitants of the city safe. However, the pro-terrorist protests have shown the strategy and tactics of the protestors. We know their actions. We know that they have: 1. Illegally disrupted traffic especially in Jewish neighborhoods. 2. Illegally occupied University campuses, 3. Illegally tried to firebomb or damage Synagogues, 4. Illegally attacked Jewish businesses, 5. Illegally attacked Jews, 6. Illegally shouted and promoted Anti-Semitic rhetoric, 7. Illegally protested and prevented traffic at events, 8. Illegally uttered threat at inhabitants of our city just because they are Jewish, and 9. Committed other illegal activity. Since we know their strategy and tactics, it is incumbent upon the police to develop effective methods to stop, apprehend, and charge those that commit these illegal acts. Civil society demands it, not just for Jews but for all law-abiding Canadians. We urge the police board to: 1. Make sure the Police are adequately funded to carry out the methodologies developed to end the illegal Anti-Semitic activity. 2. Police are trained on the law and make sure they know how to enforce the law against all law breakers, whenever the law is breached. Zero tolerance period for breaking our laws: Federal, Provincial, or Municipal. Thank you for the opportunity to provide input. Yours truly, Julius Diamond.
- Hayley Goodman
As a Jew living in Toronto since October 7, I DO NOT FEEL SAFE. I have ceased to wear any outward sign of being Jewish (for example, Star of David necklace; T-shirt with the Walk for Israel). The synagogue in my neighbourhood has been vandalized FIVE times, the community near mine was targeted for months with Palestinian supporters blocking traffic in and out of the neighbourhood, waving flags and shouting. The targeting of Jewish businesses, places of worship, community centres, the university encampments that have gone on longer than any protests I've ever experienced living in Toronto for over 40 years, the traumatic experiences that many Jewish university, elementary school and highschool students have had to endure - slurs, rocks thrown at them, taunts - have all combined to make me feel unwelcome living in this city I have known and loved until now. The right to protest should NEVER makes others feel unsafe.
I have had to remove myself from Toronto on a number of occasions for an extended period of time for my mental health. I find it difficult to sleep and do not wish to go downtown or use public transport. The frightening protests on our city streets and continued intimidating and aggressive behaviour MUST STOP. For no other group in the city would this behaviour be tolerated.
THE TPSB must ensure that: 1. All protestors show their faces. Face coverings are unlawful. 2. Protests only occur with permits and are not permitted to disrupt the public (ie. travel the streets, target Jewish neighbourhoods, businesses, community centres, places of worship) 3. Any vandalism of private businesses be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. 4. ANY anti-semitic acts at any school be taken seriously with parents and teachers involved.
I appreciate the mobile police services vans set up in neighbourhoods, but the TPSB must go on the offensive to take the action noted above. Toronto used to be a tolerant city, welcoming of all races and religion. We won't be back to that until our Jewish citizens feel safe. - Jennifer Kassel
First, thank you for all you are doing to keep the Jewish community safe. I am deeply grateful.
I am very concerned with what is considered hate speech targeting Jews. There are countless examples of hate speech, calling for violence against me and my people (Globalize the Intifada, inverted red triangles, bloody hand prints and From the River to the Sea Palestine will be Free.) These were not only tolerated, but justified by biased antisemitic sources such as the United Nations and CBC given "context". Many groups use lies (oppressors, white colonialists) to rationalize violence against Jews. How do calls for the extermination of a people and their only state in the world not constitute hate speech?! These groups have not been shy 㤼㸶 Samidoun, Students for Justice in Palestine, Palestinian Youth Movement and U of T Occupy for Palestine - have been openly vocal, calling for the genocide of Jews. Their funding, ties to terrorist organizations and money laundering must also be investigated. I do not understand how encampment participants were free to break the law and then face absolutely no consequence for their actions (trespassing). Their actions excluded Jews from a major portion of the campus and trespassing on private property was unacceptable. Blocking traffic and preventing regular use of a public space is also illegal and violators should be charged. Even worse is the use of fringe antizionist Jewish groups being given such a significant platform when they represent a tiny fraction of the Jewish population in this situation. Please use CIJA, FSWC, B'nai B'rith and other Jewish groups to help inform your policy on hate speech. Both Canada and Ontario have accepted the IHRA definition of antisemitism because it was rigorously studied, and written after 15 years of consultation. Antizionism is antisemitism. Protests should be documented Arabic chants and posters should be translated for later arrest. Peaceful protesters should NOT be masked. Arresting peaceful counter protesters for their safety, like Dominic Cardy, is not a viable solution. Protests on any issue should be tolerated in public, dedicated spaces, but not at Jewish institutions, businesses, and neighborhoods. This holds true for ANY ethnic or religious group. Intimidation is not the same as peaceful protest. - Michelle Stock (The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs)
- Susan Sager
I am a citizen living in Toronto and I am Jewish. Over the last several months I have felt extremely threatened and unsafe.
The police and mayor must take more action against these so called "peaceful" protests. Yes protests are legal. But what is not legal are forms of hate speech. Inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group is "hate speech". I would ask that this not be tolerated at all. The groups who are involved should be removed and arrested if necessary. The police standing by and taking no action only allows these groups to continue their hateful and disgusting behaviour.
We need support for police training about laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order.
We need a hero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations and an updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement.
Blocking of streets/areas, encampments is not legal and should be stopped. More support is needed for police to maintain peace and order. There needs to be zero tolerance for hate speech at demonstrations.
University campuses are private property. Encampments that occur on university campuses are considered trespassing and against the law. University leaders are responsible for ensuring their campuses remain free from obstructions and should enforce laws relating to trespassing on University property. These encampments have been the source of hate speech directed toward Jewish and Israeli Canadian students. Resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments is desperately needed.
The message here is that these protests and hate speech gatherings should not be allowed. People should not be threatened in their city. Students should not be harassed, made to feel unsafe and harmed. More police are needed. More training is needed. - Jeannine Girard-Pearlman
Hateful and anti-semitic signs should not be tolerated and should be against the law. Canada is a land of tolerance and respect. Anti-semitic signs and anti-semitic rallies should not be tolerated. These are changing the fabric of our Canadian society. There is a difference between free speech and virulent attacks. As a 78 year old woman, I have felt very unsafe while walking in Toronto and meeting people carrying these kinds of signs usually coming from rallies. Please make these kinds of signs illegal. My grandchildren should not be afraid of living in Toronto.
- Nathan Rapoport
Isn't it time for the police to be more active at protests? Protests that hold up traffic whether vehicle or personal impediment should not be tolerated. We see police at all of these protests, what are they doing, keeping the protesters and counter protesters separated, something needed, but, if the protesters don't have a permit to protest where they are, isn't this illegal, shouldn't it be broken up? Having police standing around and doing little seems to be a waste of their time. Action is what is called for. Again, a 'legal' protest with a permit, is fine, but if it is illegal, and in many cases since October 7th, antisemitic, the police need to be more aggressive. Arrests should be made. I don't understand the purpose of having police at a protest when they are doing little to stop the protest. Blocking traffic is not making a point, it is plainly an illegal act and the police should act. I am tired of watching my television and seeing police in riot gear, doing nothing but watching. It is time for the police board to institute more aggressive action. Keep fining them or giving them a night in jail and we might see them thinking twice about joining a protest.
These protester are looking to intimidate, and if our police department are going to let them do this, there is something just not right about this. Again, if there is a legal protest with a permit, in a park or somewhere not blocking people from doing their ongoing daily plans, standing around like we oftern see police, is okay, but, not illegal protests, they must be stopped, aggressively, if necessary.
I know I have repeated myself in this commentary, but, because I don't think anyone is listening, it is worth repeating over and over again, until maybe the message gets listened to. - Alan Bender
I live at Dundas/University neighborhood. I am fed up with the noise and disruption perpetrated by the protesters. I believe they do not realize that they support terrorists. Why doesn't the police dept. Realize this. I am appalled that police resources are used to protect them and not the people affected, and dealing with excessive crime on our streets. These protesters are hateful and belligerent, and often times violent. There are times I am detoured or cannot even get out of my parking garage. If permits are granted, these protesters should be relegated to areas where traffic and citizens are not impacted, like parks or CNE grounds for example. Noone except these protesters cares about them anyway. Don't they realize that what they are doing has no bearing on any outcome or solution.
- Daniel Taras
Canada is the greatest country in the world.
As a Jewish person living in Toronto (or Hindu/Christian/Muslim ...), I deserve the right to feel safe when I walk the streets of my community.
Radical Islamist are trying to change that by manipulating young naive Canadians and recent Immigrants into behaving in a way that contradicts the Canadian way, including vandalizing, shootings and threatening Jewish institutions.
Our amazing police force needs to set the precedent and reward those who promote inclusion and severely punish those who try to instill fear.
I'm not sure how to do this, but EVERYONE respects Police Officers so we need to use that to get those who are young and influencable to behave in the Canadian way.
Don't let them push us around. We love our way of life and never want to change our freedoms. - Randi Libman
- Janine Lindgren (private citizen)
I am concerned about the rise of antisemitism, I am not Jewish, but have Jewish friends who are quite upset. These pro-Palestinian encampments and protests only fan the flames of hate. The problems of the Middle East should not play out on the streets of Toronto.
- Karen Fingrut
I was appauled that a group of Pro Hamas protesters were present at an information session which included MP's,MPP's, members of Toronto city council, and Mayor Olivia Chow that took place at the Pride of Israel Synagogue. The people were shouting "Intifada, Intifada." From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free. Genocide...." I thought that pro-Hamas flags and words of hate are against the law here in Canada. Please make the police aware of what this hate speech implies to the Jewish community. I was terribly distressed that for weeks a group of bused in pro Hamas protestors blocked the Avenue Road access to and from the 401 provincial highway. I spoke to several Toronto policemen who were sitting in their cars "protecting this neighbourhood" while these actions were breaking the law. When I called the non emergency phone number the officer said that there was nothing that they could do about it! I respect that the police have had a most challenging time assisting the Jewish Community. They do not have enough financial resources nor manpower to be everywhere. Some of the threats and actions have been disturbing. I am positive that this community has thanked each officer working at rallys and protests, and especially at the Walk for Israel which had 50,0000 people of all ages and nationalities. I thought they were doing an outstanding job protecting us. My concern is that Mayor Olivia Chow, in the name of equal opportunity, has not actually asked the Toronto Police to know and better enforce the municipal laws regarding hate speech. Thank you for your attempts to keep peace and order during a difficult time for us.
- Marc Grushcow (--None--)
- Simeon Olsberg
I am deeply disturbed by the mob rule that appears to run through Toronto's streets during anti-Israel demonstrations, where the police are consistently understaffed to deal with in any real way.
These demonstrations glorify illegal Terror Organizations e.g. by flying Hamas, Hezbollah or ISIS flags - all proscribed in the Criminal Code of Canada (CCC).
They threaten Jews and Jewish institutions in Canada and use genocidal language calling for the death of Jews: "From the River to the Sea" being a call for the genocide of Jews in Israel, contrary to the CCC.
They threaten death to Zionists - a clear reference to Jews, contrary to the CCC. They prevent Jews from walking in certain areas, e.g. UofT and York's encampments, reminiscent of Nazi actions during WW2, abrogating the rights of innocent Canadians. They prevent traffic from circulating in the streets and on our highways and prevent commuters from reaching their trains at Union Station.
The police are unable and or unwilling to respond with appropriate action. Jews in Toronto are scared to walk the streets openly as Jews, whether wearing a Kipa, a Star of David necklace or other clearly Jewish identification.
Jews do not feel comfortable in going into downtown Toronto as a result of the violence and threats emanating from the leaders of these demonstrations.
Let me be clear 㤼㸶 these demonstrations are not pro-Palestine 㤼㸶 they are in support of the globally documented October 7, 2024 barbarity that Hamas-affiliated Palestinian Terrorists participated in, where they raped men, women and children, burnt entire families alive, hacked off body parts of still-living victims and kidnapped 250 Jews, Christians, Muslims and Buddhists into Gaza.
There is no Genocide of the Palestinian people 㤼㸶 if Israel were intent on Genocide, it would have levelled Gaza on October 8. The High Level Military Group (HLMG)* has, in published reports to the United Nations, made it clear that Israel is conducting this war with more care shown to reduce civilian casualties than any other military force in history.
There is no famine 㤼㸶 the UNHCR has admitted that is a fallacy 㤼㸶 and one need only look at the pictures of people in Gaza 㤼㸶 they are clearly not starving.
As a result of these lies, however, our synagogues have been firebombed, graffitied and vanadalized and our schools have been shot at. Parents at the most recently targeted school were told the police would not provide any form of security outside of paid duty - essentially refusing to protect the community in the face of terror. No arrests in that shooting have been made.
Police - you need to do better - Police Board - you need to encourage the police to do better and provide them with the tools and resources to do same.
If we need to call out the militia/reserve Armed Forces to help the police maintain order and effect the arrest of those breaking the law, perhaps it is time to do so.
These gangs are bullies - dangerous bullies - and the police and government have allowed them free reign in Toronto for far too long. Fix this.
*The High Level Military Group (HLMG) was formed in early 2015 with a mandate to examine Israel's conduct of military and domestic security operations in the context of a larger project seeking to address the implications for Western warfare of fighting enemies who fight with a hybrid concept combining terrorism with more traditional military methods. Such adversaries show a total disregard for the Law of Armed Conflict (LOAC), while exploiting our own nations' adherence to LOAC - Don Colt
Toronto Police Service is doing a GOOD job.
STILL, much more is possible and truly NEEDED!
All forms of TERRIORISM must be STOPPED.
IT is a very big job and with public support the TPS can be achieved high success
ALL LIVES MATTER! - Tom Lobel
Sad to say but as a Canadian Jew I am now very concerned about my safety and the safety of my children, grandchildren and great grandchildren and the threats to the whole of the Jewish community. I recognize that the sometime violent demonstrations often involving illegal hate speech represent a serious problem for our police forces. My suggestion for dealing with this problem is to videotape as many of these demonstrations as possible and then have those tapes reviewed by people trained as experts in identifying the purveyors of hate speech and/or the individuals that are engaging in illegal actions. I suspect that there are a limited number of leaders of these demonstrations and once identified and if they are breaking our laws can then be properly charged. I believe that the present situation will get much worse until proper action is taken against the worst of the law breakers and that proper action requires serious consequences for the law breakers. Respectfully submitted, Tom Lobel #422 1 Benvenuto Place, Toronto. M4V 2L1
- Michelle Stock (The Centre for Israel & Jewish Affairs)
- Lisa Shiff
Since October 7th, I have felt afraid personally and as part of the Jewish Community in Toronto. I am shocked at the level of vitriol and hatred that has been permitted in the protests, in our streets, highway overpasses, in front of Jewish owned businesses, community centres and places of worship. I know that the police have tried their best to protect us. However, it is clear that they are woefully underfunded, and as well may not have the proper training to determine what constitutes hate speech. There should be a zero tolerance policy on hatred towards Jews. We are Canadians, just like every other ethnic group here. However, the level of hate crimes and speech levelled at us is unique. As a result, the resources should be vastly increased to protect us. It will be a horrible stain on Toronto, should a mass incident occur and it is not far fetched to anticipate that possibility. If that happens you will see a mass exodus of Jews from Toronto and Canada, and the economic repercussions on Canada will be permanent. Please give the police the funds that they need to increase protection of the Jewish community, our places of worship, our schools, and enforce laws governing protests. In addition, please encourage the law makers to pass laws, banning masks at protest. I believe it countervenes the criminal code already, if so then ensure that it is being thoroughly enforced. I am still hopeful that this dire situation in Toronto, the intimidation and violence towards the Jewish community, can be turned around if properly addressed with Zero Tolerance towards hate.
- Talia
As a resident of Toronto of over 60 years, I believe We ALL deserve freedom of movement and freedom from harassment. I suggest the police force create an app alert similar to amber alerts to inform the public of street disruptions.
The public deserves to be informed of dangerous street blockades and other event disruptions as soon as possible.
An alert could also prevent and expose many of these pop up disruptions before they grow. It provides the public with the opportunity to avoid these situations and potential confrontations. The attempts to take over our and disrupt our everyday life is overwhelming Unopposed, it enables further break down. If masked vigilantes can roam our streets with impunity it effectively means we have abdicated our collective duty to defend a free society.
We have laws . Obstruction of streets, harassment, incitement, slander and disturbing the peace is not free speech.
We have to empower the police to differentiate, and not give this over to the media or the mob.
We also can support the police with information. Input with a TIPS style format can be specifically be designed for these pop up disturbances. This gives the police more intel and tools to work with
The majority of Canadians ,when polled , value tolerance but they highly value law and order. We support and want policing. Community policing like neighborhood watch can be revitalized and assist.
A public survey can be done and a method for alerts and input can be devised to be effective. Input could be though regulated community agencies so that they can filter and substantiate legitimate posts.
In summary , The general public needs to be informed but also to be enlisted in helping the police secure our streets. . An alert sent to cell phones raises awareness in real time. Public input about the presence of pop up attacks can aid police and be preventative.
Together we can provide support, more calm, take back our streets and secure law and order for all.
Thank you and Blessings onward, In unity, Talia - PHIL DROZNIKA (None)
Peaceful demonstration by legitimate organizations is meaningful. When groups turn to hate and racism they need to be dealt with in the harshest methods by police. No pussyfooting around them. Protesters calling for violence against Zionists or Zionism is purely racism and antisemitism. THEY MUST BE DEALT WITH BY BEING CHARGED AND ARRESTED. This is Canada, ignorance is no excuse. People who teach hate must be dealt with as well….there is no room for this in Canada. Respectfully, P. Droznika
- Lorraine Franklin (Citizen)
As a Jewish mother and grandmother I am most concerned about the rise of anti semitones and increased shows of violence against Jews. I am umpiring the police to help protect the Jewish community against this so we can once again feel safe in our cities
- Jack Kugelmass (private individual)
- Linda Novick
- Gary Stoller
I am a Jewish Canadian who was born and has lived my entire life in Canada. I experienced little antisemitism until after October 7, 2023. The protests against Israel since that date have been clearly antisemitic and should not be tolerated in an open country like Canada. I have seen instances where people are threatened ("I will put you 6 feet under" at a downtown shopping mall) and the police stand by and do nothing. I live near the Avenue Road 401 highway overpass where it took many weeks before police put a stop to protest actions clearly intended to intimidate the Jewish community. I believe the police need to be more forceful in addressing these sorts of actions in an immediate and effective manner. Thank you.
- Mike
In general, I feel that individuals that are making threatening, taunting, or derogatory remarks to others in the community--whether at a rally or in a smaller setting--should NOT BE allowed. It's disgusting that assembly of people that are clearly doing mischief, trespassing, or demonstrating lawlessness are not being arrested. They SHOULD BE. Individuals that wear intimidating clothing--with derogatory language printed on it, or on banners and flags, or with apparel that is clearly in the public view meant to incite--should NOT be allowed. As a victim of a home invasion where I was physically assaulted by three males wearing masks and head scarves, seeing these images on TV and in person on the street is unacceptable. It's also unacceptable that being witness to demonstrations that call for my EXTERMINATION and killing (I am Jewish BTW) are NOT being stopped. I support that law enforcement receive better training to properly identify hate speech and hate rallies, and be accountable and responsible to swiftly end these demonstration, if only to prevent future ones from occuring. Protestors should NEVER be allowed to interfere with the public order, especially clogging up streets and neighborhoods in the name of "free speech". That's not free speech--that deliberate incitement and is illegal. Zero Tolerance should be the norm. Officers should have proper training to identify this..and the police CHIEF needs to direct his officers to end the shenanigans of hate groups.
- Ron Hoffman (citizen)
I have lived all my life ( 81years) in Toronto. while I experienced some antisemitism as a child I had thought it part of Canada's past and not its present. Given that protesters supporting Hamas ( a recognized terrorist organization having committed murders rape and other atrocities against Israeli/ Jewish people of all ages on October the 7th ) have since blocked traffic and have harassed Jewish students and Jewish owned buildings with graffiti and signage promoting hate against Jews, I fear for my safety in Greater Toronto and for that of my children and grandchildren all of whom live in predominantly Jewish areas or attend Jewish institutions. I ask that you advise the police to arrest those who are promoting hate in our communities and to prosecute them as well. While free speech and assembly are the rights of all when that speech or assembly is abused and promotes a fear for life person and peoplehood in some while promoting genocidal thoughts and violence in others regardless of objective, the police must be seen serving and protecting the lives and wellbeing of all our threatened citizens. I encourage you also to err if at all on the side of restricting such protests and demonstrations to places and times that do not interfere or at least very minimally with the public's carrying on of its daily activities. Toronto must be seen as a city that puts safety and order first and not giving the benefit of doubt to those who wish to support terror as an acceptable political statement by their words and actions in Canada through the promotion of fear and specifically antisemitism on our streets.
Thank you for this opportunity. - Samantha Goodman
How is it possible that Jewish schools are being shot at? That bomb threats are the norm for Jewish institutions? That people can walk around our streets wearing masks and intimidating Jewish people? Toronto is no longer a city where I feel safe and comfortable. I was raised on the values of multiculturalism and respect for all races, cultures, and religions. Why does this not extend to Jewish people? The Toronto Police need to step up and enforce the law. Lawless protests with faces covered yelling intimidations, harassing people and blocking the streets cannot be allowed. We must do better in our city. While the police have been wonderful at Jewish events, they have failed to keep our streets safe and secure for everything. Please start enforcing the law fully. People cannot protest without permits. They can't cover their faces. They can't make symbols for known terrorist organizations.
- Elaine Lazarus
- Roger Goldstein (Professor Medicine University of Toronto)
Firstly-thanks for the wonderful service you provide the Toronto community. It is much appreciated and not to be taken for granted. The issue of cultural intrusion came to light loudly in the recent campus protests. It is great that we are a multi-ethnic group and we also promote multiculturalism. However the latter must not be translated as a dominance with a disruptive level of protest such that Ontario is a secondary consideration. Caring for Ontario means respecting diversity and not using pretend equity to dominate, intimidate or suppress. We rely on the strength and clear messaging from the police to contain protest (not at schools or places of worship) to designated public area such as city hall. Similarly ordering adherents to pray visibly and vociferously in large numbers in public places is an example of abuse of freedoms granted to all not to have one culture impose itself on others. Thanks for considering. Please designate prayer to be in appropriate prayer buildings-temples, mosques, churches etc, where they rightly belong. Thanks for considering. RG
- Stephen Breslin (independent)
We all, as law & order respectful Torontonians, request that our exemplary Toronto Police Dept protect all Jewish residents, institutions, & organizations in Toronto.
And forcibly expel all violent protesters & anti-Israel & anti-Semitic camping on university campuses & elsewhere.
And not allow violent protesters & vandals to perpetrate harm & damage or engage in hate speech & anti-Semitic communication under the phony guise of 'free speech'.
Please don't allow Toronto to become a California, or like other major US cities that are allowing themselves to be hijacked by criminals & Hamas terrorist supporters.
I have always had the highest respect & admiration for our city's Police Force. And I'm confident I always will. - Mina Korman
Please keep our Neighborhoods, streets, homes, schools, synagogues, safe with adequate public police security. These protests are often hate speech.
- Katherine Greenstein
As long time members of the Toronto Jewish community, my family and I are feeling incredibly unsafe in our own city. We so appreciate the police presence at pro Israel rallies and the police vehicles at the Jewish schools in our neighborhood. A continuation of such protection and support would be a blessing. We have never felt threatened in the decades we have lived in Toronto. These are precarious times and police presence is necessary , I'm afraid . Thank you for your excellent work!!
- Jennifer Galet
Protests should not be allowed to disrupt the public by impeding roads or public services. Permits should be required, and rescinded if protests cross lines of intimidation or hate speech.
Masks must not be permitted as this enables agressive people to remain anonymous and not be identified if they are violent and engaged in criminal activity.
Schools, community centres and places of worship must be protected and there must be a security presence so that people can engage in community life without intimidation. - Susan Rosen Speigel (None)
I would like to see the laws that are in place held up by the Toronto Police. I would like them to be applied to ALL groups equally. Demonstrations should always be peaceful and not infringe on the rights of other citizens to move about their neighbourhoods and their city freely and without fear. I do not think this has been the outcome of many protests lately. I think the police allowed demonstrators to go too far in disrupting the peace and safety of our city. I am 66 years old. I was born in Toronto and have lived here all of my life. I have never witnessed such chaos in our city.
- Barbara Brachi (self)
- Elaine Marans
August 28, 2024
Elaine Marans To: Toronto Police Services Board Re: Public Order Policy Consultation Dear Board Members,
Thank you for the opportunity to provide input on your discussions regarding police responses during protests, demonstrations, and occupations. I am a member of the Jewish community and a proud Zionist. To clarify, Zionism represents the belief in the right of the Jewish people to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. The term 㤼㸱Zionist' is frequently used as a stand-in for 㤼㸱Jew' to avoid hate crime charges. If one were to replace 'Zionist' with any other minority group, it would be clear that such hate speech would not be tolerated.
Conduct that otherwise triggers non-discrimination and anti-harassment policy cannot be shielded by using "Zionist" as a substitute or codeword for Jew or Israeli. "Excluding Zionists from an open event, calling for the death of Zionists, applying a 㤼㸱no Zionist' test for participation in any activity, should not be tolerated.
Since October 8, 2023, I have watched with increasing discomfort and concern for my safety as a Jewish woman in Toronto as aggressive and brazen actions by "Pro-Palestinian" (or, more accurately, anti-Israel and antisemitic) protesters have unfolded. These protesters have occupied public spaces, intimidated students on campuses, entered predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods to block roads, and held demonstrations outside Jewish businesses, community centers, and places of worship.
While I strongly support the right to free speech and assembly, free speech does not include hate speech or incitement to violence, which is precisely what we are witnessing on our streets. My broader concern is how these protests, both here and around the world, are eroding the principles of Western democracy.
The police must consider the broader context of these protests and set clear boundaries beyond which actions become threats to others. Part of this context is the unique position of the Jewish community in Canada and worldwide. Jews make up approximately 1% of the Canadian population, yet they experience 70% of all religiously motivated hate crimes. By any measure, Jews are the most targeted and harassed minority group in Canada. Jews also carry the intergenerational trauma of systemic racism and genocide, most notably the Holocaust, which decimated the European Jewish community and eliminated one-third of the world's Jewish population. Globally, Jews make up just 0.2% of the population, yet they are discriminated against across vast regions. Israel, the Jewish state, is treated as the "Jew among nations," receiving more condemnations at the United Nations than all other countries combined despite being a liberal democracy. The legitimacy of attacking Israel provides an outlet for antisemites who wish to harm Jews indirectly. Governments, news organizations, and law enforcement often turn a blind eye when Israel, Israelis, and Zionists (which includes the vast majority of Jews) are delegitimized and threatened.
In this context, I propose the following policy recommendations:
1. Heightened sensitivity to protests targeting groups with a documented history of hate crimes. Objective criteria must be established to identify groups that require additional protection. 2. Restrict protests to locations with a direct connection to the cause being protested. For instance, protesting high municipal taxes at city hall is appropriate, but protesting outside private homes or synagogues is not. Jewish neighbourhoods and places of worship have little to do with the Hamas-Israel conflict and should not be deemed legitimate protest sites, especially when protesters are not local residents. 3. Zero tolerance for violence, threats, and property damage. Protesters who engage in such actions should be promptly arrested, prosecuted, and, at a minimum, sued for damages to deter future incidents.
I understand that balancing free speech and public safety is a complex challenge. We rely on the police to protect us from threats, violence, and intimidation while also safeguarding the rights of all to free speech and assembly. I hope these suggestions help in finding the right balance.
Sincerely, Elaine Marans Eglinton-Lawrence - Matthew Wood
- Rev. Daniel J. Winter (Calvary Church Toronto)
As a Christian church, we take a stand against anti-semitism and hatred against the Jewish people. We have had two Israel nights before October 7, 2023, and our senior pastor comes from a Jewish background. Every year, we participate in "Light up the Church" in solidarity with the synagogues world wide on the anniversary of Kristallnacht, November 9. Our senior pastor's grandmother was killed at Auschwitz, and many of his family members, including his own father, were persecuted in Nazi-controlled Germany, simply for being Jewish. We haven't had protests outside of our church, but we have removed "Free Palestine" stickers on church property, and on multiple occasions encountered an individual on the sidewalk outside the church doors waving a large Palestinian flag as some of our seniors were coming out of Bible Study. We believe in freedom of speech, but do not condone defacing of private property, nor any form of public harassment.
- Daniel McAlister (None)
The anti semitic rallies of hate must end. Those participating must be arrested and charged. "From the river to the sea" for example, is a call for violence against Israelis and must be treated as a hate crime. Furthermore, face coverings in public demonstrations must be made illegal. The cowardly Hamas terrorist supporters are afraid to be known to police because they know they are committing a crime by participating in hate marches. They do not deserve anonymity and their faces and names must be exposed to the police and public.
- Karen
After experiencing protests and graffiti in my neighbourhood, I believe there is a need for police to adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech, symbols or signs at public demonstrations and for those wearing face coverings while breaking the law at these demonstrations. There needs to be updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement, and resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests. Thank you.
- Jane Knop (Self)
The wearing of masks at public protests is intimidating and should be banned. If people are choosing to hide their identity it is likely because they are scared of doing something "wrong" and are ready to intimidate and break the law. Further, there should be no protests in residential areas that in any way intimidate local communities and/or block traffic. This is threatening behaviour and should be fully prosecuted rather than enjoy police protection funded by tax dollars. There should be no protests allowed near schools or religious institutions and again instead of spending police resources "protecting" said institutions there should be clear messaging and actions to not have them occur in the first place. If organisations wish to hold protests etc they should be done in places that are set up to handle this and not impede the regular life of the city tax paying citizens. It is time for the city to be proactive and make clear the rules and consequences and enforce them across the board. They duty and the mayor have been reacting in a delayed matter based on politics rather than the well being of tax payers. Further the city must enforce rules around hate speech and adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism. The city should make clear that substituting the word Zionist for Jew will not be viewed differently under the law and is discriminatory and against the law. The city should in addition review its own DEI offices and rework the clearly politically charged nature of administration.
- Marvin Cooper
ENFORCEMENT OF LAWS Laws not being enforced by police. During protests, encampments, and demonstrations, laws relating to mischief, trespassing, lawlessness, and unlawful assembly are not being enforced or interpreted as being an offence under criminal law. I am asking for support for police training about laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, particularly in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods.
HATE SPEECH VS FREE SPEECH Where is the line between hate speech and free speech? It is the job of the police to know where that line is and to be ready to hold perpetrators to account for their actions. To be clear, inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group ARE severe offences and must be dealt with accordingly. The is a serious need for police to adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations and need for updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. - Anthony Camisso
The overriding principle is that every member of the public should be able to feel safe at all times in our beautiful city. No interest group, no matter how strongly they feel about their particular cause, should be allowed to override that principle. I am sure, at least hopeful, that Toronto police are trained and empowered to uphold that principle and where necessary, are allowed to use the force that we, the public, equip them with. Antisemitism is a terrible evil which seems to be becoming more prevalent these days, should not be allowed to take hold and seemingly empower those who would espouse it. I am not Jewish, but I am disgusted by the tactics of some of those who attack Jews simply because they are Jews. It seems that we have allowed some people to bring with them their inborn hatred of Jews when such people come to settle in our country.
- rhoda singer
first and foremost i thank you for the ability to voice our concerns to you
as a grandmother of 9 wonderful grandchildren i have been very disturbed as to the dangers that are present in schools, streets, places of worship, shopping malls etc.
to have witnessed the encampment and occupation at the university of toronto for 60 days without our police having the ability to clear it within hours behooves me to wonder how much power does our police have when this was totally unlawful as it was trespassing.
i understand the wonderful freedom we have in canada of freedom of speech. however hateful speech which entices others that might not even know the truth of what is being spouted and therefore joins the band wagon is unthinkable.
thank you till now of what our wonderful police force has been doing to protect us, but it must definitely be kicked up a BIG notch. more protection in all the areas i mentioned before.
our children need to know that their safety is your concern in all these public places and that 911 will respond if they feel frightened, intimidated or threatened.
rhoda - Judy Nyman
To the Toronto Police Services Board. Thankyou for listening. I am a second generation Jewish senior, living in Toronto. I am a retired investor and have had extensive involvement with philanthropy both in support of the Jewish community and the broader secular community. The events of October 7th shocked and upset me for many reasons. But the reaction of too many of my fellow Canadian citizens and residents to the events of October 7 and the Israeli incursion into Gaza has upset me far more!. I, my children and grandchildren, are being blamed for a situation in the Middle East I have no control over, and for the decisions made by a government on the other side of the world. As a result, I no longer feel safe in my own city. We used to refer to Toronto as "Toronto the Good." Personally, I cannot say that any more. It's not Good when a significant number of people do not feel comfortable in their own city. You know the reasons why because of your positions on the TPSB. The implied threats, actual threats, and general intimidation that has taken place along with the actual attacks on physical structures and individuals, in apparent response to decisions of a foreign government, are simply uncalled for regardless of whether you agree with that (Israeli) government or not. I can effectively argue the Israeli case but that is not the point. The point is, that importing conflicts into our multi-cultural society is highly problematic to the overall health of that society. Moreover, the fact that actual or threatened violence, and "in your face" aggression is used by the pro-Hamas supporters against supporters or perceived supporters of Israel, is simply wrong and in many respects, illegal. We Jews are not accustomed to behaving as our enemies currently are doing. We tend not to bully, we march but positively, and avoid disparaging those with whom we disagree other than via the use of rational argument. And we try hard to be good Canadians. Many of us are responsible for that which has been Good about Toronto. Thus far, we have not responded to our adversaries with aggressive tactics as they have done, because it is not our style. However, there are those in community who are tired of the attacks, and believe we should be responding to fire with fire, so to speak. What has stopped that from happening is the Toronto Police, as well as the police forces in other areas near Toronto. Led by our community organization, UJA, we are encouraged to refer our fears and challenges to the police which is what should happen in a healthy society which believes in law and order. Which leads me to the major point of this note. There are some 200,000 Jews in the GTA. Due to the security threats against us, we are mobilizing and spending large amounts of time and money to combat those threats and keep ourselves safe. To the extent that we can continue to count on the Toronto Police, who have generally done their best to respond to protect us as best they can, we do not need to mobilize to threaten or bully or respond to that bullying. To the extent however that the Toronto Police do not have our backs, or are not properly equipped to deal with those who would upend our society, many of us will inevitably be forced to take matters into our own hands. For some that may mean leaving the city. For others, it may mean organizing groups to protect each other, which will inevitably lead to escalation and more conflict. This is not what we want. But it is an inevitability which leads to the recommendations which follow: The Board must ensure that the necessary funds are available for the police to do their job properly, a job that is much greater in scope now than it was several years ago. There are two aspects to the necessary investments. First, more funds are required simply because the demands being put on the police forces to respond to specific incidents which are increasing monthly, and to deal with the many marches and protests, are materially greater in scope than in the past. We are well aware that the funding provided to the Toronto Police, even before considering the current challenges presented by the Pro Hamas protesters, has been insufficient to deal with rising crime, an increasing population, etc. Add to that the exponential rise in need because of the Pro Hamas protesters, and it becomes virtually impossible for the Toronto Police to do their jobs optimally. A related challenge is to ensure that the individual members of the police force, who are generally well intentioned, have the necessary training to use existing hate laws effectively, and know when to use them. The Police must apply the rule of law consistently in order to maintain order and trust. Therefore, all members of the Toronto Police must be educated and up to date on current challenges, and the application of current laws to those challenges. Part of that must be training in the nature of the protests, the anti-semitism which is embodied in much of what the pro- Hamas crowd participate in and some understanding of the origins and nature of the hatred which is often at the core of what are often overly aggressive protests and attacks, not to mention the individual anti-semitic attacks taking place daily in our city. The Toronto Police are entrusted with maintaining law and order in the City of Toronto. That means there should be zero tolerance for hate crimes and public disturbances which violate federal, provincial or municipal laws/bylaws. We do not blame the police for the predicament we are all in. In fact, we appreciate the police for their hard work in helping us to deal with the intimation, bullies and attacks thus far. And we know that this Board would love to have the necessary funding to do what is needed. But, given that there is every chance that the pressures will increase before they subside, it is critical that the Toronto Police and its members be provided with the funds, the resources, and the education and training they need to manage what is now an escalating and challenging situation. The first responsibility of government at all levels is to ensure an orderly society and require the adherence to our laws. To the extent that is done with the necessary resources, we can weather this storm. But without the necessary resources, you can expect an escalation which could be explosive in nature and far more costly in many respects to deal with. Respectfully submitted, Judy Nyman
- Yakov Soloveychik
I am very concerning and upset by pro Palestine demonstrations in Toronto. There are a lot of antisemitic slurs in this demonstrations. Calling to destruction of Israel, the only Jewish state in the world, is clear act of antisemitism. Antisemitic acts in schools and universities makes the life of Jewish families unbearable in Canada. It makes Jewish Canadians to think about emigration from Canada. All this happens with impunity . Police just watches. The people, involved in these action , are not prosecuted. All them should be deported or jailed. It is the shame for Canada for not being able to protect its own citizens.
- David Kates
We need to be able to recognize and identify the role of incitement in these pro-Palestine demonstrations. Calls for "resistance," "intifada" and "revolution" are often intended as a rallying call not just against the state of Israel but against Jews everywhere. The result of this rhetoric has too often been the targeting of Jews, Jewish-owned businesses and Jewish institutions for acts of violence, harassment, vandalism and more. A lot of their protest activities fall within free expression but these incitements absolutely do not, no matter how much plausible deniability protesters attempt to work into them as cover. Unfortunately, to the uninitiated, it's often hard to distinguish where these lines are being crossed. I think that the police need to consult with Jewish community leaders to build a better understanding of how to identify these incitements and act accordingly.
Right now, it often feels like we're the only ones who can see what they're doing to us, and this is probably the most distressing part of the Jewish community's experience over the past year. Few people believe us, just as few will give us a fair hearing, and all the while, an angry mob continues to have its way with us about 90% of the time.
Our kids are being harassed and bullied at school and the bullies' parents are the ones encouraging it! Our synagogues are being vandalized. Even Jewish-run charities that serve the broader community are being faced with harassment while they are on the ground trying to help people in need. We cannot go on like this. - Brent Belzberg
There are well reasoned laws on the books dealing with trespass, public disorder and hate crimes . A refusal to enforce them on Avenue Rd or on U of T or TMU campuses is not an option. Absolutely your board and officers should have discretion but by not enforcing even minor infractions, you give permission to others to participate and create more infractions.
In addition, certain communities particularly the Jewish community, is being forced disproportionately to fund their own protection . This is not the society we anticipated . All of us should be treated equally and our services should protect those most vulnerable and on hate crimes and the anarchy resulting the Jewish community is at the present time most at risk. - Seth Frieberg
I am concerned with all the protests happening around the city. They don't make me feel safe and I think that if people/groups don't have permission to protest, the police should enforce the law. And when protests do occur, police should be there making sure that they are civil and not terror supporting.
- Don Citron (CIJA)
Only peaceful demonstrations should be allowed Any reference to death to Jews death to Israel From the River to the Sea should not be permitted and charged with hate crimes University occupations should be removed Not freedom of speech!!
- Gary Bourgeois
I am deeply concerned about the level of hate being generated on the streets and public spaces in our beloved city. I am an immigrant to Canada as are most others resident in Toronto. In all my years here (almost fifty) I have never seen such blatantly illegal and unCanadian behavior from any other ethnic or religious group. These antisemitic hate rallies should not be tolerated by the TPS. The rules against hate speech should be enforced. The illegal and unpermitted rallies and occupation of public spaces (such as Union Station) should be shut down. My question is why is this now being tolerated? Have we decided to give our city over to a bunch of radical Islamists who are blatantly harassing and intimidating the public. THIS MUST STOP.
- Joanna sherman (Citizen of Ontario)
Concerned about the increase hate towards the Jewish community and the lack of discipline needed to stop this hate from non Canadian and new comers who don't hold Canadian values.
- Mitch Altman (Mhouse Inc)
- Balla Smith
Not feeling safe with pro Hamas demonstrators-they're protesting in Jewish communities, synagogues, Jewish schools, place of businesses, encampments on universities, etc. They're Stopping traffic, events, etc. There are no consequences. And what do Canadian Jews have to do with what's going on in the Middle East? These protesters initiating these protests are being funded by Iran and Palestinian organizations and creating havoc on Canadian soil. Freedom of speech is one thing but harassment towards Jewish Canadians/and or destruction of Jewish property is another matter. Please enforce consequences.
- Susan Stronell
My understanding, is that we already have laws in place that dictate the rules and regulations regarding what is permissible and what is not when hosting a public protest.
I would like to see these laws enforced vigorously. For example, no demonstrating in retail locations unless you own them. No blocking public access to highways,roads, places of worship,hospitals and schools. No protesting with your face covered protesting within hours that are reasonable so not late at night. If only The police would enforce these laws. I would be very grateful. Thank you. - Karen Hyman
It's my opinion that lawlessness in the name of freedom of expression is a loophole that needs to be closed. Masked riots, angry mobs, hateful speech and targeted antisemitism being tolerated in our city makes me feel unsafe, unwelcome and misunderstood. I resent that my tax dollars are being misappropriated to managing these protests - our police time should be better used to solving the myriad big city issues that Toronto faces instead of wrangling rioters, closing streets, repairing damage. The mayor has made no effort to curtail this violence and hate. I wonder how she would react should these be anti- another country/religion? I suggest no masks. No hate speech. No blocking Jewish neighborhoods. No destruction of property. And real consequences for those who disobey.
- Karen Goldlist (individual)
Thank you for the opportunity to provide my input regarding safety in Toronto. Firstly I want to thank the Toronto Police for their commitment to keep us safe during this unprecedented time in our beautiful city. The following are the concerns that are my priorities.
I believe there should be zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations and ask for updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. Police need to have the training to identify and respond quickly to hate speech (speech / slogans / symbols) when it occurs. Further, if someone is masked and inciting hate speech, I believe that is illegal and they should be arrested. The police force should be educated on these protocols.
I would also like to be ensured that protests are not obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business. I would also like explicit instruction on how to deal with protesters blocking my car from moving. How do I know if they are protesters or someone wanting to hi-jack my car? This is a fearful situation that I would never want to find myself in. Do I flee and not worry if I injure that person? I would like for police to impose safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent them from being used as venues for protest. I acknowledge that protest management comes with resource costs, and it is important that Mayor Olivia Chow provide support for police to obtain necessary resources to maintain peace and order. - Shirley Meisels
- Allan Goodman
I am quite upset with the blatant disregard for the law occurring in our city on an ongoing basis with the weekly and daily unlawful protests occurring on our streets with little or now enforcement of the law. I appreciate everyone's right to peacefully protest, which means applying for a permit and conducting the protest in a confined area in accordance with those permits, but far too often in this city on a weekly and often daily basis demonstrations are taking place in the public streets with total disregard for the law. Not only do these protests block public movement, they often include public intimidation. The criminal code does not allow people to protest with masks and intimidate others. These laws must be enforced. If these protests are to occur in our city, they must apply for permits and abide by the rules of those permits and the law. The police must send a message and enforce the laws as written and not be afraid to enforce the laws when they are being breeched. Enough is enough. It is time to step up the enforcement and return the city to a peaceful place to exist. Nobody should feel threatened or insecure on our streets. It is time to return the City to a place of law and order and stop the intimidation and scare tactics being used during these unlawful protests.
- Anne Creighton
Why aren't you arresting any protesters inciting violence against Jews?? You job is to protect and serve. You are not protecting us.
- Howard Saginur (self)
Words pledging "protection" are great, but I can't see how effective that protection is when a nearby synagogue got vandalized four times. If I as an individual start praying in the middle of Dundas and Yonge, I should be arrested. SIMPLE. If a mob occupies the AGO, then a significant number should in my mind be arrested.
Why don't we hear about arrests ? What are the incidents for which arrests have been made ? - Julie Fass
I don't understand how hate can be shouted in our public streets and nothing is done. Free speech doesn't not mean you can spread hate speech….this should be enforced. Not just during public demonstrations but on our walls and streets….if the Jews of Toronto see and hear, why don't our officers? Let's stop it when it happens at the rallies. Let's clean up the hateful graffiti before it's reported for the 3rd or more time…..
- John Sewell (Toronto Police Accountability Coalition)
- Dr. Lesley Simpson (Personal submission by Toronto resident)
I write to the TPSB as someone who feels fortunate to call Toronto my home. I l feel lucky to live here but I am unsettled and alarmed by the attacks against Jewish institutions including synagogues, schools and businesses.
I am writing to the TPSB to voice support for more resources for training for the police when it comes to hate crime and hate speech at public demonstrations. As a Toronto citizen, I recognize training costs money, and I am happy to pay more property taxes to pay for additional training for the police. We know silence enables the oppressors. Since October 7 there are many days I do not recognize the city I love and call my home. I am asking for the Toronto police to enforce a zero tolerance policy when it comes to hate crime and hate speech to keep all of our citizens safe. What begins as attacks against Jews never ends with the Jews and is a symptom of a society in distress. Anti-Semitism is not like other forms of racism. It can be confusing to identify . For a great quick primer listen to what the late Rabbi Jonathan Sacks explains about this mutating virus. We have the power together as a community to make a difference. https://rabbisacks.org/videos/the-mutation-of-antisemitism/ Thank you for the opportunity to make a submission for consideration. Dr. Lesley Simpson - Noam Pratzer
- Rob
We need you to crack down on the antisemitism. That means marches that support the terrorist group Hamas & Hezbollah as well as the Houthis That means quickly removing free Palestine graffiti and arresting those that do it. Ending public prayer sessions that are designed to intimidate Jews by showing they can stop traffic and impact everyone life in the name of Allah
- Cathy Seetner
The police failed at every early opportunity to rein in anti Jewish pro-Hamas encampments and demonstrations that specifically targeted the Jewish community. By failing to take action early on and making arrests ONLY of the peaceful pro-Israel/pro Jewish bystanders and counter protesters the optics of your failure served to enable and embolden the vile pro terrorist pro demonstrators to the point where they shot up Jewish childrens schools, places of business and places of worship and make bomb threats. Your failure has put the Jewish community of Toronto at risk to the point where the entire world has been made aware of how bad it has become to live as Jews in Canada.
With increasing frequency and audacity mobs spewing hate rhetoric and calling for global Jihad and genocide against Jews and Israel, are surrounding our places of worship with aggressive demonstrators, marching through our Jewish neighbourhoods and city streets like Nazi storm troopers, intimidating and harassing residents, students and congregants,. Instead of arresting the ringleaders, the police chatted them up, escorted them on their march and even brought them refreshments in Toronto! Meanwhile Jewish and non-Jewish community members are being harassed, threatened, intimidated and even assaulted by the mob of antisemite "protestors" and encampments who are aided and abetted by foreign funding and gullible student rabble rousers. Right out of the Nazi playbook. While the Mayor of Toronto giggles about Democracy in action this is not democracy or free speech. This is hate. This is support for terrorist groups. They have vowed to return and carry out worse threats and the police department I hope will do a better job to put an immediate stop with arrests before it escalates. Masks need to be banned too! Pro Palestinian mobs are emboldened by police and governmental action or lack thereof, to escalate the harassment and targeting of Jewish residential areas, schools and synagogues and it is because the police DO NOTHING to deter them. Police don't disperse or arrest the protesters, they don't uphold the laws already in place against hate speech, they don't remove or prevent screaming mobs from blocking access to synagogues, community centres and schools for children at risk. These are not political targets and not a legitimate place of protest these are antisemitic attacks and interfere with the civil rights of law-abiding citizens. Instead of arresting the pro terrorist pro Palestinian protestors who verbally abused, threatened and assaulted police officers and bystanders, in Toronto the police arrested a reporter doing his job, an Iranian man waving an Israeli flag and an East Coast Politician answering back to the mobs. In Thornhill, three Jewish residents who were trying to defend their person and property were arrested, on an elderly woman in her 60's! When you are arresting the victims and not the perpetrators spewing hate and making threats and intimidation that is giving the pro Hamas groups a license for ramping up the violence. Imagine if masses of people started protesting in front of mosques?
There is no way these groups should be allowed to terrorize or otherwise block access to neighbourhood communities, schools, shopping malls and places of worship; they must be forced to cease and desist and not fed refreshments and HELPED by police for God's sake.
Had the police been doing their job they should have also arrested the individuals responsible for threatening the individuals who saw fit to try and defend themselves since the police did not. It was so bad in Thornhill I could hear the shouting from the protestors storming my neighbourhood from my porch near Centre St. blocks away and I was afraid.
PLEASE DO YOUR JOB . keep the peace, arrest aggressive protestors, arrest the ringleaders, keep them away from schools and places of worship and from blocking access roads and marching unchecked through our neighbourhoods screaming hate and inciting violence against Jewish citizens. Arrest the ringleaders and other individuals making the threats, committing the assaults. Investigate to trace the source of their foreign funding and cut it off. If you don't do your job It is only a matter of time before this escalates into more people being seriously hurt or killed as in other cities and possibly more citizens resorting to self defensive measures. We have seen this story unfold before in the 1930's and we know how it ends. We can do better here. - Nicki Weiss
As a Jew in Toronto, I no longer feel safe nor supported by our government nor police. In a recent Globe opinion article, Robyn Urback expressed my thoughts exactly. Here is an edited version of her article, which I totally agree with.
A mass bomb threat against Jews? Who could have seen that coming?
If only there were signs.?If only we could have foreseen 㤼㸶 somehow 㤼㸶 that the climate in Canada would become so toxic toward Jews that now, in August of 2024, more than 100 Jewish institutions would receive a bomb threat, warning that the buildings' occupants "will all end up in a pool of blood."?"None of you deserve to keep living," it read.?How did we get here??
If only there were signs. Like, say, weekly protests that regularly included antisemitic chants about sending Jews back to Europe or celebrations of terrorist groups.?If only there was a way to know that the most extreme rhetoric expressed by participants 㤼㸶 including those who shouted "Long live October 7? and "October 7 is proof that we are almost free" 㤼㸶 were not simply errant opinions.
Maybe we would have noticed it if some people cheered, in Vancouver and Ottawa, when speakers celebrated the deaths of Israeli civilians. Or if a gathering was held in Toronto on Oct. 7 "to honour and celebrate the Palestinian resistance." Or if, after Israeli forces killed Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh, a group assembled in Ottawa to engage in a "prayer in solidarity with our assassinated resistance freedom fighters."
Perhaps then we might have seen that a rogue voice expressing hatred for Jews wasn't actually so rogue after all.??
If only there were signs that Canadian Jews were being maligned for the actions of a foreign government. Like if, for example, protests against Israel somehow routinely ended up on a highway overpass in a heavily Jewish community in Toronto, or if they migrated outside a Jewish community centre.
Or if Jewish-owned restaurants in Montreal were listed for boycott. Or if a menorah was destroyed outside a Toronto Jewish cultural centre. Or if Jewish kids were being bullied at school.?
Maybe we could have foreseen that things would get violent if someone shot at a Jewish school in Montreal in November, or firebombed a Montreal synagogue that same month, or vandalized a Fredericton synagogue in January, or shot at a Jewish elementary school in Toronto in May, or shot at a Jewish school in Montreal days after that, or lit the door of a Vancouver synagogue on fire the following day, or threw rocks through the windows at two Toronto synagogues one month later. Maybe then this mass bomb threat wouldn't be so shocking.?
How could we have known that antisemitism would become so entrenched in Canadian society? Perhaps a clue would have been if a Victoria theatre cancelled a play set in Israel, or if a Vancouver comics festival banned an Israeli-American artist because of her past service in the Israeli Defence Forces, or if organizers of an Ontario International Women's Day event disinvited a keynote speaker for the same reason.
Maybe if pro-Palestinian encampments popped up at Canadian universities, where gatekeepers demanded ideological conformity for admission, and some called for globalizing the intifada.
And maybe if this was just allowed, for weeks, as if it was normal and acceptable, we might have had some indication that antisemitism 㤼㸶 even overt displays thereof 㤼㸶 would be tacitly condoned.?
Maybe if York University teaching assistants claimed in written materials that their university's tolerance of the campus group Hillel, which engages in such divisive activities as hosting Shabbat dinners for students away from home, was evidence of its complicity in genocide.
Maybe if the president of CUPE Ontario celebrated "the power of resistance" a day after Hamas's mass slaughter of Israeli civilians, and if he shared an antisemitic video in August. Possibly then we might have been able to recognize that antisemitism had infiltrated some of our highest institutions.??
But even then, what would have given someone such a sense of impunity that they would threaten 100 Jewish institutions at once? Was it Winnipeg's mayor taking down the city's menorah, or Moncton's mayor doing the same? Or Calgary's mayor skipping the city's menorah-lighting ceremony, or Toronto's mayor declining to attend the Walk with Israel or calling the annual flag raising at Queen's Park on Israel's Independence Day divisive?
Was it the empty words offered by Canadian politicians, over and over again, in lieu of action each time a Jewish institution is attacked??Or maybe these individuals were emboldened by the national indifference this country has shown toward the targeting of Catholic churches, dozens of which have been set ablaze over the course of the last few years?
Maybe it was the constant dismissal of the concerns of Jews feeling unsafe in Canada, because, as many have taken to saying now, why should anyone care about hurt feelings here, when people are dying in Gaza??
If only there were warnings, beyond the threats, violence, vandalism, harassment, cultural exclusion, institutional antisemitism, empty words and constant gaslighting. And when 㤼㸶 not if 㤼㸶 someone gets seriously injured or worse, we'll wish there had been more signs, too.?
I wish the police would act, act quickly, act consistently, and become educated about Jew hatred. Enlist the help of Jewish organizations like UJA, Bnai Brith, CIJA. The above behaviours and attitudes Robyn Urback so clearly articulated would not be tolerated towards any other minority community in Toronto and elsewhere. There is a constant double standard when it comes to Jews and it needs to stop. The police are a major part of stopping antisemitism.
Thank you. - david sefton (Citizen)
I have been a Toronto resident since 1954. I have never been so frightened as i am today as i have to face the Anti-Semitic hatred and demonstrations that have been occurring in this City since October 7 2023. Some of the demonstrators are breaking the law. They should be arrested and I should be allowed to live my life in peace. David Sefton
- Ian Cohen (N/A)
There needs to be a much better Police response to antisemitic, anti-zionist, anti-Israel hate speech. I would like the Police to respond in the exact same manner as if the KKK set up encampments and ran through the streets shouting "Kill all Blacks". This would not be tolerated and action would be swift. The Police need to take the mindset that protestors shouting " from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free" is exactly the same. In fact when protestors shout "Kill all Jews" - nothing happens!!! Police leadership need to be much more forceful and provide CLEAR direction to policemen that this is HATE speech.
I talked to numerous policemen last year and all of them stated they were understaffed to act immediately, or NOT given direction to do so and were WAITING on the judiciary and supervisors for "direction". I cannot imagine this would be the case if the KKK were marching.
Dr. Ian Cohen - Lee Geller
- Sheryl Waxman
I live in the Armour Heights neighbourhood and experienced first hand aggressive protestors on the bridge over the 401. A friend in the neighbourhood was swarmed by pro Palestinian protestors while walking his dog, several months after they were deemed illegal. As the Jewish High Holidays approach in the fall, I am worried for the safety of my community. As Robyn Urback wrote in The Globe and Mail, where I work "A mass bomb threat against Jews? Who could have seen that coming?" https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-a-mass-bomb-threat-against-jews-who-could-have-seen-that-coming/. The incidents of antisemitism are horrifying and escalating.
- Mohamed Boudjenane (Canadian Arab Federation)
- Lindsay Soberano Wilson
As a Canadian Jewish woman and a mother of Jewish children I am alarmed at the lack of policing to protect Jews at public institutions such as schools and our places of worship and even our own homes. I am frightened and intimidated when men and women chant to rape Jewish women in the streets chanting "by any means necessary" and sometimes are even holding Hezbollah and Hamas flags. I am the granddaughter of Romanian Holocaust survivors who was born and raised in Toronto --I am Toronto. I taught many students in Toronto about diversity and inclusion. This is not my Toronto. Clean up the streets from these hate festivals and hate teach-ins where "protestors" hide their identity with masks and intimidate Canadians. Why are masks not banned at protests ??????
- Sebastian Decter
I have personally witnessed the Toronto Police escalate conflicts at peaceful protests, and I urge the board to direct the police to have a minimal presence at these protests. Some other changes that would make me feel more safe as a community member engaging in my charter rights to peaceful protest:
-Banning the mounted unit from policing protests. I have witnessed officers intentionally and recklessly ride horses into crowds or unarmed people. I have also witnessed officers lose control of their horses and have them buck wildly in the presence of large crowds of people. I can not imagine what role the mounted unit has in keeping the peace.
-The establishment of some sort of unarmed crowd/traffic control role, maybe in a completely different agency. I have witnessed officers be way too quick to pull out batons/pepper spray etc, and I wonder if there could be some sort of liaison or crowd marshal that could direct these protests without violence or intimidation. I have witnessed many organizations create their own marshals for this reason. I've seen civilian marshals at these protests practise better deescalation and crowd control tactics than the police.
-Banning mass surveillance at peaceful protests. I have become aware that police vans driving in front of peaceful protests are photographing and documenting people participating in the protests. I've also witnessed officers writing descriptions of civilians participating in people protests. This intimidates and discourages Torontonians from engaging in their charter rights to peaceful protest.
Thank you. - Max Dublin
I am a former refugee and naturalized citizen of Canada. My parents were Holocaust survivors and I was born in a Displaced Persons (DP) camp in Austria after World War II. The killing of most of one's family, the loss of all assets and most material possessions, the trauma of having endured many years of hunger, cold and danger--I doubt that there is or has ever been a more compelling definition of refugee than that but that is my family's story. Nothing the world has ever known compares to the killing and wanton destruction of World War II with 25 to 35 people, mainly civilians killed every day.
My family came to Canada for safety and security. Safety and security are the number one job of any government, indeed they are the main reason that governments have been formed throughout the world. When safety is secured then people can fend for themselves to provide for themselves in a free and open society. On the local, municipal level the police are the main agent that assures the citizens safety and security. That is why the motto of the Toronto Police Service is "To Serve and Protect." In this respect one of the most fundamental principles in a free and open society is equal protection under the law. All citizens are first-class citizens, all whether rich or poor part of a majority or minority are deserving of safety and protection. For this purpose we already have on the books all the laws that are needed both in the Criminal Code of Canada as well as in the Municipal Codes of Toronto. Enforcing these laws should be a self-evident mandate.
I recognize that resources of all government agencies, including the police services are limited. That is why it is necessary to nip all public disturbances in the bud and to penalize all criminal activity in order to deter its escalation. When I was growing up in Toronto and for most of my life this is exactly what was done and because of the safety and security that that provided us my family was able to rebuild our lives and live happily hear. Because of this my late father came to call Canada "a golden land, the best country on earth." Were he alive today I'm afraid that he would be compelled to take back those words.
It is not too late to restore those conditions in Canada. And it is the duty and honour of the Toronto Police Services to do its part in making that happen. - Jeff Waldman
- Ellen Rosenbluth
A cornerstone of being a Canadian, and even more so, a Torontonian, has been a sense of pride that we have one of the most multicultural cities (if not the most) in the world and that the City works because people are largely welcoming, tolerant and proud of that diversity. This sense of pride and accomplishment is rapidly disintegrating. Jewish Canadians, a group that has lived and contributed positively to that diversity, are now being targeted, vilified and threatened. As a Jewish Torontonian, I no longer feel safe wearing a Jewish star; I do not let strangers know I am Jewish for fear of a negative or hateful reaction; I was afraid to go to UofT during the occupations for fear of my safety - even though I am a two-time graduate of UofT. Because our political leadership has been largely absent in terms of condemning the aggressive antisemitic protests, speech, occupations, road closures, etc. etc., as a society we now have to rely on the police for protection of Jewish institutions and communities. It is sad, shocking and would have been unthinkable just one year ago. But here we are.
Notwithstanding the challenges we face as a Jewish community in particular and as a multicultural municipal community more generally, I would like to take this opportunity to commend the Toronto Police for the stellar job they did during the Walk for Israel in May 2024. Everything was done thoroughly with professionalism, sensitivity and an incredible display of force. The presence of the police at Jewish community institutions and events has also been greatly appreciated.
To help control the public expression of hatred and to help keep Jews in Toronto safe, I would recommend the following:
a) We now know that there are those who are trying to upend our social fabric, including growing evidence that international actors are fomenting the activities and aggression. Toronto police need to enhance their monitoring, surveillance, monitoring and response capacities for demonstrations, protests, encampments and occupations before they occur to better plan for anticipated disruptions and aggressions. b) Protests need to be better managed to prevent protesters from terrorizing and scaring people where they live and work; from fomenting hate; and from obstructing traffic and preventing people from going to their homes or places of work. This might involve establishing safe access zones to ensure that schools, community centres and services, and places of worship are protected from protests.
c) Enhanced office training and education on hate crimes is now essential. All police, be they experienced or new recruits, need better training to identify and respond to hate speech, symbols and slogans. Yes - people have a free speech right to protest. But that right cannot supercede the rights of people to live without fear, aggression, violence and threatening hate speech. Hate speech has no place at protests, rallies, demonstrations or anywhere in Canada. This must be enforced.
It is often said that Jews are the canary in the coal mine. Hatred and hate speech, racist aggression, intolerance tend not to be contained to just one group. As phenomena that seek to destroy our relatively peaceful co-existence, they threaten all groups. They threaten Canadian society at large. It is time to approach this issue with the seriousness it demands and show those who would destroy our values that we, as a society, will not stand for that.
Thank you for this opportunity. - Melissa Keetley
Police should be required to intervene in any protest. demonstrations or occupations when they are used to spread hate and incite violence. These forms of protests should not be allowed if they are meant to demean another group or put another group at risk of harm (physical or emotional).
- Cynthia Lazar
Download file
The major deficiencies that I can identify in policing hate crimes in Toronto are resources and education. The biggest threat to Jews now comes from the left rather than the neo-Nazi right. Therefore, Holocaust education is not particularly useful, other than to serve as a historical example of how most of the world can be brainwashed into believing that exterminating Jews would be righteous. I am a Jewish alumna of the University of Toronto Medical School, taught there, and still live in the area. I am the daughter of a Holocaust survivor. During the spring encampment, on the doorstep of my alma mater, I saw many examples of hate speech, calling for violence against me and my people (Globalize the Intifada, inverted red triangles, bloody hand prints and From the River to the Sea Palestine will be Free.) These were not only tolerated, but then ignorantly denied by the court, who relied on biased antisemitic sources such as the United Nations and CBC for context. Thankfully the court recognized that excluding Jews from a major portion of the campus and trespassing on private property was unacceptable. Blocking traffic and preventing regular use of a public space is also illegal. Both Canada and Ontario have accepted the IHRA definition of antisemitism because it was rigorously studied, and written after 15 years of consultation. Antizionism is antisemitism.
The police are doing their best, performing a difficult, expensive and thankless task while resources are strained, and education is insufficient. The hate crimes unit needs financial and human resources to allow for case based education. Practical scenarios will help them understand how to apply our robust criminal code and municipal by-laws at protests. Education should be provided by mainstream Jewish organizations, like CIJA, B'nai Brith or ALCCA. Do not be led astray by fringe antizionist Jews, representing less than 3% of us, like Independent Jewish Voices and Jewish Faculty Network. The protests should be filmed. Arabic chants and posters should be translated for later arrest. When masks are worn, arrests should be made earlier while identification is possible. Arresting peaceful counter protesters for their safety, like Dominic Cardy, while expedient, is absolutely the wrong path. Jew hatred permeates many of the groups promoting absurd and hateful lies (genocide, apartheid, white colonial oppressors.) These groups then use those lies to rationalize violence against Jews, since it feels righteous. They ironically feel justified in exterminating, what they see, as the only impediment to a better more peaceful world. While the hateful lies do not constitute a crime, calls for violence and genocide do. These groups have not been shy 㤼㸶 Samidoun, Students for Justice in Palestine, Palestinian Youth Movement and U of T Occupy for Palestine - have been openly vocal, calling for the genocide of Jews. Their funding, ties to terrorist organizations and money laundering must be investigated.
Lastly, protest, no matter how abhorrent is tolerated in public spaces, but not at Jewish institutions, businesses, and neighborhoods. Intimidation is not the same as peaceful protest. - Farooq
I salute the TP for the difficult job of maintaining public order especially among protests/demonstrations. However, the Police has a tendency to use excessive force or to unwittingly instigate flare-ups at anti-war demnostrations, resulting in unfair escalations and arrests. The police must, instead, practice calming and de-escalation techniques to avoid maligning community members unfairly, especially youth. The goal of policing is to accommodate expression, not create barriers to it. From memory, these flare-ups have been witnessed most commonly in demonstrations against the genocide in Gaza - leading to overall allegations of anti-Palestinian racism against the Toronto Police. I hope the police board can take these practices into account for an improved public experience.
- Marni Tolensky
I would like to see a policy by the TPS that respects the right to protest but also maintaining law and order in our streets and respecting the right of Torontians to live their lives and move freely in our city and to exercise our right to free speech without being silenced by protesters shutting down events they don't agree with in the name of free speech. There should be a zero tolerance policy towards unpermitted protests, hate speech and calls for violence of any kind, and intimidation. Given the disproportionate numbers that TPS face in trying to maintain the law when attending protests, they should be allowed to use various methods to help them do their job properly. Some examples could include outlawing masking at protests, arresting those spewing hate speech and supporting recognized terror groups and also keeping roadways clear for traffic so that Torontonians can move freely around our city. The right to protest is a fundamental right but it should not outweigh all the other rights citizens have to free speech, association, expression, etc. There also should be less tolerance for protests and bad behaviour where the subject of the protests may be vulnerable eg religious institutions, schools, residential areas and the protest is intimidating or causing apprehension.
- John Chris
- Boris Milman
- Jonathan Rotchtin
August 26th, 2024
RE:Public Order Policy Consultation
As a Jewish person and new father, I am deeply disturbed by the rise of antisemitism in Toronto. This rise of hate has been on display across our communities for nearly a year. The protests and acts of violence both in public spaces and targeted at Jewish community buildings have made me feel less safe in Canada than I have ever felt before.
While I am a believer and fierce advocate of free speech, I firmly believe that using language and actions that target a specific group to promote hate and incite further violence puts all Canadians at risk. We are a country of freedom, but also of laws. If as a society we cannot enforce those laws and ensure its citizens feel secure and safe to belong to a specific community, we don't uphold the values of diversity and equality this country stands for.
I urge the Toronto Police Service Board to ensure your policies reflect: Interfering, quelling or arresting, when necessary, protesters that use language that is clearly identifiable as promoting hate and/or terrorism Shutting down protests in and around Jewish neighbourhoods and places of worship that are clearly meant to intimidate (for example, the protests that went on for over a week at the 401 overpass at Avenue Road) Not allowing full face coverings from protesters, which protect identities and embolden people to spread hatred without consequence
I appreciate your support and commitment to protect the citizens of Toronto - including me and my family.
Jonathan Rotchtin - Jenna Herman
August 26th, 2024
RE:Public Order Policy Consultation
As a Jewish person and new mother living in Toronto, I am deeply concerned about the safety for myself and my family. With the rise in antisemitism and protests that incite hate and promote terrorism, it has become increasingly frightening and disturbing. The protests and acts of violence both in public spaces and targeted at Jewish community buildings have made me feel less safe in Canada than I have ever felt before. As a mother of a baby boy, I feel this concern goes beyond myself.
While I am a believer and proponent of free speech, I firmly believe that using language and actions that target a specific group to promote hate and incite further violence put all of Canadians at risk. We are a country of freedom, but also of laws. If as a society we cannot enforce those laws and ensure its citizens feel secure and safe to belong to a specific community, we don't uphold the values of diversity and equality this country stands for.
I urge the Toronto Police Service Board to ensure your policies reflect: 1. Interfering and quelling demonstrations or protests that use language that is clearly identifiable as promoting terrorism (for example, "From the river to sea, Palestine will be free") 2. Shutting down protests in and around Jewish neighbourhoods and places of worship that are clearly meant to intimidate (for example, the protests that went on for over a week at the 401 overpass at Avenue Road) 3. Not allowing full face coverings from protesters, which protect identities and embolden people to spew hatred without consequence
I appreciate your support and commitment to protect citizens of Toronto - including me and my family.
Yours truly, Jenna Herman - Michael Teper (Canadian Antisemitism Education Foundation)
- Nolan Grubert
I am a proud Jew fortunate to have lived during what could only be described as a golden age for Jews in North America. Until recently, I'd experienced only a handful of instances of antisemitism in my lifetime and those experiences were restricted to my youth over 50 years ago.
My life as a Jew in Canada changed on October 7th, 2023. Every day since, I and Jews across this country have been vilified in the streets of our country by gangs of terrorist sympathizers who advocate for the murder of Jews and the destruction of the only Jewish state in the world. Some go so far as to call for murder of Jews right here in our country.
The narrative they espouse is rooted in falsehood, the product of conspiracy theories that date back over 100 years. The demonization of Israel and Jews by these groups serves only one purpose, and that is to delegitimize the existence of the State of Israel and the right of Jewish self-determination in the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, whose documented historical tie to the land dates back over 2500 years.
Since October 7th, Jews across this country have been subjected to a flood of protest that almost always crosses the line of free speech rights into hate speech and intimidation.
Sadly, Toronto police have refused to act too many times when confronted with blatant antisemitic hate speech and threats of intimidation that clearly cross the line into criminal behaviour. This lack of enforcement has simply emboldened the protesters and escalated the level of their hate-filled rhetoric to the point that many in the community wonder what it will take for the police to act. The foundational values of this country are under attack. As such, the rights of all Canadians are under attack and the future of this country as we've known it is at risk.
Our police must do their job; they must enforce our laws, protect the citizens of this country and uphold the values that so many Canadians of every race, religion and ethnicity have fought and died to establish and preserve. - Debra Anthony (none)
I am deeply concerned about the rise in antisemitic hate and violence demonstrated in our city since October 7. Why are protesters allowed to block roads, cover their faces, intimidate people and prevent access to public areas? Why are the current laws not being enforced? This laissez faire attitude to policing gives implicit permission to the protesters to continue their hateful and dangerous behaviour. The rest of us, law abiding citizens who are not afraid to show our faces in public, are afraid of going about our daily business. Uphold the law so everyone feels safer.
- Diane Leith
I have read the excellent letter from Mark and Eva Madras. We need constant police protection at all times in order to secure a safe environment for our families. Thank you for helping us with this goal!!!
- Liora Freedman
Thank you for the opportunity to submit to the Police Board. I am a Canadian citizen of the City of Toronto. I live and work here, and I live in an area where protests and encampments have had a severe and negative impact on my life. Enough is enough. Allowing hate on our streets has to end. We must stop emboldening hate and fostering radicalization. I have read the submission of the Alliance of Canadians Combating Antisemitism (ALCCA) and I agree with their points. We can no longer normalize antisemitism; just as we do not tolerate anti-black racism we can not tolerate anti-Jewish or anti-Israel hate.
Hate activities are taking place in this city. Today they disproportionately target the Jewish community. They target me, my family, my friends, my colleagues at work, children at schools, Jewish institutions and places of worship, and university students. But tomorrow it might not only be Jews who are the targets of hate. How are bomb-threats, arson, death threats and daily harassment now normalized for Jews in Toronto? For we are the canary in the coal mine. Who will be next if we do nothing to stop Jew hate?
These activities require a significantly enhanced law enforcement response. Hate and intimidation are currently being tolerated, including in my neighbourhood and where I work. All too frequently, the correct balance has not been struck between freedom of speech and community safety.
The police and the city of Toronto have available to them a wide range of measures to regulate and respond to protests, demonstrations and occupations. The Board's policy should identify the full range of criminal enforcement measures available to the police to address such public order events. In my view, some of these measures have been under-utilized. We also need to request changes at the Provincial and National level to support our local police, to support the Toronto Police, in combating hate and intimidation. Equally important, police discretionary decision-making requires an appreciation of the full range of provincial offences such as those under the Highway Traffic Act, as well as City of Toronto bylaws available to police. This full toolkit of measures must be considered by police in addressing lawlessness, including the obstruction of highways and roads, interference with the lawful use and enjoyment of private and public property, and/or with critical infrastructure. Freedom of expression is critically important, but it does not mean that the city is powerless to take measures to regulate the time or place of such speech. A number of these measures need not impair freedom of expression or minimally do so in the public interest. Kindly refer to the ACCLA submission for their fulsome and thoughtful views as they represent my own. Thank you very much. - Marnie Gold
Hi As a citizen of Toronto I am appalled by the arrest of a senior citizen tied to a pole at Yonge and eglinton bringing awareness about the hostages as he was arrested for blocking traffic yet many Hamas supporters block whole lanes of traffic praying in the streets I am Not sure of your hands are tied because of our terrible sympathizing mayor but this is not right or fair
- Fredelle Brief (personal)
I am concerned about the anti-Israel demonstrations that take place weekly near my home. I live around the corner from the US consulate. Some of the demonstrators carry antisemitic signs and shout antisemitic slogans. Although there is a police station at the corner of my street, there is little police reaction. Is it ok to block streets? Is it ok to shout antisemitic slogans in the streets? Walking in the area is a challenge. I use a walker and I find this atmosphere to be intimidating
- marcie zajdeman
I support completely and in totality the submissions of the ALCCA on this matter. I also support the "Written Submissions to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights Study of Antisemitism, May 2024" made by the Honourable Harry Laforme and Karen Restoule, providing an Anishinaabe perspective, and rebuking governments that purport to care about Truth and Reconciliation and the Duty to Consult, and that virtue signal regarding Land Acknowledgements; but, that did not consult with Indigenous Peoples regarding protests on their Treaty and Traditional Lands. According to the Laforme/Restoule submissions, many of the protestors' chants and signs (such as "There is only one solution intifada revolution") are deeply offensive, hateful, racist and antithetical to the sacred teachings of Indigenous Peoples. My own view, as an expert in Indigenous Law, is that politicians and policy-makers who favour undue appeasement of the hateful sloganeers or indulgence of the hateful sign-carriers need to brush up on what Truth and Reconciliation means and requires. Toronto can and must do better to balance freedom of expression, which is not an unfettered right, with the rule of law and vigilant enforcement of hate and utterances of threats. All levels of government must support and facilitate law enforcement in their mandate to serve and protect, and not shackle them in the pursuit of their roles and responsibilities. There is no place for identity, progressive, or other politics in this matter. Constitutional rights are the cornerstone of a free and democratic society, but they can't be "rolled back" by bad actors to create anarchy, unsafe agitation and/or to promulgate hate and danger. We all know you can't scream "fire" in a crowded theatre. And you don't have to wait for the genocide of the Jews to ACTUALLY HAPPEN before you come down hard on those promoting this. Nor should you be fooled by the semantic gymnastics designed to provide cover for messages that are clear, hateful, incendiary and antithetical to the Duty to Consult and Truth and Reconciliation.
- Ariella Pratzer
Dear Chief of Police, I understand愼㸰that the Toronto Police service board愼㸰is looking to愼㸰establish a policy on police action in respect of protests, demonstrations and occupations, and that you are愼㸰seeking the public's input on the愼㸰overriding principles and key elements愼㸰that should be a part of this policy.愼㸰 Toronto is a vibrant, diverse city that prides itself on inclusivity and mutual respect. However, recent protests have seen an alarming increase in hate speech, and specifically antisemitic remarks, which undermine the values we hold dear. Such speech not only harms targeted individuals and groups but also jeopardizes the overall safety and unity of our community. I believe that an overriding principle of your policy needs to be a zero-tolerance stance on hate speech. While there is freedom of speech and a right to protest (and these should be protected), hate speech and calls for genocide have no place in our public spaces. The Toronto Police Service should愼㸰implement training for officers on recognizing and addressing hate speech and antisemitic language effectively. Additionally, there should be clear guidelines and communication to the public about the zero-tolerance stance, so that all participants in public demonstrations understand the boundaries of acceptable conduct.
Policing protests (especially the number of protests our city has seen in the past year) is expensive, time consuming, and takes up police personnel. I appreciate that this places strain on the police department. However, given the degree of hatred at many of these protests, the targeting of Jewish people and businesses, the blocking of people from living daily life, failing to police these protests comes at great risk to our communities and is not something we as a city can afford to do.愼㸰 I believe the police should receive the training and resources necessary to do this effectively and so as not to detract from the other many important functions they play in our city. Thank you very much for allowing the public to provide input. - Lorie Shekter-Wolfson
I am very concerned about what we have experienced this past year. Although anti-semitism has been present for many years, I was fortunate enough to be able to live in a city that appeared to support different religions, races and peoples from many nations. Since October 7, I no longer feel as safe or welcomed beyond my community and close friends. As a mother and grandmother I now fear for my children and grandchildren and what the future world will be like for them.
Although my parents were born in Canada, I heard from my grandfather what life was like for him in the Ukraine and why he had to flee and the anti-semitism and hate speech my parents had to endure growing up.
This past year we have seen demonstrators and protestors talk about their hatred of Jews, Zionism and Israel. Although some have argued they do not have a problem with Jews, it is Israel and/or Zionists that they do not like, they do not see that for many Jews that is the same. Some may also argue they have a right to protest, as Canadians are entitled to free speech. But what has been seen this past year is not free speech but hate speech. " From the river to the sea" is about the annihilation of the Jewish community wherever they live.
When the University of Toronto encampment occurred this past summer I was shocked by the fact that it was allowed to continue for as long as it did. As an alumni and financial supporter of the University I felt betrayed. I was surprised that the police could not or did not do anything despite the fact that the University encampment was on private property and staff and students did not feel safe. I never thought I would see that in my lifetime.
I have felt that the Police have been a tremendous support to the Jewish community these past 10 months and have been relieved to see them at important events such as the Walk for Israel, at synagogues and Jewish Day Schools. But there seems to be a lack of understanding of what is free speech and hate speech. I feel that there needs to be more education re: this and more funds to support our police. Please do not let what has happened these past 10 months continue. Our lives ( quite literally) depend on how we address these issues in the future. - Dinah Poliwoda
Walking in Ontario's cities feels like the 1930s in Germany or Gaza. Is it what you want in Ontario? Allowing apologies to terrorism and mass murders? Wake up!
- Anaïs Bussières McNicoll (Canadian Civil Liberties Association)
- Michael Diamond (Jewish Community.)
To the Toronto Police Services Board. Thankyou for listening. I am a second generation Jewish senior, living in Toronto. I am a retired investor and have had extensive involvement with philanthropy both in support of the Jewish community and the broader secular community. The events of October 7th shocked and upset me for many reasons. But the reaction of too many of my fellow Canadian citizens and residents to the events of October 7 and the Israeli incursion into Gaza has upset me far more!. I, my children and grandchildren, are being blamed for a situation in the Middle East I have no control over, and for the decisions made by a government on the other side of the world. As a result, I no longer feel safe in my own city. We used to refer to Toronto as "Toronto the Good." Personally, I cannot say that any more. It's not Good when a significant number of people do not feel comfortable in their own city. You know the reasons why because of your positions on the TPSB. The implied threats, actual threats, and general intimidation that has taken place along with the actual attacks on physical structures and individuals, in apparent response to decisions of a foreign government, are simply uncalled for regardless of whether you agree with that (Israeli) government or not. I can effectively argue the Israeli case but that is not the point. The point is, that importing conflicts into our multi-cultural society is highly problematic to the overall health of that society. Moreover, the fact that actual or threatened violence, and "in your face" aggression is used by the pro-Hamas supporters against supporters or perceived supporters of Israel, is simply wrong and in many respects, illegal. We Jews are not accustomed to behaving as our enemies currently are doing. We tend not to bully, we march but positively, and avoid disparaging those with whom we disagree other than via the use of rational argument. And we try hard to be good Canadians. Many of us are responsible for that which has been Good about Toronto. Thus far, we have not responded to our adversaries with aggressive tactics as they have done, because it is not our style. However, there are those in community who are tired of the attacks, and believe we should be responding to fire with fire, so to speak. What has stopped that from happening is the Toronto Police, as well as the police forces in other areas near Toronto. Led by our community organization, UJA, we are encouraged to refer our fears and challenges to the police which is what should happen in a healthy society which believes in law and order. Which leads me to the major point of this note. There are some 200,000 Jews in the GTA. Due to the security threats against us, we are mobilizing and spending large amounts of time and money to combat those threats and keep ourselves safe. To the extent that we can continue to count on the Toronto Police, who have generally done their best to respond to protect us as best they can, we do not need to mobilize to threaten or bully or respond to that bullying. To the extent however that the Toronto Police do not have our backs, or are not properly equipped to deal with those who would upend our society, many of us will inevitably be forced to take matters into our own hands. For some that may mean leaving the city. For others, it may mean organizing groups to protect each other, which will inevitably lead to escalation and more conflict. This is not what we want. But it is an inevitability which leads to the recommendations which follow: The Board must ensure that the necessary funds are available for the police to do their job properly, a job that is much greater in scope now than it was several years ago. There are two aspects to the necessary investments. First, more funds are required simply because the demands being put on the police forces to respond to specific incidents which are increasing monthly, and to deal with the many marches and protests, are materially greater in scope than in the past. We are well aware that the funding provided to the Toronto Police, even before considering the current challenges presented by the Pro Hamas protesters, has been insufficient to deal with rising crime, an increasing population, etc. Add to that the exponential rise in need because of the Pro Hamas protesters, and it becomes virtually impossible for the Toronto Police to do their jobs optimally. A related challenge is to ensure that the individual members of the police force, who are generally well intentioned, have the necessary training to use existing hate laws effectively, and know when to use them. The Police must apply the rule of law consistently in order to maintain order and trust. Therefore, all members of the Toronto Police must be educated and up to date on current challenges, and the application of current laws to those challenges. Part of that must be training in the nature of the protests, the anti-semitism which is embodied in much of what the pro- Hamas crowd participate in and some understanding of the origins and nature of the hatred which is often at the core of what are often overly aggressive protests and attacks, not to mention the individual anti-semitic attacks taking place daily in our city. The Toronto Police are entrusted with maintaining law and order in the City of Toronto. That means there should be zero tolerance for hate crimes and public disturbances which violate federal, provincial or municipal laws/bylaws. We do not blame the police for the predicament we are all in. In fact, we appreciate the police for their hard work in helping us to deal with the intimation, bullies and attacks thus far. And we know that this Board would love to have the necessary funding to do what is needed. But, given that there is every chance that the pressures will increase before they subside, it is critical that the Toronto Police and its members be provided with the funds, the resources, and the education and training they need to manage what is now an escalating and challenging situation. The first responsibility of government at all levels is to ensure an orderly society and require the adherence to our laws. To the extent that is done with the necessary resources, we can weather this storm. But without the necessary resources, you can expect an escalation which could be explosive in nature and far more costly in many respects to deal with. Respectfully submitted, Michael Diamond 305-80 Yorkville Ave, Toronto 416 433 8590.
- Tal Vilenski
Antisemitism and anti-Muslim hate are equal in abhorrence but unequal in scope. This is clear from TPS' own reporting of statistics that clearly demonstrate the abhorrent increase and escalation of Antisemitic violent hate crimes in Toronto. Palestinian and pro-Hamas supporters have specifically targeted Jews and Jewish institutions with a goal to intimidate Jews at their places of worship, the communities they live in and the businesses they own or work at. The hypocrisy makes this especially egregious given such demonstrations would not be tolerated if they targeted Muslims, the LGBTQ community or people of colour. Police inaction and lack of enforcement has simply emboldened the terror-supporting mobs that are inciting hatred and intimidating innocent Torontonians. There are many existing Canadian, provincial and municipal laws that are not - but MUST BE - enforced. Based on the Criminal Code of Canada, what the mobs are doing is not "lawful" protest protected by a constitutional right, rather they are committing criminal acts that are hateful, violent, targeted, and well-organized. Torontonians want to see enforcement and prosecution, not more platitudes and virtue signaling. Police should all be re-trained and understand the relevant sections of the Criminal Code (below) so they can consistently implement a set of protocols to SHUT DOWN the protests where hatred and/or violence are incited, peace is disturbed, or access to religious institutions or transportation infrastructure is blocked. Relevant Criminal Code sections: - Blocking or obstructing a highway (Sec. 423(1)(g)) - Intimidation (Sec. 423(1)) - Causing a disturbance (Sec. 175) - Common nuisance (Sec. 180) - Interfering with transportation facilities (Sec. 248) - Breach of the peace or imminent breach (Sec. 31 - Riots (Sec. 32, 33, 64, 65, 67, 68, 69) - Unlawful assembly (Sec. 63) - Mischief (Sec. 430) - Wearing a mask while committing the above offences (Sec. 65(2))
- Barbara Seagram (Barbara Seagram Bridge Associates)
- Yoni Levy (Private citizen)
Requesting the following Police Guidelines for Managing Protests:
*I. Pre-Protest Planning*
- Review protest permits and notifications - Assess potential risks and threats - Develop contingency plans - Establish clear communication channels - Designate protest liaison officers - Gather intelligence on potential protest-related criminal activity
*II. Protest Monitoring*
- Maintain situational awareness - Monitor protest size, location, and behavior - Identify potential flashpoints - Use surveillance and intelligence gathering - Track social media and online platforms
*III. Engagement and De-Escalation*
- Establish dialogue with protest leaders - Use de-escalation techniques - Provide clear instructions and warnings - Employ crowd control measures (barriers, etc.) - Avoid confrontations
*IV. Enforcement*
- Focus on criminal behavior, not protest ideology - Use graduated force responses - Prioritize arrests for violent or criminal behavior - Minimize use of force - Document incidents and evidence
*V. Addressing Illegal Activities*
- Illegal Occupation: - Identify and address illegal occupations - Provide clear warnings and instructions to vacate - Enforce trespassing laws and regulations - Use appropriate measures to safely remove occupants - Masking to Conceal Identity: - Identify individuals masking to conceal identity - Assess potential risks and threats - Enforce laws prohibiting mask-wearing during unlawful activities - Use appropriate measures to safely identify and apprehend individuals - Incitement of Violence: - Monitor and address incitement of violence - Enforce laws prohibiting hate speech and incitement - Arrest individuals promoting violence - Harassment and Intimidation: - Identify and address harassment and intimidation - Enforce laws prohibiting harassment and intimidation - Protect vulnerable individuals and groups - Disruption of Essential Services: - Identify and address disruptions to essential services - Enforce laws prohibiting disruptions - Ensure continuity of essential services - Property Damage: - Identify and address property damage - Enforce laws prohibiting vandalism and property damage - Protect public and private property - Failure to Comply with Lawful Orders: - Enforce lawful orders - Use appropriate measures to ensure compliance - Document incidents and evidence
*VI. Use of Force*
- Follow established use-of-force policies - Use proportionate force - Avoid excessive force - Consider alternatives (pepper spray, etc.) - Document force used
*VII. Arrest and Detention*
- Follow lawful arrest procedures - Provide clear reasons for arrest - Ensure humane treatment - Provide access to medical care and legal counsel - Document arrests and detentions
*VIII. Crowd Control*
- Employ crowd control measures (dispersal orders, etc.) - Use clear communication - Avoid kettling or corralling - Provide escape routes - Minimize injuries
*IX. Protection of Rights*
- Protect freedom of expression and assembly - Ensure equal treatment - Prevent discrimination - Respect privacy and property - Facilitate media access
*X. Accountability*
- Document all incidents and actions - Conduct internal reviews - Cooperate with external investigations - Discipline officers for misconduct - Review and update policies
*XI. Training and Equipment*
- Provide regular training on protest policing - Ensure appropriate equipment (protective gear, etc.) - Maintain communication devices - Stay updated on legal developments
*XII. Community Engagement*
- Foster positive relationships - Engage in dialogue - Address community concerns - Provide information - Build trust - Lala Loon (ALCCA)
To the Toronto Police Services Board, I am fortunate enough to be born shortly after the Holocaust; my parents and brother were not as lucky. I grew up in a house where the memory of wartime horror and anguish was ever-present. My family's anger at the world's indifference while the Jews of Europe were disenfranchised and sent to their death was palpable. Almost 80 years later, today's Toronto Jewish community is once again demonized and threatened with cries of "Death to the Jews" and so, we have every reason to be greatly concerned.
Defacing Jewish schools, institutions, and houses of worship with messages of hate, lies, and threats of violence is not OK, and is against the law. This is not merely a case of simmering anti-semitism that can be shrugged off as ignorant. It is real and in-your-face anti-semitism. I am afraid when I hear of Jewish schools for young children shot at; synagogues defaced and defiled with hate-filled words and outright lies; and university campuses taken over by proponents of Jihad who exclude anyone not aligned with their ideology of terror. I so much need to know that the police will protect me and deal with these offenses in a way that upholds the law.
"Global Intifada by Any Means Necessary" is a call to action for terror and death against all Jews. The Pro-Palestinian movement is tied directly to groups designated by Canada as terrorist entities, Hamas and the IRGC included. Its leadership is cut from the same cloth as its Nazi heroes and its pursuit of eliminating the state of Israel and Jews everywhere is relentless. Its members have even felt within their right to threaten to put a Toronto Policeman 6 feet under while he was in the line of duty, and that on top of everything else really terrifies me! Without the police there to keep law and order, will I and my children be safe at the Ashkenaz Festival next weekend? What about the Jewish holidays? Will our synagogue still stand or will it be targeted like so many others? Will my Keffiyeh-wearing neighbour treat me with disdain, or worse, if he finds out that I'm Jewish?
I hope that the efforts of the Toronto Police will prevail and help to stop the proliferation of hate in our midst. I know that theirs is a demanding and often dangerous job and I am grateful for what they do. I would like to make a few suggestions: I think that a comprehensive training program on anti-semitism for the police would be very useful in helping the Toronto Police recognize anti-semitic tropes - past and present This would help clarify when to lay charges. The Toronto Police could also be assisted in their work by having the services of a unit that could document and translate Arabic, French, or other languages used in video footage of Pro-Palestinian rallies. Finally, I would like to see Toronto Police working with CSIS, the RCMP, and the CSE to identify and hold accountable foreign entities who fund anti-semitism through illegal encampments, Pro-Palestinian protests, and terrorist training camps such as the one taken down at McGill.
Thank you again to the Toronto Police Services, and thank you very much for reading my submission.
Sincerely, Lala Loon - Morton Brown (Retired MD an FRCSC)
I am a retired surgeon of 87 years of age, born in Canada and practiced surgery in Toronto at a major hospital for 42 years. I am of the Jewish faith and like many other Jewish medical doctors have devoted my life for the betterment of our community as well as others who came to Toronto specifically for our medical care. Our numbers are small but we have played a major roll in offering first class medical care to all peoples. So also have other professionals, business people, entertainment companies, builders, government officials and donors to hospitals, the arts and charities been also the Other professionals of the Jewish faith have done the same offering their expertise to the betterment of our citizens. Toronto has become a top notch centre through the expertise and efforts of those professions. The sky line of Toronto has been greatly achieved through Jewish builders , engineers and architects. Jewish companies have played a major roll in the business world. The entertainment industry has also benefited from Jewish companies producing top quality live entertainment. When one walks through our hospitals , theatres and major facilities they quickly note the major Jewish donors who have done much to make Toronto what it is today. We are small in numbers and have done much for the betterment of society and our country Canada. Over the last few years antisemitism to an extreme degree has made it's presence in our country. We Jewish people deserve better consideration and protection than what is the case today. Those in governments at all levels and the police MUST STAND UP NOW TO STRONGLY SECURE THE SAFETY OF THE JEWISH COMUNITY. Everyone deserves and expects safety and respect. Certainly we have earned it. Sincerely Morton Brown MD. FRCSC
- Laura Schwartz
1) I ask that the police take advantage of and are trained to know about existing laws and bylaws to ensure that criminals are apprehended and charged without delay lest they continue to be emboldened. They need the support of the government to pay for trainers and translators and a sufficient number of officers to ensure parity when they are on site at a hate rally. 2) In order to understand hate crimes and to reduce their confusion, the police need a translator who can immediately interpret the hate speech that occurs during unlawful occupations, in mosques, in Jewish neighbourhoods, and at non-sanctioned rallies. Could police wear a mic while a translator listens and advises them? 3) It's important to have a policy for ongoing education and training to distinguish hate criminals from others. The Jewish community, which is one of the smallest minorities in Canada (and in the world) has been disproportionately attacked--psychologically and physically--and these crimes continue to escalate unchecked. In order to reduce antisemitic hate crimes that specifically target Jewish people, the police need ongoing education and training in the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition. This entails teaching them what it means to be a Jew (e.g. history, culture, extraordinary contributions to Toronto and to the world). They need to understand and comprehend the depth of antisemitism, which is DNA-driven--it is the oldest, most persistent and mutable form of hatred in the world. In order to have a police force that is well prepared to tackle antisemitism, the police need an adequate number of instructors for mandated courses, followed by exams to ensure that they have absorbed the information.
- Stanley Kugelmass and Margery Hecht-Kugelmass
We are citizens of Canada and long-standing residents of North Toronto where we have raised our children. We are proud members of Toronto's Jewish community and value the many Jewish institutions which have been built over the years in the Bathurst Street corridor. Up until October 7th we have considered ourselves to be most fortunate to be living in a City where our personal security and the security of our family and community seemed assured.
Unfortunately, since October 7, 2023, we have witnessed the large disorderly and threatening so called "pro-Palestinian" demonstrations which have seemingly been given unfettered access to public and some private places in downtown areas and, of even more concern, in and around our Jewish institutions and neighbourhoods.
To us, it is obvious that these demonstrations do not reflect principles of freedom of expression or peaceful assembly. Rather we experience these demonstrations, which are really in effect mobs, as unruly, prone to violence, aggressive and lawless. We have witnessed demonstrators breaking the law and believe the expressions "from the river to the sea" and "intifada now" which are proclaimed by demonstrators constitute hate speech and incitement to kill Jews. If not stopped, we have no doubt that lives will be at risk. Allowing these demonstrations to continue has destroyed our sense of personal security and undermines our faith in the rule of law.
In light of the foregoing, we submit the following recommendations:
1. Enforce the law and specifically hate speech laws; 2. Do not accommodate lawless and criminal behaviour; 3. Protect private property and interests; 4. Recognize and protect the sanctity of neighbourhoods; and 5. Permit lawful demonstrations only in limited relevant public locations
We believe it is incumbent upon the Toronto Police Services Board to address these concerns and to implement these recommendations for the benefit of not only Jewish Torontonians but for the benefit of all citizens of Toronto. - Lisa Klug (Canadians for Israel)
I do NOT feel safe in Toronto. My city. I've lived here over 50 years and don't recognize my city. Why? In mid-December, I was exiting the ballet, and was swarmed by a pro-Palestinian mob as I exited the Four Seasons Centre at the corner of University Avenue and Queen Street. I didn't know what to do. I froze to my place. People around me were pushing, yelling through a loudspeaker, yelling for my death. Did they know I am a Jew? Do I wear that? I don't know. But clearly something about me upset them for they tried to push me. There were no police officers present. It was my daughter who was able bring me to my senses then pull me out of the crowd and back into the building. Again, there were no police in the area. A few weeks later this happened again. I was walking across the Avenue Road bridge over highway 401. It was mid-day and there were a few pro-Palestinian people waving flags plus a few others (Jews? Non-Jews?) waving Israeli and Canadian flags. As the crowd grew, police showed up --- but there weren't enough. One lady with a hijab looked at me and drew her hand across her throat while saying "death to you" or something like that. I couldn't believe what she had done. A few days later, I went to the police station to report what had happened. The police officer who took my report said she needed my address and phone number which would be released to the person who had threatened me. I couldn't go through with the complaint because I didn't want that lady to know where I lived. She already said she wanted to kill me. I was afraid and realized the police couldn't do anything to protect me or to stop this lady from doing to others what she had done to me. My mother lives very near Bay and Bloor. She is elderly and frail. One time in February, she was walking north along Bay Street, from her regular ice cream shop on Charles, and she met up with a pro-Palestinian rally. She was unable to cross Bloor to get to her home. She asked a few policemen to help her cross the street. She was denied. There was nowhere for her to sit and rest. She became panicked. No one there was able to help her. Fortunately, I was not too far away at the time and was able to come to her rescue, with my car. She should have been able to get home safely on her own. The rally was huge and noisy. I was afraid --- no wonder that she too had been afraid.
We need a lot more police on our streets. We need to change the law so that an accusers personal information (like address and phone number) is not given to someone who has threatened her. - Yifaht Korman (clinical psychologist)
- Karin Brothers (self)
It appears to me, from both public and private information, that the police treatment of the public tends to reflect an inappropriate racism against Muslims and those who support Palestinian rights: those who are demonstrating against criminality such as apartheid, genocide, ethnic cleansing, torture, and other crimes against both Canadian and international law. I think that anti-Palestinian and Islamophobic racism should be treated with at least the same seriousness as anti-Semitism. Given the current situation, attacks on Muslims and mosques must be taken at least as seriously as attacks against Jews and synagogues. Police visiting Israel for training should also meet with Palestinian counterparts in the occupied Palestinian territories as part of that experience.
- David
I note that over the last year in particular, unpermitted and illegal protests have taken Toronto over, and created lawless areas where intimidation and hate speech are allowed without deterrence. Private property has been taken hostage and vandalized, public areas have been privatized illegally, and the public space has been invaded by those who would use Canada's fair and rules based freedoms to hijack the public's ability to walk, drive, cycle and otherwise participate freely and securely in public spaces (including public transit). Many of these illegal actions have impacted the public negatively by taking Canadians' freedoms away from them and forcing them to face thuggery and intimidation in common areas. These same illegal protests have taken over our streets, interrupting daily commercial and personal life.
I would like to see a policy by the TPS that allows its members and service people to operate freely in maintaining law and order in our streets. These officers should be free to use reasonable and non-lethal methods at their disposal to deter lawlessness, keep public spaces open, and protect private spaces. There should be a zero tolerance policy towards unpermitted protests, hate speech of any kind, and intimidation of public and private groups, especially those who are operating properly and within the bounds of the law. Given the disproportionate numbers that TPS face in trying to maintain the law, they should be allowed to use various methods to help them do their job properly. Some examples include tasering resisting individuals acting illegally, outlawing masking at protests, arresting those spewing hate speech, arresting those who would flaunt the symbolism and imagery of terrorism and illegal entities in Canada, and also clearing public areas to allow for traffic to move freely and people to move , without fear of brazen thugs operating in our streets with impunity. - Jane Garthson (Garthson Leadership Centre)
- Mark Arbus
1) video recording anti-Israeli protestors for the purpose of identifying hate speech and charging such individuals 2) educating TPS on the difference between hate speech and free speech 3) interpreting coded language (i.e., intifada, from the river to the sea, zionism=nazi, armed resistance, martyrs, we don't want no two states, we want 48...) 4) not allowing protestors to wear face masks 5) ensuring Jewish students/faculty/staff are not being prevented access to schools/campus spaces 6) arresting those flying the Hamas flag 7) Investigate all public-service employees, especially teachers of younger students, who advocate in opposition the existence of the state of Israel and/or openly show and demonstrate antisemitic behaviours
- Shari Braham
- Samuel Mincer (Citizen)
As a resident of 32 Division for over 60 years I feel disheartened that as a community we are being asked to submit a statement to ensure the safety of our community in 2024. At a recent residents local meeting we were able to hear some enlightening words from Superintendent Belanger. As a community member I was given a sense of comfort knowing that the TPS indeed has our safety concerns at heart. I believe that the members of the TPS would benefit from additional hate speech/action sensitivity training and when words from individuals have crossed the line into hate incitement. Additionally they should be empowered to arrest and help prosecute these individuals without fear of recourse. There seems to be no relenting to the illegal protests affecting all citizens, businesses and public services. The expenses to the TPS to try to safely manage these illegal gatherings , respond and investigate bomb threats, hate crimes and more will continue to escalate without firm and decisive action by the TPS and subsequently our legal system. I hope for a safe curbing to this escalating violence so that all citizens of our city can safely enjoy this great city, their religions and continue to live peacefully together.
- Ryan Matthews
Ryan Matthews [Personal information redacted - Board Office]
August 25, 2024
Toronto Police Services Board 40 College Street Toronto, ON M5G 2J3
Subject: Public Consultation Submission on Public Order Policy and Hate Crime Enforcement
Dear Members of the Toronto Police Services Board,
I am writing to provide my input for the Toronto Police Service (TPS) Public Order Policy consultation, particularly regarding the enforcement of laws, the management of public protests, and the handling of hate speech. As a concerned community member and advocate for the safety of Jewish Canadians, I urge the Board to adopt stronger measures to ensure the protection and well-being of all citizens, especially those targeted by hate crimes and antisemitism.
1. Enforcement of Laws During Protests and Demonstrations
It has come to my attention that laws related to mischief, trespassing, lawlessness, and unlawful assembly are not consistently enforced during protests, encampments, and demonstrations. This is particularly concerning in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighborhoods, where public order must be maintained to ensure community safety. I recommend:
㤼㸵 Enhanced training for TPS officers on protest management laws to ensure that existing laws are enforced consistently and effectively. 㤼㸵 A zero-tolerance policy toward actions that obstruct traffic, block access to businesses, or prevent people from going about their daily lives, which are reasonable limits on the right to protest.
2. Hate Speech vs. Free Speech
While the right to free speech is constitutionally protected, this right does not extend to hate speech or incitement to violence. The line between free speech and hate speech must be clearly understood and enforced by police officers. It is imperative that TPS adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations, including:
㤼㸵 Updated training for TPS officers specifically focused on identifying and responding to antisemitic hate speech, slogans, symbols, and calls for genocide. 㤼㸵 Immediate intervention and accountability measures for individuals and groups who engage in hate speech, ensuring that perpetrators are held responsible under the law.
3. Protest Management and Safe Access Zones
The right to protest is not absolute and should not infringe on the rights of others. Protests that block streets, prevent access to businesses, or create unsafe environments around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies pose significant public safety concerns. I propose:
㤼㸵 Improved protest management strategies to prevent traffic obstruction and ensure that protests do not disrupt public order. 㤼㸵 The establishment of safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community centers to protect these spaces from being used as venues for protests that could lead to intimidation or violence.
4. Encampments on University Campuses
University campuses are private property, and encampments often constitute trespassing. These encampments have sometimes become hotbeds for hate speech and antisemitism, which threatens the safety of Jewish and Israeli Canadian students. I recommend:
㤼㸵 Collaboration between TPS and university leadership to manage illegal encampments and address hate speech directed at students. 㤼㸵 Provision of resources and training for police to support campus security when needed to maintain a safe and inclusive environment.
5. Masking at Protests
While masking for peaceful protest is legal, concealing one's identity while committing a criminal offense is not. I call for:
㤼㸵 Strict enforcement of laws against masked individuals engaging in hate speech or participating in illegal riots. 㤼㸵 A comprehensive understanding among TPS officers of the specific language, symbols, and historical context of antisemitic hate speech to effectively enforce these laws.
6. Training and Education for Police Officers
Current training on antisemitism and hate crimes has proven insufficient. Police officers need updated, comprehensive training to better recognize and address acts motivated by hate, including emerging hate groups and symbols. This training should cover:
㤼㸵 Historical context and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 㤼㸵 Identification of tactics, symbols, and propaganda used by hate groups, including foreign language materials. 㤼㸵 Collaboration with experts in hate crime enforcement to provide ongoing education and resources.
7. Reporting and Responding to Hate Crimes
Incidents of hate symbols, graffiti, and incitement to genocide in public spaces must be treated as serious crimes. I urge the TPS to adopt a robust reporting and response protocol that includes:
㤼㸵 Immediate action when hate speech or hate symbols are identified, including 911 response if the crime is in progress. 㤼㸵 Enhanced training for officers to recognize and respond to hate crimes quickly and effectively, ensuring a zero-tolerance approach at all protests and public demonstrations.
8. Graffiti and Hate Symbols in the Community
To maintain public safety and inclusivity, TPS should work closely with municipalities to ensure the swift removal of graffiti and hate symbols. I support:
㤼㸵 TPS-wide enhanced hate crime training to equip officers to identify and act on hate speech, symbols, and propaganda. 㤼㸵 A collaborative approach between TPS and municipal authorities for the rapid removal of hate graffiti to prevent further harm to the community.
Conclusion
The safety and well-being of all Toronto residents, including Jewish Canadians, must be a priority for the Toronto Police Service. By adopting these recommendations, the TPS can help create a safer, more inclusive environment that upholds the values of peace, order, and respect for human rights.
Thank you for considering my submission. I look forward to your response and the implementation of policies that reflect a strong commitment to public safety and the protection of all citizens from hate crimes.
Sincerely,
Ryan Matthews [Personal information redacted - Board Office] - Peter Lorne Davis (CIJR announcement)
Dear Toronto Police:
I feel that people who wish to communicate their ideas publicly:
SHOULD: + Distribute written accounts of their ideas to people who express interest. + Display signs that convey their ideas peacefully
SHOULD NOT:
+ Distribute hate literature or material that obviously encourages violence. + Block or impede any form of traffic. + Create loud noise. Police should arrest all those how violate the law.
Peter Davis 416 801 3171 - sheldon finkelstein
- Dahlia Kurtz (Independent)
Download file
I wrote an open letter to Toronto Police Service Board in my National Post Column dated Aug 22, 2024. I attached the file. This is the link: https://nationalpost.com/opinion/police-must-start-cracking-down-on-hate-rallies - Barb Leonard (Beit Rayim)
Thank you for your support. We need tough opposition to hate! Zero tolerance! Stop allowing this hate to fester! Crack down now!
- Fern and John Spencer
We would like to endorse the submission by Mark and Eva Madras. We feel very strongly in favour of everything they wrote.
- Gail Wilson
Thank you for organizing the consultation on public order. This is a critical issue, and there are several areas that require attention and improvement.
Firstly, hate speech in any form, especially at public demonstrations, is a significant concern. The use of hate speech, slogans, and symbols that incite hatred must be met with zero tolerance. To address this, it is crucial that police officers receive updated training in anti-hate crime enforcement, with a particular emphasis on combating antisemitism and other forms of discrimination. This training should ensure that officers are well-equipped to recognize and respond to hate speech, ensuring that public demonstrations do not become platforms for spreading hate.
Secondly, when it comes to public demonstrations, it is essential to strike a balance between the right to protest and the need to maintain public order. Demonstrators should not be permitted to block streets or disrupt businesses, as this can have a significant impact on the community. The police must enhance their protest management functions to prevent such disruptions while allowing peaceful protests to proceed. This includes establishing and enforcing safe access zones around sensitive areas such as schools, community centers, places of worship, and other locations that require protection from potential disruptions or threats. These zones will help ensure that the daily activities of the community are not hindered and that everyone can go about their business safely.
Furthermore, I strongly support providing the police with the resources they need to maintain peace and order effectively. This includes not only physical resources but also the necessary training to handle complex situations, such as protests and encampments, in a manner that respects the rights of all involved while ensuring public safety.
University campuses have also become focal points for protests and encampments, which can disrupt the normal functioning of these institutions. It is vital that these areas remain accessible to all members of the university community, including students, staff, and visitors. Therefore, police need the appropriate resources and training to manage these situations effectively. This includes addressing issues such as masking during encampments and public demonstrations, as it can hinder the identification of individuals and pose a challenge to maintaining order. Masking should not be tolerated in these contexts to ensure transparency and accountability. - Mahina
- maintain a position of impartiality in dealing with all parties involved. That means not being racist and assuming people of color are threatening peace. - no aggressive policing tactics for "crowd control" - Civic engagement must become an expected p
- Leslie Wolfe (Private Citizen)
- Aaron Paul
- Beryl Berazadi
- Stephanie Snopek
After seeing a great number of "pro-Palestinian" protests, there are several things I think would be important to consider when updating police procedures and keeping Jewish people and allies (as well as the greater public) safe.
First, I think there needs to be a stronger understanding of what hate speech is and what the consequences of incitement to violence are or should be. Statements such as "zionism is racism" and other similar statements against Israel, and the belief that Israel is illegitimate is very clearly a misinformed antisemitic belief that was first established in the Soviet union, however most people I don't believe have done the research to understand this. As such, the police force could benefit from a professional development track to understand the historical depth of antisemitism globally and then create informed, decisive procedures for handling hate speech that denigrates and calls for violence against anyone who believes Israel has the right to exist (which is zionism).
Second, I believe there should be restrictions on masks during protests. If someone is chanting hateful speech and wearing a mask, or if they are harassing people while wearing a mask, or if they are damaging public property while wearing a mask, there should be an immediate de-masking and record made of the behavior or arrests if warranted. Such people are behaving worse because of the anonymity of masks, and I believe they are much less likely to be as radical in their actions because of the social judgment that comes from being publicly identified.
Third, I think it should be prohibited to protest outside a synagogue, a Jewish school, or specifically target a Jewish neighborhood. Places of worship, learning or simple residence should be safe from protest as we understand that policy change comes from government officials at work and not regular families living regular lives.
Fourth, I think there should be remedial efforts to educate the public on antisemitism. This should be happening in school, but also as part of bail conditions for people who are arrested for violence, hate speech or harassment towards zionists or Jewish people in general. I think we can strengthen our use of education to deradicalize these groups, and part of the education is understanding that many of our immigrant families that move to Canada also come from very antisemitic cultures. Without judgment, how can we both accept immigrants in search of a better life and also impress upon them that antisemitism, no matter if it comes from Europe or the Middle East or South Asian cultures, is not acceptable in Canada? And that violent antisemitism in both rhetoric and action will face consequences?
There are so many additional ways to tackle these tricky protests, which I'm sure many people will highlight. However, ultimately my intention is to focus on a strong and educated police force, that is clear on decisive consequences, and also has a remedial education aspect of handling violent extremists that may never have questioned their antisemitic beliefs before. Canada should be safe for Jewish people and we should also be encouraging a culture of respect for our allies such as Israel, while understanding international conflicts are complex and having a certain amount of sympathy for people who come from cultures that have not confronted their antisemitic biases. Creating a society that recognizes antisemitism and has zero tolerance for violent antisemitism is very important and I think the police still have a necessary role in protecting progressive Canadian culture. Thank you for reading! - Daniel Pearlstein
Hi there, thank you for the opportunity. I'm gravely concerned with spread of hate and support for Canadian-listed terrorist organizations, and would like to suggest a few potential solutions to make ALL Canadians - who stand for traditional Western values - feel safe.
Investigate foreign interference: Additional resources and teams to investigate how these well-organized protesters continue to show up week after week, month after month - particularly after the U.S. government has recently said there's evidence of interference and influence from the Islamic Republic of Iran on campus protests.
Protest management: Additional police training regarding laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, particularly in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods.
Cracking down and recognizing hate speech: Adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations and updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. Hate speech is not protected by law at protests.
Enforcing laws when masked individuals cross the line: Anonymity is fuelling lawlessness. It is an offence to conceal one's identity while committing a criminal offence; and masked protestors who engage in hate speech or illegal activity should be arrested.
Enforcing laws at protests: Additional resources and funding for a variety of matters. Ensuring protests are not obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business. Imposing safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent them from being used as venues for protest. Police to receive training to help identify and respond quickly to hate speech when it occurs.
Preventing encampments in public property: Additional resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests.
Enforcement against support for internationally recognized terrorist organizations: Additional resources and education to identify the tactics, symbols, and propaganda by foreign influencers.
Thank you - Randi Skurka
Dear Toronto Police Service Board,
The past ten months, since Hamas's brutal attack on Israeli civilians, have been terrifying to most all Jewish Torontonians, in light of the alarming surge in antisemitic hate crimes, already on the rise for years.
Many of us are hesitant to identify publicly as Jews and risk harassment, threats of violence or worse, as we go about our day, especially attending synagogue, community institutions, or when taking our children and grandchildren to school, where security has been heightened with good reason.
It is vital and urgent for law enforcement, particularly hate crime units, to create and enforce policy based on the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted several years ago by Canada and Ontario, in order to understand and address contemporary forms of antisemitism. A good first step would be to identify and ban hate symbols, like the flags of designated terror organizations - Hamas, Hezbollah, ISIS and the PFLP, as is done in Germany, in order to send a clear message that support of terror organizations is not acceptable.
It is urgent to identify and ban, in all public spaces without exception, hateful slogans that clearly call for violence against Jews and their allies - such as 'globalize the intifada' and 'from the river to the sea' and to prevent the swarming of hate mobs in public spaces, burning of Canadian and Israeli flags and the blocking of traffic especially near Jewish institutions. The intent to harass and instill fear in our city's Jewish population and allies is constant and increasing, for example the firebombing of synagogues and Jewish schools, shattering of windows, burning of signs and the bomb threats to over 100 Jewish synagogues over the last two days.
Finally, the use of masks to hide identities of those perpetrating hate crimes needs to be banned, organizers of hate rallies need to be identified and charged, and the leaders of Samidoun, recognized proxy of the PFLP, arrested, charged and deported from Canada.
There needs to be zero tolerance for those who harass, vandalize, threaten, intimidate and vilify Jews and their allies. These crimes, in fact, threaten all people, as well as national security, freedom and democracy.
These policies need to be consistently enforced, also, in all educational institutions from universities to elementary schools in order that all students are safe and feel included. Antisemitic messaging dressed up as political activism does not belong in our classrooms, and its high time this indoctrination is addressed and eliminated from all our schools. Rather, our children should be taught tolerance, coexistence and dialogue, Canadian values.
Thank you for you continued action and diligence in this alarming and dangerous trend.
Sincerely,
Randi Skurka - Julie Jacobson (Citizen)
- Patty Carlson
In February of this year I was the victim of hate speech. A young traffic officer attended and I gave him my report. He listed me -incorrectly as a witness-- I tracked down the report and found it was put into the District 31 files. I spent days tracking down the detective you was assigned to Hate Crimes. The 3 hooligans were outside a synagogue at Neptune Dr. and Bathurst. They were screaming Jews kill babies- jewish baby killers and vindictive statements about Israel-- and gesticulating with a gun gesture at myself and others present. I am a 72 year old Jewish Lawyer who pressed your police and made many call backs. And I got no where. After a months of frustration, I can't give you the file # as I tossed it into the garbage.
Terrible lack of treatment by your service.
You need a call back system, more fully trained officers and increase in # of hate crime detectives. . - Samya Hasan (Council of Agencies Serving South Asians)
Download file
August 23, 2024
The Council of Agencies Serving South Asians (CASSA) is a charitable organization established in 1991 which serves over 120 member agencies serving South Asian communities across Ontario. CASSA has been working for many years to create systemic change in the criminal justice system including advising Toronto Police on many issues that impact South Asian and other racialized and faith minority communities.
The Toronto Police Service (TPS) continues to over-police racialized communities with significant issues of anti-Black racism and systemic discrimination. The Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) released 100 recommendation in December addressing anti-Black racism in the TPS. Various research and reports tell us that police reported hate crimes do not depict an accurate picture of actual hate motivated incidents and crimes.
While recognizing that the last 10 months have been particularly difficult for the TPS in managing the rising number of protests, these kinds of lasting protests have historically been proven to be successful tactics to bring large scale societal and racial justice reform. As Black and Brown bodies recognize the ongoing colonial projects that are created and upheld to keep our communities oppressed, they will find ways to resist. These protests, demonstrations, and occupations have overwhelmingly been peaceful and are constitutionally protected rights of all Canadians. Through protests, the people can find legal and effective ways of resistance to oppression. If we curtail and restrict their constitutional right to peacefully protest, we are setting a very dangerous precedence for a democratic state. Over the last 6 to 8 months, the TPS decided to get more aggressive in controlling protests, demonizing those who take part in it, and criminalizing trivial behavior due to the political pressure they were getting. This was something admitted to CASSA in confidence by high-ranking seniors at the TPS. The work of the TPS was no longer to protect communities but to protect political interest and secure more funding. This led to further alienation of Black and Brown bodies who regularly took part in protests and that trust eroded completely in these communities.
CASSA reached out to TPS on numerous occasions to present opportunities for community dialogue and discussion. We were either ignored or our attempts to meet were indefinitely postponed.
It is extremely disappointing to see Toronto Police criminalizing Brown bodies, especially when given opportunities for community discussion and dialogue. How can Brown and Black communities trust police when they practice bad faith in dealing with our communities, unjustly criminalize our men and boys, and abuse their power to trample on civil liberties? We have worked with the TPS since 2020 to improve hate-crime reporting, apparently in vain. A waste of our communities' time and theirs. During our training with the Toronto Police, the issue of "trust" was repeatedly brought up. TPS wanted organizations like CASSA to help build trust with our communities. Unfortunately, TPS has lost much, if not all, of its trust with racialized communities with the way they have been dealing with protests, especially over the last eight months.
The protests, demonstrations, and occupations against tyranny, occupation, oppression, and genocide will not go away. The people with a conscience will continue to protest these forms of oppression. Is it a matter of time before the International Courts finds that the protesters were right all along to protest the breaking of International Law. The TPS must decide if they want to be on the right side of history or if they want to continue to criminalize our communities for political and monetary gains. Instead of taking a criminal and heavy-handed approach; it will be more peaceful and effective for the TPS to engage our communities in dialogue and work together to uphold the constitutional rights of all Canadians, not just for the ones with white skin.
In solidarity, Samya Hasan Executive Director Council of Agencies Serving South Asians (CASSA)This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. - Lina Alquds
As Canadian citizens and residents of the city of Toronto, we assert our right to peacefully protest Canada's involvement in international conflicts. We demand that the Toronto Police Service operate independently of political influence and focus on keeping the peace and de-escalating. The protests we participate in are overwhelmingly peaceful, yet violence consistently starts with the actions of the Toronto Police Service especially in the recent few weeks. The regular police response is not only excessive but also brutal; it starts with a large number of officers deployed to control peaceful gatherings. This extreme over-policing that we witnessed firsthand is unnecessary and further escalates tensions, serving only to suppress our freedom of speech as a result of political influences from certain organizations. We call for the removal of political bias within the police force and insist on the protection of our rights to free expression and assembly. The Toronto Police Service must prioritize the safety and rights of the people they are sworn to protect rather than serve political interests by actively suppressing the freedom of speech and creating an intimidating environment on the streets of Toronto.
We demand that the police force require all officers to undergo mandatory unconscious bias and sensitivity training. This is essential to prevent brutal actions against visible minorities, who are often targeted in unprovoked police attacks while peacefully protesting - Peter Sevitt (Individual living in Toronto for over 51 years)
To me the number 1 item is
Police should enhance officer training/education on hate .Officers need to understand what they can do correctly and swiftly to enforce law and order.
Hopefully the consultation process will be enacted swiftly
.We are presently in the UK and seeing Britain consumed by riots and unrest . These rioters( mostly thugs) are being met with the full force of the law SWIFTLY( unlike the response of universities to the anti Israel / pro Hamas protestors of the left)
As the UK justice secretary has said "It doesn't matter who you are or what you are protesting - if you are intent on disorder you will face the full face of the law
UK Police reportedly anticipate that SWIFT administration of serious punishment will persuade miscreants from intimidating people or smashing windows of shops etc
The problem has been that large and threatening groups - such as Pro PalestinePro Hamas or anti Israel are managed more "carefully"!
Justice must be seen to be fair to extremists from the left and right
So it is vital the police work with the justice system as well as consulting with the public
Peter Sevitt - Yasmeen Siddiqi
Police violence against peaceful protesters should NOT be allowed. As it stands, the violence has happened against mostly racialized people.
There should instead be a system of creating a meeting or consultation with the protest leaders to identify how to ensure safety for all. Open communication is key - Alexandra Smith (EndJewHatred)
- Leah Duckman
I support police training about laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, particularly in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods.
Police should adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations and ask for updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement.
It is important that we have improved protest management functions from the police such as ensuring protests are not obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business. I ask for police to impose safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent them from being used as venues for protest. I realize that protest management comes with resource costs, and I support for police to obtain necessary resources to maintain peace and order. There should be zero tolerance for hate speech at demonstrations and ensure that police have the training to identify and respond quickly to hate speech (speech / slogans / symbols) when it occurs.
As for university protests and encampments, it is important that police get the support for resources and training to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests.
I'm very worried about people concealing their identity at public protests. As it IS an offence to conceal your identity while committing a criminal offence, I ask for police to exercise a zero-tolerance approach when it comes to any form of hate speech at a public demonstration (which means an additional charge if they're also wearing a mask). I understand that police must also be educated on the use of certain sayings and connotations that have an equally negative impact on the community. I support the police to obtain additional resources that may be required to support antisemitism and hate crime enforcement training. - Daphne Hoffenberg
Download file
This past week, there was a mass bomb threat against the Jews. The climate in Canada has become so toxic toward Jews that over 100 institutions were warned that the Jewish people "will end up in a pool of blood" and "none of you deserve to keep living."
How did we get here? There were so many warning signs. The weekly protests since Oct. 7th have included: 㤼㸵 Antisemitic chants about sending Jews back to Europe (meaning the gas chambers) 㤼㸵 Celebrations of terrorist groups such as Hamas and Hezbollah 㤼㸵 Celebrations of massacres of Jewish civilians while screaming "Long live Oct. 7th", making reference to the largest slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust
These weekly protests have been allowed to continue with no recourse. Apparently "Free Speech" trumps Antisemitism. Because of the lack of police and government action, these terrorist supporters have become more emboldened with their intimidation each week. Since Oct. 7th, we have seen 㤼㸵 Protests moved onto highway overpasses in a heavily populated Jewish community, which is a safety hazard 㤼㸵 Protests migrated to being outside of Jewish Community Centres, Jewish owned restaurants, and synagogues 㤼㸵 A menorah was destroyed outside a Toronto Jewish cultural centre 㤼㸵 Jewish kids are now being bullied at schools, particularly at TDSB and PDSB 㤼㸵 Vandalism of Jewish owned restaurants, stores and synagogues 㤼㸵 Encampments at Universities, where gatekeepers demanded ideological conformity for admission
The intimidation techniques of the Jihadists on Canadian streets have now turned into violence against the Jewish community. Since Oct. 7th, we have seen 㤼㸵 Shots fired at Jewish schools 㤼㸵 Fire bombs of synagogues 㤼㸵 Synagogues being lit on fire 㤼㸵 Rocks being thrown at Jewish schools, stores and synagogues 㤼㸵 Jews are starting to hide their star of David necklaces and removing their kipas (head coverings)
It has become normal and acceptable to hear "Globalize the Intifada." Intifada refers to the violence that is needed (i.e. terrorism) in order to achieve radical Islamists' end goal of having a worldwide caliphate ruled by Shariya law. This, is modern day colonization of radical Islam without even firing one bullet.
The police need to understand what history has taught us: What begins with the Jews, does not end there. The Jews are on the front lines of an ideological war that is trying to bring down western values and democracy. Every day of inaction by the police and governments allows the Jihadists to get closer to their end goal. Canada has become a breeding ground for terrorism because the seeds planted by the weekly protests have been allowed to grow and thrive like weeds. Their tactics are straight out of the Nazi handbook. If you've heard people saying that it feels like Toronto has become like 1930's Germany, it's because all the vicious hatred you are seeing now is exactly the same as propaganda and violence the Nazis used. What you are seeing on Toronto's streets are the new Nazis.
We have a cancer growing in our culture. The Muslim Brotherhood and their affiliates have been openly vocal about what they want. It's time for the government and police to believe them. We are at a critical place in human history and if we don't fight for our democracy and western values, we're done. The Jihadists have openly stated that in 40-50 years from now, their goal is to increase in population and continue to spread their ideology in our government and educational institutions. We need to listen to them and deal with this urgent matter.
As you can see, there is a bigger picture here. Don't make the Jews be the front lines on their own, because after the Jews, they will come after all infidels (non-Muslims) and no one will be safe.
The police have the ability to shut down these hateful, disruptive protests once and for all and return order to our streets. It's time to bring out the water cannons or tear gas because this problem will not go away. - Amjad Ramadan
The constitutional rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly Should be respected. If these rights are breached, Canada will not be a free and democratic country anymore.
- Roilui Sin
Secure funding to prioritize and promote mental health and trauma-informed practices that grounds every interaction with every person that police may encounter. Additional priorities made to protect designated groups through proactive collaboration with communities. End police violence through harm reduction policies and put in place accountability measures that will guide actions to effective outcomes. Form committees or groups with community representation (including dissenting voices) to robustly evaluate policing strategies used with emphasis on lobbying for de-escalation and preventative practices.
- Jeffrey Stutz
- Leslie Wolfe (Private citizen)
- Deborah Tameanko
I am 60 years old, was born and raised here and have lived in Toronto my entire life. I am Jewish. I have never experienced the vile hatred and terrorizing that is going on in this city today and it is shocking and disheartening to see and it must be stopped. I have friends who have been terrorized and my place of work has been threatened. There is no place for this in a democratic society and I am afraid of what will become of what I considered home.
- Elie Sugarman
First, I would like to start off by thanking the Toronto Police for their efforts and assistance in combating what has become an epidemic in our community, antisemitism. I also thank the Toronto Police for opening the consultation to the public and soliciting opinions from the community. With respect to the matter at hand, I believe there are three things that should and need to happen.
1) Existing laws need to be enforced, and politicians and the crown need to empower the police to do so. This means that hate laws under section 309 of the criminal code (Public incitement of hatred) need to be applied. The code specifically deals with incitement of hate and violence, which has become a cornerstone of many of the protests (as may be obvious, this would not apply to all protestors nor do I suggest all are involved in illegal activity, but this has been the case in many protests, some of which have been caught on camera with the police standing idly by). The code also specifically refers to antisemitism (section 319(2.1)), which refers to condoning the Holocaust. This too has become a mainstay at many protests ("Hitler was right", "Hitler should have finished you off," unironically "the Jews made up the Holocaust," etc.) Videos of such statements can widely be viewed online, and some incidents have been reported by the media. Application of these laws extends beyond the power of the Toronto police; they are often the result of crown counsel and politicians calling out these matters and forcing arrests. The crown and politicians must step up and set the proper tone from the top. Other aspects of the criminal code also need to be applied. This includes arresting those illegally occupying areas and blocking traffic. Neither of these fall under free speech laws and must be applied.
2) Large groups of Individuals, protesting and acting in unison, should not be allowed to cover their faces. These face coverings are not being used for any purpose other than to disguise individuals to avoid prosecution and intimidate the Jewish community. People masked are, as may be obvious, more inclined to participate in criminal behavior. In one famous incident, a man whose face was covered in a Kufiyah, is seen threatening to kill people in front of a police officer at the Eaton Centre. For clarity, the Kufiyah should not be made illegal, but face coverings in groups over a certain size would decrease the likelihood that individuals would be willing to engage in criminal behaviour.
3) Protests should not be permitted in residential neighborhoods, particularly when they are focused on a specific community. Why permits are allowed for protests in such places is beyond my comprehension, and if no permits for a protest are being granted, protestors are engaging in illegal activity, and the law should be applied.
I thank you for your time and consideration on this matter. - Mark and Eva Madras
Introduction:
We are residents of Toronto and citizens of Canada. We are parents and the grandparents, all resident in Toronto. We are making this submission in large part out of concern for the future of our children and grandchildren in this city and this country.
Eva's parents were Holocaust survivors. They fled their homes in the face of the Nazi onslaught in Europe during World War 2, travelling east into territory controlled by Russia. They spent the latter war years in a forced labour camp in Siberia. They emigrated to Canada from a displaced persons camp in Europe following the war to start new lives in a country without a history of hate and its consequential violence. Their dominant aspiration was to raise their children in a society that was safe, in which they could be educated and become productive citizens of their native land, lives they were deprived of. They would be horrified by what is happening on Toronto's streets and campuses today.
Mark's parents were born in Montreal. His grandparents arrived in Canada from eastern Europe at the turn of the 20th century, to leave behind the vicious antisemitism which periodically erupted as lethal pogroms of unspeakable horrors that terrorized and decimated their communities. Mark's father served in the RCAF during World War 2, based in England, where the RCAF was engaged with the RAF in the defence of England from German bombardment, and then with our allies in the liberation of Europe from the terror of Nazi Germany. Mark's uncle served in the Canadian Army, entering the Netherlands shortly following D-Day, witnessing the horrors which were revealed as the few skeletal survivors of Nazi concentration camps were liberated.
We therefore make this submission with our family's experience in mind. Our family has known first hand the consequences of unconstrained hate speech and the violence that follows. We have seen that hate speech and incitement can lead to death and destruction, for individuals, families, societies and nations. We fear that we are on a trajectory here, which if not interrupted and reversed, may lead to serious violence with consequences for us, our children and grandchildren, as well as for our city and our country.
Our Recommendations:
1. Enforce the law.
While it is a worthy objective to seek de-escalation and conflict avoidance in certain situations, it must be in the context that the law will be enforced. Appeasement as a response to criminal activity, as opposed to law enforcement, emboldens the perpetrator. It does not lead to de-escalation; it actually results in escalation. The perpetrator does not respond to an absence of enforcement with gratitude but rather with the repetition of the offending conduct along with further and more brazen offending behaviours. If the state is weak, then those with an agenda of hate have shown throughout history that the weakness of the state will be exploited, with disastrous consequences for social order and civil society. Tolerating hate does not lead to tolerance; tolerating hate leads to more hate.
2. Prosecute Hate Speech and Incitement
Hate speech is illegal because it is harmful. It is conduct from which society must be protected. Hence it is an offence in the Criminal Code.
It must be recognized that hate speech is not benign, it is not merely verbiage which does not result in bodily harm and property damage, therefore meriting less attention from law enforcement than conduct resulting in physical harm or property damage.
The hateful speech, slogans, signage and banners at demonstrations in Toronto have been horrifying . We feel threatened. We are fearful. Our lives are impacted by fear of what we may encounter in our neighbourhoods, community centres, places of worship and on city streets. We are concerned for what our grandchildren may be exposed to if we take them to an event that may be the site of a demonstration marked by screams, banners and signage that are full of hate.
Indeed, all of us in Toronto should feel that our peaceful society has been violated and we are all at grave risk if this trajectory continues. The expressions of hate are themselves harmful, and as we well know the consequential harms derived from hate speech can be enormous.
The hate that has been screamed on our streets and in our faces includes calls for violence against Jews, in direct and "dog whistle" terminology that is understood by the mob and the Jewish community it targets. It must be understood by the police. Calls to "Go Back to Poland" and calls that "Hitler was Right", are calls to rid the country of Jews and to send the Jews to the gas chambers. Calls to "Globalize the Intifada" and the slogan "Revolution is the Solution" are calls for the violence and the destruction of our civil society. The hallmark of the Intifadas in Israel has been terrorism by murder: bus and car bombings, bombings of restaurants and celebration venues, car rammings and random street killings. Exhortations to repeat Oct 7; calls that glorify the massacre, rape, torture and butchery of Oct 7; calls for Lawful Armed Resistance; the flying the flag of Hamas and calls for the mob to emulate Hamas - these are are all shoutouts for violence here in Toronto. The screams will only get louder, the signage bolder and the mobs more aggressive if this behaviour is permitted to continue without law enforcement consequences.
To hear this hate, to listen to this incitement, is to experience a gut punch. It is a direct threat to our safety and security in this city and country. It is a verbal gut punch, but it is violence nonetheless.
Police must act not only at the scene of demonstrations but before the harm of the hateful demonstrations occurs. These events are not spontaneous. There are organizations and leaders of organizations that are scripting and choreographing these events, There is funding that is enabling these events to happen. There are online postings calling for streets to be blocked, Toronto to be shut down, community events, schools businesses, and places of worship to be sites of demonstrations of hate. There are manuals written and training now happening, on how to respond to and resist law enforcement. There is an agenda here that is being implemented in a planned and coordinated way. There are elements of conspiracy here to commit hate speech and incite violence. The conspiracies underlying these events need to be investigated and the Criminal Code conspiracy laws enforced. As you well know, a conspiracy to commit a criminal act is itself a crime; there is no need to wait for the act to occur before stepping in and interdicting the conspiracy.
3. Police Must be Properly Resourced and Trained
To properly address these issues police must be adequately funded, trained and equipped. The demonstrations of hate and incitements to violence we are experiencing are formidable threats, well planned, organized and resourced. Police must be capable of addressing this phenomenon with superior funding, training and equipment. Police leadership has to recognize the significance of the undertaking, it must understand the threat, it must know the meaning of the language of hate that is being expressed, and it must understand the urgency of enforcing the law with respect to hate speech so as to prevent escalation to acts of hateful violence. And police leadership must give the necessary guidance, training and direction to all officers on the force tasked with law enforcement in this context.
Toronto Police need to investigate in coordination with their provincial and federal counterparts the sources of funding for these demonstrations, possible linkages between the leadership of the hate demonstrators to international organizations with connections to terrorist organizations. Consulting with, and accessing information from, NGOs with expertise in these matters also needs to take place on a regular basis. NGOs with subject matter expertise can also be useful sources for training materials and can provide educators on hate speech, including the language of hate, decoding the terminology, and understanding the historic progression from hate speech to the violence of hate.
4. Crimes On Private Property
As you well know, private property can be the site of criminal activity. It is no different for hate speech than for assault or robbery. The Criminal Code should be enforced on university and college campuses, in shopping malls, upon whatever property the utterances of hate and incitement occur, as well as on our public streets. We must not allow the veil of private property to shield unlawful conduct. In particular, we must not allow the properties of academic institutions to continue to serve as breeding grounds for hate speech, threats, intimidation, discrimination and violence. There can be no sanctuary for criminal activity in this city and this country.
Conclusion
We are grateful for the efforts of law enforcement in Toronto to date to deal with the unprecedented level of hate speech that we are experiencing. The task is indeed formidable.
We must also recognize that more needs to be done and more resources need to be allocated to address the crisis that we now face. History teaches us that simply adopting conflict avoidance strategies in the context of a hate campaign such as we are experiencing will lead only to further emboldenment, further escalation, and will likely cascade into violence. Our tolerant civil society is at risk, for it can not tolerate hate and remain a civil society. Our police need to be trained and resourced to meet this very serious challenge. Most importantly, knowledgeable, strong and committed leadership, with appropriate guidance from your Board, is required immediately.
Thank you for your consideration of our submission. - LISA GILBERT
No group should not be allowed to block, assemble ( ie: Yonge and Dundas streets) so that they block off access to major hospitals and emergency vehicles! The square or Nathan Phillips should be used.
- Laurence Price
- Jim Lisser
- Joanne Jubas
I would like to offer my opinion/suggestions regarding Board policy for protests and demonstrations. First and foremost, protests in a public space, particularly blocking either car or pesestrian traffic, need to be shut down without fail. At the very least, there should be more attempt at control of the crowd. If a permit is required for a protest, it should be required by all groups. Another key suggestion is to understand what constitutes hate speech, particularly in today's political climate, and charge people who choose to utter said hate speech (whether verbally or written on signs.) When hate speech is a call to incite violence (eg. "By all means necessary"), this is no longer free speech, people need to be charged with inciting hate and/or violence. Another key issue in the recent protests is the face coverings that people are using to hide their identities. This is both a form of intimidation, as well as a way to hide themselves from being found out. If someone chooses to wear a medical mask, there is still a portion of their face that can be seen. These are all concerns that apply to protection of all communities, it is just unfortunate that the Jewish community is the most targeted of late. I hope for days of more clarity and direction for the police to offer all communities the protection we all deserve.
- Grace Shafran
- Diane Lavi (None)
I am sure you will receive comments from the community which will reference the law, freedom of speech and the legality of the "protests" which we have all witnessed across Canada.
However, I would like to offer a different perspective. I am a grandmother of three young children. Canadian children. They deserve to live and grow in an environment where they feel safe. Currently, when I am looking after them, I only take them to certain places where I am hopeful they will not have to witness hundreds, sometimes thousands, of angry people with their faces covered, literally calling for their death and the death of their family members living in Israel. They are still young, but old enough to read and understand that these people hate them.
Please put yourselves in my place. What if there were people marching in the streets threatening you and your children? Would you really just shrug and say it's OK, they haven't actually killed anyone yet?
Something has to change. We Canadians deserve to feel safe in our own streets. And we don't. Our schools, places of worship, homes and cars are vandalized. Hate speech and hate crimes need to be punished. If they are not, what kind of a society are we handing over to the next generation?
Please find a way for our young children to feel safe in their own community, their own, city, their own country. They deserve it.
Thank you. - Alena Gotz
My submission is simple. The police should enforce existing criminal laws, those thar prohibit hate incitement towards an identifiable group and those that protect private and public property from trespassing and vandalism. If the police need special procedures to deal with such common crimes then I wonder what they have been doing up to now?!
Just enforce the law, so the perpetrators have a record and law abiding society can protect itself from such known criminals by access to their criminal records. This will serve as a deterrent to future vandals and haters inclined to abuse Canadian good will.
Alena Gotz, Markham ON - Ann
Born & raised in Toronto, I have lived here for the past 55 years. I am deeply saddened for my beloved city. Protests have deterred my family & I from enjoying the downtown core for more than 10 months now every single weekend.
I believe strongly in freedom of expression. As such I will always defend it, even & especially when I disagree with the opinions expressed. However, the board's policy needs to address the balance that has been lost in our city between individuals' rights to freedom of expression, & the violations of other individuals' rights to feel safe & secure in their city as a result of these constant protests. This balance has not been properly struck since Oct 7th in my opinion.
Reasonable limits need to be put in place on the frequency, size, and content of protests so as to respect ALL Canadians rights, and not exclusively protect freedom of speech. What constitutes "peaceful protest" needs to be more clearly delineated, specific counterexamples should be given eg holding signs that clearly call for violence against certain groups is not peaceful. Consequences of violation of these reasonable limits need to be clearly outlined in the policy & easily enforceable. Consequences need to be applied swiftly & consistently so as to deter others from repeating any non-peaceful protest activities every weekend.
I have tremendous respect for Toronto Police officers who have tried to do their jobs to maintain order. I look forward to seeing a new policy in place that is far more specific & makes it much easier for them to do their jobs properly. My sincerest hope is that the new policy will help return our city to a place that all Canadians can enjoy & people from all over the world will want to visit again for the open & hospitable reputation we once had. Unfortunately I have found in my travels that at the moment that reputation is severely tarnished. - Assaf Dvir
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Liz Feld (Private)
In addition, masks at protests should absolutely be banned. It is only intended to intimidate and threaten and protesters should be ashamed of what they are protesting so why would they need a mask?
- Liz Feld (Private)
I ask that protests be limited to relevant locations, ie embassies, consulates and government buildings. The intensity of protests in residential neighbourhoods is intimidating and threatening. Also, allowing protesters to block streets and highways is outrageous and absolutely should be shut down immediately. Thanks for your consideration.
- Randy Gladman (Toronto resident, homeowner, and taxpayer)
I have been appalled and outraged by the lackadaisical manner in which the City and its enforcement agencies have managed the anti-Semitic, anti-Israel, pro-terrorist demonstrations over the past year since the atrocities of October 7, 2023. Shame on Toronto. In particular, shame on Mayor Chow for allowing these embarrassing, threatening, and dangerous actions to persist.
In particular, the blocking of Avenue Road at the overpass to Highway 401 was an abhorrent example of City complicity in anti-Jewish racism. The fact that this was allowed to persist for two weeks when laws prohibiting exactly this kind of behaviour could have been enforced IMMEDIATELY unfortunately demonstrated an ugly racism within City Council and further encouraged ugly, threatening, dangerous behaviour by hordes of racist people in our City.
I am disgusted. I expect and demand much better from our City leaders. Toronto is for everyone and Council needs to start protecting everyone. Lately it appears to be pandering to various religious and immigrant groups at the cost of others.
City Council must do better. This period is a stain on our history that can never be cleansed. But the City can do better going forward.
Randy - Sabra Bouchahma
Restricting charter rights to protest is a dangerous area for police to be entering into. Police policy should affirm that right first and foremost and only restrict that right based on evidence based risk to community safety. It is not sufficient to base police restrictions on the right to free expression and protest based on community hyper sensitivity and pressure brought to bare by communities of power exercising political muscle. It is clear that Toronto police have restricted the rights of pro-Palestinian protesters and even indulged in intimidation of them based on irrational fears and the indulgence of politically powerful constituencies. The policy needs to ensure that this kind of police behaviour stops and that their are objective, effective, and accessible avenues of redress provided to citizens where they believe that police have behaved in this manner. Arbitrary and biased policing can no longer be tolerated.
- Sajidah azmi
Restricting charter rights to protest is a dangerous area for police to be entering into. Police policy should affirm that right first and foremost and only restrict that right based on evidence based risk to community safety. It is not sufficient to base police restrictions on the right to free expression and protest based on community hyper sensitivity and pressure brought to bare by communities of power exercising political muscle. It is clear that Toronto police have restricted the rights of pro-Palestinian protesters and even indulged in intimidation of them based on irrational fears and the indulgence of politically powerful constituencies. The policy needs to ensure that this kind of police behavior stops and that their are objective, effective, and accessible avenues of redress provided to citizens where they believe that police have behaved in this manner. Arbitrary and biased policing can no longer be tolerated.
- Ali Badreddine
We need to say that restricting charter rights to protest is a dangerous area for police to be entering into. Police policy should affirm that right first and foremost and only restrict that right based on evidence based risk to community safety. It is not sufficient to base police restrictions on the right to free expression and protest based on community hyper sensitivity and pressure brought to bare by communities of power exercising political muscle. It is clear that Toronto police have restricted the rights of pro-Palestinian protesters and even indulged in intimidation of them based on irrational fears and the indulgence of politically powerful constituencies. The policy needs to ensure that this kind of police behavior stops and that their are objective, effective, and accessible avenues of redress provided to citizens where they believe that police have behaved in this manner. Arbitrary and biased policing can no longer be tolerated.
- norma finkelstein
I am concerned about this for our kids and our own future. How do you feel about all this ? Can you work hard to protect us from these threats ? Please help
- Barbara Atlas (Resident of Toronto)
I appreciate the hard working members of the TPF and realize what a difficult time this is for policing in Toronto. I am a third generation Jewish citizen of Canada and a lon time resident of Toronto. This is the first time that I feel and and discomfort living in Toronto. I recognize the importance of the Charter of Rights for Free Speech and Free Assembly and support them fully. And I need to know that police have the training, political support and intent/strategy of intervening when it slips into hate speech and intimidation. Genocide speech, Arabic slogans and posters need to be translated, blocking entrances, bridges to public locations and preventing others from managing there day to day life is not acceptable and I need to know and trust that TPF will intervene in a speedy manner
- Ben Levy
Not enough has been done to prevent the hate speach going on during these protests. I do not take my kids downtown anymore due to this. I also fear for their saftey. The street have been taken over by thugs and terrorists funded by countries outside of our own. Nothing has been done and Canada is no longer safe.
- Penny Dimos
I am in support of free speech BUT wholeheartedly support police exerting authority where there is threat to the general, law-abiding community as well as to smaller group members of specific race or religion. Protesters who incite hate, creating chaos and compromising public safety and security has become deeply concerning particularly when such incidents have been escalating in our beloved city.
Additionally, concealing one's facial identity - while protesting - should be given consideration. Hate-driven groups should not be encouraged - by default and through lack of police enforcement - at the expense and detriment of the community at large, and for the greater Toronto good. - Michelle M
Please help out our community and police our Jewish schools and institutions to keep our children safe from harm. We just need moral support from your hard working police squad to maintain a safe and friendly city. Thanking you in advance??
- Tarif Halabi
I'd prefer to see fewer police at these protests. Their large presence is costly, can intimidate some members of the public, and does not necessarily contribute to maintaining order.
- Tsipi Mandowsky
Situation for the Jewish community is becoming really scary. Please train policemen to handle this situation, boost police presence near Jewish schools and institutions!
- Karmel
End of March 2024 I was protesting peacefully. I have the right to assemble and protest against the genocide taking place. Toronto police used their coop technique and cornered us in. I let the police know their force is unacceptable as I was UNABLE TO BREATH. They were shoving, pushing and throwing us to the ground. I told the officers I couldn't breath and they continued to assault me and other protestors.
Defund the police and use that money for social workers that will help keep protest a peaceful event.
TPS is violent and don't keep me safe. My children are now afraid and hate the police. - Sara (None)
Body camera for ALL officers ON at ALL times Should not cover it or turn it off Less intimidating tactics such as walking and putting sunglasses on at night Don't face one group - unbiased in their tone, mannerisms. You can't yell at one group and be aggressive yet be gentle, laugh, put hands on shoulders with the other group. Same rules for not groups - if TPS won't allow for example one groups people on the sidewalk of the other group, then same should apply to the counter group side not being allowed. Consistency Respect for all - peaceful demonstration is a charter right. Stop villanizing because of political agendas or personal views. Set up a procedure to get help from officers - shouldn't have to yell to flag down and officer and then get told we're being aggressive. Focus on using de-escalation techniques such as using their voice with respect to relay information before putting hands on people. Respect for women and elders - way too much physical aggression. Remind officers they are public servants and serve the community m huffing, swearing, walking away isn't an option when a member of the public is speaking to you.
- Sarit and Steve
We are writing this letter because we arevery concerned about the situation in our city about the safety of our Jewish community We are both children of holocaust survivors Escaped from a country where antisemitism was felt still after the Holocaust We are scared now in Canada Scared, because of bombtreats, Encampments Hate speeches Hate signs Violence Children's safety in schools Demonstrations Blocking entrance to synagogues Closing streets for prayers Violence Antisemitism at its worst since Second World War! Our police is doing its best, which we are very thankful for, But They need more people More training And a much bigger budget We need to stop the hatred, and enforce the Canadian laws
Sincerely Sarit and Steve Nagy - Howard Vernon
I appreciate the efforts made by the TPS since October 2023 in protecting the Jewish community in Toronto. I wish that there existed clearer guidelines for the TPS to use in circumstances of protests in public spaces which would permit officers to distinguish between speech that is protected by free speech rights and speech (oral or written on a poster) which is threatening, hateful and hurtful. Far too often, I observed clear instances of protestors uttering or declaring on posters language that was hateful; yet, they were allowed to proceed without any consequences. In my opinion, this just gives protesters an incentive to continue or even escalate their behavior. On the other hand, if, in the right circumstances, an interaction with an officer to either warn or arrest an offending protester would go a long way to dissuading this behavior.
Finally, I think that any protestor wearing a mask should be fined or arrested for this unlawful behavior. - Naomi Roskies
- Erin
From the outside it looks like the Toronto Police are not doing much at these pro-Palestinian rallies as individuals spew hate speech and make threats to Jews, which doesn't take a genius to figure out does nothing for the Palestinian cause. Daily threats and vandalism towards Jews are now regular and it's in direct correlation to the lack of repercussions and response from the police and government - allowing for these radicalized individuals to get more confident and take next steps towards more dangerous activities. The blood will be not only on their hands but also on the police and governments if more is not done to protect the Jewish community who has only ever positively contributed to society. Are the police identifying these individuals and surveilling them to see how radicalized they are and if they pose a threat to national security? There should not be allowed any face coverings at these "rallies" if you're too embarrassed to show your face, you know you're doing something wrong. We need a law against this so they can be arrested. There needs to be more tracking of these individuals to ensure they are not a public threat.
- Sandra Herlick
As a Jewish woman in Toronto, I no longer feel safe in the city that has been my home for 65 years. I was born here, grew up here, and cannot believe that I am feeling this in 2024. Jew hatred is rampant. I feel I must hide my Jewish identity on the subway, and even in the hospital to ensure proper care. This is the result of allowing the hateful rhetoric to become normalized on line, on our city streets, and on our university campuses. Repeated calls for violence against Jews and Jewish institutions remind us that extremism and radicalization are growing and thriving in Toronto. It must be stopped before it is too late!
- Robert Dunn
The Jewish community feels like it is underside! We are constantly watching for safety concerns. Recently my synagogue was the target of an arson event. this was chilling. While the police have been supportive of the community, I feel that their hands are tied by the rules of engagement and the lack of understanding of where the line between legitimate protest and intimidation and hate speech is. An example is the protests which closed Avenue Road north of Wilson, the heart of the Jewish community. this was not legitimate protest, this was an act of intimidation. there a significant number of jewish institutions as well as a heavy jewish community in that area (my synagogue is near that site). However there are no Israeli government buildings in that area. How is this legitimate protest and not targeted intimidation? There is legislation that precludes the closing of a major arterial road but it was not used for many weeks. Why was it not used? Police need more training on making the distinction between protest and intimidation but I feel that they are not supported by their political masters in making this very tough distinction. I feel that they fear that if they make arrests in relation to these protesters, they will be penalized. Police also need to be clear about how to manage protests. In canada we value our right to protest. However, once these protests devolve into intimiation, police need to training in how to mange these protests and shut them down. I would also suggest that police need the right to unmask the protesters. These people feel that they are untouchable because their indentity is hidden by masks. they need to unmasks and face the consequences of their actions. the Jewish community needs a dedicated community liaison officer. the Muslim community also needs such a person, since it is clear that Islamaphobia is a real thing and also on the rise (although not as great as anti-semitism but any hate based on religion of belonging to a people is abhorrent). Communities need to feel that they are protected by the police and the police need the political support to enforce keeping communities a members of minority groups safe. I must must say that the police presence in my community has been welcomed. For some time there was a mobile police command centre in my community. I felt incredibly grateful for the presence and appreciated the presence. Regrettably, this command centre is no longer in my neighbourhood. I do recognize that this is a resource issue. Recently, I participated in the UJA walk. The police did a terrific job of managing the protesters. I felt completely safe during the walk and I applaud their work. THANK YOU
- Rick Sutin (Richard Sutin LLB)
I think there are two general areas of concern - 1. protests, and 2. threats
Protests
As a general principal, protests should be permitted to the extent they do not infringe on the rights of others. Protesters should not be able to occupy public places, impede traffic etc unless they have first obtained a municipal permit - and then for only the duration of the permit In addition, excess noise, garbage, hate and belligerant behaviour ( eg taunting ) and face covering should not be permitted I understand that law enforcement is faced with the difficulty of making things worse and violent by attempting to break up illegal protests, but I think its a " broken windows" issue - by refraining from enforcement we risk encouraging worse behaviour Even though the crimes and penalties are not serious and it is an imposition on an already overcrowded court system, there needs to be some consequences
Threats
Of course real threats of violence ( bombs, gunshots , arson targeting ethnic or religious institutions) are very serious, I think we need better camera surveillance to assist law enforcement in finding perpetrators with sufficient evidence to prosecute
Expressions of hate and calls for violence also need a robust law enforcement response - Val (MAC)
Our time was cut from the original 5 minutes, down to 3 minutes last minute, leaving us not enough time to complete our statement. Hope next time they can be organized in giving each speaker ample time to complete their thoughts. Thank you.
- Barbara Wade Rose (City Shul Congregation)
Our small synagogue holds most of its Saturday services out of St. George's Grange Park, at the south end. Due to some of the pro-Palestine, anti-Israel demonstration staging in Grange Park, our small synagogue felt unsafe: we took down our welcome board, hired extra security and on one occasion were detained briefly after services. The police were incredibly helpful, courteous and professional during these times. It is hard to overstate the unease with which you see your community targeted, and I personally felt reassured that the police were -- not on our 'side,' regarding the issues, because that's not the point -- demonstrably agents of personal freedom. Thank you.
- David G (n/a)
Check out today's National Post article: "Multiple Jewish Organizations, Hospitals Across Canada Receive Identical Bomb Threats"
This is happening in Toronto. Not ok. - Dr. Sheldon Cooper
To Whom it May Concern at the Toronto Police Services Board:
I grew up in Toronto. I currently live in York Region but what happens in Toronto greatly affects the rest of the GTA. I am deeply concerned by the growing anti Semitism and increasingly violent pro Hamas protesters. It has opened the floodgates of hate and anti Semitism such that just recently an elderly man at a peaceful pro Israel rally in Toronto was physically assaulted. Fortunately that perpetrator was charged. And recently multiple bomb threats were e mailed to several Jewish institutions. This is the result of allowing violence promoting rallies to overrun our streets, our places of business, blocking access to our community and religious centres. The Police Services Board must reinforce the prime importance of maintaining safety and peace for all people. Condoning rallies that promote violence ( globalize the intifada / from the River to the Sea) has shown these bad actors that there are no or minimal consequences to behaviour that crosses the line. Law abiding citizens are fed up. Please take an appropriate leadership position and call for all people to behave and insist the police have the tools to maintain public safety. - Jocelyn Zephrani (Quality Initiatives Inc.)
Have TPS enforce existing law. We have laws for blocking roadways (Municipal Code Chapter 950), encamping on private property (Trespass to Property Act), defacing public and private property (Criminal Code and MC), harassing people (many but let's go with Sections 264, 265 and 319 of the Criminal Code), obstructing sidewalks (MC, Chapter 743), and beating up people for no reason (Sections 265, 266, 267, 268, 269, 271 and 273 of the Criminal Code).
- Eden Stein
My son is 9 years old. When waiting to be picked up from his school, a terrorist sympathizer yelled antisemitic comments at him and his peers. How can this type of hateful intimidation be tolerated in Canada? Would this be accepted for any other minority? Ensure Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech by Implementing and enforcing a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. Ban protests and intimidation near schools, synagogues, Jewish institutions. When these despicable acts occur, hold people to account. Consistently enforce the law. Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. Arrest and charge every time. Educate officers on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable intifada, from the river to the sea, etc.
- Evelyn Simon
Last Fall, we had a family outing. My children and grandchildren who live out of town were in Toronto and my husband and I were taking them to the Royal Ontario Museum so the youngsters could see the dinosaurs and other exhibits. We took the Yonge subway down to Bloor St. where we were confronted by pro-Palestinian protesters marching through the streets and chanting "From the River to the Sea." We are Jewish and we found the call for the destruction of the democratic state of Israel and the annihilation of its people very upsetting and this was prior to the eruption of anti-semitism and hatred that occurred after October 7.
During the past year in Toronto, there have been protests, encampments, and demonstrations, as well as incidents of public mischief, trespassing, lawlessness, and unlawful assembly. While the right to protest is constitutionally protected in Canada, that right is not absolute and so not all protest gatherings are legal. It is important to note as well that hate speech is NOT protected at protests. Additionally, actions like obstructing major city intersections, highways or transportation facilities are not allowed. There are limits on the right to protest. Pro-Palestinian protests in primarily Jewish neighbourhoods or in front of religious institutions, hospitals, businesses, or community centres are not peaceful protests but acts of bullying and intimidation. Police need to impose safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent them from being used as venues for protest. Student encampments are not peaceful protests either pushing beyond the boundaries of free speech into the areas of trespassing and harassment.
Police need further training about laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, particularly in predominantly Jewish areas. There is a line between hate speech and free speech. It is the job of the police to know where that line is and to be ready to hold perpetrators to account for their actions. Inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group ARE severe offences and must be dealt with accordingly. Police must adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations. Police require training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement and should be able to identify and respond quickly to hate speech (speech / slogans / symbols) when it occurs. Resources and training are also necessary for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests. Training must include specific content regarding how to address the presence of antisemitism / acts motivated by hate as part of public demonstrations. This includes understanding the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech as well as being able to identify the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda (including foreign language material) and the use of certain sayings and connotations that have a negative impact on the community.
Protest management comes with resource costs and it is important that the police obtain necessary resources to maintain peace and order.
Money laundering and foreign interference are related issues. There are foreign actors who have no love for the West and they are helping to fund the protests and encampments. If Iran is praising the student encampments, you know that is not a good thing. Police resources need to be devoted to this area as well so perhaps the police budget needs to be increased so more officers can be hired.
Thank you for reading my submission. I look forward to hearing the results of the Consultation on Public Order.
Yours truly,
Evelyn Simon - Marlee Pinsker
Please continue and enhance your efforts to protect the Jewish Community in Toronto. We know that we are a targeted community but we also know that fast and effective policing can make a big difference in outcomes. We need your help!
- Judi Platt
I used to be so proud to be a Torontonian. I would tell people how multi cultural we were, that we all got along and lived side by side. I am no longer proud to be a Torontonian, I am scared and thoroughly disappointed in my government on all 3 levels, local, Provincial and Federal. Toronto is no longer safe for Jewish people. It is obvious that our Mayor supports and believes the Palestinian narrative. It is ok to threaten Jews, tell them you will kill them, hurt them physically, threaten their children's schools with guns etc, conduct prayer in the streets and disrupt the city daily. It is ok that millions of dollars have been spent on the policing which protects the anti Jewish mobs. Those are my tax dollars! If this were any other minority, it would not be tolerated.
- Alexandra Lerner
- Dana Rostowsky
Further to my earlier submission, I wish to add that face coverings (other than medical masks) need to be banned, especially for people participating in protests. Additionally, in order for Jewish students and our community to feel safe, order and security needs to be restored on all campuses, with a zero tolerance policy for violence, hate speech, and public displays of support for terror, as well as dissemination of terrorist propaganda.
- Sam Azoory (StandWithUs Canada)
I have witnessed many hateful slogans and speeches at the U of T encampment and elsewhere. I would like to understand (a) what constitutes a hate speech from a legal standpoint. (b) Is the police equipped to arrest people directly onsite when the slogan or the shouting crosses the line of hate speech. (c) Is burning the Canadian Flag meant to be free expression ? (d) Why can't the Police use water canon to disperse unruly participants ?
- Anthony Mohamed
Priorities: 1)Implement significant on-going training on the held biases (prejudices) of officers and other personnel when dealing with demonstrations/occupations, focusing on the reasons people feel the need to take these actions. 2)Create an internal understanding of the challenges faced by affected communities including around homelessness/addictions/mental health/specific ethno-cultural groups including people with disabilities and 2SLGBTIQ+ folks and work with those who address their particular challenges. 3)Commit to equity, diversity and inclusion principles throughout all written and spoken policies (& more importantly unspoken) and your visible (& more importantly invisible) actions - recognizing that it is a privilege to carry weapons in our society and to be given authority. As uncle Ben said to Peter Parker, "with great power comes great responsibility." 4)Re-commit to the values established in Policing with a priority being to protect and serve all of us including those who participate in demonstrations/encampments.
Procedural: 5)Given the recent incident of a TPS officer clearly assaulting a by-stander causing medical trauma, it is clear that many but not all officers are abusing their power. Weed out that element in order to be a leader in reforming TPS through hiring, firing and regular performance reviews with regards to abuse of power. Many will be closely watching your next steps regarding this and other incidents of abuse. 6)Create with politicians and organizers, clear channels for protesting strongly held views. I did not agree with the Ottawa Convoy, but I recognize their right to protest in a peaceful manner that does not harm local residents or promote ideologies against the Charter such as white or faith based supremacy or acts of violence against public servants or the general public. 7)Work with organizers directly before dismantling encampments such as at the UofT. In these situations a very good role for TPS should be as trusted and fair negotiators/mediators as TPS should be primarily concerned with keeping the peace and not taking sides. That fair approach should be throughout TPS and it is not currently. 8)TPS needs to change and stop the para-military image portrayed. I was at Caribana and when walking near the viewing stand, there were massive military vehicles and officers in riot gear ready to go. I understand why this is needed in any large festival but the image I saw promotes continued distrust in TPS and quite frankly fear that BIPOC people will not be treated fairly. I did not notice these vehicles present at Pride for example. There must be ways to find a balance but it starts with actively building trust with communities proven to be unfairly treated. In the meantime, put those vehicles and officers in a nearby parking garage, not visibly part of a joyful festival. - odette
As a canadian Jew, I am grateful for the Toronto police to keep me and my community safe. As we have witnessed endless violent demonstrations since October 7th. these are the remarks that I hope can be addressed: - Why are pro palestenians wearing masks, can we demask?? - most times these demonstrations are hateful, when are the hate laws enforced - sometimes these demonstrations do not desplay Canadian flags, is this allowed or democratic - can we curb these demonstrations to a time limit, ie one hour only, or once a month?
- Camille Renda (Canadian citizen)
We as Jewish immigrants and my family to Canada since 1967 worked very hard respected all the Canadian rules paid our taxes still do are Canadian citizens deserve and demand the right to be protected and respected by everyone in our Canada and our police government and politicians need to ensure we are safe as anyone here it's our right thank you
- David Spiegel
- It is evident that Al Quds day protests contain a significant amount of hate speech. This has been going on for many years. Why have TPS allowed this to happen? Furthermore, on at least one occasion, it took place on the Queen's Park grounds and the pro
- Karina Rootshtein
Dear Board members,
The amount of hate we have seen since October 7th across Canada and the Western countries is unprecedented and it is very important for all levels of leaders to show moral clarity and take action to prevent hate speech turning into more violence on our streets. This is impacting not just the Jewish community but all Canadians and enough is enough. I want to be able to walk with my kids over the weekend in our beloved downtown Toronto and not fear for our safety (there is always police presence at the protests but these protesters keep walking around the area after it's done). I want to walk with my kids without hearing protesters screaming and calling for more terrorist attacks (Resistance is justified, Viva Viva Intifada) in Israel, an ally and where our family is and to Globalize the Intifada (terrorism) across the Western countries as well as hateful slogans on buildings, posts etc. This is glorification of terrorism not a free speech. I don't want to see masked protesters who look just like terrorists in Gaza and the West Bank. I don't want to see and hear Free Palestine (from Jews) or From the river to the sea Palestine will be free, basically calling for annihilation of Israel. How does that fall under the definition of Free speech and peaceful assembly?! It is important to understand that Holocaust didn't start with gas chambers, it started with propaganda lies and hate. You have the power to stop this madness. It is important to understand that all this hate will not magically disappear on its own. As you know, the protests became bolder because they see that everything is allowed under the "Freedom of speech". I want my daughter to start her first year in university just like all students, without seeing all this hate directed at her not just from students but also from professors and hateful events. I don't want to receive another email from my son's school about another antisemitic incident. I don't want to hear about another sinagogue or Jewish school vandalized. I see that many leaders refrain from speaking out against this hate as there is a lot of gaslighting and they might want to avoid to be wrongfully accused of Islamophobia or Anti Palestinian Racism and instead appease those who support and justify Palestinian terrorism. Let's face the truth, pro Palestinian hate rallies are not pro Palestinians they are anti Israel and anti Jewish. And, usually they are not peaceful. They are well organized and well funded same as the encampments. Free speech should not be confused with Glorification of terrorism. What about a right of every Canadian to live in a safe environment?! I am asking you to take courageous actions to protect all Canadians. I trust you to do the right thing. Thank you! Karina Rootshtein - Eve Bergstein
I am very concerned with the many acts of violence against our Jewish community by pro-Palestinians who are clearly uneducated as to why they are protesting. They are antisemites who are supporting the terrorists who terrorized Israeli citizens, they murdered, raped and kidnapped innocent people who befriended many gazan neighbors, they tortured people who were peace activists! Do these protesters believe that Israel will not respond, do they believe that Israel has no right to protect themselves? As a senior and long time resident of Toronto, I would like to see more arrests of these "protesters". Eve Bergstein
- Ilana Halperin
The anti-Israel protests that have taken over our city since October 7th have created a real sense of fear and intimidation in my Jewish family. while I can appreciate the right to protest and critique the decisions of a foreign government I cannot accept the targeting of Jewish neighborhoods and institutions. protest in front of the Israeli consulate are reasonable but protests in front of Jewish institutions and highway overpass and university campus are unacceptable. the lines between free speech and hate speech have been crossed with slogans like only one solution intifada/revolution and from the river to the sea… these slogans imply the desire for violent destruction of Jewish Israelis and make Jewish Canadians whose Zionism is a part of their core identity feel very unsafe. in addition the over antisemitic graffiti with swasitikas and vandalism is out of control in our city and I think this is because the offenders feels emboldened to act in the current climate. I have tried to attend peaceful vigils for hostages and victims of October 7 and been met with angry loud counter protestors who don't seem to have a permit and use a megaphone that drowns out our own gatherings. I would like to ask that going forward the TPS set clearer ground rules about where and how protests can occur and if within the pervue take a broader view of what constitutes hate speech. I do appreciate that the police have had a stronger presence in my neighbourhood since October 7th and that they are seeking our input at this time
- Amanda Bertoia-Cristini (Private citizen)
I am writing as a member of the Jewish community of the City of Toronto. I am 50 years old and was born and raised in mid-town Toronto, feeling very proud of our City and safe as a Jewish person. Since October 7, my family (my two young adult children, and 85 year old mother) have felt overwhelmingly unsafe in Toronto as Jews. There are blatant displays of hatred towards our community, acts of violence and vandalism that are reminiscent of the pogroms which caused my family to flee Eastern Europe in the late 1800's and even more alarming , closely resembling early Nazi Germany in 1933. The overt displays of intimidation, blood libel and discrimination against our religious institutions, our community businesses and even the hospital that was created as a result of Jewish doctors not being able to practice medicine in the early 1900's in Toronto is beyond the pale and completely unacceptable. If this was happening against ANY OTHER GROUP OF PEOPLE it would not be tolerated. While I am impressed by the continued support of the Toronto Police Service and their presence in keeping Jews physically safe, the politicians are not showing up to ensure our psychological safety and wellbeing. Jews are being treated as second class citizens and being held to a double standard. I implore the Toronto Police Service to continue to show their support in keeping ALL communities safe and in particular, the Jewish community as we suffer the greatest display of violence and hatred against us in Toronto since the Christie Pits riots in 1933. Thank you.
- Jason
Toronto Policy Service Public Order Policy Consultation
I supporting training for police about laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, particularly in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighbourhoods.
I believe it is the job of the police to know where that line is between hate speech and free speech and to be ready to hold perpetrators to account for their actions. To be clear, inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group ARE severe offences and must be dealt with accordingly. The police should adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech (speech / slogans / symbols) at public demonstrations and updated police training should be provided in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement.
I also support providing resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests.
I want emphasize the importance of applying a zero-tolerance definition to hate speech, but police must also be educated on the use of certain sayings and connotations that have an equally negative impact on the community. Additionally, I would ask that police receive updated training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. Training must include specific content regarding how to address the presence of antisemitism / acts motivated by hate as part of public demonstrations. This includes understanding the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech as well as being able to identify the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda (including foreign language material). Furthermore, I advocate for TPS-wide enhanced hate crime training that would equip all police to identify the tactics / symbols and propaganda necessary to be able to enforce hate laws. - Candice Rose
Hello TPSB,
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to share my thoughts on the public order policy. First of all, I would like to express my gratitude to the TPS for all that you do to keep my community safe. These are challenging times and tireless efforts of the TPS is essential to protecting our right to live safely.
I would like to express my support for police training about laws that govern protest management to assist with enforcement of laws to maintain peace and order, particularly in major city intersections and predominantly Jewish neighborhoods. It essential for the members of the TPS to receive training and support to ensure the safety of individuals in these communities and to ensure that all individuals are comfortable and free to move within the city safely.
I believe that there is also a need for police to adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations and I would ask for updated police training in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement. Unfortunately, I have witnessed protesters using hate speech and Anti-Semitic rhetoric. This is completely unacceptable and has no place in Canada. I would like to emphasize the importance of applying a zero-tolerance definition to hate speech and police should be educated on the use of certain sayings and connotations that have an equally negative impact on the community. I would like to request updated training for police officers in both antisemitism and hate crime enforcement.
I understand that protest management comes with resource costs and I support the police in obtaining the necessary resources to maintain peace and order. There should be zero tolerance for hate speech at demonstrations and police should have the training to identify and respond quickly to hate speech, slogans, and symbols. There should be a zero-tolerance approach to hate symbols/speech at any protest another public place. I advocate for a TPS-wide enhanced hate crime training that would equip all police to identify the tactics/symbols and propaganda necessary to be able to enforce hate laws and to identify hate tactics and propaganda. I also support resources and training for police to assist campus security when support is needed to manage university encampments and protests.
Thank you for the opportunity to share my input. The TPS has an essential role in maintaining law and order in our city.
Sincerely,
Candice Rose - ILYA BAHAR
Since October 7, 2023 and the Israel Gaza War, my neighborhood ( Avenue and Wilson) has been targeted by protestors in order to intimidate residents. Protestors have blocked access to the neighborhood, have roamed residential streets with racists signs, have vandalized businesses, schools and places of worship. These acts were directed at the Jewish community. In many of these cases, the police force was outnumbered and uncertain on what constitutes peaceful protest and hateful protest. I call on the board to boost the police force in Toronto and to provide training to the force on how to distinguish hateful protests and intimidation.
- Frank Abrams
I have lived in the City of Toronto for 68 years and have never witnessed the level of hate speech and criminal activity that has gone unchecked in demonstrations since Oct. 7th. The Police do not have the full support of the board and municipal politicians, who have themselves expressed comments in support of pro Hamas lawbreakers. I believe these council members should resign from the Police Board or recuse themselves from this discussion as they are clearly biased and hold views contrary to public safety and upholding the law.
Further, the city should designate public spaces for demonstrations and the police should enfore the law strictly. There is no place for demonstrations in front of businesses or private homes, or in communities that feel threatened by this lawlessness. The role of the police is not to judge the merits of a protest or to defuse tensions - it is to enforce the law. If we don't stop out of control, unlawful activities, threats and hate speech, public order and peace will disappear. - Rochelle Bowmile
Download file
The Toronto Police Services Board
To Whom it May Concern:
I have lived in Toronto my entire life. I grew up here, I went to school and University here, and I got married and raised my family here. I have always been a proud Canadian and even more a proud Torontonian. However, since October 7th I have become anxious and fearful, scared and extremely frustrated. The blatant antisemitism spurred on by the "pro Palestinian" protests, and the media coverage these protesters and antisemites have received is horrifying. I must believe that inciting hatred and calling for the genocide of an identifiable group ARE severe offences and must be dealt with accordingly. In addition, a zero-tolerance approach toward any form of hate speech at public demonstrations must be enforced and perpetrators arrested and charged. This includes ensuring protests are not obstructing traffic or preventing people from going about their business. I believe that police should have the resources and abilities to impose safe access zones around places of worship, schools, and community service agencies to prevent them from being used as venues for protest. Finally, the Toronto police should have the power to apply a zero-tolerance approach to hate symbols / speech at any protest. In conclusion, TPS should be given enhanced hate crime training that would equip all police to identify the tactics / symbols and propaganda necessary to be able to enforce hate laws.
Regards. Rochelle Bowmile [Personal information redacted - Board Office] - Erica Leon
Since October 7th, the world has been complicit with the atrocities that took place at the hands of the terrorist group, Hamas. People blamed Israel and the Jewish population for committing genocide, a claim which has been disputed repeatedly by both Jews and non Jews alike. The protests have been used as intimidation tactics to instil fear in the Jewish community. Synagogues have been vandalized, Jews have been assaulted both verbally and physically and Jewish businesses have been boycotted, Jewish doctors have been doxxed by pro hamas agitators and pro pali doctors have refused to treat Jewish patients. The keffiyeh has become a symbol of violence and has no place in protests when used as face coverings or in hospitals or schools. Universities have become indoctrinated with anti Jew propaganda, banning Jewish students and teachers from entering buildings on campus. Throughout all if this the police have been submissive by allowing this bad behavior to escalate and by not instilling law when violence is instigated towards the Jewish population. The police need to enforce the law by charging anyone who threatens to cause harm to another, in this case any Jew who wears Jewish symbols such as a star of David necklace or a kippah. It shouldn't be scary to live in Toronto, yet it is. The teachings of DEI and any form of oppressive teachings is creating hatred towards the Jewish population. There is absolutely no reason the police shouldn't be committed to keeping our city safe, yet every day they dismiss arson incidents at Jewish places of worship or Jewish schools, violence incidents sending the message that its acceptable to harrass the Jewish community because the police won't do anything and if they do, a judge will dismiss all charges. School is starting in a couple of weeks. If those tents go back up there will be the continuation of anarchy we all saw a few months ago. If the police can't enforce the safety of Jews, bring in the national guard or whoever can help because, the way things are going the safety of all Jews has been ignored and it's unacceptable.
Thank you Erica Leon - Gilda Rovan
I was born and have lived my entire 75 years of life in Toronto. It has always been a safe and wonderful city to grow up in, attend school in, raise a family in, and a city where I could go anywhere with a feeling of safety and without fear. Toronto was the best and safest city in the world.
As a child, my Mother, a Holocaust survivor, taught me that the police were my friend. That if ever I felt scared or lost, I should find a policeman and he would make sure that I got home safely.
Tragically, today, our Mayor, and even some of our police officers, stand for, and support, the antisemitic rhetoric, vandalism of our community spaces, the targeting of Jewish-owned businesses, constant protests, and encampments, which have impacted the ability of myself, my family, and my community, to feel safe.
It is your job, which is not an easy one, to keep us safe. It is your job to arrest the ones who violate our laws, threaten our safety, prevent us from carrying on our businesses, and who participate in terrorist activities. It is not part of your job to allow your personal ideology to decide who is right or wrong, who has a right to live here safely, or who shouldn't be protected due to their religion, colour, or who they choose to love, preventing you from doing your job.
I ask that you keep your pledge to honour the laws of our city, and this country, and keep our citizens safe.
Respectfully, Gilda Rovan - Ray Naim
These protests have upended our city. There has been a complete disregard for our laws and regulations and it's time to stop.
Protests should not be allowed to take place in the immediate vicinity of daycares, religious institutions, schools, community centres, or locations that target a specific ethnic group. Signs or flags containing hate speech or support for terrorist organizations should lead to arrest. Using hate speech, calls to violence, or physical violence should lead to arrest. The protests should not be exempt from the law. - Gilian Horenfeldt- Pomer (Jewish Family and Child Service of Greater Toronto)
I would like to see more hate speech and discrimination criminally charged at these demonstrations and protests. These protests are about hate and scaring people and this is not ok. Toronto now, is not the same place that I grew up in. I was never afraid to walk around as a proud Jew prior to October 7th, I was more afraid of being a female. Now I am worried about being a proud Jew. This is not ok and I fear what this city will continue to look like if these people are not dealt with accordingly and appropriately.
- Candice Wasserstein
Dear Police Chief, I do not feel safe living in Toronto. Jewish places of worship and schools where my children attend are being targeted by violence including bomb threats. Protestors are blocking roads and restaurants. Protestors are using violence. There have been no peaceful Palestinian protests in Toronto. They are all violent in nature. Please put a stop to this and make Toronto safe again.
- Shulamis Laufer (My Family)
My family has been visiting down town Toronto such as the aquarium or CN tower for decades each summer since I was a child myself. I have had to vacation in the US to go to attractions because we are so scared of the pro-Hamas and Pro-Hezzballah signs we keep seeing. When people chant to globalize the intifadah it is petrifiying and I do not want my children seeing and hearing that. Please make these ,awful and openly anti-Semitic marches and chants a thing of the past. The stain on Canada will be there until we choose to remove these haters of Jews from our streets. I am looking forward to returning to Toronto attractions again.
- Rob Goldstein
As a concerned Jewish parent in Toronto, I am writing to express my deep fear and anxiety for the safety of my family and community. The alarming rise in antisemitism, coupled with the tolerance for rallies that support terrorist organizations, has created an environment where we no longer feel safe in our own city. The recent increase in hate crimes against Jewish people and the normalization of rhetoric that glorifies violence against us are profoundly unsettling. We should not have to live in fear of being targeted for our faith, and it is unacceptable that such hatred is allowed to proliferate in our streets. I urge the Toronto Police to take decisive action to protect all citizens and to ensure that our city remains a place where everyone can live without fear of violence or discrimination. My family, like many others, is increasingly anxious about our safety, and we look to you for the protection and assurance that our concerns are being taken seriously.
- Paul Bagnell (None)
I realize the Toronto Police Service has a difficult task on its hands when it comes to policing large protests - particularly those that have occurred since October 7 2023 and related to the Israel-Hamas conflict. I believe, however, that these protests have often a) obstructed public streets without advance notice or permission; b) included statements, slogans and symbols that can fairly be described as hate speech directed against Toronto's Jewish community (for example: the inverted red triangle; and the "river to the sea" chant); and c) taken place intentionally in Jewish areas of the city in a way that is intimidating to our Jewish citizens. None of these things are acceptable, in my opinion, and I strongly doubt they can properly be described as peaceful protest.
I believe the TPS should act more forcefully to prevent make sure protests are conducted lawfully and peacefully, and I believe Toronto's political leadership should support the TPS in doing so. I have been very disappointed at some public statements by some members of Toronto City Council, particularly after TPS officers were assaulted while policing one particular protest. This was the protest during which officers were assaulted with a pole of some kind, and had horse manure thrown at them. The refusal of Toronto's mayor to denounce a statement made by a small group of elected councilors criticizing the police for making arrests at this protest was disgraceful and counter-productive, in my opinion.
Thank you for soliciting the views of the public on this. - Barbara Chatz (Private Citizen)
I as a Jewish citizen of Toronto feel extremely vulnerable.I do not believe that enough has been done by the police to show the strength necessary to not tolerate the hate and order of this society.I have grandchildren who go to a Jewish school and worry for their safety every day.This is not a way to live.more needs to be done !!
- Jayne Naiman (Personal)
Toronto has changed in a way I never thought was possible. The hate and antisemitism in the streets today is alarming and I am questioning whether my future is based in Toronto. I am in my 60's, a life long resident who was proud to call Toronto my home. I'm in shock to see what the anti Israel protestors have gotten away with while the police mostly sit idle. The masks have got to go; the image is horrifying and enables the protestors to hide their identity and hate. Protests should be in public gathering places - not in Jewish neighborhoods and streets. Too often we are hearing that police won't intervene because of Charter freedoms. That to me is a cop out. And enables the hate to escalate. The lack of action at university campuses which displayed the worst hate and antisemitism is inexcusable. It will take the city and police years if ever to rebuild the trust of the Jewish community. A start will be to acknowledge the mistakes. The Jewish community has greatly contributed to Toronto and been a major force in building this City. The events over the last year have caused the community to reevaluate our love for this City. Let's start strictly enforcing rules of common decency and respect and regaining control of the city. It seems the anti Israel protestors are in charge!
- Brian Ginsler
This seems reasonably straightforward to me: 1. protests that are not peaceful need to be shut down 2. protests that have hate speech or signs/phrases need to be shut down (or the offenders removed). 3. protestors should not be allowed to cover their faces and hide from identification. If the protests are peaceful, the participants should have no reason to cover their faces. 4. protests should be held only in designated public spaces and should not impede the general public's use and enjoyment of their cities, streets, neighbourhoods and roadways. For further clarity, protests should not consist of "marches" through residential neighbourhoods. 5. Following on #4 - any protests blocking public roads or highways (or causing a distraction on such - like on a bridge over a roadway or highway) and impeding people's ability to travel to their destinations need to be - at minimum - moved, or shut down.
- Shannon Moldaver
I speak on behalf of my family when we say how grateful we are to the Toronto Police. As priorities, we plead and hope that resources can be given to the police to hire extra officers to deal with hate crimes, extra training for police in hate speech and hate crimes so that police recognize what is hate speech and can arrest people and masked people who make hateful comments, ensure protests are run safely in appropriate places and don't make the community feel scared and intimidated. The peaceful Canadian society that I have enjoyed all of my life, relates to acceptance and standing up to hate in all of its forms. Recently, there seems to be some confusion about this and hate crimes have flourished. This is particularly the case with respect to antisemitism and the concern of the Jewish community. Any assistance that can be provided in this respect will be greatly appreciated and supported. Please find resources to increase staff, increase training, increase school and campus safety, support meaningful legislation, and community safety. Thank you.
- Suzanne Heft
I have lived in Toronto for most of my adult life and never felt less safe or secure than I do today, in 2024. As a member of the Jewish community, I have had lived experience, both that of my own and that of close friends, neighbors, and community members, that include: Verbal intimidation, harassment, vandalism of property, and visible acts that incite violence. Bricks have been thrown through the glass window of Jewish businesses owned by friends and family. Only a few metres from my residence, swastika was painted on a Canada Post mailbox. Jewish independent Day schools the a few blocks away from my home have received bomb threats. The places of worship that I attend, require height and security measures, including limited access to buildings, Metal detectors and other important measures. Even so, my attendance has declined because of the anxiety that it triggers being in those spaces. Many people, I know, including myself, modify their behaviour and avoid crowds. The encampments at my alma mater, the university of Toronto throughout the majority of 2024, have been a disgrace to the city . And to the university. Both my children, one of whom is a university of Toronto graduate, have had experience with intimidation on university campus. The environment is divisive and stressful. The police services need to work more proactively and not reactively with the mayor to create deterrence to some of this activity. It is not enough to show up after the fact. We need greater constraints on public gatherings where hateful speech And calls for violence are now being normalized. This toxic behaviour disguised as so called peaceful protest degrades the fabric of a civil society, and it must not be allowed to continue. When people call for armed resistance, it should be a signal to police services that their intentions have nothing to do with peace and nothing to do with protest. I urge Toronto police to work with Jewish community groups who are tracking, monitoring and researching the infiltration of foreign agitators, who are now working inside Canada, to create disruption, mischief, and public mayhem. There is ample evidence that this is happening, and campus in particular has been infiltrated with these activists, masquerading as students. Toronto does not feel safe to me as a Jewish person. It does not feel like a Canadian city. It feels like a hostile backdrop to a future crime scene and I greatly fear we are headed towards tragic consequences unless we do not course correct. What will it take for improved security to become a priority? Does a synagogue need to be bombed? Do we need to see children at a Jewish daycare gunned down by a terrorist shouting for a holy war? Are we waiting for. Jewish student at U of T or TMU to be stabbed? What will it take?
- Jessica Weiss
What can we do about safety of the schools? I want our children to be able to play outside and move about freely, but protests have sometimes made this very challenging. Is there anything that can be done?
- Ezra Grossman
Covering ones face should be banned on the streets. Screaming at anyone in the streets should be banned. If someone who's masked walks into a bank for example are they welcomed and just business as normal? So to, why would anyone feel comfortable or safe with the same masked person running around the streets screaming at people.
- Ollie Schwartz
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Shayne Train
I am afraid. The Jewish community is being targeted and intimidated and crime is rising. I am thankful for what the TPS has done, however our community needs to see more. To start with, we want enforcement of misbehaviour around masks, blocking roads, sometimes violent attempts to shut down events, trespassing at synagogues, hospitals, and schools.
I realize that the crowds can be intimidating, but somehow we need to put a stop to these disruptions of people going about their lives.
Thank you. - Eithan Dudnik
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Milana
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Greg
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Jacqueline Welland
Dear Members of the Toronto Police Services Board
You have asked for our suggestions regarding improving your services to the Toronto community particularly in recognizing and addressing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech, and enforcing existing policies.
Toronto has become a very intimidating and dangerous place for Canadian Jews. No-one is stopping clearly unacceptable and sometimes violent behaviour by mobs of people. We have been very concerned about TPS not intervening at all with many clearly hateful demonstrations and protests recently.
There is a vast difference between democratic free speech and genocidal hate speech.
SUGGESTIONS FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
Education and Training
Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognise and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. Chant awareness; Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognise and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement Zero tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. Public masking ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. Noise control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business.
Reinforcement and Accountability
Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hare speech and the importance of tolerance. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence and provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
Thank you for considering these suggestions. Hopefully implementation may help defuse the growing unsafe situation for Canadian Jews that has been allowed to proliferate recently. - Fran Levine (Resident of North York, Jewish, retired PHN,)
Download file
I am pleased with Toronto Police Services. I understand that human resources and money (physical resources) are necessary to support the anti-hate/racism programs for our police. They are mandated to protect the safety of all citizens. The current Pro-Palestine rallies have, since October 7th, been very hurtful to the majority of Jewish people. When Police were unable to clear the protesters from places like Yorkdale, Eaton's Centre, Avenue Road and 401 Highway and even synagogues, they were unable to fulfil their mandate. I have personally been at rallies at synagogues where Pro-Palestine protesters were allowed to stand on the grass and shout "genocide" at Jewish people lined up to enter. This was the Pride of Israel. Mayor Chow was attending along with representatives from local, Provincial and Federal levels of government. I feel that words have done nothing. Our Mayor and Police Services need to take ACTION. It is time to define what constitutes hate language against Jews. It is time to define when Police can take action so that no person is threatened because of race, religion nor ethnicity. Protesters can disagree with the State of Israel. It is unacceptable when they try to exclude Jewish students from campuses; confront citizens outside their home; shoot guns at Hebrew Day Schools; arson Jewish businesses; and continuously place horrible memes and posters on public property. If no one speaks loudly that Antisemitism is at an all time high in Toronto, eventually some Jewish person will get badly hurt or killed. I am a 77 year old woman who resides in North York who wants to make our city peaceful once again. Take action now. I have posted a letter that will go to Mayor Chow asking for feedback on actions she can or will do. - Helene Zonana (None)
I would suggest the following criteria:
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Gabrielle Macklin
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services to improve their service to the community, particularly in recognizing and addressing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech, and reinforcing policies.
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Sandy Connors (Public Health Agency of Canada)
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chants being heard at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Shawna Kreidstein
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services to improve their service to the community, particularly in recognizing and addressing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech, and reinforcing policies.
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Nasima, Akter (Bangladeshi-Canadian Community Services (BCS))
I spoke with some youth in my organization, following ideas they shared: 1. Community/public awareness on TPS 2. More interactions with public to make them comfortable and know the role of police. e.g. may organize events to show their policing cars, equipment , and answer youth's question; community dialogue and events 3. Cultural competency of police officers, so that they better understand cultural behavior of a victim or accused person 4. Comply with both party's mental health & wellness 5. Training and monitoring of activities in response to racism and discrimination. 6. initiatives to ensure TPS for all of us, built/keep the trust, reduce the fear, encourage public empowerment.
- J Weinberger
Download file 1
Download file 2
Download file 3
Download file 4
Download file 5
I would first like to thank the Toronto Police Service for all that they have done to ensure the safety of my family during the past few months.
I have grown up in Toronto all my life and I never thought I would fear for my family's safety, because of the fact that we are Jewish, but this is now our reality and much more needs to be done to ensure that the police are empowered to ensure our safety, as Jews, in Toronto. Since October 2023, the rhetoric employed by an overwhelming majority of those who purport to support Palestinians, actually does nothing to help anyone, anywhere, but does in fact threaten the safety of Jews living across the globe including in Toronto. It is not a coincidence that since October 2023, Toronto area synagogues have been vandalized repeatedly - for example, the Kiever synagogue in downtown Kensington Market in June 2024, Kehillat Shaarei Torah in North York vandalized multiple times including in June and July of 2024, and including an instance where individuals pulled up to the synagogue's parking lot, removed a dead raccoon from their vehicle, and left it at the synagogue's doorway. The Jewish high school that I attended was evacuated this past spring on receiving a bomb threat. The Jewish day school Bais Chaya Mushka in North York was *shot at*. On October 30, 2023, I had to rush to the Paul Penna Jewish day school, housed in the Miles Nadal JCC at Bloor and Spadina, because of protestors in the area whose loudly shouted slogans included 'Viva Viva Intifada', which is unequivocally and unambiguously a call to violence. My children were in the area and the reality is that *they were not safe* and they were specifically not safe because they are Jewish. I have the footage from that day and am happy to send it along, but the file was too large to attach here. I have attached, though, multiple images of graffiti, stickers, and messages that are a small sampling of what I see daily in my downtown Toronto neighbourhood. These images are a mix of blood libel, images meant to intimidate, threaten, and silence, all emboldened by the current climate of complacency and lack of enforcement. Note that the inverted triangle symbol is an image used by Hamas, a recognized terror group, to delineate targets. Calls to 'globalize the intifada', 'by any means necessary', 'From the River to the Sea', and 'justified resistance' are all incitements to violence and they are directed against the Jewish community everywhere. This is undeniable and I have provided examples above. It is imperative that more be done, as the message right now is that this violence and intimidation is tolerated. Every Jewish gathering place in Toronto and beyond is currently a potential target. I am very apprehensive of the safety risk to my family and my community as we gather for the High Holidays which will fall in October this year. I told both of my children to remove their Magen Davids (Star of David) because I knew it would make them potential targets of violence in their downtown Toronto world - unfortunately I was right and unfortunately I do not know when it will be safe for them to put their Magen Davids back on. Toronto is a place where people of various cultural, religious and ethnic backgrounds should feel safe to practice their customs, religions and show their backgrounds without fear of violence and it is simply not true for the Jewish community in Toronto in 2024. We need the robust support of the Toronto Police Service to ensure we have the same right to a peaceful existence free from the threat of harm as anyone else. - Julie
I am writing to share some suggestions on how the Toronto Police Services (TPS) can improve their strategies for maintaining public order in our city. In light of recent incidents, it is imperative that TPS focuses on effectively identifying and managing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. Below are several recommendations that could enhance TPS's service to the community:
Education and Training
1. Thorough Hate Speech Training: Officers should receive education on the historical context, implications, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is essential for police to understand that certain chants at protests may be calls for genocide rather than harmless expressions.
2. Recognizing Propaganda: Training should include identifying and understanding the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that might disguise themselves as anti-racism or advocacy. For example, "anti-Palestinian racism" can sometimes be used to target Jewish and Israeli identities without evidence.
3. Awareness of Chants and Symbols: Officers should be trained to recognize specific chants and symbols that advocate for the destruction of Jews, ensuring such expressions are recognized as unacceptable.
4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate historical lessons to underscore the dangers of unchecked hate speech and its potential to lead to violence.
5. Psychological Training: Provide officers with skills to identify and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Strict Hate Speech Policy: Enforce a zero-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech.
2. Ban on Public Masking: Prohibit public masking used to intimidate or conceal identities during protests, especially outdoors.
3. Control of Noise Levels: Regulate the use of excessive noise as a form of intimidation or assault.
4. Use of Barriers: Implement wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests, preventing clashes.
5. Ensuring Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not disrupt individuals' ability to conduct their daily activities.
6. Traffic Management: Keep roadways clear and prevent traffic disruptions during public events and protests.
7. Anti-Intimidation Efforts: Actively prevent and address any intimidation tactics used against individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Enforcement: Apply policies consistently and without bias, addressing all violations appropriately.
2. Addressing Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is met with appropriate consequences.
3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Facilitating Dialogues: Host open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the effects of hate speech and the importance of tolerance.
2. Collaborative Partnerships: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation.
3. Support for Victims: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence, providing them with necessary resources and assistance.
I hope these recommendations are taken into account to foster a safer and more inclusive community in Toronto.
Sincerely, Julie - Joe Schneeweiss
As a Jew who has felt increasingly unsafe in my city, hesitant to go downtown, and under police protection when attending religious services, I want to first thank the police for their ongoing presence, and efforts to keep the jewish community safe. At the same time, I want to urge the police force to do more to deal with and prevent further escalations of anti-semitism and anti-Israel hate which are making Toronto increasingly dangerous for Jews. While I have many suggestions, for the sake of being succinct, I will mention only a few here:
1. Increase police presence - in Jewish neighbourhoods and during the (usually illegal) anti-Jewish demonstrations. A heavy showing is a deterrent against escalation.
2. Training on anti-semitism and anti-Israel propaganda for all officers: the more readily you can identify hate marked as "peaceful" the easier it will be to identify ways in which Jews are being targeted. From the River to the Sea, is a call for genocide, Free Palestine erroneously implies and feeds the misconception of an Israeli occupation, despite the 2005 disengagement. Learn about the IHRA definition of antisemitism, which has been adopted by the governments of Canada and Ontario.
3. We have ample criminal laws, use them. And demand support from our government when doing so. As examples, Prevent illegal demonstrations, by barricading the streets (this is possible and was done effectively during Covid). Further, The use of disguises with he intent to harm is a criminal offence in Toronto 㠼㸵 increasing arrests during illegal protests which call for the erasure of the Jews, is a simple act to show the police is serious in its intent to protect all citizens.
While there are many more recommendations, the general spirit of the above is to ensure that Toronto returns to being a respectful and peaceful place where differences of opinions are expressed within boundaries of respect and safety. And where the terms "peaceful demonstration" returns to its meaning.
Thanks Joe Schneeweiss - Mary
Firstly thank you for taking the time to listen to us. To get to the point I am petrified for my children. Outside our Jewish bubble, Toronto no longer feels safe. We have to hide who we are in fear of being insulted or attacked. The protests, albeit "democratic" have gotten out of hand and individuals were able to spew so much hatred and spread propaganda to the point that we have been alienated. We need to see more action taken against hate. People need to be seen getting reprimanded for hateful acts. It needs to be on the news. There is no deterrent for hateful and inciting behaviour. Punishments should be harsher. Canada needs to stand firmly behind its longstanding values of tolerance ALSO when it comes to Jews. Newcomers need to understand that they have to adapt to Canadian values and not the other way around. Places of worship should be monitored for spreading hate. This needs to stop. Many of us are talking about leaving Canada. A thought I never had in my life before now. Take us seriously.
- Hedy Segal
Please help your Jewish citizens feel safe by providing the security we need.We never demonstrate with hate speech or deafening noise.We never threaten anyone or make them feel fearful.We never block streets and we deserve the same.
- Dahlia Solomon
I would like to see the police be more active in shutting down these protesters who spew hatred against the Jewish community.
- Ilana
While all community members are entitled to assemble and protest peacefully they should not be allowed to conceal their identities with masks and other forms of cover as this allows people to engage in hate speech, incitement of violence and other forms of harassment without accountability and without the ability for law enforcement to charge persons who contravene the criminal code. There are laws preventing people from concealing their identity under the criminal code and these laws should be enforced. Furthermore, while protestors are entitled to protest peacefully they should not be able to close roads and impede people passing by from peaceful enjoyment of public spaces or from being able to enter buildings, particularly hospitals, places of worship and public venues and private homes. Also, while people are entitled to pray they should not be allowed to do so at busy intersections. This form of conduct is intended as a power play and not as a peaceful demonstration. There are many places of worship for all religions and denominations and Bay and Bloor or Yonge and Dundas are not such places. Closing down busy intersections on busy routes is not only a nuisance but dangerous. What if there is an emergency and someone is attempting to drive to an accident scene or to a hospital? Please enforce laws against loitering and public mischief. If it is allowed to continue it will grow into a much bigger problem Thank you for your consideration.
- Josh Rot
The recent wave of protests in Toronto have raised some serious questions and implications for the Toronto Police. Firstly we must note our appreciation to all the police officers that unfortunately deal now on a daily basis with protesters that have zero respect for the police. These protesters harass, degrade and harm the work of our police officers. Unfortunately, the behaviour exhibited by these protesters towards the police is just a fraction compared to the behaviour of these protesters when police are not present. Toronto has a major problem with criminals, racists, and plain old bullies who have found a way to legalize and legitimize their behaviour. The average Torontonian is not blind to this and we are quickly reaching a boiling point. Unfortunately TPS management of the situation has been detrimental to date - in an effort to "maintain the peace" TPS has allowed mobs to terrorize places of worship, ordinary Torontonians, and the streets of Toronto. This is long not a protests, but a flagrant spit in the face of other citizens. My suggestion as it relates to policy: Protests should continue to be allowed but clear red lines need to be established. 1. No blocking of roads unless approved by permit 2. Use of any tool for violence should bot be tolerated (sticking megaphones in people's ears etc㠼㸵). 3. No blocking entrances to any place of business or worship 4. Any usage of sound systems beyond hand held systems most be approved by permit
Enforcement of the above four simple items will enable the TPS with time to restore order to our streets while still enabling the important freedom of expression and protest.
I urge the board to address this growing problem of open disrespect to our fellow citizens and to the established rules and laws. If the course isn't changed soon and the police simply continue to "maintain the peace" by appeasing a mob we will find ourselves slipping into a hole that will be hard to climb out of. The cost will end up much greater than today. - Lisa Grant
I would ask that police take action to safeguard houses of worship, religious institutions and their community organizations by ensuring a cordon of at least 500 meters around their premises be maintained and manned by polie officers to protect them when protest groups and demonstrators are amassing in front of them.
- Joanna Kagal (CIJA)
To the Toronto Police Service Board, First off I want to thank you for allowing us local residents to share our ideas, experiences and suggestions on how to make Jewish residents feel safe again. For 50 years I have always felt safe growing up in the city of Toronto. However since October of 2023 that safe and secure feeling has drastically changed. The height of my stress materialized and has not been mitigated since March of 2024. In March I attended a rally with pro-Israel and anti-Israel demonstrators. Although police supervision and protection were present, it did not stop the anti-Israel protesters from singing these lyrics "All the Zionists are evil, All the Zionists are rapists....." These lyrics bothered me very much because they are extremely disturbing and full of misinformation. The words "Zionist, Zio, Zionism" are being thrown around as slurs. Anti-Israel protesters are using those words to replace the words they really mean which are Jews and Jewish. A Zionist is a person that believes in "development and protection of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel". -Oxford dictionary. Not all Jewish people are Zionists and not all Zionists are Jewish. Furthermore, there are 57 Muslim countries in the world. Israel is the one and only Jewish country in the world. This is important for Police to know because anti-Israel protestors will claim to justifiably hate Zionists and not Jews. This is a convenient go-to line that has been used in Europe in the 1930's and is being revived again. I recommend that anti-Israel protesters stop singing hateful and untrue lyrics about people they don't personally know and about a country they most likely never lived in. Furthermore, I would like to see higher police presence at synagogues, supermarkets in Jewish neighbourhoods, coffee houses (Starbucks in particular) and Jewish private schools. We have seen evidence of these places being vandalized, shot at, and lawn signs set ablaze. Although at this point only property has been damaged, the Jewish community simply cannot wait until these violent acts escalate to human causalities. Furthermore, people living in predominately Jewish neighbourhoods have the right to travel to work without disruptions or protests taking place on highway overpasses. Finally when anti-Israel protesters are banding together to rally they need to uncover their face. If their beliefs are that important and relevant they should not have the need to hide their identities. The lyrics in their songs are not peaceful, nor are carrying around large poles over 6 ft tall to these rallies which I've seen first hand. In my opinion they resemble weapons and should not be allowed at any protest or rally. Finally donning the keffiyeh, or checked scarf should not be allowed. The keffiyeh is not a hijab, niqab or burka. The hijab, niqab and burka serve legitimate religious purposes. A keffiyeh is strictly a political symbol. Since October 7th the checkered scarf has been weaponized as a symbol of resistance. To wear keffiyeh in Jewish neighbourhoods induces the same flight or fight response that a Klu Klutz Klan outfit invokes in a predominately Black neighbourhood. I feel that the Police need to be aware of how Jewish people feel around people who don masks with keffiyehs. This should be part of their culturally relevant training along with the regular diversity, equity and inclusion training. Thank you for considering my suggestions. Joanna Kagal Toronto resident
- Ronnen Lederman
B"H Bais Chaya Muska schools shooters are on the loose. Zero communications with community. These criminals have guns and knowingly shot at an elementry school. Public perception is police not pursuing case.
- Susan Schendel
Dear Toronto Police Service Board Members, I would like to share an incident with you. I have lived in Toronto most f my adult life and I am happy to say that the majority of the time has been peaceful. However, after October 7, 2023 as a resident and citizen of Canada I have grown fearful for my family's safety. Why you ask? I will share the following incident. My husband and I participated in the 2024 Walk For Israel. The event was a huge success and there was security throughout the route and the Prosserman J.C.C. We decided to walk to our son's home after the Walk For Israel. He lives in the Bathurst Manor Community. As we left the route for the Walk there were no police presence. Everything was going well until we met up with 6 young men all of whom were wearing black and black face masks. I felt my heart pound and a sickening sense enveloped my body. I became very nervous and scared. No police. No security guards. As we got closer they started to scream at us. "Fuck you" in loud voices. We were wearing our Walk For Israel T-Shirts so these men knew we were from the Walk.They all made hand gestures and they cried out .."death to you fucking Jews!" The group of men dressed in black who hid their identities then walked past us. In that one minute I never felt so threatened, so alone. Real fear gripped me- as anything could have happened and the result would not be a good one. The Jewish community needs to be protected. The data of Jewish hate incidents in evident- it is the highest in years. schools, synagogues, Jewish neighborhoods need to be demonstration/protest free zones. Police officers need to be trained.There needs to be more police officers. The laws cannot be enforced by a few police officers- laws to protect against hate is for every one- Asian, Black, LGBTQ and yes- even Jews. The Board needs to take a more active role in demanding more Provincial funds to stop the hate. Existing laws need to be enforced- why wait til someone in killed? As a woman, mother and grandmother please let me recapture a sense of safety and security for my well being and for my community. Susan Schendel
- Belinda Schneeweiss
As a Jew who has felt increasingly unsafe in my city, hesitant to go downtown, and under police protection when attending religious services, I want to first thank the police for their ongoing presence, and efforts to keep the jewish community safe. At the same time, I want to urge the police force to do more to deal with and prevent further escalations of anti-semitism and anti-Israel hate which are making Toronto increasingly dangerous for Jews. While I have many suggestions, for the sake of being succinct, I will mention only a few here:
1. Increase police presence - in Jewish neighbourhoods and during the (usually illegal) anti-Jewish demonstrations. A heavy showing is a deterrent against escalation.
2. Training on anti-semitism and anti-Israel propaganda for all officers: the more readily you can identify hate marked as "peaceful" the easier it will be to identify ways in which Jews are being targeted. From the River to the Sea, is a call for genocide, Free Palestine erroneously implies and feeds the misconception of an Israeli occupation, despite the 2005 disengagement. Learn about the IHRA definition of antisemitism, which has been adopted by the governments of Canada and Ontario.
3. We have ample criminal laws, use them. And demand support from our government when doing so. As examples, Prevent illegal demonstrations, by barricading the streets (this is possible and was done effectively during Covid). Further, The use of disguises with he intent to harm is a criminal offence in Toronto 㠼㸵 increasing arrests during illegal protests which call for the erasure of the Jews, is a simple act to show the police is serious in its intent to protect all citizens.
While there are many more recommendations, the general spirit of the above is to ensure that Toronto returns to being a respectful and peaceful place where differences of opinions are expressed within boundaries of respect and safety. And where the terms "peaceful demonstration" returns to its meaning.
Thanks - Alan Leavitt (Chabad)
The Canadian government has to do more about Jew hatred
- Jeremy Rosmarin (N/A)
Dear Members of the Toronto Police Service Board,
As a Jewish resident of Toronto, I am writing to contribute to the consultation on the development of the Board's new Public Order Policy. I appreciate the Board's commitment to balancing the constitutional rights of freedom of expression and peaceful assembly with the need to ensure community safety and preserve public order.
Given the recent rise in protests, demonstrations, and other public gatherings, it is crucial that the new Public Order Policy takes into account the specific safety concerns and cultural sensitivities of Toronto's diverse communities, including the Jewish community. The Jewish community has been particularly affected by recent events, with a notable increase in antisemitic incidents during public demonstrations.
In light of these concerns, I respectfully urge the Board to consider the following priorities in the development of its Public Order Policy:
1. Cultural Sensitivity Training: The policy should prioritize cultural sensitivity training for officers, specifically focusing on the unique challenges faced by the Jewish community during public demonstrations and protests. This training should equip officers with the knowledge and skills to manage these situations while respecting cultural norms and addressing specific security concerns. 2. Proactive Engagement and Communication: The policy should encourage proactive engagement and open communication between the Toronto Police Service and community organizations, including those representing Jewish Torontonians. This collaboration will ensure that the Service is aware of and responsive to community-specific concerns in real-time. 3. Enhanced Presence and Visibility: The policy should prioritize an increased and visible police presence in areas where protests or demonstrations are likely to occur, particularly when these events have the potential to target specific communities. This presence will serve as both a deterrent to potential threats and a reassurance to vulnerable communities.
By incorporating these priorities, the Board's Public Order Policy can reflect the expectations and values of the Jewish community while ensuring the safety and security of all Torontonians. It is essential that the policy recognizes the complexity of balancing public order with the protection of minority communities and that it provides clear guidelines for the Chief of Police to establish effective procedures that meet these goals.
Thank you for considering my submission. I look forward to seeing a policy that addresses these concerns and contributes to a safer, more inclusive Toronto. Thank you so much for everything you do to keep our community and all communities safe in this great city. - Marc Morgenthau
The Toronto Police motto is "to serve and protect". With this philosophy and overarching goal of protecting our community, the Toronto police have contributed meaningfully to the high quality of life that we enjoy in Toronto.
I urge the Toronto Police Service Board to ensure that a top priority of the Toronto Police Public Order Policy is to protect all members of the Toronto community. In particular, the Toronto Police must protect members of minority groups and communities. We are seeing a tremendous surge in hate crimes in our city. Toronto Police have a vital role ensuring that we are a community with the rule of law and not the rule of the mob. Free speech rights must be protected, while a sharp and bright line is drawn against hate speech and deprivation of other members of our community's rights to safety and security. Toronto Police must prevent protest from turning Toronto into an unsafe place 㤼㸷 especially for minority groups experiencing active hate crimes at unprecedented levels. This may require active and at times forceful intervention of Toronto Police.
Serving and protecting our community is not an easy task. Toronto Police Service Board must ensure that the policy it sets leaves Toronto Police appropriately empowered to keep our city safe for everyone. - Gary Chapman (Individual:)
- David Smith
Prohibit anti-Israeli and pro-Palestinian protestors, campers and squatters from being present within 500 meters of a Jewish residence, Jewish residential area, synagogue, Jewish owned or Jewish operated business. Ensure that police create a 10-meter-wide safe passage corridor through anti-Israeli and pro-Palestinian protestors and encampments for the use of those who wish to pass through an anti-Israeli or a pro-Palestinian protest or encampment, without impediment, harassment or intimidation.
- Audrey Berend
I am deeply concerned for our Jewish citizens. Pro-Hamas individuals spent two weeks on a bridge intimidating a community with impunity. Schools, businesses, rails and synagogues were targeted. The occupation of university campuses was disgusting and ignored. Misinformation and demonization of Israel is accepted in this country. It is repugnant and shameful from Trudeau and Chow. The police need to crack-down on this. It is long overdue.
- Tristan Hobbs
Toronto police have the ability to condemn hate speech during protests. Calls for intifada revolution and from the river to the sea is some of the hate speech I've been forced to hear when I walk around the city on weekends. I'm scared, I'm triggered, and when I've gone to police in tears asking why they don't stop this they said it's complicated and it's not their job. I'm all for the right to free speech and to protest in a democracy, but terrorizing innocent jews in the community should be swiftly condemned prior to things further escalating. I'd also like to reinforce efforts to ask protestors to remove face coverings so they can be identified. Walking around my Jewish neighborhood in a keffiyah and mask is deliberately intended to scare Jews on a Sunday walk. To witness this around Jewish teens and children is heartbreaking. You have the ability to help me and other Jews feel safe. Please help us.
- David Latner (Advocan Law LLP)
1. It is important to balance the right to protest, with the needs of other people living in Toronto who are affected when protests block public streets, entrances to hospitals, office buildings, restaurants etc. etc. What if we required protests to have permits, and gave them the right to protest at Queens Park and Nathan Phillips Square. They could gather safely, not and not disrupt the lives of others, who can easily avoid those places. 2. The police should try to apply the law consistently. Letting shoplifters run free, or letting illegal protests occur without arrest and punishment sends a signal about who the police are willing to protect, and who they are not willing to protect. It sends a signal to extremists that they can keep pushing the envelope for their pet cause. 3. I recognize that the prosecution is up to the crown, not police, but the police could publish stats about which crowns are letting off people. Sunshine is a disinfectant for bad behaviour. 4. To accomplish this, the police need to be better resourced. This could include increased funding for police "on the street" and in "intelligence". It can also include better training of police so they know that the law, even as it exists, has offences on the books that could be used to arrest people. Thanks
- Evelyn Breslin
As a Jewish person living in Toronto I'd like to express thanks to the Toronto Police for helping to protect our community from anti Semetic protesters & individuals who have wreaked havoc on our people & property! We continue to need your support & assistance in maintaining our safety—now & always! With sincere appreciation..,
- Ruth Abrams
I am a 95 year old woman born in a Toronto that was safe for Jews, and where there was an atmosphere of common civility and respect. Not so today. Parade protesters are free to threaten murder and intimidate Jewish businesses and institutions, even hospitals and schools, and to spread vile hate. How is this different from Nazi Berlin? Those who openly advocate murder and the committing of atrocities against schoolchildren and synagogues should be arrested. Period. Allowing this to continue will encourage more and more fanatical groups to do likewise in future demonstrations of their own, that will become more and more violent. It can happen. This city already has areas, where I feel unsafe to enter.
- Dana Rostowsky
In order to feel safe I expect TPS to disallow any illegal and/or violent protest - promoting hate speech and including threats - from happening in public. Individuals whose behaviour supports and glorifies terrorism should be arrested. The synagogue to which our family belongs has been attacked and vandalized 5 times in recent months, and in order for us and our community to feel safe, we need increased police surveillance and protection, and perpetrators need consequences.
- Robbin Dichter (Individual)
I ama concerned citizen about the rise in antisemitism. I want to see more enforcement of hate crimes to the full extent, starting g with arrests in every single hate crime and not to be fluffed off.
- Jeremy Bass
There are increasing incidents in Toronto of anti-semitism being manifested in many ways, including attacks on Jewish institutions such as schools, private Jewish businesses and synagogues, and by extremist anti-Israeli actions that blame all Jews worldwide for what is going on in Israel. Hate speech against Jews is making the Jewish community feel unsafe. There has to be more police action not only to protect physical Jewish establisments such as schools , private business and synagogues,, but more police action on hate speech, as well as mischief against Jewish instituions.vandalizing Jewish property and institutions. We cannot allow hate to be imported into Canada from other places in the world, and action against hate speech and vandalism is essential.
- Daniel
Our streets and communities are no longer safe. Mobs target Jewish neighborhoods with threatening marches and hate speach We regularly have mobs shutting down streets and intersections, yet there are no consequences, and law abiding citizens are obstructed and delayed Many in the community no longer feel safe living in Toronto. Laws are repeatedly broken, with no consequences. We have mobs protesting in front of or blocking entrances to religious institutions while chanting threats and hate speech We have mobs defacing public property and preventing access for all or some groups to parts of our city The police have a difficult job. Yet repeated failure to enforce all of our laws simply perpetuates illegal behaviour, and degrades the quality of life for the silent law abiding majority. A change in policing strategy is needed. There should be zero tolerance for and consequences for breaking the law.
- Dorothy Halberstadt
As a Jewish person I feel like a second class citizen. No other group would get away with this disruption. Please be a police service for all your citizens. I have lived in this city for 80years and never felt like an outsider. I have a great deal of respect for the police force. They were always fair with every religion,not any more.
- Dr. Shayna Nussbaum
We in the Jewish community have appreciated all that the Toronto Police Services have done to help our community stay safe in 2023 and 2024. There has been an alarming rise in anti-Zionist, anti-Israel, and anti-Semitic incidents in this city since October 7. We have seen activities that would have been previously unthinkable in our city, including shooting schools, arson and other defacing of synagogues, possible arson of her children's school bus, vandalism of Jewish businesses, intimidation and bullying towards Jewish students in public schools, and Jewish students and faculty in our esteemed local universities. Notably, the hate crimes perpetrated against schools, businesses, and synagogues cannot be attributable to political protest, but are clearly directed at Jewish institutions rather than political entities associated with the state of Israel. It is incumbent upon the Toronto Police Service to respond to hate crimes and other intimidation of minority groups in a balanced manner. In other words, if a series of behaviours would be unacceptable if directed at any group, it is unacceptable if directed at every group. Those of us in the Jewish community strongly feel that in the current political climate, discrimination and hate crimes directed towards Jews are not taken as seriously as they would be if directed at other minority groups (e.g. BIPOC, LGBTQI2SA+). The Toronto Police Service Board has an ethical and legal obligation to develop maintain standards that ensure that the Chief of Police directs the police service in equitable execution of the law and protection of community members.
- Elana Yuval
I have immigrated from Israel to Canada when I was 13 years old., My name is Elana Cohen Yuval and I am 68 years old. It was my dream to become a Canadian and I felt honoured and privileged to live in this country . I no longer feel that way. I am a Jew With children and grandchildren that are afraid to the point where my daughter has asked me if she should take off her Mezuza from her Front door. Three of my grandchildren attend Hebrew school and for the first time in my life, I feel afraid for them. I miss the days where wearing a necklace the with a Magen David feeling very proud and not afraid. This is not a way of living Not for me and definitely not for my children and grandchildren. We need this government to wake up and realize that we are going to become the next Europe. Please be there for us protect us arrest the people who are making this community not safe. If they want to live in this country in peace, then they should live like Canadians if they want ton live the way they live Which is making other feel afraid and threaten then they should go back home to their country.
- Marvin Talsky
Projected indifference or failure to act responsibly encourages continued disregard of the rights of the public. Demonstrations with violence and or threats of violence which are not punished in some manner such as arrest and charges such as breached of the peace only fuel the continuation and expansion of the demonstrations, threat of violence and violence. For the overwhelming amount of threats and violence comes from one side only and disregard or soft reaction feeds the flame aside from giving the appearance that reaction is not even handed further embolding the side that is violent or threatening. Incitement by marching in neighborhoods not inhabited by the Inciters is nothing but intimidation, as is blocking traffic, demonstrating in main thoroughfares. Holding prayer services is commended but on main streets used by other citizens should not be countenanced and should be broken up if not for any other reason that it interfere with rights of the majority and are plainly in disregard of those interests.
- Elana Rosenberg
While the police has done many things to help my community over the past year, there is one area I need them to enforce. Under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms people have the right to peacefully protest but threats and hate speech are not allowed. Being in many situation this past year where people are chanting "Gas the Jews", "Hitler was right", "Die Kikes", "Intifada now", and many other horrific chants at me, my family, my students, and my community, (while cowardly masked), is a violation of the Charter. These are direct threats and police should be shutting down and arresting anyone who is shouting these dangerous and illegal threats. Allowing this kind of poisonous and hateful rhetoric makes me and many members of the Jewish community feel that the police are giving a free pass to this illegal behaviour. It also goes against everything our wonderful country stands for. I believe everyone has the right to voice their opinions but threats and violence are unacceptable and the police should be standing their ground on this. Thanks.
- Caroline Benyes (None.)
Jewish Charities are being dismissed by CRA while Canadian Terrorist groups like Samidoun (run by an American and a Jordanian/Palestinian) are getting tax breaks and Canadian cultural funding. The do called arts group The Plenty Collective have received arts grants to fund protests in Toronto's Jewish community. Enough. Why are The Liberals getting away with this? Melanie Joly is dangerously and actively anti semetic.
Please help us
Caroline - Linda Waldman
I am very saddened that my country where muslims Jews Christian's, sikhs, and all religions have been coexisting is now allowing its people to support terrorists. There terrorists are setting fire bombs, breaking windows, prohibiting students to enter classes that they have paid for, shooting bullets at children's schools, stopping traffic, disrupting other people's protests and making our city unsafe. Please continue to protect us from this evil. Thank you
- Shelley Black
I have lived in Toronto for 57 years and my husband (72 years old)and two children were born here. We have had long careers In Toronto media and communications industry and been involved in volunteering for the Toronto community and our neighbourhood. As Jews we have always felt safe and treated like any other Canadian born citizens, free to practice our religion in peace and to share values with our neighbours that include peace and respect for individual rights and freedom. I have always viewed this as a privilege and our right as citizens. Until now. Anti semitism in the form of Anti-Israel hate has made our lives in Toronto feel unsafe. Our grandchildren go to Jewish Day School and feel unsafe at the age of five! Can you even imagine what that is like to be discriminated against because of your religion. We are just like our neighbours and want to live in peace and contribute to the well-being of our Toronto society. We are even willing to put up with the terrible traffic and high taxes to live in Toronto which we always considered a safe city to raise our family and the next generation. Until now when pro-terrorist demonstrators are given free reign in our city and access to the public spaces that should be safe for all citizens. Until now when our synagogues and schools are threatened and vandalized. Our adult children have removed any signs of Judaism from their home because they are frightened. We are afraid to use ride share programs because of anti Semitic behaviour of drivers. The laws of our country should protect us and be enforced. That is actually our right as citizens. So all we ask is that our great Toronto Police Force do their jobs and protect citizens from threats and violent acts that come from people who advocate violence against Jews. Please let us return to "Toronto the Good" where all citizens feel safe and able to raise their families and contribute to a better world.
- Rachel
I am very concerned about the unprecedented rise in protests in the city and would like the wearing of face coverings banned in these settings. I would also like to see the use of keffiyehs banned and signs glorifying terrorism and acts of terrorism result in charges against groups and individuals
- Beth
My list of Priorities was developed with cost and safety in mind. We cannot be spending large amounts of Police budget on uncontrollable protests that currently start anywhere in the city. This is a great waste of taxpayers money and not fair to our Police staff. When protests prevent politicians from meeting - we have to think about the expense of getting everyone there, including the Prime MInister, only to have the meeting cancelled. This is not acceptable. It is not acceptable to have our health care workers being put in jeopardy or having to cancel expensive visits and tests. The list goes on. With that in mind, here is my list of tolerated/not tolerated activities: * that protests be organized and take place in a specified area that is easy for the police to manage * that a public representative responds to the crowd so they feel they are heard * that overnight stays at the place of protest are not permitted * that the demonstration is respectful and does not include hate speech * that the demonstration does not disrupt others trying to access work or services * that no place of business (including public institutions such as government buildings, hospitals or schools) be disrupted from conducting regular activity *that no person entering a place of business be hampered, harassed or threatened *that no roads are blocked by the protest
- Jordan Stone (None)
No face masks. People who use them are always the ones who become violent. If they wee illegal most trouble would stop and people wouldn't get hurt by fists or ugly words.
- Linda Gruson
Protests need to be peaceful. It is not peaceful to issue threats or commit violence to other persons or groups. It is not peaceful to disrupt events or to block the passage of others. The police must be present to maintain peace and arrest individuals carrying out acts that harm other persons.
- Susan Glickman
While free speech and legal demonstrations must be tolerated whether we agree with the message ir not, illegal behaviour should not be tolerated by any group. It should not depend on how threatening or large the group is or else the rule of law means nothing and we have anarchy. Right now to Jews it appears that it is acceptable to break the law, so long as the victims are Jews, since Jews tend to be nonviolent.
So, the following is openly tolerated. - The pro Hamas, openly antisemitic mobs have unauthorized demonstrations - Make open threats against the Jewish community - Impede rights to access stores, restaurants, synagogues, etc. - Block roads, intersections, overpasses, access to hospitals - Write Graffiti on Jewish owned businesses - Openly make death threats ie. "six feet under", " 1000 more Oct. 7 th" , " Glory to our martyrs" and openly praise terrorists who kill Jews - Carry and display flags of listed illegal terrorist organizations - Openly intimidate Jews in their own neighbourhoods -Cover their faces while demonstrating These are all illegal actions that target the Jewish community and yet have been permitted to continue for ten months.
We all know that this would not be permitted against ANY other minority. In fact we have seen the rapid police reaction to words said to Black or Muslim victims when hate speech is involved. Even the smallest micro aggression is dealt with definitively.
We see the difference when Jews are the target. Everyone should be equal under the law. Law breakers should be prosecuted even if they come from a community that tries to intimidate. The police should not show a reluctance to enforce the law .
The Jewish community has seen this movie before. It did not end well. We are Canadian citizens and are owed equal protection under the law. This is currently not happening.
Please do better. The pro Terrorist mobs are now becoming emboldened with an actual terrorist plot foiled by police. Synagogues vandalized, Jewish schools shot at, windshields smashed㠼㸵.. Where does it end. They will not stop until they ARE stopped. Please do the right thing. Thank you. - Jen
If our politicians would listen to their constituents, they wouldn't need to protest. It is our Democratic right to protest if our systems and policies do not reflect our values. Police should not engage with protesters unless requested to do so. We should not be spending our precious tax dollars for police to stand around when so many people are suffering. Again, if our spending reflected our values, there wouldn't be a need to protest. Time to take a step back and think strategically. Too many people are struggling.
- Alanna Handelman
I no longer feel safe in this city, as a Jewish woman and a mom. Our streets have been hijacked by extremists intent on changing the fabric of Toronto from one of inclusiveness to one of fear. Since October 7, I have encountered endless protests where participants chant for "intifada" (violent uprising), "from the river to the sea" (annihilate Israel), and wear symbols of terror (Hamas, Hezbollah, and Houthi flags, upside down red triangles to mark their targets). I have also seen "Pro Palestine" organizations co-opt Torontonians through deceitful marketing (example: "Worker's March" posters across the city, with fine print indicating this is supported by Palestinian organizations). I have seen countless graffiti across the city ("Gaza Will Rise," "Zionists are Nazis").
The police, together with the mayor, need to enact anti-hate laws, disband these extremists, and restore public order. Toronto has become a shell of its former self, and your Jewish constituents are frightened for our safety. Our sense of belonging is shattered. - Wendy Woods
As a member of Toronto's Jewish community, I am extremely concerned about my safety and that of our community. The pro- Palestinian protesters have been blocking streets, intimidating us near our homes and places of worship and shouting slogans that are clearly antisemitic and calling for violence (e.g. resistance by any means necessary).
Free speech is not hate speech. The fact that the protesters have been allowed to carry on for months without any real consequences has emboldened them. With no deterrents in place, I fear that these mobs will become violent and start acting on their words. This will jeopardize our community as well as innocent bystanders in Toronto.
We need the Toronto Police Services to have the funding and the support from government to deescalate these mobs and prevent them from harming anyone. TPS needs to act before it's too late. - Michael Kinrys
I would like to thank the Toronto Police Services for their support of the Jewish Community over many years, and especially the last 10 months. I have seen the increased police presence at synagogues, schools, and other Jewish institutions and appreciate this very much.
I still think, however, that there is more that could be done. Specifically, many people have been attacking Jewish individuals and groups verbally (and sometimes physically) with no repercussions. I worry that many police officers have not received sufficient training to know what laws are being broken so are reluctant to arrest anyone. I recommend that more resources be devoted to training your officers regarding what constitutes an antisemitic act.
Along the same lines, I think that protests that turn violent could be nipped in the bud with better, more aggressive restraints on what the protesters are saying and doing.
I know that your budget is being exceeded by the extra costs necessitated by keeping a lid on the demonstrations and I fully endorse an increase in your budget to address this shortfall. - Adam Cutler (Adath Israel Congregation)
On June 9, along with 50,000 Canadian Jews, I participated in the annual Walk with Israel. The counter-protesters were light in number, but vile in behaviour. As my family passed one group, two masked protesters held their hands forward, using their fingers to create a downward pointing triangle. This gesture is used by the most radical pro-Palestinians, mimicking the triangle superimposed by Hamas over human targets in their terrorist videos. In context, such gesture is no different than pulling an index finger across one's throat or pantomiming a gun and pulling the imaginary trigger. Adjacent to the triangle-makers were other masked protesters videotaping the Walk's participants. The Jewish community was threatened that such videos would later be used to identity the participants. Clearly, the counter-protesters were threatening bodily harm or death to people they could later identify. Uttering threats is an offence under Canada's Criminal Code. This behaviour cannot be tolerated. Unfortunately, it will be difficult to identify the perpetrators after the fact. Almost all of them had keffiyehs wrapped tightly around their heads, with only eyes showing. Covering one's face in such fashion may itself amount to a crime – a crime the police have also been ignoring. Enough is enough. Calls to "Globalize the Intifada" or "Free Palestine by any means," reasonably understood by the Jewish community as incitement to violence, are now a regular occurrence in Canada, but they too go unpunished. The situation on our streets is deteriorating. The law must be enforced! Without a change to the status quo, bodily harm (or worse) is all but certain. Those in authority must act now to prevent future violence. I have always believed in the promise of the City of Toronto. Our city has grown not only to tolerate diversity but to embrace it. Because of that pluralistic ethos, Toronto has been a wonderful place to be Jewish. That faith is now wavering. Democracies strike a balance between one person's freedom of expression (including the right to dress as she pleases) and another person's safety. Our city and country are now dangerously off-kilter. Jurisdictions like New York State are considering the kind of face-covering ban that our country already has on the books. Bad actors are shielding themselves from future prosecution by purposefully concealing their identity. Those who commit crimes or threaten to do so must no longer be able to hide behind the veil of freedom of expression. To date, the police have done an excellent job making their presence known. My relationship with our community liaison officer is such that we are now, sadly, on a first-name basis. Toronto Police Service is fully aware of the many written, spoken and gestured threats made to our city's Jewish community. Now it is time to enforce the law. Death threats and incitement to violence against Jews must not go unpunished any longer.
- Dr Alan Jaff (Beth Avraham Yoseph of Toronto Congregation)
1) No new laws are needed if police commit to both proactive and reactive enforcement of existing laws
2) Protests which impede traffic, restrict general public access to public/private space, are unlawful and should be disrupted.
3) Section 63 of the Criminal Code deals with unlawful assemblies. When a protest is either known in advance or develops in real time to a situation that could reasonably provoke a breach of the peace, police must be proactive in arresting and charging members of such protests for unlawful assembly. Proactive policing demands cautioning suspected unlawful assemblies IN ADVANCE that unsanctioned unpermitted protests designed to reasonably provoke a breach of the peace ARE unlawful assemblies and participants will be arrested and charged for proceeding with such protests.
4) Police must be trained to understand the modern language of hate speech and recognize it in its context. This includes removing and / prosecuting persons who display signs / flags / clothing of designated terrorist entities. It further requires police to be trained to understand and recognize symbols and phrases of hatred such as the inverted red triangle used by Hamas supporters, chants of "From the River to the Sea", "Go back to Europe" etc.
5) Public prayer which impedes road / infrastructure access is NOT Charter protected. Prayer should be directed to spaces designated for that purpose and should never interfere with the public's ability to utilize roadways, buildings or parkland
6) A law that prohibits anyone from organizing or participating in a nuisance demonstration or protest within 100 metres of the property line of any vulnerable social infrastructure, such as a place of worship, school, childcare centre, hospital or congregate care facility. - David Farb (Attorney)
It is vital that the police prevent sit ins and encampments on any public lands . These encampments prevent people from entering areas such as the university at U of T campus. Specifically Jewish people were harassed and threatened . The courts have ruled that the encampments are illegal and therefore police should remove them them and arrest those failing to leave.Blocking of traffic should result in arrests of those preventing people from free movement on the streets.Blatant antisemitism in the form of threats or physical battery should result in charges against the offenders.Mob rule is chaos and not permitted in a civilized society.None of these actions constitute free speech.
- Marjorie (The Neighbourhood Group)
Hi Toronto Police Service Board, I know it's not exactly popular to like the police right now and I think that's unfortunate. I have family who is a police officer and have met understanding officers as well so I know it isn't so black and white to what we see online. Seeing this post that the board for Toronto police is open to hearing from the public gives me hope. I think people should be able to continue to protest peacefully and rightfully and be treated equally (for example, there are videos online that police treat Israeli and Palestine protestors differently). It would help to know ahead of time when it's happening so either I know to avoid making plans where it is being held or to plan accordingly to attend. It would be great if protestors who will be taking up public spaces to work with the city so it's a little more organized. I still like to believe police presence does help deter suspicious activities and to keep the public safe, regardless of where protestors stand in their beliefs. And when I mean peaceful I do not mean quiet per say, but no violence and no expressions of hate or any of the -isms. I think it's one thing to be have chants or signs of" everyone deserves freedom and safety" vs "except these people, they should stop existing" etc. Anyway, I digress. Thank you again for reading and I appreciate your time and service.
- KM
The pro Palestinian protests all around the city have been highly disruptive, promote hateful rhetoric and spread hateful messages (calling for intifada which promotes rebellious and calls for violent resistance). It is particularly hateful when protests occur in front of Jewish places of worship. Violent messages should not be tolerated period.
- Pavel (Paul) Paskovatyi
- Ams Sweiger (RCM)
Policing of protests is unjust and a waste of TPA resources. TPA escalates violence by existing within protest spaces. The only role TPA is supportive for in these events is traffic control and redirection and ensuring protesters are not harmed by for example cars. Inherently the policing of just protest movements is a waste of money, resources and police time. Further masking at protests is a community effort to prevent the spread of covid 19. As a health care worker police should be considerate of these community safety protocols and the current summer wave of covid infections. They should be be asking community members to remove masks in public setting where the chance of contagion is higher. They should also refrain from touching protesters or trying to redirect protest routes and instead focus again, on ensuring traffic is carefully redirected alternate routes. My deepest concern as a health care provider is the TPS lack of accountability in escalating violence during peaceful rallies and protests. And their undue use of force particularly against racialized members of community. For example policing a protest against police violence and the murder and attempted murder of community members by police is the height of escalation. Police should defer to community stakeholders such as EMS, fire, and crisis support services in these scenarios when support is needed. The mobile police nurse crisis team is equally useless and escalating to community.
- Michelle Foster
First, I'd like to express thanks to the police force for the amount of time and resources spent over the last 10 months in managing the ongoing protests and for liaising with the Jewish community in the face of substantial increases in antisemitism and hate crimes in the Jewish community.
I have reviewed the laws in contrast with the events over the past many months. I ask that greater attention be paid to arresting and charging those engaging in illegal behaviours. We see at every protest individuals concealing their identity (contravening S.C. 2013, c. 15) and often doing so while making threats and uttering hateful speech, as they're emboldened by anonymity. We've seen parents with kids dressed up holding fake weapons while chanting for violent uprising to crowds as they flash flags for groups classified as terrorists in Canada. This is not only inciting hate, but it is child endangerment and indoctrination in line with the criminal code and needs to be addressed. We have also seen many instances of pro-Hamas and pro-Palestinian protests blocking city infrastructure, which is cited in the community safety and policing act as an actionable offence, yet it's often allowed. We had people blocking Yonge street to pray in protest this past weekend when there are hundreds of mosques available around the city - it's nothing but an intimidation tactic and it cannot be allowed (especially given our streets all now have reduced lanes for cars, but perhaps that's another issue). Provincial, municipal and federal laws are regularly broken during these protests, with frequently uttered threats, concealed identity, and hate speech left unaddressed, which has only served to reinforce and embolden the bad actors. If you tolerate this behaviour you are endangering all Canadians.
People have a right to peaceful protest. They don't have a right to intimidation, noxious substances polluting our air via red and green flares, property damage, hate speech, threats, and chants for violence and retribution (eg., as seen this weekend videos chanting to strike Tel Aviv). The police force needs to rely on the law and arrest those who break it. Fears of backlash or complaints can be evaluated by the courts, though the criminal code offers much leeway to officers breaking up riots and protecting the peace. Ultimately your job is to protect the public and arrest offenders, and with the increase in hate crimes and threats, we are terrified because so much has been left ignored, and those caught are often simply re-released with no significant consequences. The leash needs to be tightened ten fold, not loosened.
I recognize there is only so much capacity given the volumes of unlawful behaviour. But once you start charging individuals who don't follow the law, these behaviours will decrease.
Please start setting firm and consistent expectations for all members of the public to follow the law. If they aren't, please do something about it. As soon as people have to uncover their faces they'll likely be substantially more likely to actually behave in a lawful manner㠼㸵because consequences matter.
Thank you. - Leonard Swartz
I felt very threatened at two (2) pro-Palestinian demonstrations that I witnessed in the Spring of 2024. At both, people hurled verbal assaults at me, even before I had a chance to explain my views. At each, all I did was start to explain that there were 2 sides to the conflict. People started shouting and denouncing me as a fascist, Zionist, white supremacist, colonizer, land-stealer, traitor, etc.
- Clara Tucker
Download file
Statement to Toronto Police Service Board By: Clara Tucker Thank you for the opportunity to share my views with the Board. These are the main points I'd like to raise: GRAFITTIES: I live at the Beaches, Toronto. The first time in my entire life that I felt threatened and insecure in my own neighborhood was during Covid. I went for a walk with my dog early in the morning, and there was graffiti on the wall of the Church across the road from my building saying, "Jews are Pigs". This event stuck in my mind and my heart for months. Today, thousands of graffiti harassing Jews are seen everywhere in the city, and attacking Jews verbally has become normalized in this city. This affects our community's mental health and safety tremendously. PROTESTS THAT ARE NOT PEACEFUL: I was also in the Café Landwer in Downtown Toronto when a Pro-Palestinian rally stopped in front of the Café and started yelling at people inside it. Everybody was terrified and traumatized for weeks after. Most of the protesters were wearing masks, just like Ku-Klux-Klan do, to terrify and intimidate people. Why are masked protesters allowed? Why are protesters allowed to terrorize businesses and their attendees without any punishment? VERBAL ABUSE: In June 2024, I attended a peaceful event in downtown Toronto for the Israeli hostages. As I was at the back of the event, I saw the Pro-Palestinian protesters exchanging wording with the Pro-Israel attendees. I saw a man from the Pro-Palestinian side harassing little Jewish kids, telling them that their parents were pigs and murderers. Why is such blatant harassment of Jews permitted? As a Jew, I'm afraid to go to downtown Toronto. I'm afraid to walk in my own neighborhood, showing my Jewish identity as little as wearing a Star of David. I'm afraid to go to work. I feel we are in a new pre-Holocaust period, just like 1930's in Germany. Thank you for the opportunity to speak up. - Sharon Green (Potomac Construction Ltd.)
- Glynn Perkins
I am becoming increasingly concerned about the number of protests that are being held in the city that disrupt traffic and my right, and that of other residents to move freely and unhindered in Toronto. I appreciate and accept peaceful rallies that are planned in advance, have police escort and are contained to one lane of roadway. What is becoming Increasingly frustrating are the groups of people who consider it okay to block major roadways on a whim.
Most recently, August 6, 2024 at 7:30 in the morning, People are trying to get to work. Driving in Toronto is bad enough and then this protest. The demonstration began shortly after 7:30 a.m. on the Gardiner Expressway at Jarvis Street, police said. It is unclear what the demonstration was for.
Approximately 40 people gathered on a highway entry ramp, blocking traffic and causing multiple road closures.
One warning should have been issued to these demonstrators, clear off from this road or you will be arrested.
This whole situation is getting out of hand. Local politicians and law enforcement officials need to recognize this will only get worse and become a much bigger problem. - Rena Neufeld
To Whom It May Concern:
I would like to submit the following concerns regarding the dramatic rise in antisemitic and anti-Israel protests in the streets of Toronto since october 7th. As a Jewish person, I have never felt as unsafe and unprotected in my city as I have in the past ten months. The protests across the city have been in support of terror, by incorporating hateful and jihadist slogans such as "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free" or chanting antifada, which essentially is a call for violence against Jews and support of wiping Israel off the map. Protests which applaud violence and celebrate a massacre of my people, have no place in Toronto and should not be tolerated. I request, respectfully, that police do not allow protests to occur near our institutions (namely our Synagogues and Jewish schools) as they are threatening to our safety. They should not be taking place in residential neighbourhoods in Jewish areas and support of terrorist organizations and slogans cannot be tolerated. Thank you in advance for your support and for all your efforts to ensure the safety of the Jewish community. - Robert Szasz
Everyone regardless of their religion has the right to live in peace in this country. Hate speech during protests,demonstrations, encampments must be stopped and punished. Hate actions against persons and businesses must be stopped and punished.Residential neighborhoods , schools, religious institutions, etc must be kept free from harassment and hate.
- Alison Kuchinsky
Protests, demonstrations and occupations have been allowed to proceed in Toronto in a threatening and dangerous manner. While people have the right to peacefully protest, these gatherings have allowed people to engage in violence and hate with a sense of anonymity. In order to maintain safety and the rule of law, these gatherings should only be allowed to continue if they do note promote violence or hate. Police officers should be instructed to arrest and remove anyone who promotes violence or hate at these gatherings. It should not just be about keeping the peace at the even, but also preventing the incitement of violence and hate at the events.
- Gord Fogel (Private citizen)
To: Toronto Police Service Board Re: Public Order Policy Consultation
The Toronto Police Services Board has launched a consultation on public order, soliciting members of the public to share views on important elements they would like to see in the new Public Order Policy and suggest priorities for the Board to establish for the Service and the Chief in this area.
I am concerned about the protests, demonstrations, and occupations that have taken over our streets, targeted our religious institutions, and invaded our campuses. In my view the new Public Order Policy must correct a troubling trend that sees Toronto police losing control of our streets and public places to specific sets of protesters, agitators, occupiers and aggressors. As example: 㤼㸵 A group of 40 protesters formed a blockade of moving traffic on an on-ramp of the Gardiner Expressway, clearly breaking the law on a main thoroughfare. No protesters were charged although Police arrested one motorist who collided with protesters when his way was impeded and he was threatened. 㤼㸵 Hundreds of protesters took to the streets to lament the death of Hamas terrorist leader Ismail Haniyeh. They blocked one of Toronto's busiest intersections, with no permit, chanting hateful messages and burning Israeli flags. Instead of disbursing the illegal demonstration, Police arrested New Brunswick MLA Dominic Cardy for chanting a contrarian view. This after he had already been physically assaulted with protesters kicking him.
Public order is being compromised in the name of 㤼㸱tolerance'. Protesters and the groups that are bankrolling these actions know that Toronto doesn't yet possess the political, judicial and policing will to take control of our streets. The lion's share of hate is being directed at Toronto's Jewish community. Eighty per cent of hate crimes targeting a religion are anti-Jewish occurrences (ref. 2023 TPS Hate Crimes Report). Any updates to Public Order Policy must direct Police and courts to hold unruly and illegal protesters accountable for their actions. Further, groups who are subsidizing these disruptions must be held to account.
I look forward to hearing progress as the city grapples with a new reality. Thank you for inviting input. - Erica Colin
Protests have occurred at the Sheppard and Bathurst intersection every Sunday for the past few months. These protests are happening in a residential community surrounded by many buildings. These protests last several hours and cause immense noise disturbance. While these protests preach peace, they cause noise disturbance in an area with many residents who already know about or are affected by the issues this group intends to spread awareness about. While there seemed to be police patrolling this area for a while, I cannot understand how this is being allowed to continue. Sunday is typically a day of rest for many people and is sometimes the only day off that residents have to spend with family. I understand everyone has a right to freedom of expression, but this expression is more harmful than helpful. If anything, I believe the police should redirect these protesters to city hall or to a space where their protests will have actual impact and will not have adverse effects, disturbing a peaceful, quiet community that is already experiencing trauma and hardship due to the issues in Israel.
- NAVA JAKUBOVICZ (PRIVATE CITIZEN)
- Edward (Ted) Perlmutter (Edward Perlmutter Professional Corp.)
I think it's become clear that the "Pro-Palestinian" protests are mainly pro-Hamas pro-Iranian protests against the interests of Canadians and the democratic West in particular – Iran expressly and repeatedly has called for the annihilation of Israel, meaning the killing of all Israelis, including the 20% who are Arab Muslims, and recently tried to commit a killing with their 300-missile attach on Israel. Hamas has vowed to repeat its Oct 7, 2023 mass-killing again and again. In this context, it's horrific to see these protesters try repeated to shut down or disrupt activities and ordinary like in Toronto (mobs at a hospital, blocking roads etc.) and to terrorize Jews in Israel (fires at Jewish schools and synagogues). It seems to me and many others in the Jewish community that the police prioritize vainly attempting to escalate and deference to the protesters. However, this only encourages greater outrages by the mobs, who only see weakness and lack of resolve and, frankly, that the police are afraid to really confront the police. The mob is emboldened to keep ratcheting up their attacks and intimidation, thinking, understandably, they can do so with impunity. Why don't police immediately remove those who block roads and commit other illegal acts? Instead we see them protecting and giving space to the Jew-hating, pro-Hamas pro-Iranian, protestors (even passing along coffee). If the protestors were non-Muslims screaming for the killing of Muslims instead of Jews, I imagine that the police would quickly deplore, remove and charge them. In Toronto, as elsewhere, we should be doing all we can to protect those being attacked and threatened. In particular, Jews should be safe and feel safe from Islamist threats and intimidation. The police command posts are a start and the Jewish community appreciates them. But much more needs to be done, starting with the police issuing forceful statements and arresting, charging and prosecuting those who break the law (e.g., hate speech, blocking roads, masking in mobs). Law-breaking is not protected by by free-speech.
- Difat Jakubovicz
- Ruth Benaim
I am writing to you as a concerned citizen regarding the activities of Samidoun Palestinian Prisoner Solidarity Network and the urgent need to designate this organization as a terrorist entity under Canadian law.
Recent evidence has come to light indicating that Samidoun is using the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) manifesto to train individuals in Toronto on July 17th, 2024. This training aligns with the PFLP's known terrorist activities and objectives, posing a direct threat to public safety and national security.
Furthermore, the leader of Samidoun, Charlotte Kates, has been arrested for hate speech. The organization not only funds encampments and rallies where hate speech is prevalent, but also openly advocates for violence. Their chants of "Long Live October 7th" and "By Any Means Necessary" are clear endorsements of violent actions and incitement to terrorism.
Given these alarming developments, it is imperative that the Canadian government takes immediate action to protect its citizens and uphold the values of peace and security. Designating Samidoun as a terrorist entity would send a strong message that Canada will not tolerate organizations that promote hate, violence, and terrorism.
I implore you to do the right thing by taking decisive action against Samidoun. Our nation's security and the safety of our communities depend on it.
Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter.
Sincerely,
Ruth Benaim - Penina Honig
Masks must be illegal at demonstrations. The public has a right to see who is demonstrating. Blocking entrances of public buildings, places of worship, community centres or schools must be illegal if it isn't already. It should be illegal for protesters to harass in ANY way people entering or exiting said establishments. It should be illegal to block any roads, streets, intersections, sidewalks, etc. Police should enforce the laws. NO EXCEPTIONS!
- Michele Aitken
Peacefull, public demonstration or assembly is fine, but it must not impede other citizens in any way from going about their normal business of make them feel unsafe. Other citizens have a right to continue with their lives too. Maybe we should have designated areas where demonstrations are permitted and the groups have to apply and pay for the use of the location.
- Behnaz
Download file
Ok. No problem with public revord - Stephanie Niesner
I have personally witnessed police instigate violence at many public demonstrations that I have attended. I have seen police officers act in ways that are unlawful and violent when they are seeking private information or they are called to attend to a crisis. I do not trust the judgement of police officers, and as a community member and a community mental health worker, I do not want police officers attending public rallies or mental health crises.
- Les Kottler
I've added a few sentences and fixed some typos from my earlier submission.
The "constitutional rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly of all people..." is not a "complex and delicate challenge" as you assert. Peaceful protest and freedom of expression are one thing - making hate-filled statements, blocking people going about their business through intimidation and physical harrassment, occupying premises illegally, or beating up people, are quite another. It doesn't take the exercise of too much brain power to understand that these actions are breaches of the law. Calling for the genocide of Jews and the eradication of Israel ("From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free" or "Intifada revolution is the solution" (referencing thousands of Israeli Jews who were killed in uprisings)) is not free speech but hate speech - a breach of the law. At the very least, it's incitement against an identifiable group - another breach of the law. Supporting proscribed organizations by displaying support signs and waving their flags is not free speech - it's a breach of the law. TPS would not find similar actions against people of colour; Muslims or members of any religion other than Jews; Indigenous or members of the LGBTQ+ communities, to be "a complex and delicate challenge." The TPS would, in all these cases, invoke the full force of the law against perpetrators targeting any of these groups - and rightly so. But somehow, when it comes to the persecution of members of the Jewish and pro-Israel community by pro-Palestinian "activists" and supporters, taking action in the enforcement of the law becomes "complex and delicate." These perpetrators of vile, hateful and antisemitic rhetoric can block our streets, prevent Jewish university students from attending classes (that they've paid for), block entrances to synagogues, threaten and intimidate, disrupt cultural events, wave Hamas, Hizbollah and even ISIS flags, and get away with it. None of this is, by the remotest stretch of the imagination, either free speech or peaceful assembly. Only physical damage to Jewish property seems to invoke a serious TPS response. Why is TPS's response to all the other breaches of the law mentioned above, so muted? It's not "complex and delicate" - the laws of all levels of government - municipal, provincial and federal - are already on the books. Use them to the fullest extent possible against whomever breaks the law - and that includes the supporters of Hamas' October 7 genocidal barbarity. - Les Kottler
The "constitutional rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly of all people..." is not a "complex and delicate challenge" as you assert. Peaceful protest and freedom of expression is one thing - making hateful statements, blocking people going about their business through intimidation and physical harrassment, occupying premises illegally, or beating up people, are quite another. It doesn't take the exercise of too much brain power to understand that these actions are breaches of the law. Supporting proscribed organizations by displaying support signs and waving their flags is not free speech - it's a breach of the law. TPS would not find the actions against people of colour, Muslims or members of any other religion except Jews, Indigenous or members of the LGBTQ+ communities, to be "a complex and delicate challenge." The TPS would, in all these cases, invoke the full force of the law against perpetrators targeting any of these groups - and rightfully so. But somehow, when it comes to the persecution of members of the Jewish and pro-Israel community by the the pro-Palestinian "activists" and supporters, taking action in the enforcement of the law becomes "complex and delicate." These perpetrators of vile, hateful and antisemitic rhetoric can block our streets, prevent Jewish university students from attending classes (that they've paid for), block entrances to synagogues, threaten and intimidate, disrupt cultural events, wave Hamas, Hizbollah and even ISIS flags, and get away with it. None of this is, by the longest stretch of the imagination, either free speech or peaceful assembly. Only physical damage to Jewish property seems to invoke a serious TPS response. Why is TPS's response to all the other breaches of the law mentioned above, so muted? It's not "complex and delicate" - the laws of all levels of government - municipal, provincial and federal - are already on the books. Use them to the fullest extent possible against whomever breaks law - and that includes the supporters of Hamas' Oct. 7 barbarity.
- Laya Crust
The report that this year (2024), anti-semitism accounts for 45% of all hate-crime reports, is appalling. That 45% of hate crimes directed against 2% of the population is horrifying. The daily and weekly antisemitic rallies and taunts of the pro-Hamas demonstrators advertise hate against Jews (aka Zionists) and normalize the hatred. This is not "free" speech. It is hate speech. Burning the Israeli flag in public is allowed by the police. Calling for the destruction of Israel and genocide of Jews and Israelis (From the River to the Sea, etc) is ignored by the police and all levels of government. Canada's policy-makers and peacekeepers have accepted these hateful demonstrations for decades. They have normalized Jew-hatred and Israel-bashing. Stop the ugly, taunting, often violent rallies against Jews and Israel, and the hate-motivated crimes will subside.
- Mara Michalik (N/A)
- Sheila and Jack Kornblum
We are grateful for the work of law enforcement to keep our city and community safe. However, given the alarming rise of anti-Jewish hate crimes, we are calling for an immediate, strong, and sustained deployment of police in our Jewish community.
- Miriam Finkelstein (N/A)
Toronto Police should ensure that any protests are confined so that they do not restrict access to any public or private buildings, cannot be held on private property that does not belong to the protesting group, and cannot block sidewalks or any roads, railways, bridges, or subway lines. Protests should be restricted to areas large enough to accommodate the number of protesters while allowing other citizens to enjoy their own freedoms. Covering of the face while protesting should not be allowed, and any hate speech should be treated as the criminal action it is with immediate arrests.
- Sheryl Korn (None)
I am requesting increased vigilance and protection for the Jewish community as well as political leaders. Acts of vandalism, arson, antisemitism should be clearly unacceptable in our society.
- Sarit Nagy
I respectfully ask the police force to remove any individual from a peaceful demonstration if they are using hateful language, and any sign . Encampment, demonstration should not be allowed on any university property, so Jewish children shouldn't be afraid to go to school
- Shirley Slavens
Glorification of terror must be deemed a crime and absolutely not allowed. Free speech is not the same as terrorizing fellow citizens. For example, parades or vigils (like the one planned at York University to honour the slain head of Hamas) should NOT be alllowed in our streets! If we allow this to go on, we will end up like Europe with pockets where Islamist extremism has been allowed to fester and police cannot even enter those neighborhoods.
- Shirley Slavens
I am writing to you as a citizen of Toronto that is shocked at what our city has become. A place that is soft on terror and allows the glorification of groups like Hamas, Hezbollah, ISIS, etc. to parade on the streets without seemingly any consequences. Just yesterday the news of suspected ISIS operatives right under our nose was shocking, yet not shocking at all. The Prime Minister, Premier of Ontario and Mayor of Toronto have not been vocal enough in squashing hate the moment it rears its ugly head. Our Western values and morals and way of life are at stake. We only have to look at pockets of Europe to see what happens when Islamic extremism runs unchecked.
The Toronto Police and Chief Demkiw have been amazing. But they can only do so much with limited resources. Additional funding to ensure all communities and the Jewish community in particular have increased police presence and surveillance is a must. The type of security implemented at the Walk for Israel was a stellar example of what is required.
I urge you to immediately hold a press conference with the Prime Minister and Mayor to announce that any and all glorification of terrorism, whether online or in the streets, will be illegal, deemed a criminal offense and a cause for immediate arrest and passport revocation. Freedom of speech does not equate to terrorizing fellow Canadians.
I look forward to your immediate action and response to my email.
Regards, Shirley Slavens Concerned Citizen - Nathan Elias
Re: The Boards Public Order Policy;
While the right to peaceful protest is paramount to a thriving democracy, the notion that an ongoing 'encampment' qualifies as a protest is a perversion of that right especially when it tramples on the rights of others. We as a society tolerate protests because they meet specific criteria: 1) they raise awareness to a cause 2) they are inclusive and peaceful 3) they do not proliferate hate 4) they don't denigrate the rights of others 5) they have an end date/time
The campus encampment movement does not adhere to that criteria. They discriminated against who could have access to the space they occupied (denial of equal use of space). They acted as a focal point for both public and closeted anti-Semitism. They disrupted the peace of public space. They denied the property rights of the organization that designates the space as public. They operated with no good faith intention of ever ending their occupation.
The failure of TPS to intercede and stop this occupation movement after the university administration requested further emboldened their movement and forced a legal process that should have been unnecessary. The failure of the TPS to act has left some of the Jewish community in Toronto disenfranchised with the TPS and their selectiveness in enforcing the law especially with respect to protections for the Jewish community in Toronto.
People informed police of the proliferation of hate speech in those encampments and provided photo evidence and oral statements. The inaction of TPS to respond was harmful to the complainants. - Mitchell Shnier (Temple Sinai Congregation of Toronto)
- Rena Zayit
Dear Member of the Toronto Police Board, Before I make my suggestion as to how the Toronto police can better deal with the violent protests that have been plaguing our city, I would like to commend Police Chief Myron Demkiw and the entire Toronto police force for how they have handled the protests and protected Toronto citizens. I suggest a plan of action that would make the police force's work much easier. Mayor of Vaughn Stephen Del Duca. Mayor Del Duca and his board have passed a bylaw that prohibits unpeaceful demonstrations within 100 metres of businesses, hospitals, schools and places of worship with a maximum fine of $100, 000 if this is breached. I have suggested this to Mayor Chow but she is not listening. She didn't even respond to my letter. But if the Toronto Police Board strongly recommends such an action, I'm sure she will be swayed. You might want to remind her that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Thank you for encouraging Toronto citizens to make their input. Rena Zayit Toronto
- Michelle Factor
is long overdue that public order policies are revised to reflect the current state of affairs in Toronto. We live in a highly charged and volatile political environment, and a strong, reliable police service is more critical than ever. They are instrumental for enforcing laws with respect to protests, marches, and demonstrations, and acting as a deterrent for those who wish to engage in criminal behavior under the guise of "freedom of speech." Since October 2023, the Toronto Police have faced a difficult and unenvious position of managing large and overly aggressive demonstrations on a weekly basis 㤼㸶 an unprecedented situation that has consumed vast police resources. At the same time, there were several incidents where police inaction contributed to a perceived climate of impunity where many protestors 㤼㸶 some of whom openly claimed sympathy with terrorist organizations 㤼㸶 were able to exceed the limits of free speech and expression. Two moments come to mind: first, the police inaction when a member of a pro-Palestine protest uttered a death threat to an officer at Yorkdale mall in January 2024. The second was the time a TPS officer delivered coffee to protestors who had occupied a public bridge 㤼㸶 posing a safety risk to drivers on the highway below. These incidents were widely publicized on social media and contributed to a perceived weakness on the part of the TPS. These incidents only served to further embolden those in a movement whose mantra is to carry-out change through violence ("globalize the intifada.") These two stories should create a moment of pause and deep reflection by our police service, and how the perception of weakness can result in a deteriorating security situation in our city. Police officers should never feel afraid to act or enforce laws, and politicians and other leaders should support the TPS in this respect. Being nice, or at least too nice, can be detrimental to security and send the wrong message. These lessons should inform the proposed revisions to the Community Safety and Policing Act. Successful cities have a common feature: a strong, united, and supported police force. We all know there are various local and global entities who are trying to "dismantle systems." These entities do not care for our way of life. They do not care for western liberal values. They are the ones who advocate for defunding or abolishing police forces. It is vital that we retain, augment, and further support our police to combat these nefarious entities, as they are often our last line of defense. Our way of life must be preserved, and that cannot be done with a weak police service. The Criminal Code of Canada defines hate speech as any speech that advocates, "genocide or public incitement of hatred against any identifiable group where such incitement is likely to lead to a breach of the peace." (Sec 318/319) Over the last several months these laws have been broken repeatedly without punishment. Protestors have brazenly called for the extermination of the State of Israel (identifiable group) through the mantra "From the river to the sea..." Freedom of expression is also not an inalienable and unlimited right. Section 2b in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms says that the right to free expression reaches the limit when it veers into violence, threats, or threats to safety. Freedom of expression expires when one hijacks public infrastructure like roads, bridges, and train stations (i.e. sit-ins). Furthermore, criminal acts such as trespassing, vandalism, and intimidation of public officials as has been demonstrated over the last several months also null and voids any claim to protest freedom. When protests veer into hate speech, criminal acts, or disrupt society in
major ways, they must be curtailed. The police are our frontline defense against those who wish to cause such disruption. This is a matter of immense importance. It is about maintaining security, safety, and sending a strong message of deterrence to those who wish to create havoc and instability in society. The message that they will face a swift and severe reckoning for their actions. Without a strong, resilient, and confident police force, our cohesion as a city will continue to disintegrate. Thank you - Deborah Colman
Toronto Police Service Board,
I am a proud Torontonian who has lived her whole life in our great city. Since October 10, 2023, and the Hamas massacre on innocent Israeli citizens at the Nova Music Festival, I have witnessed a significant rise in antisemitism across the globe, including Toronto; The times have been compared to the rise in antisemitism leading up to World War 11. The Jewish people have repeatedly pledged themselves to ensuring that the atrocities from the Holocaust never happen again. And never again is now!!
While I truly appreciate everything the police force is already doing and unfortunately, it's not enough. For the first time in my life, I feel unsafe to disclose my Jewish identify for fear of emotional and physical attacks and harm.
I implore you to identify and institute additional measures to protect our Jewish citizens and organizations during your 'public order policies' during your current policy review.
Thank you in advance for your attention to this critical matter.
Best, Deborah Colman - Hossein Renani
Overriding principals of policing are best informed by the role and objective of the police department, mainly to protect and serve the public and enforce the law. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms defines the most fundamental and sacred rights and freedoms that Canadians hold. Police departments must not only fully respect the freedoms of expression and assembly of demonstrators and ensure their safety but also investigate and punish infiltrators who disguise as demonstrators to cause chaos and criminal behavior and police officers who break the law by infringing on the fundamental freedoms of demonstrator, use excessive force against demonstrators, or obstruct/destroy the evidence/recording of their brutality against the demonstrators.
- Mark Grammer
It is imperative that the police maintain safety and order and don't allow special interest groups to break the law and create havoc. The city is facing too many issues with crime and disruptions to the law abiding citizens and we need a strong police force that has the support from the city council and the mayor.
- Maureen L (The 482 Collective)
I have a written statement with 3 questions:
1. Antisemitism manifests in very different ways than other forms of hatred, and has many unique stereotypes and prejudices. It is important for antistemitism to stand on its own㤼㸷apart from other hatred and discrimination. Every form of hatred deserves its own recognition and response. Addressing antisemitism separately allows for a more tailored plan of action. Using a unique lens to combat antisemitism does not preclude addressing other forms of discrimination. Is TPS willing to mention antisemitism on its own?
2. Up-to-date, robust training and education is a vital part of identifying and countering antisemitism. A thorough awareness of the continuously evolving language used against the Jewish people allows police to detect harmful rhetoric before it escalates into more serious actions such as vandalism, threats, and violence㤼㸷and makes it easier for officers to identify suspected hate speech in the moment. How much additional funding is TPS allocating towards updated training to better combat the current rise in antisemitism?
3. Since it is difficult and time consuming to prove that violent language or behaviour is a hate crime, officers can simply start from the position that it is a crime to threaten violence. At the recent Walk for Israel, with dozens of police officers standing between protesters and ourselves, there were multiple opportunities for police officers to arrest people based on Section 264.1(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada: uttering threats as a criminal offence in Ontario. This offence includes knowingly conveying, causing, or uttering a threat to cause death or bodily harm to a person, or to damage or destroy real or personal property. I understand the need to maintain the peace, however, not arresting them creates a permissive environment that escalates antisemitism. What is the reason that officers who witness "uttering death threats" would not make an arrest to protect the victim(s)? - Karen Lasky
I live in Vaughan and I have found the amount of TOronto protests and demonstrations in particular, Pro-Palestinian invasive out of control, disrupting neighbourhoods and traffic, allowed too often and costing ALL of us . These need stemming While the Police have done their best with management of these, The City of Toronto can learn from our Vaughan mayor who has taken a stand against such disruptions with a by law and serious fine. Take more action
- Sarah Spegel (None)
Please keep protests in front of government buildings only and not marching through cities causing civil disturbances and traffic issues.
- Joel Winter
I have participated in four street protests against the war in Gaza since last October. I found each protest to be well organized, friendly and peaceful. I think the police who were present did a good job of managing the traffic and otherwise maintaining a safe environment. I applaud their efforts. I also visited the Pro-Palestine encampment at U of T one afternoon. Again, I found the protesters to be friendly and peaceful. I did not notice a police presence.
I think public protests should be fully allowed in all areas of the city and not be curtailed by the wishes and whims of special interest groups, such as the pro-Israel lobby. This lobby also falsely accused the protesters, both on the street and at the encampment, of antisemitic speech, which was later proven to be unfounded. I think the police shouldn't constrict protesters due to baseless accusations such as these. They need to take their time and investigate fully, while consulting both sides equally before acting.
I fully support street protests as they are a legitimate way to express our free speech in our democratic society. I believe a police presence is necessary in order to provide safety. I fully support any protest encampments such as the one at UofT as a legitimate means for people to have their concerns met. They act as an effective vehicle to having the student's issues heard when other methods have failed. - Aviva Frenkel
The increase in ‘protests' over the past year that include the glorification of violence and support of recognized terrorist organizations has made Toronto a city that no longer feels safe for everyone. I'm asking that TPS better enforce rules about hate speech and incitement of violence. It appears that double standards are guiding the current approach ultimately helping to nurture an increase in antisemitic hate.
- Julie Starr
First I must thank the the Toronto Police for their excellent protection as a Canadian citizen of the Jewish faith. We have had many antisemetic incidents lately and each time the police serve justice. I am writing to voice my concern for the safety of the Canadian Jewish population. I'm 66 and have lived in Toronto all my life....Never having seen the amount of hate of recent.
I hope measures will be taken that free speech is not compromised but showing of hate and voilence against any one group is not ok.
thank you. - Cindy Seligman
Good evening. I am writing to express the importance of community safety that has been compromised as a result of the ongoing pro-Hamas/Palestinian protests in Toronto. I understand the importance of free speech, but what is taking place on the streets of our city is anything but peaceful or displays of free speech. The vitriol and hate that has taken over our city and the calling for Intifada (death to Jews) along with the lies and propaganda against the Jewish community is not only dangerous, but illegal and Un-Canadian. As a Jewish person living in Toronto both within the home or the minute you leave your home, there is a fear of being assaulted, accosted, or a fear for your life because these protestors have been allowed to spread their hate for the most part, without consequences. If these things were carried out towards any other ethnic or religious group, it would not be tolerated, but because it is Jews, we are on our own and we feel that this is totally out of control and dangerous. This is not the Canada I was born in and not the Canada that in the past embraced all faiths and religions. It is open season to attack Jews and I and many others including non-Jews can not understand why the police are not shutting down the blatant display of hate speech and threats to the Jewish community as a whole. This is true antisemitism and the laws that have been put in place to protect the citizens of Toronto are not being followed. The city is caving to the loud voices of which many are paid to demonstrate and spread hate against Jews and Israel. Please protect us and don't remain silent. The silence is deafening. These groups post their intentions online everyday, so why can't the police shut down these protests before they have a chance to scream their calls for death to Jews. We are afraid and suffering and yet these protests continue.
- Jonathan Usher
Keep the law, not the peace. Use the words Muslim or Islam when it should be used. Don't avoid it and don't give Muslims lighter treatment than Jews or Christians. respond when Muslims attack you. Don't bring illegal protestors coffee and don't show that you agree with them.
- Jason Adelman
- Deborah Gottesman
Here are some points I think are important to address, based on what I have witnessed, read about or heard from others about. 1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chants we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
Thank you for asking for the public's input. - Ariel Perez
Hello,
Our city has changed dramatically over the past two decades and I no longer feel that Toronto is safe. The policies that have been put in place clearly aren't effective, as they seem to restrict our police force rather than empower officers to maintain law and order, protect our neighborhoods, and keep citizens safe.
There is no question we need to put an end to violent protests, demonstrations, and occupations. We don't need to accommodate a fringe but loud minority of activists intent on disrupting our society. There should be zero tolerance for masked individuals threatening violence against citizens and police officers.
Let's get back to basics when it comes to the role of police. Maintaining law and order (tough on crime) and ensuring the safety of our citizens.
And please- stop handcuffing our police force- DEI initiatives don't work and should NEVER be a consideration when it comes to law and order. You only need to look at San Francisco to see what happens when communities go soft on crime and make excuses/accomodations for criminals.
Let's empower law enforcement instead. Torontonians and our police force deserve better. Thank you. - SR
The Police service is considered the professional service that is highly trained and focused on serving the publics need for safety and accountability. However, at times, that service contradicts expectation and is seen as upholding safety for some and causing great pain and insecurity for others leading to mistrust of the service. When it comes to 'policing protests' it's crucial for TPS to understand (and demonstrate that understanding) that the general public are angry. Angry at the way our 'leaders' are handling (or rather not doing anything) about the active genocide occurring. It's not about religion where some are conflating this conflict with, it's about the rights of a people who are not being respected and are being murdered everyday! TPS needs to understand that it's not just about ensuring our angry voices and tears don't result in violent acts (which is important to make sure doesn't happen), it goes deeper and holding spaces for people to meaningfully express their thoughts/feelings and have that collection go towards impacting a change in the decision-makers choices regarding Canada's relationship with powers that are inflicting immense pain and suffering to civilians. We are settlers on this land we call Canada and the original inhabitants are saying for decades the c/overt violence that Canadian lawmakers have inflicted on generations of Indigenous lives. Decades later we are in the era of reconciliation and compensation for the immeasurable pain, loss of life and erasure of cultural identity. Decades from now this will be the case also for the indigenous people of PA lestine. I would emplore TPS to handle the situation of protests with this wisdom of our own local experience of "our home on Native land" and recognize the powerful position TPS is in as protectors of the public - especially when (Im sure) a vast majority of the public don't want harm to anyone - just the stopping of killing people for real estate (regardless of what other reasons are being propogated by biased media channels) the vast majority of people see right through it! I know i cant speak for others, so ill say this Im angry ....angry that powers at hand think we will blindly believe them just because they repeat the lies they've been told despite disproven. I'm angry at the double standards for support for one country in a current war and ample aid sent but barely anything (despite begging from Canadian population) to send aid to civilians in an active genocide. I'm angry that the term 'self-defense' is used unequally.....there are so many reasons to list for my anger......during a protest this anger looks/sounds like shouting, screaming, crying, chanting it's not going to hurt anyone bc it's the opposite I'm hoping for.....for "leadership" to stop the hurting of civilians. I hope TPS will understand the reasons for this anger and find constructive ways for the public to channel it in a way that impacts change for the good. This is how I offer TPS to broaden their scope of "policing protests". This form is a great step in that direction and I look forward to seeing how this collection of thoughts will be utilized/analyzed/operationalized. Thank you.
- Daniel Tate
- Daniel Pearlstein
- Brandon
Hello. I would like to see a policy change when it comes to homeless people anywhere near public parks. It's a disgrace that my kids can not use parks because people are leaving drug paraphernalia and overdosing all day in these public places. It should be a criminal offence to sleep in a park that is paid for by tax payers.
- Wendy Woods
Download file 1
Download file 2
First, thank you for the TPS for doing so much to protect our community.
The rising level of antisemitism in Toronto is a real concern for our community. I also worry that this hate will expand to other groups because harassment and intimidation is becoming the norm and it is being tolerated. Let's be clear hate speech is not free speech.
I would like to see people chanting for violence "by any means necessary", "globalize the intifada" detained and/or arrested. When these statements are accepted and tolerated in our city, I believe acting out on these words isn't far away. You will see in the attached pictures that protesters are wearing green bands to represent their support and allegiance with Hamas and calling for "intifada until victory".
TPS needs to help uphold our democracy and fight against hate and calls for violence against the Jewish community. If we accept this, then what community will be next? - Eddie Pal (Seneca Polytechnic)
I believe in the right of free speech and the right to demonstrate. However, that right does not include the right to harass others, prevent others from performing daily tasks, destroy or damage property, or speak or post hateful messages. It also does not include the right to trespass and occupy private property. In my opinion, any breaches of the above, should result in automatic arrests.
- Jonathan Usher (retired)
suggestions: 1. police should be at rallies etc to arrest wrongdoers, not to keep the peace. 2. Any arrested person should, if found guilty, be subject to strict fines or penalties. No more slaps on the wrists. 3. The public should be invited to train with the police - either in self defence or other safety issues. 4. response times must be quicker and taken more seriously even if there is no major problems. 5. More police should walk the streets in areas subject to terrorism such as Jewish areas. 6. Police should enter mosques to ensure that there is no antiSemitism or other anti-Canadian stuff being taught there. 7. The police that I have seen at my synagogue have consistently been polite, friendly and helpful, as it should be.
- Elysse Goldman (None)
With the significant increase in antisemitism in Toronto, the Toronto Police needs to prioritize the protection of the Jewish community.
- Ellen Smith
Jewish community in Toronto has been under attack by Islamists and their supporters. More protection is needed. The perpetrators have no respect for Canadian values and are bringing hate. More needs to be done to recognize the difference between Free Speech and Hate Speech.
- Charles Cohen
The TPSB must take all measures necessary to enforce existing laws against Hate Speech, be more expedient in defining terminology that constitutes Hate Speech, and apply the full force of the TPS whenever and where ever it is found. The TPSB must adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism. This non-binding definition will support the decision-maklng process when encountering the myriad methods employed to dehumanize and denigrate the Jewish citizens of Toronto.
- Jessica Wainberg
Hi There,
I am writing re: my concerns with the obvious rise in antisemitic incidents. As a Jewish person, I am now constantly looking in all directions and just don't feel as safe prior to October 7th. The plethora of anti-Israel protests has exacerbated the fear and sadness so many of us now experience on a daily basis. The City Of Vaughan has shows its community that it supports a safe environment by taking the necessary steps to keep certain areas protest-free. Please follow suit and help restore faith in this city. - Heather schwartz
I am Canadian born and raised. My religion comes second. Since Oct7,2024 Canada fell short in upholding Canadian values. We discovered that anti Canadian entities had embedded itself into all areas of Canadian life. Their anti democratic voices were allowed in our streets. Very little was done to quell the movement that took hold of our country. Schools became venues of hate. Neighborhoods were terrorized. Places of worship were attacked. Graffiti sprung up everywhere. Suddenly it was okay for hostage posters to be removed. Our mayor failed to show up for us. Students who participated and on visas were not deported. People in positions of authority did not apply sanctions against staff and students alike. Our politicians stood with terrorists and wore garments associated with terrorism. Law enforcement stood by. Everyone passed the buck. I don't feel safe in the country. This country needs a reality check and there needs to be house cleaning of everyone in positions of authority who let things get so badly out of control. Anti Semitism is alive and well. The lessons of the past have not been learned. It is the new norm to hate Jews. We are all accountable for this, social media, mainstream news, union leaders, teachers, charitable organizations that fund hate, open borders. The list is long. Trust is very low. I hope that this is not an exercise in futility. Please remember, we don't attack mosques, businesses, turn away students from campuses, yell words of hate, call for bans of items from specific countries, terrorize communities. That isn't who we are. We don't block highways, march through neighborhoods.
- Gila
Please put an end to these hateful protests. We need more of these criminals arrested so that there is a strong deterrence. They get away with openly destroying property (my Sinai hospital) splashing fake blood and threatening Jewish people and coming into our neighborhoods for the sole purpose of trying to frighten us. We appreciate the police force so much and we are grateful for all the work you do, but we need to make our streets safe. We need the hateful people to pay for their actions and to know that those actions are not allowed in Canada.
- David Miadovnik
To whom it may concern,
I would like the Toronto Police to ensure that the protection of the Jewish community is placed as a priority agenda item. Ever since October 7, rates and cases of antisemitism have exploded in occurences, including here in Toronto. - Steve Gatineau
I grew up in Toronto and am a strong beleiver in the important work of the Toronto Police.
You guys need to make sure that me and my italian, jewish, and Ukrainian friends and neighbours are safe from criminals attacking us and our families.
I'm standing with my neighbours to say you need to do more to stop antisemitic crime and protect us all.
Without you Toronto is on a downward spiral.
Help us bring public order and safety back to all of us concerned citizens. - Etta Kaner (private citizen)
Dear Members of the Toronto Police Board, Before I make my suggestion as to how the Toronto police can better deal with the violent protests that have been plaguing our city, I would like to commend Police Chief Myron Demkiw and the entire Toronto police force on how they have been handling the protests and protecting Toronto citizens. I suggest a plan of action that would make the police force's work much easier. In short, follow in the footsteps of Mayor of Vaughn Stephen Del Duca. Mayor Del Duca and his board have passed a bylaw that prohibits unpeaceful demonstrations within 100 metres of businesses, hospitals, schools and places of worship with a maximum fine of $100, 000 if this is breached. I have suggested this to Mayor Chow but she is not listening. She didn't even respond to my letter. But if the Toronto Police Board strongly recommends such an action, I'm sure she will be swayed. You might want to remind her that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Thank you for encouraging Toronto citizens to have their input. Etta Kaner Toronto
- Davis Mirza (Teachers For Palestine)
Attention: Toronto Police Service Board Please accept my submission into the Official Record. When the police kettled and arrested pro-Palestinian demonstrators at a recent anti-war protest, it was sending out a message: Chief of Police Myron Demkiw was going to bully protesters into submission by stepping on their Constitutional rights to freedom of assembly, expression and political association. This is historical behaviour from Toronto's 'finest'.
When TPS led a raid on a Lesbian bathhouse in 2000 ("Pussy Palace") & current TPS Chief Myron Demkiw was directly involved in the raid in 2000, and on other raids on Queer spaces, and his subsequent attack on a City Councillor who spoke against these atrocious acts, Charter be damned - TPS become the moral crusaders of sexual expression. So when cops violently take down a disabled Palestinian protester and intentionally smash his hearing aid, how is this serving and protecting the community when TPS are now the moral crusaders of political expression?
And how is this community policing. The guiding principles of community policing policy are prevention, problem-solving, and partnerships. When the TPS & its Chief attack queers, women, pro-Palestinian demonstrators and the disabled, what message is it sending to the community?
Simple - TPS prevents Torontonians from expressing their Charter tights; TPS problem solves at the end of a billy club and jack boot and they partner with no one because they are not accountable to the community for their transgressions. The 3 P's of community policing don't optimize contact between patrol officers and community members but instills fear and distrust of police officers among marginalized members of the community because police can criminalize political dissent at any moment.
In the 21st Century, Chief Demkiw and TPS are still a whte-supremist, cis-gendered, authoritarian, structure of capitalist patriarchy with all its facets of social (and political) control still intact. TPS should be disbanded because they make our community unsafe and stoke fear in minority communities they can still bully and oppress.
Sure, sensitivity training might help derail internalized homophobia or Islamophobia within the force, but as a blunt force weapon of class warfare it will always side with the war profiteers and the developers of greed. For shame, because if the TPS was serious about institutional reform it would de-institutionalize the very components it holds sacred - structural authoritarian power.
So, instead of a Toronto Palestinian Community Policing Centre run by dispora police liasons or a Toronto Homeless Community Policing Initiative that hires the homeless to seek better address safety, housing and mental health supports to dismantle structural inequality, or even prepping the Toronto LGBTQ2S Police Marching Band for the next Pride parade, Torontonians just wait to find out where Chief Demkiw will strike next.
We held our breath when students occupied UT to protest the genocide in Gaza hoping the TPS would not bust youngsters heads. We hold out breathe when cops didn't arrest unionized LCBO workers who shut down LCBO stores to protest the privitization of public services and we continue to watch our backs when cyclists block Toronto streets to install another ghost bike over the recent death of a young female cyclist. The problem with the TPS and the police union is they pre-determine who their enemy (protesters, union members and cyclists) will be in order to weaponize their response to political dissent.
If this is how TPS continues to operate, they should be defunded. So, when police begin to protest the hiring of non-unionized security forces as part of the City's austerity measures, who will step up to defend the rights of public sector employess, like TPS workers, to fight against neo-liberal privitization? No one - because in the capitalist folly of dividing and conquering the working class, the TPS will continues to believe the billionaire class has their back, defending their interests even while the social safety net is pulled out from under them.
Maybe then, police officers will be mandated to attend Decolonizing Power Structures & Empowering Democracy 101. Until then, I guess I'll be waiting for Demkiw's boot to come through my front door! Thank you for your attention to this urgent police reform issue and I await your response. Davis Mirza -Teachers For Palestine https://www.facebook.com/p/Teachers-for-Palestine-100064710455255/ Dated: July 25th, 2024. - Vivian Riva
I am deeply disturbed to see the police budget so high once again and believe that part of that is due to the amount of time and money we have spent having them work keeping the peace with the Palestine protests. It's ridiculous that they have been permitted to protest again and again in places that intimidate, cause safety issues and disrupt the lives of the general population. Why hasn't Ford stepped up to ban such protests? They can protest at Queen's Park, enough already!!!
- Saul Levine
As a Jew in Canada, especially in Toronto…we all need the help of the authorities, especially the police department
- Barbara Okun
I would like to see the police maintain public order by considering the needs of the population as a whole, rather than considering the loudest voices who do not respect the values of civil behaviour. These groups seek to intimidate and obstruct everyday life in a city already crowded and affected by problems a large city often has. I would also like to see the police enforcing laws rather than dropping charges for vandalism and attacks on businesses by these groups. To a large extent, I think that the current guidelines for the police have become inadequate due to the police's concern about how activists may react. Enforcement should better reflect the needs of the law abiding citizen rather than the noisy mob. Investigating individuals who promote unlawful behaviour may also help to discourage this element from stepping over the line from organizing protest to criminal intent. Public spaces must remain safe for all, and these groups should not be allowed to take them over.
- Sean Gorman
I understand that there is a requirement that people at a demonstration not wear a mask. That requirement needs to be more vigorously enforced.
As well, too many TPS personnel have been assaulted in various ways. I do not know the rules of engagement when an assault is in progress. However, TPS personnel must still be given the benefit of the doubt when they are attacked. - Melody Ehrlich
Currently fearful in Canada as a Jew. Require the police to intervene quickly and charge aggressive people (verbal and physical) quickly. Too many are allowed to continue with horrible speech that is horrible and reminiscent of the Holocaust. By not acting, it gives others the belief that negative views of Jews are acceptable. Jews need protecting so there can be a feeling of safety for all in Canada.
- Lyla Jackson (Private citizen and Toronto homeowner)
Police must stop allowing protesters to block city streets. Not only is it disruptive to people who need to work and take children places, it is a way for the protestors to show strength and that they are in charge of our city. I have been terrified to go downtown to work for months and today I have to take my child to sickkids but I don't know if they are still blocking university Avenue outside the American embassy. It is terrifying to a Jewish woman to see these protesters dressed in costumes of people who, only a few months ago, murdered mothers like me in their homes in Israel while chanting death to the Jews and they are now chanting it on my home streets. But I don't ask police to get involved in the details, just arrest anyone blocking the street, especially those wearing a mask which is illegal. It is illegal to wear a mask to a protest. Arrest anyone doing that and show that we live in a country with the rule of law. Please save my city.
- Jenny h
When peaceful demonstration turns into racism and hate speech the police need to shut it down. Also when those demonstrations are paid for by 3rd party terrorist entities or countries that Canada doesn't have a relationship with because of their human rights records/policies.
- Michael Davidson (Member of Beth Tikvah Synagogue)
As you had decided to arrest people on the 401 / Avenue overpass, please continue to do this.
Continue further and eliminate and immediately stop any protest that is inciting hatred, demonizing and deligitimizing our jewish communities. Stop the gradual and eroding down of our established law and order in Toronto in the false pretense of "free speech".
We understand you need to do work on cases and are monitoring the situation(s), hatefest protests need to be stopped from the beginning and should be prevented from causing our Sinai Hospital from being taken hostage inside and outside by holigans. This must not be allowed to go on for days, weeks and months. This gives anarchists the freedom to do anything they want.
Soft policy and enforcement is allowing the glorification of violence on our city streets and we are becoming seen as third world disfunctional City that operates in KAOS.
The budget seems to be adequate from all levels of government but why cant we stop the 300% rise in crimes such as broken glass at our synagoges, the shootings at our schools and fake bomb threats that disrupt our childrens education. Attacks on our TTC Subways, Stabbings and shootings in our public spaces. Criminals brazenly walking into our Home Depot's and loading up shopping carts and walking out of the store without anyone brave enought to stop them requires our police and response times faster than civilians.
Crimes must be punished and freedom must also co-exist with our policing. As we have seen, if justice is not being served, the worst of society emerges.
Stop in they're tracks any peoples conducting support of listed Canadian Terrorist organizations. They dont belong in our country, provinces, or cities.
While i have mentioned many ideas above. Please also consider a monitor of your own staff and morale culture. The actions of officers on and off duty. Ensure that it remains an equal opportunity workplace. Have procedures to investigate complaints and resolve disputes to maintain a united force against those who wish to hijack the system to serve self interests. - Neil Orlowsky (Abraham Global Peace Initiative)
- Giuseppe Scoleri (Citizen)
The Toronto Police have been under attack by groups looking to use the right to protest as a way of committing acts of crime. There must be ZERO TOLERANCE for "protestors" who commit crimes such as physical and verbal assault, hurling human fecal matter, threatening others and conspiring to undermine civilized behaviour. Peaceful protests are one thing but the city of Toronto has become a breeding ground for awful hate, anti semitism, racism and general disorder under the guise of "protests". DO NOT ALLOW hate mongering criminals to undermine OUR safety and use protests as their disguise when in fact all they want to do is cause disorder and trouble.
- Harriet Wagman (Retired)
1. Enforce the laws- no masks etc
2 deal directly and swiftly with hate and threatening speech etc
3 . Immediately disband protests that impede traffic or are a danger to traffic ( avenue road401 bridge )
Do your job. This is a big ticket item in the City's budget. Totally disappointing. - Esther Cohen
I was born in Toronto 86 years ago to European Jewish parents. They came to Canada for safety from anti semites and never dreamed that we would suffer the blights again. Help to protect and eradicate the evil bigots, please.
- ron yosipovich
To whom it may concern,
I would like to reiterate the sentiments of many in our community. For many of us, our lives have been irrevocably changed due to the massive increase in antisemitism in our dear country.
My life has changed forever as a result of the events in March, when an angry mob formed just 50 meters from my house. Statements such as "We are coming for you," "You will be judged," "Jewish pigs," "Go back to Europe," "Intifada revolution," "From the river to the sea," and other hateful slurs were yelled at us as the police watched and did not hold those who uttered the slurs accountable.
In one instance, (we know it happens many times in these protests) a person with a kaffiyeh totally covering their face hit a police officer. The police officer was about to arrest the person, but after a quick call on his radio, he stopped the arrest. A week later, there was another rally in the heart of the Jewish community. These events have changed us forever. We used to believe that the government could protect us; now, we are not sure. We know from history and current events that it is just a matter of time before unchecked hateful speech and actions embolden bad actors to go further. Since hate knows no boundaries, many communities are affected by this breakdown of order.
Others have taken notice. This is anecdotal, but my friends from other communities are watching and see the lawlessness as a bad sign. It is not the first time I have heard my friends stating that they are considering other options. They are watching what will happen with a strong sense of unease. This is the silent majority which does not honk to support these illegal protests as they drive through the QEW with their license plates covered by flags, which I believe is illegal in itself.
We are all noticing the same thing: this mob has an agenda. They are very well-versed in the laws, as career criminals are. We see that officers are fearful of them because they do not like to be threatened legally for doing their job. We have seen in person and on video how these agitators are familiar with just how to speak with police officers and what the boundaries are of what they can and cannot do to push further to undermine the system. These are hardened criminals. A citizen should have a healthy fear and respect for the police. There should not be a breakdown in the authority of the police as is happening. We have laws to ensure that this order is maintained, but I do not really know where the enforcement of them is.
I would like to suggest that police officers be given assurances that the board will support them when enforcing the law. Filming a police officer and threatening them legally should not be allowed. Everyone knows that it is not okay to interfere with the police while they are doing their job of keeping everyone safe. It is time that those who have not integrated this viewpoint into their way of thinking/behaving be reminded that the law exists to ensure compliance and order.
I would also like to suggest that the board treat the police fairly. Uttering hateful slurs, hitting a police officer, and threatening police should never be allowed. I never dreamt that I would see such a disturbing situation where police are mistreated this way and are not allowed to punish such behavior. At my job, if I were threatened and hit, there would certainly be consequences to deter such behaviors. I think our police deserve more for the service and commitment they made to defend our country with their lives. To not do so is to insult them and tell them that a political agenda is more important than their selfless decision to protect and serve.
Sincerely, Ron Yosipovich - Miriam Greenberg
Thank you for the opportunity to share our thoughts here. My requests are based on reflections from the protest that took place on Clark Avenue across from the Beth Avraham Yosef Synagogue in March. This protest took place in the heart of my community. My 8 year old daughter's bus home had to be rerouted to avoid the hostile crowds. I intentionally avoided the area so as not to upset her but the shrieks and chants, calling essentially for the destruction of Israel and my people, could be heard well into my home, causing her extreme distress and anxiety. The chanting and shouting went well into the night, disrupting the entire residential neighbourhood, full of young children and families. The anti Israel protestors blocked access to the walkway to our street. This disruption and unrest was brought directly to our doorsteps, in a way that was aggressive, hostile and invasive. All protests should be banned from residential neighbourhoods, within a 5 km radius, including educational institutions and places of worship. All public access walkways should remain safe and open passageways to residential homes. This was not the case at this protest, as police allowed protesters to block access to pathways to our homes. The messages and diatribes of hatred that were spewed by the protestors were abhorrent and that reason alone should have been sufficient reason for police to shut down the anti Semitic hateful protests. As fourth generation Canadians, we know we can expect much more from our wonderful public service men and women and feel confident that measures will be instituted going forward to ensure that all residents feel safe and secure in their own homes and neighbourhoods.
- Susan Cameron
I was disappointed, and eventually disgusted by the handling of both the gathering on the 401 overpass, and the encampment at the University. I felt that the city and the police looked the other way, rather than deal appropriately. The encampment were non tax paying students, who did nothing but widen the dissension. And CP 24 interviewed the students constantly which continued to give it publicity. If students cared that much, then get a job and send their money to those who suffer and need it. I am totally disgusted in the lack of respect being shown to the tax paying residents, who while they may sympathize with one side or the other, they do nothing to upset anyone. Get the law makers to get down to business and give our laws some teeth!! We have gone from rigid to nothing in our laws. No wonder residents are bailing out of Toronto!
- Tania Lebenfish
- Richie Cowen
As Canadians who are also Jewish, it is not fair that we are being intimidated, harassed, impeded, threatened and assaulted here on Canadian soil. If those that want to hurt us feel such a necessity, let them go overseas where the actual battles are occurring and protest over there. Our protections are the priority. We are the victims. For the sake of our rights as Canadians to live in peace please enforce the laws and prosecute. If there is no fear of punishment then acts against Jewish Canadians will only increase.
- Michaela Sandu
Toronto is an ugly city right now. Antisemitism and anti-Muslim hate may be equal in abhorrence but unequal in scope. This is clear from TPS' own reporting of statistics that clearly demonstrate the alarming increase and escalation of Antisemitic violent hate crimes in Toronto. Palestinian and pro-hamas supporters have specifically targeted Jews and Jewish institutions with a goal to intimidate Jews at their places of worship, the communities they live in and the businesses they own or work at. The hypocrisy makes this especially egregious given such demonstrations would not be tolerated if they targeted Muslims, the LGBTQ community or people of colour.
Police inaction and lack of enforcement has simply emboldened the terror-supporting mobs that are inciting hatred and intimidating innocent Torontonians. We are AFRAID to take our children downtown, and in some cases, AFRAID to walk in our neighbourhoods for fear of coming into contact with mobs screaming into megaphones, waving designated-terrorist flags who yell obscene, vile, hateful things at us and our children. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH.
There are many existing federal, provincial and municipal laws that ARE NOT - but MUST BE - enforced. Based on the Criminal Code of Canada, what the mobs are doing is not "lawful" protest protected by a constitutional right, rather they are committing criminal acts that are hateful, violent, targeted, and well-organized. Torontonians want to see enforcement and prosecution, not more platitudes and virtue signaling.
Police should all be re-trained on the relevant sections of the Criminal Code (below) so they can consistently implement a set of protocols to SHUT DOWN the protests where hatred and/or violence are incited, peace is disturbed, or access to religious institutions or transportation infrastructure is blocked. It is fair if these mobs want to protest in front of City Hall or Queen's Park, but they should be arrested for doing so in residential neighbourhoods, on private property, blocking roads or TTC, or preventing public access to buildings etc.
Relevant Criminal Code sections:
- Blocking or obstructing a highway (Sec. 423(1)(g)) - Intimidation (Sec. 423(1)) - Causing a disturbance (Sec. 175) - Common nuisance (Sec. 180) - Interfering with transportation facilities (Sec. 248) - Breach of the peace or imminent breach (Sec. 31 - Riots (Sec. 32, 33, 64, 65, 67, 68, 69) - Unlawful assembly (Sec. 63) - Mischief (Sec. 430) - Wearing a mask while committing the above offences (Sec. 65(2)) - Shaalee So
The main principle should be consistent enforcement. Over the last year, there have been dozens of occurrences of "letting things slide". We have seen the damage this has done: people protesting feel free to escalate their actions. The logic is sound: the police did not stop me from this illegal act, so I will continue to escalate my actions and words.
There must be immediate, consistent enforcement. A protest with no protest permit? Immediately shut down. Hate speech calling for "zionists" to leave/be killed? Immediately arrested. We all know that zionists means Jews so stop ignoring the obvious. The hate speech at every protest is so clear but police pretend to be ignorant.
Downtown has become lawless. The police must show their strength in upholding the law and protecting citizens. Today, Jews are not welcome in Toronto and the police have let the loud mob show it. I hope that tomorrow Toronto will once again be safe for Jews. - Reuben James (Racad)
Public demonstrations in favor of Palestine or Gaza or Hamas have numbered in the hundreds since October 7th, 2023, and have been accompanied by an unprecedented number of hate motivated crimes. The people involved are becoming more and more brazen and shameless in their messaging and in their rhetoric. We cannot allow these activities to become normalized. There needs to be more severe consequences before this poisons more young people with their hate messaging and spirals out of control in property crimes, vandalism and assaults.
- Brenlee Robinson (I am a Toronto resident and Canadian Citizen)
As Canadians it is our democratic right to demonstrate, and to have the right to say we don't agree with an elected official if it is so. However, disagreeing with something does not mean blocking traffic, and occupying space without permission. We need to reclaim law and order in our city and in our country, and allow all vehicles and pedestrians to proceed as they wish, unmolested. Protests can take place on public property that are designed for such purpose, such as Queens park, or any of the large public squares. Occasionally people with a cause want to march from one point to another. They need police permission to do so, and should do so without threatening passersby. There must be consequences to the individual and to the group if the terms of the permit are broken.
- Joel scoler
In every society, people the right of protest yup
- Ellen Dayan (Momentum Canada)
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Joe
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence. - Juliana Mariane Appel
Enough is enough. This has to be stopped.
- Wilfred (Freddy) & Donna Lindo
All protests should be peaceful, legal not threatening. Once that line is crossed, protesters should be arrested and charged. We saw what happened recently, give an inch and they tale a mile.
- Anne-Marie Longpre (TDSB)
I feel very strongly that peaceful protests should not be criminalized in any way. They should be protected. The ongoing policing and harassment of pro-Palestinian activists has been shocking to witness. Claims of feeling unsafe are not claims of actual harm or danger, and should not be taken as such. Furthermore, no matter the public pressure, claims of antisemitism should not be taken more seriously than any other form of discrimination. All people in Toronto deserve to be safe and make their voices heard.
- Danielle
My family don't feel safe with all the Palestinian protests going on around the city. Please make toronto safe for openly Jewish torontonians.
- James Smith
- David Dulberg (Individual)
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services to improve their service to the community, particularly in recognizing and addressing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech, and reinforcing policies.
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups. 8. Flags & support for terrorist organizations should lead to arrest 9. Targeting daycares, religious institutions, community centres, schools or locations of specific ethnic groups should not be tolerated. 10. Hate speech, signs containing hate speech or calls to violence, or physical violence should lead to arrest.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Ana Belinda Schneeweiss (individual community member)
First of all, a huge thank you to each and every police officer who has worked tirelessly since October 7 to maintain the peace, de-escalate situations and ensure the jewish community (and their peace-loving friends) have felt supported.
Thanks for looking to the public for their opinion. While peaceful and respectful protests should always be welcome, there must be a distinction between that and activities that promote hate, call for the elimination of a nation and attempt to disrupt the western/democratic way of life by twisting the vocabulary and regulations that guide us to subvert the truth.
Here are some recommendations to consider
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
Again, thanks for your incredible support to date in keeping peaceful communities protected! - Jackie N
1. Anyone waving flag, posters or chanting any calls for violence or anti-Semitic hateful speech should be arrested immediately.
2.prohibit targeting locations at religious centres, schools, hospitals
3. Prohibit use of masks
4. Prohibit protestors ability to stop rightful access to areas (e.g, protesters stopping students from accessing libraries, going into businesses etc.)
5. Arrest after vandalism occurs
6. Most importantly make these people abide by the law and ensure PEACEFUL acts are only allowed. No tolerance or exceptions - Helene Zonana (Personal)
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services to improve their service to the community, particularly in recognizing and addressing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech, and reinforcing policies.
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Yonit
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Rachel Naim
Here's what I entered if anyone doesn't have the time and wants to copy / paste: Protests should not be allowed to take place in the immediate vicinity of daycares, religious institutions, schools, community centres, or locations that target a specific ethnic group.
Signs or flags containing hate speech or support for terrorist organizations should lead to arrest.
Using hate speech, calls to violence, or physical violence should lead to arrest.
The protests should not be exempt from the law. - Ella Burakowski
I don't recognize this city I grew up in. The hateful demonstrations from masked foreigners spewing calls for genocide against Israelis and Jews is not only frightening and intimidating, it's illegal. This is not free speech, this is a call for violence and murder. How can our TPS stand by and allow this? Our police are amazing and always have been. I've lived in Toronto since 1959. Never have I hesitated to head downtown for a play or shopping, never have I been afraid to walk the streets wearing my Star of David necklace. Now, I live in fear in MY CITY! I'm all for diversity, it's what created a wonderful city. But these pro Palestinian gangs have taken over and turned my home town into a fearful, hateful, intimidating place for Jewish people. Both my parents survived the Holocaust. Canada was an amazing refuge where these two hard working people were able to rebuild their lives. I'm glad they are not here to witness what our politicians have done to this country. I beg you, our amazing Toronto Police to do anything you can to restore our loving city. How are these people allowed to protest spewing hate and threats while wearing masks? How about we start there.
- Jim Martinelli
- Emmanuel Pressman (Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP)
Protests, large gatherings, and demonstrations must be restricted to public spaces and only with proper permits. It is illegal, chaotic, negligent, disruptive, and antithetical to social order, public life, and civil discourse to tolerate or allow such protestations and gatherings in streets designed for vehicular traffic (including emergency vehicles), residential neighborhoods (where there is an expectation of quiet enjoyment and privacy), and within privately owned buildings including commercial, office, industrial, and residential buildings. The police have the power and authority to make arrests and prevent this conduct.
Protests and demonstrations that single out and threaten to harm or intimidate, or impede access by, Jews, Christians, or Muslims, among other identifiable groups, must be stopped and arrests made. Anti-religious hate such as displays of swastikas must be stopped and arrests made. - Sarit
I believe in the right to free speech…but there should be time, place and manner restrictions. These should occur at queens park, or in places where they don't disturb citizens and businesses or hospitals and essential workers.
- Daphne Pressman (Yalla)
There is an alarming rise in antisemitism seen in public demonstrations. Swastikas, threats, harassments have created "no-go zones" for Jewish residents. There is an immediate and dire need for community safety and security. The rights of the protesters cannot overrule the rights of every other citizen.
Demonstrations without permits must be shut down immediately. Demonstrators cannot occupy streets and prevent other citizens from accessing those public streets.
There has to be mandatory enhanced officer and cadet training on antisemitism/hate crimes and a request for Community Liaison Officers to work with organizations like CIJA to address concerns in a timely manner. - David John Mansell (Private citizen)
I write as a concerned private citizen who feels increasingly unsafe over the past five years, due to (i) a general increase in crime where I live, (ii) an increase in gun related crime, including home invasions and armed car jacking on my street within the past 6 months, and (iii) significant intimidation and hate-related targeting of the broader Toronto Jewish community. The suggestions below were shared with my by a friend (with some of my own edits) and I strongly endorse them.
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chants we are hearing at protests are often calls for genocide or murder 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. For example, the chart "globalize the intifada" refers to a campaign that resulted in the intentional murder of over 1,000 Israeli civilians at restaurants, hotels and busses through suicide bombings, stabbings and car ramming. Calling to globalize the intifada means, at least to me, to bring those same tactics to Canada. 2. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. The laws are on the books, they just need to be enforced. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors. When masks are increasingly used to disguise law breakers, it is a reasonable view to take that masks are not permitted at public protests. 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. One good example where this was not enforced was the intentional blockading of Mt. Sinai Hospital. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
Thank you - Sukhi
No masks, register for any protests, any affiliation at a protest funded by terror leads to file as terror supporter. required training program for actual history related to events.
- Jenny G
Violent protests and hate speech should be dealt according to the law with no compromises Jews should not feel terrified going to places of worship, Jewish stores or sending their children to Jewish schools
- Tanya B
- David Clinton (www.TheAudit.ca)
I very much appreciate the rights of all citizens to protest and even to loudly express ideas I find offensive. And, while I don't support protests that break any criminal or civil laws, I appreciate that police services will sometimes need to tolerate limited illegal activity to avoid dangerous escalations. But there should nevertheless be limits. For one thing, the normal functioning of civil society should never be disrupted. That means all Toronto residents have the right to expect no more than the usual (awful) delays to their commutes and the ability to peacefully go through their daily lives. That includes the ability to travel through any public areas without needing to worry whether they'll be violently accosted, blocked, or even harmed. This is a freedom that, as a Jew, I don't feel I've always had over most of the past year. There should be no ambiguity in Police Services communications on what the law permits. If, for example, individuals threaten violence against identifiable targets with police officers present, the Service should - at an appropriate time - clearly and publicly communicate their disapproval of those threats. That way, strategic stand-downs won't be mistaken for approval and threatened communities won't feel completely unprotected. This has, for the most part, not been the case so far.
- Schwartz Gwynne (Gwynne Schwartz Medicine Professional Corporation)
Peaceful protest is part of our democracy. It should be in public place like city hall or park.
Disrupting bridges, putting tents in the middle of universities, Blocking residential and commercial streets, climbing on hospitals is NOT. Harrassing Jews at synagogues is NOT. Hate speech should result in charges. "Death to Jews" Unaccceptible. Cheering when Jews are slaughtered. Unacceptable Shouting "From the river to the sea" Unacceptable.
Hate speech is not free speech. There is a difference. - Abe Gottesman (SSCM)
While I am all for free speech and the right to demonstrate, hate speech and virulent anti-Semitism should not be allowed and those who do such things should be arrested and deported in some cases.
- richard menich
The behaviour of Toronto police during the occupation of the avenue road overpass was reprehensible. The visual distraction and dropping of debris onto a public highway threatened the safety of every motorist using that road. Worse was delivering coffee to a bunch of hate mongers, and apparently little to no discipline for the officer who thought it was a good idea for police to take sides. There are plenty of places to protest (legislature, city hall) but the occupation of public lands and universities to use as sites for hate-mongering and intimidation was unacceptable. Yet nothing was done. Public confidence was greatly eroded by this and the police must bear responsibility. Yes, you can do damage control and set up command posts in affected neighbourhoods, but the inaction right from the start was truly a low point for the Toronto police service. Being biased in favour of the "rights" of people to foster hatred and intimidation and supporting them with coffee was completely unacceptable. The police failed miserably and there needs to be more accountability and consequences for police when they don't enforce the law! Absolutely appalling!
- Noam Samson
- Karen Gold
Public Order Policy Submission July 19, 2024 Toronto Police Service Board, Thank you for providing the community with an opportunity to share our voice in the consideration of new policy regarding public demonstrations. The Toronto Jewish community values our relationship with the police and appreciates their invaluable services in protecting our community. Regarding future policy, any public demonstrations should be prohibited within a block radius (or more) of any designated house of worship or religiously affiliated facility like a school or community center. Demonstrations taking place at our places of worship and community infrastructure are a direct form of antisemitism and antagonism. In addition, any demonstrations that block public access to roads or infrastructure should be immediately deemed illegal and dispersed to allow for the flow of traffic and freedom of movement. Aggressive, inciteful language should be categorized as hate speech and penalized. Specifically, this includes calls for "intifada, jihad, death to Zionists, death to (any specified group) or any other forms of violence in different languages. Pandering to creative interpretations of clearly violent language emboldens protesters who seek to disturb the peace and inflict intimidation on our peaceful community. Thank you again for allowing us to share our concerns with the Police Service and we continue to appreciate the important services provided. Sincerely, Karen Gold
- Chanani Kleinman
Dear TPS Board, Thank you for your commitment to ensuring safety for our community members. At this critical time, when acts of violence and calls for violence are rampant against members of the Jewish community, I urge you to double your efforts to ensure that the right of safety for law-abiding, community-promoting citizens, is preserved.
- Jonathan Jaffit (Private Citizen)
Please keep anti-Israel protesters a safe distance from Jewish houses of worship, schools and community centres etc.
- Ela Kadish
The city is becoming unsafe because of violent support for terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah. Jews and peaceful Canadians no longer feel safe.
"From the river to the sea" and calling for "intifada" are both hate speech against recognized minorities and are calls for violence and murder which are explicitly prohibited under the Canadian Criminal Code as well as hate speech legislation.
We support the police but we need the police to do their job and arrest criminals and keep our country safe愼㸰for愼㸰Canadians. - Heather Ringel
Please allow protests only in designated legal areas. "Freedom of Speech " doesn't give protesters the right to break other laws - obstructing traffic, threatening and intimidating Jewish residents and freedom of movement. Please arrest those whose protests interfere with and impede the ability of Toronto residents to live peacefully.
- Amir Fleischmann
The priority for police should be protecting people's charter rights to protest. I've seen police arrest people at protests who weren't doing anything wrong. I've seen police obstruct protest routes for no reason. This needs to stop.
The Palestine protests have been peaceful. I am Jewish and have never been made unsafe by them. The only times I've felt unsafe at a protest has been from threatening language I've heard from TPS officers (one said to someone near me, "I'd arrest you if there werent so many people around" - essentially saying he's only following the law because there are witnesses) and by Zionist counter-protestors. I've seen Zionist counter protesters assault peaceful Palestinian protestors in full sight of TPS officers who did nothing to stop the violence.
We need TPS to protect our charter rights and to be honest with the public that these protests do not threaten anyone. - Adva Budin-Mercer
Protests should be designated to specific zones. They should never take place in front of places of warships, healthcare facilities or high schools. Protests have to have a coordinator that can be contacted in cases violence occurs or hate speech takes place. Protests should never block accessible pathways for disabled people, block public used roads without advance coordination or take place on highways. Protests cannot endorse hate speech or hate symbols, they should never leave garbage behind or destroy private property. Residential areas should not be zones for protests. Organizing protests should be done through registered organizers.
- Jennifer Savage
To whomever is reading this, I have watched in absolute horror as Canada's laws have been violated repeatedly, directly in front of police officers who have done nothing to stop it. Several months ago, I saw a video where a protestor actually shoved a Toronto police officer who tried to grab the individual but they just walked away and no one went after them.
I have seen people march through residential areas shouting hate speech and even threatening to kill a child's dog and police were right there on bicycles and did nothing.
On U of T's campus, I watched as Jews were prevented from moving freely in a public space and nothing was done. I did, however, see police remove 2 peaceful Israeli activists who were there to promote dialogue. They had to leave but people screaming about Intifada were fine as was everyone preventing even a Jewish professor from accessing the campus. I fail to understand how it is that police can break up encampments for the unhoused whenever they want but when it comes to wealthy, over-privileged kids and outside agitators who are violating laws, they just stand by and watch. I can't help but think if First Nations groups were doing this, the police would have had no problem going in and violently taking it down.
They are marching through Toronto's streets waving the flags of terrorist organizations. They are screaming at Jews to go back to Poland, a country that exterminated most of their Jews during the Holocaust, so in other words, they're saying go die.
Most recently, I watched a Toronto police officer become completely unhinged on an Iranian man who was protesting the IRGC by holding a sign, on a public street, who was attacked in front of police who did nothing. The officer was screaming at the man to leave. He said he didn't need to, he was correct, he was on a public sidewalk, but the police officer was screaming over and over and though he absolutely witnessed the assaults on him and the person with him, that officer did nothing.
Protestors have been allowed to block streets, block access to things, Jewish places of worship and schools have been shot at and the police are not doing anything to protect Jewish citizens, who now talk about leaving for Israel because it is safer for them there. Think about that. Even after October 7th, Jews feel like they'd be safer in Israel than in Canada.
We have people screaming about globalizing this intifada. As you can read about on CIJA's website: Calls to "Globalize the Intifada" are not calls for civil disobedience, general strikes, or negotiations. They are calls for the murder of Israelis and Jews around the world and must be taken seriously by governments and law enforcement agencies.?
Jewish businesses have been attacked. People are hiding their Jewish selves in public. The streets have hateful postering while any posters for the hostages are maliciously ripped down. What I've seen in Toronto looks like a city that has lost all control of public order and that perception is clearly shared by the Intifada crowd who are boldly breaking Canadian laws in front of the police because they know that they will get away with it. If the police are scared, then reinforcements must be called in, whoever they may be. If this is continued to be allowed, if terrorists and terrorism continue to be ignored, it's only a matter of time before there is a major casualty event.
Why are people allowed to wave the flags of Canadian designated terror organizations? Why are they allowed to call for the deaths of Jews and the downfall of Canada? I saw a video of a man in Brampton who was calling for the destruction of Canada. These are not just words. They mean what they are saying and Jews are afraid to exist in public because nothing is being done about these constant hate marches.
Praising terrorists, terrorist organizations, calling for Intifada and the intentional intimidation of Jews not only in schools, public spaces and places of worship but in their own neighbourhoods, in front of the very places they live, must not be allowed to continue. Jews and Iranians who oppose the IRGC should not have to live in fear in Canada. In one video, a man in downtown Toronto told the person filming that they plan to turn Canada into an Islamic country. Look at what happened to Iran. These threats to our democracy and our country, as well as minority citizens, must be taken seriously.
You have lost the trust of Jewish Torontonians. I am active in many online areas and have heard many Jews say they don't trust the police to keep them safe. They've taken over subway stations, how is that legal? People have screamed at children that their parents are murderers. If you haven't seen any of these incidents, which have all been caught on video, then you aren't paying any attention. The longer this is allowed to go on, the worse it gets, the harder it will be to quell it when you finally decide to take action and by then, it may be too late for people.
Additionally, until these hate marches are stopped, you should be providing security to Jewish schools and places of worship with police and squad cars stationed out front to deter the inevitable. Additionally, given that there have been actual calls to terrorism and to the take over of this country at these protests, something must be done. I don't believe incitement is protected speech so why has it, so far, been ignored?
Online, people from other countries who have seen these videos are saying that Toronto is lost. That Jews should get out and quickly. That is the current perception. That Toronto has given in to terrorists and terrorist supporters and is a safe haven for them.
Not only should arrests be made, but anyone found engaging in this type of illegal activity, who is not a citizen, must be deported from the country. That starts with actually arresting people. There are thousands of peaceful Muslims in this country. The people at these hate marches are not peaceful and are not interested in Canadian values. Their goal is to overthrow our country and if they're allowed to break laws right in front of the police, they're only emboldened to do worse. - Adam Breslin
In general I think the police need to do a better job distinguishing between speech and action. People need to given great latitude to express their thoughts - to say things even if these things are offensive or distasteful to others. However, too many demonstrations that have been allowed by the police to continue have not been about speech - they have been about action - blocking intersections and roads, blocking access to buildings and facilities, and bringing mobs into neighborhoods to intimidate residents. Too often the police have prioritized the rights of demonstrators over the rights of the public and the community. The police need to be both more creative and more forceful in preventing demonstrators from gathering in places that infringe on the broader community's rights of access and freedom of movement and moving them when they do. They need to preserve demonstrators right to gather, speak, demonstrate - but to make sure they are doing so in locations and places that do not make the community feel unsafe. This was done extremely effectively at UJA's walk for Israel.
- Sarah Rabinovitch
To Whom It May Concern, I am writing to offer my thoughts on how the Toronto Police Services (TPS) can enhance their approach to maintaining public order on the streets of our city. Given recent events, it is crucial that TPS prioritizes the recognition and effective management of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. Below are some suggestions that could significantly improve TPS's service to the community: *Education and Training* 1. *Comprehensive Hate Speech Training:* Officers should be educated on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical for police to understand that certain chants heard at protests are calls for genocide and not innocuous expressions. 2. *Understanding Propaganda:* Officers need training to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that may masquerade as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. For example, "anti-Palestinian racism" is often a category that criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities without data-driven support. 3. *Chant Awareness:* Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. *Historical Context Lessons:* Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. *Psychological Training:* Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement* 1. *Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech:* Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. *Public Masking Ban:* Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests, especially when outdoors. 3. *Noise Control:* Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. *Barrier Implementation:* Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. *Unobstructed Daily Life:* Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. *Traffic and Road Management:* Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. *Anti-Intimidation Measures:* Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability* 1. *Consistent Policy Enforcement:* Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. *Punishment for Violence:* Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. *Bias Awareness:* Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement* 1. *Open Dialogues:* Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. *Collaborative Efforts:* Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. *Support Networks:* Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
I expect these suggestions will be considered seriously and implemented to ensure a safer, more inclusive community for everyone in Toronto.
Sincerely,
Sarah Rabinovitch - Cecilia Alterman
We need to ensure there are no more protests that include hateful comments and rhetoric against Israel, Zionism, Jews or Canada. Protestors must show their faces and not be permitted to protest in neighbourhoods, disrupt traffic or near religious gatherings or institutions, including hospitals.
- Hailey Ben-Izhak (Private citizen)
To Whom It May Concern,
I am writing to offer my thoughts on how the Toronto Police Services (TPS) can enhance their approach to maintaining public order on the streets of our city. Given recent events, it is crucial that TPS prioritizes the recognition and effective management of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. Below are some suggestions that could significantly improve TPS's service to the community:
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Officers should be educated on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical for police to understand that certain chants heard at protests are calls for genocide and not innocuous expressions. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Officers need training to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that may masquerade as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. For example, "anti-Palestinian racism" is often a category that criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities without data-driven support. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests, especially when outdoors. 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
I hope these suggestions will be considered seriously and implemented to ensure a safer, more inclusive community for everyone in Toronto.
Sincerely,
Hailey Ben-Izhak M3H 4T5 - David Alon
It's one thing to protest against government policies. But to stop traffic, or interfere with the ability to drive or get around the city should be illegal. And what we are having isn't protests, they are intimidation tactics against Jews. They are actually calling for violence against Jews which isn't legal and must be stopped. Any support for a terrorist organization like Hamas must not be tolerated or allowed in Canada. If immigrants coming to Canada can't be peaceful then they shouldn't be allowed to stay here.
- Eden
The city is becoming unsafe because of violent support for terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah. Jews and peaceful Canadians no longer feel safe.
"From the river to the sea" and calling for "intifada" are both hate speech against recognized minorities and are calls for violence and murder which are explicitly prohibited under the Canadian Criminal Code as well as hate speech legislation.
We support the police but we need the police to do their job and arrest criminals and keep our country safe for Canadians. - Robert Sobie
In Canada we have rights to free speech and free assembly. We can protest all we want as long as it doesn't get violent. If a group is offended by a protest too bad, eg DEI offends all straight white males, we put up with it.
Thank you - Elke Rubach
Since when is it ok to go around the city vandalizing and calling for the death of Jews without any consequences? All for right of protest but replace the word Jew/Israel for any of the other visible minorities and how does that work? Where is respect for authority?
Is it a free for all now? - Joshua Schon
Hello,
As a longtime Jewish resident in this city, I must say that I and most of my community have been appalled by the way The Toronto Police have handled "protests". Especially, protests which were meant to intimidate (arranging protests on the 401 overpass on Avenue Rd. because it is "A Zionist infested area" as its main organizer said, and notice they don't "protest" on other overpasses) and disrupt (like the "counter-protests" during the walk for Israel where there is video of these antisemites chanting "Allahu Akbar" as well as intimidating local neighbors as they came down side streets). These have been commonplace all year. This police force would never let a protester go unchecked where people yelled the n-word at African Canadians or the f-word at an LGBTQ rally in June. The fact that barely anyone has been arrested or charged for these crimes is abominable and despicable. Bullies only become emboldened when corrective behavior is not applied to them. There should be no place for this in any civilized society. Police and politicians shouldn't treat some vile protests differently than others. They should all be equally condemned and prosecuted as aggressively as possible. As a Jew, I know longer feel safe to go to public places in the city I was born in. I have deferred going to the zoo and the former science centre these last months with my family due to unchecked, vile antisemites within our city, who know they will not be arrested or prosecuted. Toronto Police, prosecutors, and city officials have a responsibility to do a lot better.
Regards, Joshua Schon - Batyah Kadish
The city is becoming unsafe because of violent support for terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah. Jews and peaceful Canadians no longer feel safe.
"From the river to the sea" and calling for "intifada" are both hate speech against recognized minorities and are calls for violence and murder which are explicitly prohibited under the Canadian Criminal Code as well as hate speech legislation.
We support the police but we need the police to do their job and arrest criminals and keep our country safe for Canadians. - Jocelyn Kadish (U OF T)
PLEASE -this is URGENT ?? The city is becoming unsafe because of violent support for terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah. Jews and peaceful Canadians no longer feel safe.
"From the river to the sea" and calling for "intifada" are both hate speech against recognized minorities and are calls for violence and murder which are explicitly prohibited under the Canadian Criminal Code as well as hate speech legislation.
We support the police but we need the police to do their job and arrest criminals and keep our country safe for Canadians. - Mark Salsberg
As a Jewish individual, living in the area where targeted protests have occurred, are nothing more than intimidating actions that are rooted in hatred and discrimination of the Jewish People.
The presumption from the "Pro-Palestinian" that they are not targeting Jews, but only Zionists are essentially two sides of the same coin. There is nothing further from the truth, especially when the language from these protestors are vile, violent, and hateful towards anyone who can hear them. The protestors are not only infringing on my human rights of being Jewish, but also my right to believe that the State of Israel has a right to exist and be a safe haven for Jewish people from all over the world (even though they still have millions of non Jews living in Israel peacefully).
As someone who was born, raised and lived in Toronto my whole life, and has been exposed to antisemitic rhetoric in the past, I have never felt more uncomfortable and concerned for the safety of me, my family, my neighbours, friends, family, and fellow Canadian citizens.
I have never once seen anyone from our community ever express such hateful rhetoric, and abusive behaviour, not only towards the Jewish community, but also the police, politicians, and business communities.
Hiding behind masks, using loud megaphones at deafening volume is nothing but intimidation that ultimately leads to fear and violence.
While I believe in the right to protest, I do not believe in enabling people to act with such disrespect and hatred can and should be accepted. The masks that these protestors are wearing are an act of intimidation and lawlessness, that will further enable and encourage more "anti-Canadian" behaviour. This has to stop. We are all very uncomfortable and concerned for our safety.
Something needs to be done before things continue to escalate and ultimately end in violence. We are a peaceful community that has contributed to the strength and success of Canada for generations. To further ostracize and threaten our community, will only destroy the true meaning of what it is to be Canadian. - Noah K
Please arrest supporters of terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah. They are spewing hatred in violation of hate speech laws, and the entire city is becoming an unsafe place for Jews and peace loving Canadians.
- Greenberg Dr. Mark (Sunnybrook Health Science Centre)
Strictly enforce all violations of the criminal code without exception.
Protect private property from intrusion and remove said trespassers immediately. And issue citations , notice to appear and/ or arrest said violators. - Stephanie Donovan
I have concerns around how certain protests are policed in Toronto. Some protests, the police are there to protect the protestors; while other protests are made out to be a group of second class citizens (often not white) who are treated as dangerous and concerning. We are living in a time where certain groups are given the privilege to protest and we accept their concerns. While others, who also have legitimate concerns, are treated poorly, and dismissed by the police. In case you need some examples, protests that are peaceful, say to support the Palestinian people, are viewed as dangerous and wrong. Protests around poverty tend to have more police presence where force needs to be used. This isn't the case when wealthy people take to the streets. Everybody in the city of Toronto should be allowed to peacefully protest. I do not believe that this is the case and it concerns me as a citizen wanting to live in a democratic place. Thank you for your time.
- Osnat Melamed (Member of the public)
Protests have no place next to schools, hospitals, places of worship, and community centres, nor at residential communities that are home to minority groups. Protests, particularly those with a violent nature, are intimidating. No Torontonian needs to feel intimidated in their own city! Protests should only be allowed in agreed upon central locations in the city (i.e. Nathan Phillips Sq). Everything should be done to minimize protests from interfering with day to day city operations (i.e blocking roads in rush hours). Protests should never be allowed to harbour illegal activity including vandalism and trespassing (i.e overnight camping). This is the law, please enforce it. The rule of law should return to Toronto, we will all profit from it! Please make Toronto safe again!
- Ellen Williamson
Excessive force and over militarization of the police has lead to escalation on the part of protestors which then leads to further police escalation. Police should be limited in the level of force and tactics used when dealing with protests and should not be routinely brought in for large events without extensive consultation with stakeholders
- Binyamin Bodner
Protesting with a covered face should be illegal.
- Loren devito
TPS has not been positive or supportive of any public protests in support of Palestine. Activists have been injured and treated violently while practicing their right to peacefully protest. It is outrageous that the TPS of such an international city not support the right to assemble safely. TPS has also let agitators threaten students and took no action against destroyed property. This must change.
- Peter
Hi, I would like to tell you all to please try looking out for any litter to put in your butts, followed by extra to plug your mouth-holes. All cops are bad . Thanks! ^.^
- Madison Bettle (Government)
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. The police need to crack down more on these terrorist supporters. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance.
The police must do more to address the explosion of antisemitism across Toronto, which begins with holding terrorists and terrorist sympathizers accountable. When people call for the death of Israel (aka Jews) on the streets of Toronto, the police must charge them with a hate crime. Every other minority group would not be treated like this. Human rights for everyone but the Jews.
The Holocaust did not begin with the gas chambers. It began with words. And the police have allowed language to be weaponized against Jews, nevermind the violence directed against Jews across this country and the world.
Enough is enough. - Joe Taylor
Download file
I am shocked at the level of police brutality directed at peaceful pro-Palestinian protestors. As a parent to Jewish children who has attended many rallies in support of Palestine the sheer number of police, level of force and overt racism is outrageous. As a parent to Jewish children, the behaviour of the police, rather than keeping my Jewish children safe, endangered them. We planned to attend the march where police charged peaceful protestors with police horses but had to cancel at the last moment. If we had of attended along with friends from our school community, we would still be explaining to our children why the police used horses to "control them". This is simply unacceptable. It represents a failure of leadership at every level, from top to bottom. Many in this city already have strained relationships with the police and the actions of TPS over the last 9 months have done nothing but further alienate many communities, especially Muslim and racialized communities. While I welcome this consultation I have no faith there will be any meaningful action to improve the situation. The police in Toronto act with impunity and there is no political will to seriously address this, including from Mayor Chow. The attached image is 7-8 Ontario Provincial Police vans that were drafted into Toronto on January 7th 2024. A completely unnecessary requirement that further escalates tensions and clearly demonstrates the level of over policing tactics employed. - Aisha Rana (Canada)
Along with many of my Brothers & Sisters, I live with the harmful, negative effects of police actions/brutality against Pro-Palestinian encampments & protesters: As a Mother, I always instruct the children when leaving the house: Don't turn on the stove- there is food already prepared on the counter??Only answer the phone if you recognize the name or number ??Don't answer the door without an adult present ??Leave the ironing until I come back…AND YOU KNOW WHO TO CALL FOR HELP… …a short while ago, as I was giving my 10 Commandments while getting ready to leave home, my young daughter was on the sofa in her corner of the living room, "uh huh, uh huh, uh huh" while her face was in the Chromebook. When I got to, "AND YOU KNOW WHO TO CALL", she looked up at me and said, "The Police? I'll let the house burn down before I call them." She went back to her computer and I just stood there. It was the complete calm with which she spoke that shook me. The matter of fact tone of her voice. I had always raised my children with respect for elders & teachers and to honour those in a position of authority over ourselves as they work very hard to care for us. Their deep seated impressions now with the experiences that they have personally had as Pro-Palestinians and what they have seen of injustices and dispicable behaviours against others is something I will never be able to reverse or repair. As a Canadian citizen born and raised in Ottawa with parents of Pakistani descent, as a Canadian citizen with awards and citations for outstanding community involvement over the span of my life in Ottawa, London, Toronto- Today, I would like to thank my Government and responsible agencies for reducing my life's work to zero in front of my children.
- Amal Nayyer
Police are meant to serve and protect. If there is peaceful expression taking place in form of protest, flag waving, etc the police should not be aggressive, antagonise, get in protestors faces etc. If counter protestors appear, the police ought to be there to keep the peace and arrest anyone trying to harass, or lay hands on or assault another. You guys did this well the first few months of the protests. There were almost no real incidents. Almost all incidents since has been the police instigating violence via getting in protestors faces, pushing them to the ground, pulling flags out of their hands. It had become apparant that police no longer serve and protect but are bought to carry out the agenda of the rich and powerful who are most often very unethical. Is that why officers become officers? To take bribes, serve the rich, be racist, carry out their aggression under cover of the badge???? Because I used to think people became officers to protect and do justice... because they beleived in fairness and the law. It's shameful. I had such deep respect for police before and now I see thugs when I see them on the street.
- Mahmood
It is essential that the TPS preserves the right to protest in safety. Protestors for Palestinian human rights (and other causes) should not fear brutalization and targeting by the police. The police should prioritize deescalation and protection of the right to protest.
- Mar
Education and Training
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
Policy and Enforcement
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
Reinforcement and Accountability
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
Community Engagement
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - A. W.
The role of police in this city has gone above and beyond what it should be. "To serve and protect" has become a slogan not upheld by today's officers, who are often called on to remove people from public spaces, infringe on charter rights and freedoms, and brutalize peaceful, unarmed demonstrators. The increase of police brutality upon civillians has become a horrific new wave across the globe, and TPS is no exception. Who exactly are police protecting? Certainly not the people. Police have been weaponized to serve corporate interests and do the bidding of those with money and power alone; an oppressive and armed tool of the city and state against its own people, and this must come to an end. The role of police during demonstrations should strictly be directing traffic and administering first aid if required. Currently, police are intimidating, surveilling, blocking, beating and detaining demonstrators, infringing on their right to peaceful assembly and demonstration. This is unacceptable in a democratic society which prides itself on Human Rights. Rather than being stewards of community safety, the police are nothing more than a funding-bloated paramilitary acting in ways that scream fascism. We are better than this. We must demand better and choose better from institutions that are funded by our tax dollars. I will close by addressing all members of all ranks in TPS: Remeber who you work for! Remember who you are meant to serve! It is NOT capital and inanimate objects. It is the people. Do better, because public trust has eroded entirely. When police act with miscalculated violence, our society is lost and they are at the root of the problem. Finally, the only good cop is a former cop. Quit your jobs.
- Fran Sharpe
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chants we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Victoria Grithina
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Mohammed A
Police has been displaying inconsistent and largely biased approach to ProPalestine protests. The aim of the police force appears to stigmatize and marginalize protestors asking for end to violence and killings in Gaza. Some police officer have used unreasonable level of violence which was totally unprovoked. The use of horses, heavy militarized police , tens of vans on display for arrests is a waste of public resources. Instead of wasting resources on non violent protests police better focus on car thefts and gun violence rampant in Toronto. Police must reject any pressure from corrupt politicians or business people that want to violently crush these non violent protests. We all know the politicians and business people aligned with the foreign state committing genocide in Gaza. They are doing everything in their power to shield this state from criticism. Canadian police must not become one of their tools and stay neutral.
- Karen shlesinger
Thank you for this call and for the unwavering support of the police force in keeping peace during these trying times. There is room for improvement in the following:
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Eithan Dudnik
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services to improve their service to the community, particularly in recognizing and *Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Helena Yakovlev Golani
Please see my comments. Thank you!
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Patrick Simaan
More and more zionists are getting cities to pass bylaws against demonstrations. Violating our rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms because they don't like us protesting against genocide and war crimes or reminding the world that they are murdering THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF INNOCENT LITTLE CHILDREN. If you don't like people protesting war crimes going on inside a synagogue, STOP THE PEOPLE INAIDE COMMITTING WAR CRIMES not the protesters outside. It's not difficult to understand.
- Mika Bareket
I am a longtime resident and business owner in Kensington Market. I was also, for many years, Chair or Vice-Chair of our BIA, and have been part of a few stakeholder groups focusing on our public realm.
Surely you are getting many comments regaring encampments, of which our community has had more of its fair share. I would like to speak on behalf of what I'll call Vendor Encampments. These are huddles or disparate groups of people selling their wares on our sidewalks. They range from vendors with full setups of tables, tents and wireless speakers, to individuals simply sitting on sidewalks with their products spread out.
They have taken over our sidewalks for several years now, except during winter months. This causes pedestrians to walk on the streets, endangering themselves, as well as cyclists. I know the City of Toronto is planning a pedestrian pilot project in our community to address narrow sidewalks vis a vis public safety. It would be much simpler to remove these illegal vendors. And from my estimation, the City may well embark on a project to widen sidewalks, but they will just be providing more space for illegal vending.
As a business owner, struggling to stay in business, I find these vendors 㤼㸷 who do not pay for the privilege of selling their wares, highly problematic. Visitors and tourists inadvertently enable these vendors by shopping for the "novelty" of it. But it is hurting retailers, and this is a growing problem. One intrepid former business owner has figured out a way of monetizing our public spaces by charging vendors for tables and prime corner locations, that he somehow saves for the highest bidder.
This tendency for street vendors goes hand in hand with the many Cafe TO spaces that have also popped up. I won't dwell on the issues pertaining to these patios, or how unfair it is to retailers who are not reaping the benefits of the added space and exposure. But it should be considered how these patios are contributing to an atmosphere that hinders normal retail activity, and also creates challenges for pedestrians.
A simple sweep from TPS would solve this. We have tried working with various enforcement teams on the basis of noise and/or encroachment, but it is a tedious process that rarely works. Our sidewalks should be cleared of vendors, even if they have "permission" from the businesses whose storefront they are occupying. In most cases, those sidewalks and front pads do not belong to the property or business owner - they are pedestrian right of way, and should remain so. - Jennifer salter (None)
Here are some suggestions for Toronto Police Services to improve their service to the community, particularly in recognizing and addressing antisemitic and genocidal hate speech, and reinforcing policies:
*Education and Training*
1. Comprehensive Hate Speech Training: Educate officers on the historical context, meaning, and impact of antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. It is critical that police understand that the chance we are hearing at protests are calls for genocide 㤼㸶 i.e., they are not innocuous. 2. Understanding Propaganda: Train police to recognize and understand the tactics and symbols used in hate speech and propaganda, including those that mask as anti-racism or other forms of advocacy. "Anti-Palestinian racism" is one example - a category of racism that is completely not data driven, and essentially criminalizes Jewish and Israeli identities. 3. Chant Awareness: Educate the force on specific chants and symbols that call for the annihilation of Jews, making their use explicitly unacceptable. 4. Historical Context Lessons: Incorporate lessons from history to highlight the dangers of unchecked hate speech and the path it can lead to actual violence. 5. Psychological Training: Equip officers with skills to recognize and respond to gaslighting and implied threats of violence.
*Policy and Enforcement*
1. Zero Tolerance for Hate Speech: Implement and enforce a strict no-tolerance policy for antisemitic and genocidal hate speech. 2. Public Masking Ban: Prohibit public masking that can be used to intimidate or conceal identity during demonstrations and protests. "Fear of COVID" is not a viable excuse, it, especially when protests are taking place outdoors 3. Noise Control: Enforce regulations against the use of extreme noise as a form of assault or intimidation. 4. Barrier Implementation: Use wide barriers with designated no-go zones to separate opposing groups during protests to prevent clashes. 5. Unobstructed Daily Life: Ensure that demonstrations do not obstruct or prevent people from going about their everyday business. 6. Traffic and Road Management: Maintain clear roadways and prevent traffic obstruction during public events and protests. 7. Anti-Intimidation Measures: Actively prevent and address any tactics used to intimidate individuals or groups.
*Reinforcement and Accountability*
1. Consistent Policy Enforcement: Reinforce existing policies uniformly without bias, ensuring all violations are addressed. 2. Punishment for Violence: Ensure that any act of violence, regardless of the perpetrator's background or motivation, is punished appropriately. 3. Bias Awareness: Train officers to recognize and avoid biases in their enforcement of laws and policies.
*Community Engagement*
1. Open Dialogues: Facilitate open dialogues and community meetings to discuss the impact of hate speech and the importance of tolerance. 2. Collaborative Efforts: Work with community leaders and organizations to educate the public and promote understanding and cooperation. 3. Support Networks: Establish support networks for victims of hate speech and violence to provide them with the necessary resources and assistance. - Zvi Weidenfeld
I would like to express how I have been feeling since all the different kinds of protests have happened. When I arrived to Toronto from Tel-Aviv, in the mid 90s, I was never afraid or hesitant to say that I'm Israeli or Jewish. Now - I do! Many of my Israeli and Jewish friends who live in Canada feel the same.
We as Canadians need to understand what happened to permit such a change. - A. S. Borden
- Sandra Buckler (Citizen)
The City should not allow any public demonstration that inspires hate or violence.
This is an opportunity for the Mayor to lead and for the TPS to be supported by the City to keep the peace and enforce law and order during any unplanned demonstration or disruption.
The City should not allow any demonstration that has not been requested through an official channel. All of the marathon/races/parades in Toronto have to seek a permit so why do large protests just get to happen when the agitators feel like disrupting everyone and turning an already super congested city into complete paralysis?
No demonstrations should be allowed to put a choke hold on the city. If people want to hold a protest - file a permit, get approval and go to a park - no protests should be allowed to take over Yonge Street or Bloor and any other major artery.
Put protests in a park. We simply cannot afford to have the roads tied up for hours and inconvenience everyone.
This is a City issue. No permit - no protest.
The TPS would have the Mayor's support to prevent/disperse any unplanned protest.
Free speech is important. People should be allowed to exercise their rights but in a safe, mature, responsible and respectful manner.
When it comes to protests, I support the TPS in letting them do their job - keep the peace and keep citizens safe. - Katie
I am against any changes being made to the current policy. If police have more freedom to investigate individuals while a protest is happening, they will abuse this Act in order to shut the whole thing down. There have been some shady dealings with protests being shut down or interfered with by police recently, so giving them more freedom will only make it worse. Furthermore, I feel like this proposal is being made specifically by members who support Israel/Zionism, in order to oppress the Palestine protestors. Given the timing, and that this is being supported by pro-Israeli politicians, I do not think this will be thought out in good faith.
- Shy Alter
Thank you for soliciting feedback. Considering recent events, this is a welcome debate.
Great care should be taken to ensure the Canadian public has the freedom to protest and make its opinions heard, even if it is disliked by members of the community at large or any political or other organizational entity. In fact, preserving the principles of free speech is foundational to maintaining a civic minded, vibrant democratic system. There are however principles, that should be respected, and that when breached, will demand active policing and enforcement:
1. Mass gatherings or formation of encampments (or sit-ins) in locations that have not been preapproved for the purpose. Just as "standard" protests require permits.
2. Forming encampments or "sit-ins" in locations that have not been designed for such activity, or for a length of time that creates a serious disturbance to the community at large, or specifically to businesses, or preventing peaceful access to neighborhoods or public spaces in the city.
3. Such gatherings, demonstrations, or encampments that are taking place, without permit, and are explicitly against the rules of organizations, even on their own private property (e.g. universities) - should not be out of reach for policing forces. After all, illegal activities are not allowed in one's own home, allowing policing forces to intervene when such illegal acts take place - even in one's privacy. The following is the most important principle that should guide such intervention:
4. Individuals, targeted groups of people, or communities at large are directly threatened by such gatherings, either through physical threats, but also using violent and threatening language directly aimed at this groups of people of certain ethnic, religious or gender. There are precedents that already exist governing free speech in Canada. Those could be used as guiding principles here as well. - amit Benyovits
I think that if you used the laws that are in the books about face coverings the protests would diminish to virtually nothing...studies around the world show that when this was enforced major reductions were achieved..Exposing their faces can result in consequences and will let you identify those on expired student visas or professional protestors brought into the country etc.
- Brett House
The Public Order Policy should feature an overriding principle that balances the right to peaceful, public gathering, demonstration, and protest, while at the same time preserving access to public space for competing usual, everyday uses that are customary in the relevant location.
- Sheila Banerjee (n/a)
- Brett House
The Public Order Policy should feature an overriding principle that balances the right to peaceful, public gathering, demonstration, and protest, while at the same time preserving access to public space for competing usual, everyday uses that are customary in the relevant location.
- Marla Young
- Harriet Altman
- Revi Mula (Canadian Women Against Antisemitism)
